Can anyone recommend a BMW specialist in Cheshire?
Can anyone recommend a BMW specialist in Cheshire?
Author
Discussion

dbdb

Original Poster:

5,273 posts

204 months

Tuesday 17th November 2015
quotequote all
Hi,

we have a 2007 BMW E91 325iSE automatic which we have owned since new and has now covered about 50,000 miles. The car is displaying the message, "Driving stability: Brake and drive control systems failure. reduced braking and driving stability. Avoid hard braking. Drive moderately."

There is quite a bit written on the internet about this and it seems to be a very common fault on the E90, E91 and E92 series BMWs and other BMWs of a similar age.

I tried Halliwell Jones Wilmslow (who have been servicing the car of late), but they insisted on me paying them to pick the car up on a trailer so they could do the diagnostic which is rediculous - BMW say the car should be driven with more care, not that it is undrivable!

Because of this I cast my line further and approached Williams Manchester, BMW main dealer, who I visited today.

I had the fault codes read by them (for £98.28 - I guess a standard BMW charge) and they informed me I needed a new DCS control unit which would be £2107.31 including a 10% 'loyalty' discount - presumably because the car has a full BMW service history, even though it was done elsewhere.

Williams refused point-blank to divulge the actual fault codes registered, consequently I cannot check the codes myself. I thought this very poor form, given that I had paid nearly £100 to them for the codes to be read. I was also charged £11 to charge the battery of the car whilst the codes were read - which astonished me. Unfortunately I didn't notice this until checking the bill later.

So I am looking for a recommendation of a good local independent BMW specialist garage! Does anyone konw of one? smile

2.5pi

1,091 posts

213 months

Tuesday 17th November 2015
quotequote all
Try baymow in Stockport http://www.baymow.co.uk/contact.htm

Or http://www.darren-wood.com/contact.php in Bredbury

Both excellent according to my BiL whose used them for years

Kawasicki

14,428 posts

266 months

Tuesday 17th November 2015
quotequote all
dbdb said:
Hi,

we have a 2007 BMW E91 325iSE automatic which we have owned since new and has now covered about 50,000 miles. The car is displaying the message, "Driving stability: Brake and drive control systems failure. reduced braking and driving stability. Avoid hard braking. Drive moderately."

There is quite a bit written on the internet about this and it seems to be a very common fault on the E90, E91 and E92 series BMWs and other BMWs of a similar age.

I tried Halliwell Jones Wilmslow (who have been servicing the car of late), but they insisted on me paying them to pick the car up on a trailer so they could do the diagnostic which is rediculous - BMW say the car should be driven with more care, not that it is undrivable!

Because of this I cast my line further and approached Williams Manchester, BMW main dealer, who I visited today.

I had the fault codes read by them (for £98.28 - I guess a standard BMW charge) and they informed me I needed a new DCS control unit which would be £2107.31 including a 10% 'loyalty' discount - presumably because the car has a full BMW service history, even though it was done elsewhere.

Williams refused point-blank to divulge the actual fault codes registered, consequently I cannot check the codes myself. I thought this very poor form, given that I had paid nearly £100 to them for the codes to be read. I was also charged £11 to charge the battery of the car whilst the codes were read - which astonished me. Unfortunately I didn't notice this until checking the bill later.

So I am looking for a recommendation of a good local independent BMW dealer! Does anyone konw of one? smile
I used Hind Heath BMW in Sandbach a couple of times. I had no issues with their work.

I would also be careful about advice from any garage that you need a new DCS control unit. If that's the error that pops up on their diagnostic screen, that is the first thing they change, even if it was not the true source of the problem. It's your money, they often don't feel the need to be logical.

John Laverick

2,002 posts

245 months

Wednesday 18th November 2015
quotequote all
£11 to charge the battery!!! Christ.

Swervin_Mervin

5,016 posts

269 months

Wednesday 18th November 2015
quotequote all
Darren Wood's. Every day.

Oh and you had a lucky escape with the wilmslow one - colleague just had diagnostics on his and he said their hourly rate is £150/hr, and they couldn't tell him what was wrong because the computer couldn't tell them rolleyes. Williams in Stockport are pretty good and half that figure.

His went to Darren Woods in the end and they knew what the issue was almost immediately, without having to do any diagnostics.

Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Wednesday 18th November 2015
quotequote all
David Paul in Warrington.

worsy

6,630 posts

206 months

Wednesday 18th November 2015
quotequote all
There are quite a few in North Shropshire if you are this side of Cheshire.

http://www.thebmwspecialist.co.uk/ in Whitchurch
Mt C's in Oswestry
and BMWizard in Oswestry

Have used Mr C's for servicing on a MINI and had no issues.

andy43

13,331 posts

285 months

Wednesday 18th November 2015
quotequote all
Another Darren Wood fan here thumbup
They're in Bredbury just off the m60.

EagleMoto4-2

669 posts

135 months

Wednesday 18th November 2015
quotequote all
Graham Martins is right on the North Cheshire border in St Helens. Have used them to service my BMW. Half the price of a main dealer and they did a good job.

dbdb

Original Poster:

5,273 posts

204 months

Wednesday 18th November 2015
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies - I really appreciate the time you've all taken to help me!

I will look into them all; I am closest to Warrington.

Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Thursday 19th November 2015
quotequote all
Sounds like the DSC hydro unit has failed - this has happened so often BMW actually produced a repair kit (although I'm not sure whether it covered the 6-cylinder engines or not). I would also contact BMW directly to see if they'll contribute to any repairs.

There's also this place:

http://www.ecutesting.com/catalogue/product/bmw_3_...

Edited by Monty Python on Thursday 19th November 07:42

dhutch

17,962 posts

228 months

Sunday 22nd November 2015
quotequote all
Good look with the work, I've just acquired a e46 so may be looking for somewhere in the Cheshire/North Staffs area in due course if I don't have it serviced locally.

Daniel

dbdb

Original Poster:

5,273 posts

204 months

Thursday 24th March 2016
quotequote all
I thought should follow this up!

The fault was intermittent at first and went off for a bit, but eventually returned permanently. I got quotes from Darren Wood in Stockport and David Paul in Warrington. These were:

David Paul: £865

Darren Wood: £495

Both of these were for the same procedure - removing the ABS Hydro unit, sending to ECU Testing for repair, then re-fitting it to the vehicle.

Unsurprisingly, we took the car to Darren Wood. They were a good firm to deal with and solved the problem with the car. I would recommend them.

Swervin_Mervin

5,016 posts

269 months

Thursday 24th March 2016
quotequote all
Quite a difference in price eek

Glad they delivered for you. Can't fault them. Having no courtesy cars is about the only inconvenience really, but that's to be expected of a small indy.