E92 335d or E63 635d?
E92 335d or E63 635d?
Author
Discussion

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Tuesday 8th December 2015
quotequote all
Pretty similar prices on Autotrader although the 635ds are newer with the revised gearknob etc. I don't know if they also have the updated iDrive as standard too?

What would be your choice and why?

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Tuesday 8th December 2015
quotequote all
335, for being better looking, I assume more agile as it's lighter / smaller, and the smaller size a plus for me as parking spaces at a premium.

If you like the look of 635 I think it's plus is more exclusive and prestigious.

cerb4.5lee

45,371 posts

211 months

Tuesday 8th December 2015
quotequote all
Difficult one, I like the 635d for the perceived better interior and build but I just cant get on with the looks much, so I think it would be the 335d for me but still its a tough choice.

If it was a choice between a 650i or 335d...then the 650i would win for that lovely V8 and I would put up with the looks biggrin

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Tuesday 8th December 2015
quotequote all
cerb4.5lee said:
If it was a choice between a 650i or 335d...then the 650i would win for that lovely V8 and I would put up with the looks biggrin
650is are cheaper still but I've discounted those as I think the 333d with a remap is more fun, faster in the real world and obviously much better on the fuel. The added benefit of the 3 series is the folding seats, which make it quite practical.

Agreed about the looks although I like most angles of the 6 apart from the back. It's certainly grown on me over the last few years.

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Tuesday 8th December 2015
quotequote all
The Stiglet said:
650is are cheaper still but I've discounted those as I think the 333d with a remap is more fun, faster in the real world and obviously much better on the fuel. The added benefit of the 3 series is the folding seats, which make it quite practical.

Agreed about the looks although I like most angles of the 6 apart from the back. It's certainly grown on me over the last few years.
why not 335i, I seem to recall you were asking about those before?

cerb4.5lee

45,371 posts

211 months

Tuesday 8th December 2015
quotequote all
The Stiglet said:
cerb4.5lee said:
If it was a choice between a 650i or 335d...then the 650i would win for that lovely V8 and I would put up with the looks biggrin
650is are cheaper still but I've discounted those as I think the 333d with a remap is more fun, faster in the real world and obviously much better on the fuel. The added benefit of the 3 series is the folding seats, which make it quite practical.

Agreed about the looks although I like most angles of the 6 apart from the back. It's certainly grown on me over the last few years.
Yes I do like the practicality of the E92 and it gives you options with the folding rear seats, I love V8`s but on the two occasions I have tried to run them as a daily driver I have struggled to keep up with the fuel costs!

I always love the idea of a V8 as a daily but it has never worked for me(I haven't got deep enough pockets) so I do appreciate a powerful diesel as you get the performance without it costing an arm and a leg when you put your foot down or are sat in traffic.


The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Tuesday 8th December 2015
quotequote all
Smuler said:
why not 335i, I seem to recall you were asking about those before?
Yes I did, well remembered. In a nutshell, I reckon the engine is more of a liability, which I could do without. I'd like to keep the car for 3 years and it needs to be reliable, versatile enough for a new family (fingers crossed) and not so expensive so as to attract unwanted attention from my wife! For the driving I do I also appreciate the torque of the diesels and hope the residual value will be a bit better.

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Wednesday 9th December 2015
quotequote all
The Stiglet said:
Yes I did, well remembered. In a nutshell, I reckon the engine is more of a liability, which I could do without. I'd like to keep the car for 3 years and it needs to be reliable, versatile enough for a new family (fingers crossed) and not so expensive so as to attract unwanted attention from my wife! For the driving I do I also appreciate the torque of the diesels and hope the residual value will be a bit better.
Had 14 months in my 335i and it's a great daily driver over 17k miles. So if you go 335d, should suit you down to ground smile


Crackie

6,386 posts

273 months

Wednesday 9th December 2015
quotequote all
I've had an E92 335i for 5 years and now fancy a change so test drove a 650i a couple of weeks ago. Always liked the 6 series look and found a fairly low mileage ( 53K ) example to try; it was tight and well damped with no apparent play in steering or suspension. It did a great trick of feeling smaller and more agile the quicker you went however that's probably because it felt a slow and cumbersome in town compared to the 335. The auto box wasn't great at low speeds either.

It was a great cruiser but wasn't much fun and wasn't as quick as I'd thought it would be. E63 is roughly 100Kg heavier than E92; it felt a lot more to me.

JNW1

9,568 posts

225 months

Wednesday 9th December 2015
quotequote all
Crackie said:
I've had an E92 335i for 5 years and now fancy a change so test drove a 650i a couple of weeks ago. Always liked the 6 series look and found a fairly low mileage ( 53K ) example to try; it was tight and well damped with no apparent play in steering or suspension. It did a great trick of feeling smaller and more agile the quicker you went however that's probably because it felt a slow and cumbersome in town compared to the 335. The auto box wasn't great at low speeds either.

It was a great cruiser but wasn't much fun and wasn't as quick as I'd thought it would be. E63 is roughly 100Kg heavier than E92; it felt a lot more to me.
Never driven an E63 but can't say it's ever really appealed; always seemed a bit boulevard cruiser and the interior space (or rather the lack of it) is borderline laughable given the exterior dimensions. It does have more classy materials inside than an E92 but, M6 aside, it's never really struck me as a driver's car (which is what your test drive experience would seem to confirm). If you fancy a V8 that's a bit more interesting to drive how about a C63 Mercedes? smile

However, to the OP I'd say give the E92 335d a close look; I had an E92 335i which was a very competent all-round car and I'm sure the 335d would be the same!

Edited by JNW1 on Thursday 10th December 06:14

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Friday 11th December 2015
quotequote all
JNW1 said:
However, to the OP I'd say give the E92 335d a close look; I had an E92 335i which was a very competent all-round car and I'm sure the 335d would be the same!
Used to have an E92 335d in the family, it was a great car, which must be even better with a remap. I've still never driven a 335i and I probably should at some point just for comparisons sake. They're cheaper than the D to buy and insure (for some bizarre reason) but they do appear to have more problems.

Thanks for the feedback guys.

JNW1

9,568 posts

225 months

Friday 11th December 2015
quotequote all
The Stiglet said:
Used to have an E92 335d in the family, it was a great car, which must be even better with a remap. I've still never driven a 335i and I probably should at some point just for comparisons sake. They're cheaper than the D to buy and insure (for some bizarre reason) but they do appear to have more problems.

Thanks for the feedback guys.
The problems with the 335i tend to relate to cars with the earlier N54 twin-turbo engine; the later N55 engine (fitted from the 2010 model year on the 335i and still used in the M135i/235i/435i, etc) is much more robust albeit probably less tuneable if ultimate power and torque is what you're after. If you can run to an E92 with the N55 engine I suspect you're much less likely to encounter the issues that tend to get all the bad publicity with 335i's....

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Thursday 24th December 2015
quotequote all
Finally had the time to go and test some cars yesterday and also thinking that so close to Christmas I might get a deal.

2009 635d, 70k - good spec, nice engine, car felt a bit 'used' though with lots of little scratches, dents under the doors etc. Disappointed with the iDrive unit, which I expected to be the updated HDD model, the same as the F30 330d I drove there in. Unfortunately, it was just the controller but still the old iDrive software so it felt quite dated. Back seats worse than I remembered, other than that, nice cruiser GT but a bit bland.

2007 650i AUC, 50k, pre-LCI. Really felt dated inside, even compared to the LCI 635d. Biggest mistake was visiting these cars in a new F30, which is leagues ahead in tech and not fair to compare with. However, what a stonking engine! It would really be fantastic car with a DCT box, such a shame they didn't make them then. The LCI model with paddles would be quite fun, I imagine. Definitely that over the 635d although still not very dynamic. Still has presence though.

Went to see an E92 335d but it was sold before I got there. There was a 2008 535d Touring but I didn't bother testing given the size of it; seemed even bigger than the S6 Avant I had before.

And so, I came home pretty disappointed thinking it would be another month or two before I found something I liked and worth going to see.

How wrong I was...just bought a 2011 AUC E92 335d over the phone. Should be picking it up on Wednesday! Never done that with a car before nuts

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Thursday 24th December 2015
quotequote all
The right choice wink
What colour combination did you go for?

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Thursday 24th December 2015
quotequote all
Smuler said:
The right choice wink
What colour combination did you go for?
Thanks! Le Mans Blue with Coral Red interior and brushed aluminium. Actually, quite a nice look IMHO and I usually prefer only black interiors. Nice thing was the 18 inch wheels after all the stories I'd read about 19's cracking.




Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Thursday 24th December 2015
quotequote all
smart, don't think I've many (if any) Le Mans Blue and coral red

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Thursday 24th December 2015
quotequote all
Smuler said:
smart, don't think I've many (if any) Le Mans Blue and coral red
I think they call it Superman lol! Is it too much? I'm hoping it will be darker in the flesh.

Edit: I think I'm having buyer's remorse. Need some support on the colour here otherwise I think I've just bought the car to a spec without taking into account resale.

Edited by The Stiglet on Thursday 24th December 18:45

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Thursday 24th December 2015
quotequote all
I have seen red interiors that look darker in flesh, so I think that's lighter in the photos. Probably need the view of a coral red owner to be surer.

It didn't scream out to me "hard to sell," so why worry about resale value 3 years or more down the line. Car will be by then 8 year old with surely north of 110k miles by then. Not scope for a big loss even if it did make a difference.


drgav2005

972 posts

250 months

Thursday 24th December 2015
quotequote all
The Stiglet said:
I think they call it Superman lol! Is it too much? I'm hoping it will be darker in the flesh.

Edit: I think I'm having buyer's remorse. Need some support on the colour here otherwise I think I've just bought the car to a spec without taking into account resale.

Edited by The Stiglet on Thursday 24th December 18:45
I think it looks great.

I had a F31 330d M Sport Touring which was Sapphire black and Coral red - the interior was a great place to be. Those photos look a little 'bright', you'll find the red is a little more muted in real life. I'd grown tired of black leather interiors in my BMWs and the coral red was a great choice.

To hell with resale - buy the car YOU want to drive around in... you will always find a buyer. Enjoy your new car when you get your hands on it! thumbup



The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Saturday 26th December 2015
quotequote all
Thanks guys, that's the general feedback I'm getting too. I guess I'm just worried about the image it might convey as I've always had black or silver cars with black interiors - very inoffensive. Been told that coral red is more muted in the flesh but I don't think I'd worry as much if it were black or grey on the outside.

I've put a deposit down and heading to see it on Wednesday so I guess if it's ghastly then I can always back out as I did everything on the phone. I got such a cracking deal though on Christmas Eve.