N52 Overheated - will there be damage?
N52 Overheated - will there be damage?
Author
Discussion

Billy_Whizzzz

Original Poster:

2,679 posts

174 months

Sunday 17th January 2016
quotequote all
3.0 N52 overheated yesterday on the motorway. Engine warning came on, and I limped a couple of miles to a garage where it was then towed to a main dealer. I'm presuming it's the water pump, but critically - how will I know if there's any permanent damage, and how can they test for this?


iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Sunday 17th January 2016
quotequote all
Hard to say. If it runs okay after a new pump is fitted and doesn't mix and and water, you'll have got away with it.

If you haven't, you'll need another engine - forget trying to repair a cooked N52.


8Tech

2,222 posts

229 months

Sunday 17th January 2016
quotequote all
As above but the moment the light came on you were probably still ok, but limping on further could have cost you a new engine, however slowly you went.

I have heard that soooo many times. The driver sees a red oil light but decides they can get home if they take it easy. Always the wrong call then.

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Monday 18th January 2016
quotequote all
8Tech said:
As above but the moment the light came on you were probably still ok, but limping on further could have cost you a new engine, however slowly you went.

I have heard that soooo many times. The driver sees a red oil light but decides they can get home if they take it easy. Always the wrong call then.
Yup. Heard it so many times with old E39's.

"The needle went into the red but I drive slowly for 2 miles to the next motorway services".

It's not like an old Viva - when the needle starts moving to the right or a warning light comes on, that means 'pull over and switch the engine off RIGHT NOW'.

jayemm89

4,475 posts

161 months

Monday 18th January 2016
quotequote all
I don't know about the N52 but I know the OIL light on the E46 has two stages. Yellow meaning you should really check this now, red meaning for the love of god stop driving.

I saw the amber a few times on my car - usually because my driveway is not very flat so if you were getting "near" low it would be enough to trigger it. She did have a bit of a thirst.

Billy_Whizzzz

Original Poster:

2,679 posts

174 months

Monday 18th January 2016
quotequote all
So, despite the warning coming on and it boiling over, the dealer can find nothing wrong with it. They've tested everything and pronounced it fine - which doesn't fill me with confidence that it won't do it again...

Collectingbrass

3,020 posts

226 months

Monday 18th January 2016
quotequote all
iSore said:
8Tech said:
As above but the moment the light came on you were probably still ok, but limping on further could have cost you a new engine, however slowly you went.

I have heard that soooo many times. The driver sees a red oil light but decides they can get home if they take it easy. Always the wrong call then.
Yup. Heard it so many times with old E39's.

"The needle went into the red but I drive slowly for 2 miles to the next motorway services".

It's not like an old Viva - when the needle starts moving to the right or a warning light comes on, that means 'pull over and switch the engine off RIGHT NOW'.
I may be the exception that proves the rule, I may be jinxing it ( fk I hope not) but this might reassure the OP:-

2001 525i E39 FBMWSH till I got it in July 2014. Red over temp light came on late afternoon of 23rd December 2014, I had driven about 5 miles and was climbing a hill at the time. No excessive heat from heater, no sign of damage to coolant system in engine bay, i.e no split hoses and the engine bay and bonnet were dry. At this point the car had done 73,000 miles.

After giving it ten minutes I drove it another half mile, with no red light then parked for 30 minutes for a flat viewing. I then went back home again. At two miles the over temp light came back on, again when climbing a hill now I think about it. I parked in my local Tescos, did the pre xams food shopping, and came back out again to see what I was faced with. As soon as I put the ignition on the over temp light came straight back on again. At that point I decided not to chance it any further and called the AA.

The AA added 5 ltr of water, bled it and let it settle down. They also checked for head gasket failure by sniffing (with a machine) for gas traces in the water but didnt find anything. They said it should be ok to get me home and I drove it 2 miles home, no problems. The AA advised that I change the water to the correct antifreeze mix at my "earliest opportunity". The AA man said the most likely cause was that I hadn't bled it when I had topped up the system recently with just half a pint - what little I knew. Ah well, I know now...

Removing the under tray showed that the bottom of radiator bowed down from straight by over an inch. Other than that the expansion bottle, thermostat, pump & all hoses were all ok. I changed the radiator and expansion bottle (a reknowned weakness according to Google) , and replaced the coolant and bled it properly. The temp held steady, and there was no coolant loss. I changed the thermostat & pump the following Easter, I didn't do it at the same time as the radiator as not enough a/ £, b/ time and c/ I was DIY and it was very cold!. The car has now done another 20,000 miles and hasn't missed a beat in the year since; swearing like a docker at it for two days straight seems to have taught it a lesson.

OP, I don't want to say" ignore the naysayers, it'll be fine" but what you did is as you can see very similar to me and I would therefore expect that if the dealer can't find anything wrong then it should be OK. That said in your shoes I would premptively change out all the major coolant system parts as they seem to be a weak point in the BMW power plants and you've probably had the only warning shot you're ever going to get that something is amis. It is easy enough to DIY but if you don't fancy it I'd go to an indie though, and depending on the age of the car think about pattern parts; my local stealer wanted £400+ just for the OEM radiator & ECP wanted £100, I dread to think what their labour charges would be. I would also get the belts & idler pulleys checked and changed at the same time as that is also a fan out job, which necessitates draining the radiator.



Edited by Collectingbrass on Monday 18th January 21:22

helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Monday 18th January 2016
quotequote all
The N52 is a little different to the M54. Sounds like the OP needs a water pump and thermostat.

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Monday 18th January 2016
quotequote all
Collectingbrass said:
I may be the exception that proves the rule, I may be jinxing it ( fk I hope not) but this might reassure the OP:-

2001 525i E39 FBMWSH till I got it in July 2014. Red over temp light came on late afternoon of 23rd December 2014, I had driven about 5 miles and was climbing a hill at the time. No excessive heat from heater, no sign of damage to coolant system in engine bay, i.e no split hoses and the engine bay and bonnet were dry. At this point the car had done 73,000 miles.

After giving it ten minutes I drove it another half mile, with no red light then parked for 30 minutes for a flat viewing. I then went back home again. At two miles the over temp light came back on, again when climbing a hill now I think about it. I parked in my local Tescos, did the pre xams food shopping, and came back out again to see what I was faced with. As soon as I put the ignition on the over temp light came straight back on again. At that point I decided not to chance it any further and called the AA.

The AA added 5 ltr of water, bled it and let it settle down. They also checked for head gasket failure by sniffing (with a machine) for gas traces in the water but didnt find anything. They said it should be ok to get me home and I drove it 2 miles home, no problems. The AA advised that I change the water to the correct antifreeze mix at my "earliest opportunity". The AA man said the most likely cause was that I hadn't bled it when I had topped up the system recently with just half a pint - what little I knew. Ah well, I know now...

Removing the under tray showed that the bottom of radiator bowed down from straight by over an inch. Other than that the expansion bottle, thermostat, pump & all hoses were all ok. I changed the radiator and expansion bottle (a reknowned weakness according to Google) , and replaced the coolant and bled it properly. The temp held steady, and there was no coolant loss. I changed the thermostat & pump the following Easter, I didn't do it at the same time as the radiator as not enough a/ £, b/ time and c/ I was DIY and it was very cold!. The car has now done another 20,000 miles and hasn't missed a beat in the year since; swearing like a docker at it for two days straight seems to have taught it a lesson.

OP, I don't want to say" ignore the naysayers, it'll be fine" but what you did is as you can see very similar to me and I would therefore expect that if the dealer can't find anything wrong then it should be OK. That said in your shoes I would premptively change out all the major coolant system parts as they seem to be a weak point in the BMW power plants and you've probably had the only warning shot you're ever going to get that something is amis. It is easy enough to DIY but if you don't fancy it I'd go to an indie though, and depending on the age of the car think about pattern parts; my local stealer wanted £400+ just for the OEM radiator & ECP wanted £100, I dread to think what their labour charges would be. I would also get the belts & idler pulleys checked and changed at the same time as that is also a fan out job, which necessitates draining the radiator.



Edited by Collectingbrass on Monday 18th January 21:22
Jesus, buy a lottery ticket tomorrow! :-)

The N52 has an electric water pump - whilst they're reliable, I'd still rather have a belt driven one. Electric pumps aren't £30 from Euro Car Parts either.

Mr Tidy

31,949 posts

158 months

Friday 22nd January 2016
quotequote all
I hope the news is still good OP!

My Z4C did exactly the same thing 2 weeks ago - gauge in the red!

I was on an unlit NSL dual carriageway at 10 pm - and to all those who say "stop right away - it isn't a Viva" well you can take your chances stationary in the inside lane in a black car but I still value myself more than the car!

Anyway, heating and heater fan on full and window open until I could stop anywhere safe!

It's now at the menders' getting a water pump (£400+ FFS) and thermostat (wrong side of £100!) so tomorrow night I'll be out selling body parts!

Out of curiosity, what mileage was yours at when it died? Mine hadn't quite made it to 62K.

I read loads of stories about injectors and fuel pumps on N53 engines and decided an N52 was as new as I wanted, but I'm now starting to think the M54 might be a better place to draw the line!rolleyes

Billy_Whizzzz

Original Poster:

2,679 posts

174 months

Saturday 23rd January 2016
quotequote all
The dealer carried out 2 days of tests - and insisted that although there had been a pump fault stored in the OBC there was now no fault. Apparently they'd never heard of water pumps failing which comes as a surprise as it is a common problem. Irrespective, at my insistence they quoted £1000 to replace pump and thermostat but advised me against it. So, picked it up and had a rather nervous 300 mile round trip the next day - but seems to be running fine. So now I'm wondering - should I spend the £1000 to get the pump and stat replaced just to be sure intermittent fault won't return?

mad4amanda

2,410 posts

195 months

Saturday 23rd January 2016
quotequote all
Given they didn't know about a less than rare issue I would find another dealer and get it rechecked ?

Patrick Bateman

13,223 posts

205 months

Saturday 23rd January 2016
quotequote all
Mr Tidy said:
I hope the news is still good OP!

My Z4C did exactly the same thing 2 weeks ago - gauge in the red!

I was on an unlit NSL dual carriageway at 10 pm - and to all those who say "stop right away - it isn't a Viva" well you can take your chances stationary in the inside lane in a black car but I still value myself more than the car!

Anyway, heating and heater fan on full and window open until I could stop anywhere safe!

It's now at the menders' getting a water pump (£400+ FFS) and thermostat (wrong side of £100!) so tomorrow night I'll be out selling body parts!

Out of curiosity, what mileage was yours at when it died? Mine hadn't quite made it to 62K.

I read loads of stories about injectors and fuel pumps on N53 engines and decided an N52 was as new as I wanted, but I'm now starting to think the M54 might be a better place to draw the line!rolleyes
What on earth? That makes the M tax I paid look great value.

Billy_Whizzzz

Original Poster:

2,679 posts

174 months

Saturday 23rd January 2016
quotequote all
Patrick Bateman said:
What on earth? That makes the M tax I paid look great value.
Particularly as my S54 engined Z4M has always been faultless, and my N52 that is the subject of this thread rather troublesome!

Mr Tidy

31,949 posts

158 months

Sunday 24th January 2016
quotequote all
Billy_Whizzzz said:
Patrick Bateman said:
What on earth? That makes the M tax I paid look great value.
Particularly as my S54 engined Z4M has always been faultless, and my N52 that is the subject of this thread rather troublesome!
I know, I had wondered about a Z4MC before I bought mine but got put off by M-tax scare stories!

To be fair I have been really pleased with my Z4C up to now - I can't help smiling when I'm driving it!

Just a thought OP but I think I would consult a local BMW Specialist rather than going main agent - there is a listing of them at the top of the BMW General first page. That is how I found mine and they have been great (both guys are ex-Sytner anyway)! BTW, how many miles has your N52 done?

CB 987

404 posts

178 months

Sunday 24th January 2016
quotequote all
OP - I've been having some issues recently with my N52 330i not getting hot enough, I suspect a faulty thermostat. As the water pump has to be removed to change the stat, I'm planning to get the pump done at the same time. It is quite a big job, but don't pay the dealer £1k, you can get new Pierburg water pumps on eBay for £248 delivered, I understand Pierburg make the BMW pumps. If you do decide to go ahead, you could source the parts and get a decent Indy to fit them.

I've had several M54's, when compared to the N52 cooling system they were much cheaper and easier to work on!

Mr Tidy

31,949 posts

158 months

Monday 25th January 2016
quotequote all
CB 987 said:
OP - I've been having some issues recently with my N52 330i not getting hot enough, I suspect a faulty thermostat. As the water pump has to be removed to change the stat, I'm planning to get the pump done at the same time. It is quite a big job, but don't pay the dealer £1k, you can get new Pierburg water pumps on eBay for £248 delivered, I understand Pierburg make the BMW pumps. If you do decide to go ahead, you could source the parts and get a decent Indy to fit them.

I've had several M54's, when compared to the N52 cooling system they were much cheaper and easier to work on!
Actually from what I was told the thermostat has to be removed to change the water pump rather than the other way around, but from what you say it sounds like your thermostat is jammed open - wish mine had stayed too cold rather than too hot! But probably best to change the pump while you are there, especially as you probably don't have a temperature gauge! rolleyes

My 325ti daily (with an M54 engine) had its routine cooling system refresh last year just after 80,000 miles - you know, radiator, expansion tank, temperature sensor, etc.

Why can't BMW make a cooling system that lasts the life of the engine for the Ultimate Driving Machine FFS - Vauxhall managed it for my 1992 Cavalier SRi at 105K miles, even Mercedes for my otherwise terrible W202 C280 at 110K miles!

Looks like I may be going back in time for my RWD options, but good luck with yours!

Billy_Whizzzz

Original Poster:

2,679 posts

174 months

Monday 25th January 2016
quotequote all
It's on 84,000 miles - and yes getting it done preventatively by my local garage seems way to go!

Collectingbrass

3,020 posts

226 months

Monday 25th January 2016
quotequote all
If you're going that route, GSF offer a discount on parts here: http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a... and you can get up to 35% via their mailing list.

Mr Tidy

31,949 posts

158 months

Monday 25th January 2016
quotequote all
Billy_Whizzzz said:
It's on 84,000 miles - and yes getting it done preventatively by my local garage seems way to go!
Yes, I think I would do the same - it's pretty worrying when the gauge goes into the red and the light comes on! Especially as N52's are reportedly scrap if they cook!

I had a call today to say mine has had it's thermostat and pump replaced, been tested and all looks good with no fault codes so tomorrow I will just need to go and collect it (and pay the bill of course)!

Looks like the reportedly routine M54 cooling system refresh at 60-80K translates to a water pump and thermostat replacement on an N52 at 60-80K!

But when they work N52 engines are fantastic - good luck with yours! thumbup