N52B30, what car?
Discussion
Hi All,
apologies if that is a re-occurring theme, but I'd really like to run an N52 engined car for a while and would appreciate input regarding what box to get around it.
Requirements: daily driver + touring car for holidays. I do around 14k miles / year, roughly 50% Autobahn, 20% city, 30% German A/B roads. I don't really need rear seats (but they could be of use at times) and like 2 door tin tops. Nothing set in stone though. Budget is 20k EUR but the less spent over the next 3-4 years the better.
What would you do? Decorked E82, base Z4C or grown up but much more common E60 / E992?
apologies if that is a re-occurring theme, but I'd really like to run an N52 engined car for a while and would appreciate input regarding what box to get around it.
Requirements: daily driver + touring car for holidays. I do around 14k miles / year, roughly 50% Autobahn, 20% city, 30% German A/B roads. I don't really need rear seats (but they could be of use at times) and like 2 door tin tops. Nothing set in stone though. Budget is 20k EUR but the less spent over the next 3-4 years the better.
What would you do? Decorked E82, base Z4C or grown up but much more common E60 / E992?
Edited by Kolbenkopp on Monday 18th January 00:59
Kolbenkopp said:
Hi All,
apologies if that is a re-occurring theme, but I'd really like to run an N52 engined car for a while and would appreciate input regarding what box to get around it.
Requirements: daily driver + touring car for holidays. I do around 14k miles / year, roughly 50% Autobahn, 20% city, 30% German A/B roads. I don't really need rear seats (but they could be of use at times) and like 2 door tin tops. Nothing set in stone though. Budget is 20k EUR but the less spent over the next 3-4 years the better.
What would you do? Decorked E82, base Z4C or grown up but much more common E60 / E992?
If you don't need back seats, can't see why the E60 is on your list as size/space seems its only plus over others.
I've not driven the Z4 but if you can live with the space limitation and it is a good daily driver as well as fun on fast back roads, then go for it.
Otherwise, I'd go E92 [I find my 335i a good daily with enough speed and agility to make a back road ride fun] as it's better looking than the E82, you can have the faster 330 (there's no 130 coupe) and if you are going to step above the Z4 in size, you might as well have more useable rear seats.
So a 2 horse race.
In the uk at least for your budget, I reckon you'd get a lot newer, lower mileage 330i than Z4 3.0l.
apologies if that is a re-occurring theme, but I'd really like to run an N52 engined car for a while and would appreciate input regarding what box to get around it.
Requirements: daily driver + touring car for holidays. I do around 14k miles / year, roughly 50% Autobahn, 20% city, 30% German A/B roads. I don't really need rear seats (but they could be of use at times) and like 2 door tin tops. Nothing set in stone though. Budget is 20k EUR but the less spent over the next 3-4 years the better.
What would you do? Decorked E82, base Z4C or grown up but much more common E60 / E992?
If you don't need back seats, can't see why the E60 is on your list as size/space seems its only plus over others.
I've not driven the Z4 but if you can live with the space limitation and it is a good daily driver as well as fun on fast back roads, then go for it.
Otherwise, I'd go E92 [I find my 335i a good daily with enough speed and agility to make a back road ride fun] as it's better looking than the E82, you can have the faster 330 (there's no 130 coupe) and if you are going to step above the Z4 in size, you might as well have more useable rear seats.
So a 2 horse race.
In the uk at least for your budget, I reckon you'd get a lot newer, lower mileage 330i than Z4 3.0l.
Edited by Kolbenkopp on Monday 18th January 00:59
They don't officially do a 130i Coupe, however if you get the 125i it is exactly the same engine as the 130i just with the wick turned down, and there are friendly people with laptops who can turn the wick back up again for you. Fit the bigger front brakes from a 130i (just needs a caliper swap) and you have a 130i Coupe.
I've had a 125i for about 18 months now and love the thing - feels like a proper classic BMW - small size, manual box, straight 6, but without the classic tail-happiness. The rear seats are useable - bit of a pain to get into, but perfectly comfortable for anyone under 6 foot when you get in there. Mine is still running 125i power levels, but has plenty of grunt for day to day motoring.
Only slight criticism I have is the ride can get a bit challenging, but mine's an M Sport with runflats so to be expected, perfectly comfortable on the motorway, it's only speed bumps that get uncomfortable. We've done 2 1000 mile plus road trips, and comfort was never really an issue.
Personally I think the 125i is one of BMW's hidden gems - overshadowed by the 135i, but what you lose in outright speed you gain in throttle response and that noise.
I've had a 125i for about 18 months now and love the thing - feels like a proper classic BMW - small size, manual box, straight 6, but without the classic tail-happiness. The rear seats are useable - bit of a pain to get into, but perfectly comfortable for anyone under 6 foot when you get in there. Mine is still running 125i power levels, but has plenty of grunt for day to day motoring.
Only slight criticism I have is the ride can get a bit challenging, but mine's an M Sport with runflats so to be expected, perfectly comfortable on the motorway, it's only speed bumps that get uncomfortable. We've done 2 1000 mile plus road trips, and comfort was never really an issue.
Personally I think the 125i is one of BMW's hidden gems - overshadowed by the 135i, but what you lose in outright speed you gain in throttle response and that noise.
bodhi said:
Fit the bigger front brakes from a 130i (just needs a caliper swap) and you have a 130i Coupe.
In fact the calipers are the same, you just need the bigger 330mm discs and the carriers that will move the existing calipers accordingly. Those carriers can be found on many BMW with the bigger discs, E90, Z4s, 123d etc etc - About £40/pair in a salvage.Btw, can I suggest you have the engine de-restricted asap ?
nickfrog said:
In fact the calipers are the same, you just need the bigger 330mm discs and the carriers that will move the existing calipers accordingly. Those carriers can be found on many BMW with the bigger discs, E90, Z4s, 123d etc etc - About £40/pair in a salvage.
Btw, can I suggest you have the engine de-restricted asap ?
Oh don't worry it's on the list of things to do Btw, can I suggest you have the engine de-restricted asap ?
I'm away with work for most of February and have about 3 weeks of hotels to finance first, but when the expenses come back from that I will hopefully be taking it to P-Torque to get de-corked - as long as SWMBO doesn't find something else to do with the money in the meantime....I'll need new brakes this year as well (OBC is showing 5,000 miles, but it has been showing that since I bought it) so will be a good chance to fit the bigger brakes too.
I bought a Z4 Coupe 18 months ago, having loved the look of them since they came out. I finally changed job so was no longer doing business miles with car allowance so I kicked my diseasal habit!
From what I have read the Z4 is the quickest model you will get with an N52 engine, and it certainly feels so much more special than my E46, 1 Series or E9* courtesy cars ever did. Plus the coupe is reputedly much stiffer than the convertible so handling should be better, and you have the perfect excuse to avoid any taxi duties!
I think if I needed more seats I would go for an upgraded 125 Coupe or 130i - they are smaller and lighter than any E9*s so should be more nimble.
My only slight reservation is that as far as I can tell only Z4s and 330 Coupes have a temperature gauge, which to my luddite way of thinking may be an issue given that thermostats have been reported to have stuck and the electric water pump with plastic impeller can be an issue! Plus N52s don't have a dipstick, so you have to rely on the sender working to check the oil level because if it were to fail you wouldn't know it was low!
Having said that the N52 sounds fantastic, and in Z4s you get the bonus of a sound generator so you can hear it better in the cabin - I hardly ever use the stereo!
Good luck anyway - I can't imagine a 3 litre N52 being a disappointment whatever it is fitted in!
From what I have read the Z4 is the quickest model you will get with an N52 engine, and it certainly feels so much more special than my E46, 1 Series or E9* courtesy cars ever did. Plus the coupe is reputedly much stiffer than the convertible so handling should be better, and you have the perfect excuse to avoid any taxi duties!
I think if I needed more seats I would go for an upgraded 125 Coupe or 130i - they are smaller and lighter than any E9*s so should be more nimble.
My only slight reservation is that as far as I can tell only Z4s and 330 Coupes have a temperature gauge, which to my luddite way of thinking may be an issue given that thermostats have been reported to have stuck and the electric water pump with plastic impeller can be an issue! Plus N52s don't have a dipstick, so you have to rely on the sender working to check the oil level because if it were to fail you wouldn't know it was low!
Having said that the N52 sounds fantastic, and in Z4s you get the bonus of a sound generator so you can hear it better in the cabin - I hardly ever use the stereo!
Good luck anyway - I can't imagine a 3 litre N52 being a disappointment whatever it is fitted in!
Not going on a quote fest here, but learned quite a few things -- so thanks for the excellent input
! Not sure if this makes deciding any easier, though...
Looking at weight/power, Z4C is first and with a gap E81, E82 (de-restricted), E92 all very close. Really like the Z4C styling, E82 second closely followed by the E92.
Function wise, the E92 and E81 seem like the best choice, Z4C last and E82 not much better. But my requirements in that area are so minimal it is not making much difference. The Z4C's lack of rear seats is equally appealing for 'no-taxi' reasons as it could be annoying on the very few occasions extra room could be useful...
Need to somehow get a test drive in an E82 and Z4C. The 3 series I know a bit with different engines.
Think else it is all going down to availability/price. Preliminary browsing of mobile.de indicates that the Z4C is nudging into collector pricing, 9 year old cars often seem to be offered for around 40% list. E82 and E92 a bit more 'normal' with a lot more choice of 3 series. At the lower end of the market there are a handful of E82s with basically 0-options which is somewhat appealing.
! Not sure if this makes deciding any easier, though...Looking at weight/power, Z4C is first and with a gap E81, E82 (de-restricted), E92 all very close. Really like the Z4C styling, E82 second closely followed by the E92.
Function wise, the E92 and E81 seem like the best choice, Z4C last and E82 not much better. But my requirements in that area are so minimal it is not making much difference. The Z4C's lack of rear seats is equally appealing for 'no-taxi' reasons as it could be annoying on the very few occasions extra room could be useful...
Need to somehow get a test drive in an E82 and Z4C. The 3 series I know a bit with different engines.
Think else it is all going down to availability/price. Preliminary browsing of mobile.de indicates that the Z4C is nudging into collector pricing, 9 year old cars often seem to be offered for around 40% list. E82 and E92 a bit more 'normal' with a lot more choice of 3 series. At the lower end of the market there are a handful of E82s with basically 0-options which is somewhat appealing.
Mr Tidy said:
Just to make your choice more difficult I had to add gratuitous photos of my Z4C!!
Hope you find what you want!
Thanks Hope you find what you want!
, and as expected that did not help. Just when I had more or less settled on a 1er Coupé you post this beauty BTW, any opinions on how good/bad the standard halogen lights are on the E81/E82/E87? Not sure what the xenons cost when new, but it must have been a fortune since there's a surprising amount of cars out here (even decently equipped otherwise) that run H7 lights...
Kolbenkopp said:
Just when I had more or less settled on a 1er Coupé you post this beauty
.
On that basis let me post a couple of pics of my E82 125i/130i. Not to everyone's taste but to me a superbly resolved designed although it took me a good 4 years to start liking it after launch, but then only 2 months after that to buy one.

Sorry for making things difficult, but it was the looks that drew me to a Z4C in the first place. They are really striking - I just love them.
Anyway, don't know about the standard lights as my E87 has Xenons. Just looked at a price list and they cost £415 in the UK - I was expecting them to cost more.
Just a quick heads-up as I collected mine from my local BMW Specialist this morning with it's new water pump.
As far as I know the N52 engines all have an electric water pump, and my new genuine part just cost me £420.84 + VAT!!!
My car has done 61,700 miles but another user seems to have managed 84,000 before his gave up, so depending on what age car you go for you might want to see if it has had a new pump so you know whether to budget for one.
Edited to add that on a forum dedicated to Z4s the consensus seems to be that water pumps last around 10 years regardless of mileage (mine was 9 years old in December 2015).
And to nickfrog, that is a lovely looking car you have. That colour seems to suit it really well.
Anyway, don't know about the standard lights as my E87 has Xenons. Just looked at a price list and they cost £415 in the UK - I was expecting them to cost more.
Just a quick heads-up as I collected mine from my local BMW Specialist this morning with it's new water pump.
As far as I know the N52 engines all have an electric water pump, and my new genuine part just cost me £420.84 + VAT!!!

My car has done 61,700 miles but another user seems to have managed 84,000 before his gave up, so depending on what age car you go for you might want to see if it has had a new pump so you know whether to budget for one.
Edited to add that on a forum dedicated to Z4s the consensus seems to be that water pumps last around 10 years regardless of mileage (mine was 9 years old in December 2015).
And to nickfrog, that is a lovely looking car you have. That colour seems to suit it really well.
Edited by Mr Tidy on Tuesday 26th January 19:12
Edited by Mr Tidy on Saturday 30th January 02:08
Mr Tidy said:
And to nickfrog, that is a lovely looking car you have. That colour seems to suit it really well.
Thanks ! Sadly, I sold it 12 months ago (at a profit from 18 months earlier??!!!).In some ways I miss it but the M135i has been a decent replacement in fairness. The engine is not quite as charismatic as the N52 though...
nickfrog said:
Thanks ! Sadly, I sold it 12 months ago (at a profit from 18 months earlier??!!!).
In some ways I miss it but the M135i has been a decent replacement in fairness. The engine is not quite as charismatic as the N52 though...
Well your loss is someone else's gain! And as you say, an M135i as a replacement isn't a disaster! In some ways I miss it but the M135i has been a decent replacement in fairness. The engine is not quite as charismatic as the N52 though...

Just to (hopefully) help with the case for the 125i, here's mine. Not quite as nice as Nick's but I like it.

Previous owner did a few upgrades (better speakers, Black Kidney Grille, Aftermarket Xenons) but thankfully resisted the temptation to get carried away. Done 25k in it in 18 months and it's been faultless, returning 29-35 mpg in the process. Never plan on selling it, when the finance is paid off I'll be keeping it for weekends and getting something in addition. Once you have an N52 in your life it is incredibly difficult to let it go

Previous owner did a few upgrades (better speakers, Black Kidney Grille, Aftermarket Xenons) but thankfully resisted the temptation to get carried away. Done 25k in it in 18 months and it's been faultless, returning 29-35 mpg in the process. Never plan on selling it, when the finance is paid off I'll be keeping it for weekends and getting something in addition. Once you have an N52 in your life it is incredibly difficult to let it go

Both really nice colours for an E82. Yum! Styling wise the 1er Coupé has really grown on me. So much so that I don't mind the 1er's signature side (pot-belly-pig
) at all. A bit too heavy, but apart from that as close to an E30 as it gets in modern times.
Appreciate the additional technical input chaps. Pump is definitely on the list of things to watch out for. Regarding E82 headlights, was afraid it would be like this. Not so costly workaround seems to be retrofitting after market projectors with (almost legal)
H7 65 watters. But much better to see if an acceptable specimen comes up in budget that has the xenons.
Interestingly, on the local market there are currently more Z4Cs than N52 E82s. But the asking prices for the E86 are definitely on the up and tad optimistic IMO. Think it is a telling sign when the two Z4Cs listed by official BMW dealers (nationwide!) look like OK value compared to the rest that is out there.
The few N52 E82s listed here seem to be better value in comparison, basically same budget (~18-20k EUR) buys you a car 3 years younger. On the other hand, the E82 still seems to be depreciating a bit.
The conclusion of course is that I need to stop wasting your kind souls time and get my arse out there to test drive the things. And just buy which ever I like better
.
Edit: any opinions on the 6 speed auto box in the E82? On the Z4C, I think I would not mind either way. The manual is my default preference, but the auto seems to have higher cruising gears (welcome on the Autobahn) and less issues with transmission noise (not really relevant, but would not mind having less of that in a GT setting).
) at all. A bit too heavy, but apart from that as close to an E30 as it gets in modern times. Appreciate the additional technical input chaps. Pump is definitely on the list of things to watch out for. Regarding E82 headlights, was afraid it would be like this. Not so costly workaround seems to be retrofitting after market projectors with (almost legal)
H7 65 watters. But much better to see if an acceptable specimen comes up in budget that has the xenons.Interestingly, on the local market there are currently more Z4Cs than N52 E82s. But the asking prices for the E86 are definitely on the up and tad optimistic IMO. Think it is a telling sign when the two Z4Cs listed by official BMW dealers (nationwide!) look like OK value compared to the rest that is out there.
The few N52 E82s listed here seem to be better value in comparison, basically same budget (~18-20k EUR) buys you a car 3 years younger. On the other hand, the E82 still seems to be depreciating a bit.
The conclusion of course is that I need to stop wasting your kind souls time and get my arse out there to test drive the things. And just buy which ever I like better
.Edit: any opinions on the 6 speed auto box in the E82? On the Z4C, I think I would not mind either way. The manual is my default preference, but the auto seems to have higher cruising gears (welcome on the Autobahn) and less issues with transmission noise (not really relevant, but would not mind having less of that in a GT setting).
Edited by Kolbenkopp on Wednesday 3rd February 00:51
Edited by Kolbenkopp on Wednesday 3rd February 00:51
I don't know about the E82 gearing, but my manual Z4 Coupe is only doing 3,000 rpm at between 80 and 85 mph in 6th so given that it happily revs to 7,000 rpm it seems to be reasonably high-geared for autobahns - 155 mph limiter will arrive way before the red-line!
If you don't ever need rear seats OP just get an E86 - over here they seem to be holding their price over the last year, so hopefully that trend will continue! I think rarity is a factor - they only made the E86 for about 3 years. And it is just so different getting into that driver's seat than any other BMW - makes it feel special every time you go out!
Whereas as good as the E82 is I think they are probably still dropping in value, and the driving seat doesn't offer much that my "old" E87 didn't have!
If you don't ever need rear seats OP just get an E86 - over here they seem to be holding their price over the last year, so hopefully that trend will continue! I think rarity is a factor - they only made the E86 for about 3 years. And it is just so different getting into that driver's seat than any other BMW - makes it feel special every time you go out!
Whereas as good as the E82 is I think they are probably still dropping in value, and the driving seat doesn't offer much that my "old" E87 didn't have!
Kolbenkopp said:
Both really nice colours for an E82. Yum! Styling wise the 1er Coupé has really grown on me. So much so that I don't mind the 1er's signature side (pot-belly-pig
) at all. A bit too heavy, but apart from that as close to an E30 as it gets in modern times.
Appreciate the additional technical input chaps. Pump is definitely on the list of things to watch out for. Regarding E82 headlights, was afraid it would be like this. Not so costly workaround seems to be retrofitting after market projectors with (almost legal)
H7 65 watters. But much better to see if an acceptable specimen comes up in budget that has the xenons.
Interestingly, on the local market there are currently more Z4Cs than N52 E82s. But the asking prices for the E86 are definitely on the up and tad optimistic IMO. Think it is a telling sign when the two Z4Cs listed by official BMW dealers (nationwide!) look like OK value compared to the rest that is out there.
The few N52 E82s listed here seem to be better value in comparison, basically same budget (~18-20k EUR) buys you a car 3 years younger. On the other hand, the E82 still seems to be depreciating a bit.
The conclusion of course is that I need to stop wasting your kind souls time and get my arse out there to test drive the things. And just buy which ever I like better
.
Edit: any opinions on the 6 speed auto box in the E82? On the Z4C, I think I would not mind either way. The manual is my default preference, but the auto seems to have higher cruising gears (welcome on the Autobahn) and less issues with transmission noise (not really relevant, but would not mind having less of that in a GT setting).
For i think a good write up on Z4 with auto, check out a thread from mid January by Tameracingdriver.
) at all. A bit too heavy, but apart from that as close to an E30 as it gets in modern times. Appreciate the additional technical input chaps. Pump is definitely on the list of things to watch out for. Regarding E82 headlights, was afraid it would be like this. Not so costly workaround seems to be retrofitting after market projectors with (almost legal)
H7 65 watters. But much better to see if an acceptable specimen comes up in budget that has the xenons.Interestingly, on the local market there are currently more Z4Cs than N52 E82s. But the asking prices for the E86 are definitely on the up and tad optimistic IMO. Think it is a telling sign when the two Z4Cs listed by official BMW dealers (nationwide!) look like OK value compared to the rest that is out there.
The few N52 E82s listed here seem to be better value in comparison, basically same budget (~18-20k EUR) buys you a car 3 years younger. On the other hand, the E82 still seems to be depreciating a bit.
The conclusion of course is that I need to stop wasting your kind souls time and get my arse out there to test drive the things. And just buy which ever I like better
.Edit: any opinions on the 6 speed auto box in the E82? On the Z4C, I think I would not mind either way. The manual is my default preference, but the auto seems to have higher cruising gears (welcome on the Autobahn) and less issues with transmission noise (not really relevant, but would not mind having less of that in a GT setting).
Edited by Kolbenkopp on Wednesday 3rd February 00:51
Edited by Kolbenkopp on Wednesday 3rd February 00:51
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


