New 320i Sport Auto or 320d ED Plus Auto?
New 320i Sport Auto or 320d ED Plus Auto?
Author
Discussion

Pioneer

Original Poster:

1,351 posts

162 months

Tuesday 19th January 2016
quotequote all
Trying to decide between these. Has anyone driven both? The ED Plus comes with leather and is more economical however cabin noise is meant to be worse plus power is down and wheels restricted to 16" to get the mpg. I've also read the engine isn't as refined as you'd expect. 320i Sport has the cosmetic advantages but I suspect the overall driving experience will be better which is more important to me. MPG is lower obviously but not too fussed about that. It won't be used for regular long journeys, mostly short journeys 4 or 5 times a week and the occasional 5-6 hour journey maybe once a month. It's replacing a 318d SE with just under 30k on it so we've done less than 10k per year in this one. Will probably be the same amount of use in the new one. None of the local dealers to me have either car available to test drive. Any feedback is appreciated.

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Tuesday 19th January 2016
quotequote all
Pioneer said:
Trying to decide between these. Has anyone driven both? The ED Plus comes with leather and is more economical however cabin noise is meant to be worse plus power is down and wheels restricted to 16" to get the mpg. I've also read the engine isn't as refined as you'd expect. 320i Sport has the cosmetic advantages but I suspect the overall driving experience will be better which is more important to me. MPG is lower obviously but not too fussed about that. It won't be used for regular long journeys, mostly short journeys 4 or 5 times a week and the occasional 5-6 hour journey maybe once a month. It's replacing a 318d SE with just under 30k on it so we've done less than 10k per year in this one. Will probably be the same amount of use in the new one. None of the local dealers to me have either car available to test drive. Any feedback is appreciated.
My neighbour suffers with ED, has done for 5 years, but then he's a high mile company car driver which the ED is geared towards I thought? It's funny you mention less refined, cos I always thought his cars sounded rougher than the other BMW diesels in the neighbourhood and certainly does when compared to the 320d (normal) and 520d (normal) loan cars I've brought home.

Based on my drives of normal 320d and use of the auto box in other 2l BMWs, I can't see why the 320i would be a worse choice for you, other than lower fuel consumption, but your miles don't really justify that as a concern.

Aren't there any Approved Used cars , ED and 320i, that you could try, @ dealers near you, if there are no demos?


Pioneer

Original Poster:

1,351 posts

162 months

Tuesday 19th January 2016
quotequote all
We're out in the sticks so the choice of dealers within a reasonable distance is limited. There's a couple of 320d M Sport Autos around but the ride/set-up is different. A couple of reviews have said the ED Plus engine is quite noisy compared to the standard diesel, also the general cabin noise. I have no idea why that would be - maybe to do with the active air flaps behind the front grill on the ED?

Mr Tidy

31,949 posts

158 months

Thursday 21st January 2016
quotequote all
OP, for the mileage you propose Diesel is probably not the right option!

And talking to my local BMW specialist yesterday he doesn't recommend anything with less than 6 cylinders, and generally the older the better! (He runs a 52 plate 530i as his daily, which is hopefully a clue as to the ideal scenario)!

Newer may be "better" while they are in warranty, but they are likely to bite you in the ar*e after that!

Good luck anyway! thumbup

CraigyMc

18,374 posts

267 months

Wednesday 10th February 2016
quotequote all
Pioneer said:
We're out in the sticks so the choice of dealers within a reasonable distance is limited. There's a couple of 320d M Sport Autos around but the ride/set-up is different. A couple of reviews have said the ED Plus engine is quite noisy compared to the standard diesel, also the general cabin noise. I have no idea why that would be - maybe to do with the active air flaps behind the front grill on the ED?
I drive an E90 ED. It's not louder than the usual 320d (it's the same engine with 20bhp less). If anything the car is quieter due to longer gearing and non RFT tyres, which also mean it has a nicer ride.

Given your original post it sounds like you'd be better off with the petrol anyway.

Craig