E92 330d or 335d?
Discussion
I am looking for a bit of advice about purchasing an E92 330 or 335d coupe.
I have a budget of about £10k and I'm hoping those in the know can advise me as to which car to go for. A bit of background is that I do about 28k miles per year, hence the reason for wanting a diesel. Most of my miles are motorway/dual carriageway, but I do enjoy a bit of a hoon on weekends so a good blend of performance and economy is important.
Looking at my budget, I reckon I should find a tidy 2007ish 80k miler for that money, can folks in the know advise me between the two? What is the real world difference between the two in performance and economy, what mpg can I expect to get sat at 70mph on the motorway?
Also, I will be considering a re-map once I have purchased, mainly for the fuel economy improvement. I am not that fussed between an auto and a manual, obviously a 335d is auto only. Also, are there any discernible differences in reliability/things going wrong between the two?
Thanks in advance.
I have a budget of about £10k and I'm hoping those in the know can advise me as to which car to go for. A bit of background is that I do about 28k miles per year, hence the reason for wanting a diesel. Most of my miles are motorway/dual carriageway, but I do enjoy a bit of a hoon on weekends so a good blend of performance and economy is important.
Looking at my budget, I reckon I should find a tidy 2007ish 80k miler for that money, can folks in the know advise me between the two? What is the real world difference between the two in performance and economy, what mpg can I expect to get sat at 70mph on the motorway?
Also, I will be considering a re-map once I have purchased, mainly for the fuel economy improvement. I am not that fussed between an auto and a manual, obviously a 335d is auto only. Also, are there any discernible differences in reliability/things going wrong between the two?
Thanks in advance.
No real differences in reliability between them apart from gearbox if you compare to a 330 manual.
Around that mileage look out for the following
Swirl flap seals leaking
Manifold seals leaking
Perished vacuum hoses leading to poor boost
Failed actuators on the 335d bi-turbo system
Failed glow plugs and controller
Failed thermostats (the engine has 2 of them)
Blocked DPF
Don't want to put you off but these are all common items around 80-120k miles at that age. If the cars you look at have these already taken care of then it's a bonus.
Around that mileage look out for the following
Swirl flap seals leaking
Manifold seals leaking
Perished vacuum hoses leading to poor boost
Failed actuators on the 335d bi-turbo system
Failed glow plugs and controller
Failed thermostats (the engine has 2 of them)
Blocked DPF
Don't want to put you off but these are all common items around 80-120k miles at that age. If the cars you look at have these already taken care of then it's a bonus.
My 2009 330d auto would do nearly 50 mpg on a gentle m/way cruise. (70 mph) It was a great all rounder. Dont overlook the 325d either, as it had the same 3.0 engine, but boost restricted by the map. A remap would make both cars around 290 BHP.
335d is lovely, but 0-60 in 6s for the 330d is hardly sluggish, and it felt faster than that. 335d woud be at least 4 mpg down overall. I had an E92 M3 after the 330d, and found its lack of torque & DCT gearbox that tried to keep the revs below 2k in auto mode very irritating.
335d is lovely, but 0-60 in 6s for the 330d is hardly sluggish, and it felt faster than that. 335d woud be at least 4 mpg down overall. I had an E92 M3 after the 330d, and found its lack of torque & DCT gearbox that tried to keep the revs below 2k in auto mode very irritating.
Duncan McKay said:
I am looking for a bit of advice about purchasing an E92 330 or 335d coupe.
I have a budget of about £10k and I'm hoping those in the know can advise me as to which car to go for. A bit of background is that I do about 28k miles per year, hence the reason for wanting a diesel. Most of my miles are motorway/dual carriageway, but I do enjoy a bit of a hoon on weekends so a good blend of performance and economy is important.
Looking at my budget, I reckon I should find a tidy 2007ish 80k miler for that money, can folks in the know advise me between the two? What is the real world difference between the two in performance and economy, what mpg can I expect to get sat at 70mph on the motorway?
Also, I will be considering a re-map once I have purchased, mainly for the fuel economy improvement. I am not that fussed between an auto and a manual, obviously a 335d is auto only. Also, are there any discernible differences in reliability/things going wrong between the two?
Thanks in advance.
Something that's missing from your write up is whether M Sport or SE is a factor. I did a quick autotrader query around your spec {of budget and miles} and cars around your budget were all SEs, irrespective of whether they were 330d or 335d.I have a budget of about £10k and I'm hoping those in the know can advise me as to which car to go for. A bit of background is that I do about 28k miles per year, hence the reason for wanting a diesel. Most of my miles are motorway/dual carriageway, but I do enjoy a bit of a hoon on weekends so a good blend of performance and economy is important.
Looking at my budget, I reckon I should find a tidy 2007ish 80k miler for that money, can folks in the know advise me between the two? What is the real world difference between the two in performance and economy, what mpg can I expect to get sat at 70mph on the motorway?
Also, I will be considering a re-map once I have purchased, mainly for the fuel economy improvement. I am not that fussed between an auto and a manual, obviously a 335d is auto only. Also, are there any discernible differences in reliability/things going wrong between the two?
Thanks in advance.
You need to check, but I'm almost certain that like the petrol 335i (I have a M Sport) the 335d SE gets the sports seats and suspension as standard. If these are important factors to you (I for one hate SE seats/suspension) then a 330d SE may not be a good choice.
Although it's going to come down to the specific car as it's possible a 335SE owner deleted sport option/s and maybe (if that was possible) a 330SE owner added them? But I think you get my drift

Hope this helps.
Vee said:
No real differences in reliability between them apart from gearbox if you compare to a 330 manual.
Around that mileage look out for the following
Swirl flap seals leaking
Manifold seals leaking
Perished vacuum hoses leading to poor boost
Failed actuators on the 335d bi-turbo system
Failed glow plugs and controller
Failed thermostats (the engine has 2 of them)
Blocked DPF
Don't want to put you off but these are all common items around 80-120k miles at that age. If the cars you look at have these already taken care of then it's a bonus.
Thanks for the info, very valuable. Both cars that I have in mind have not had these issues looked at as far as I know, would you recommend a fixed price inspection before purchasing to check these things?Around that mileage look out for the following
Swirl flap seals leaking
Manifold seals leaking
Perished vacuum hoses leading to poor boost
Failed actuators on the 335d bi-turbo system
Failed glow plugs and controller
Failed thermostats (the engine has 2 of them)
Blocked DPF
Don't want to put you off but these are all common items around 80-120k miles at that age. If the cars you look at have these already taken care of then it's a bonus.
Thanks for the info Bungle, I think what I'm getting from this is that it is marginal for both. I have heard that an Auto tends to handle a remap better than a manual because of clutch issues, is this true?
The two cars that I am considering are below, the 330 has a better spec but is 12k worse on miles, I'm really a bit torn!
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
The two cars that I am considering are below, the 330 has a better spec but is 12k worse on miles, I'm really a bit torn!
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
Duncan McKay said:
Thanks for the info Bungle, I think what I'm getting from this is that it is marginal for both. I have heard that an Auto tends to handle a remap better than a manual because of clutch issues, is this true?
The two cars that I am considering are below, the 330 has a better spec but is 12k worse on miles, I'm really a bit torn!
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
I'd go for 330 which is plenty quick for your daily duties, even when stock. I know squat* about diesel remaps, but on the premise you can increase fuel consumption (your priority) and also performance with one map then even better The two cars that I am considering are below, the 330 has a better spec but is 12k worse on miles, I'm really a bit torn!
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...

- I've not heard any concerns for manual gearboxes on 335i remaps though, at least within reasonable limits.
I hate the step auto and think for fun driving it's best to have a manual as there's no DCT on the diesels.
The wheels on the 335d look awful. They are definitely 19s, whereas I have a feeling the 330's are 18s, which mean cheaper tyres and likely a better ride.
Plus 330 looks better as it's a M Sport.
It's a shame it's higher miles, but as I found when looking at E92s that's not a given that it's likely to have more problems within your ownership. If these are the 2 on the shortlist just make sure you research their history as thoroughly as you can.
Smuler said:
I've not heard any concerns for manual gearboxes on 335i remaps though, at least within reasonable limits.
I hate the step auto and think for fun driving it's best to have a manual as there's no DCT on the diesels.
Just bear in mind that a mapped 335i will probably push out rather less torque than a mapped 330d!I hate the step auto and think for fun driving it's best to have a manual as there's no DCT on the diesels.
It's each to their own where gearboxes are concerned but, much as I love a manual, I really think an auto suits the character of a big diesel rather better. You don't rev a diesel through the gears in the way you do a petrol and for me you're better with an auto that just keeps it in its relatively narrow power band.....
Vee said:
No real differences in reliability between them apart from gearbox if you compare to a 330 manual.
Around that mileage look out for the following
Swirl flap seals leaking
Manifold seals leaking
Perished vacuum hoses leading to poor boost
Failed actuators on the 335d bi-turbo system
Failed glow plugs and controller
Failed thermostats (the engine has 2 of them)
Blocked DPF
Don't want to put you off but these are all common items around 80-120k miles at that age. If the cars you look at have these already taken care of then it's a bonus.
This is a great post and not one to be overlooked. These are very very common issues, you don't have to look far on dedicated forums to find people suffering with any of the above.. Thermostats are linked to DPF issues etc.Around that mileage look out for the following
Swirl flap seals leaking
Manifold seals leaking
Perished vacuum hoses leading to poor boost
Failed actuators on the 335d bi-turbo system
Failed glow plugs and controller
Failed thermostats (the engine has 2 of them)
Blocked DPF
Don't want to put you off but these are all common items around 80-120k miles at that age. If the cars you look at have these already taken care of then it's a bonus.
To add, the swirl flaps can still fail, removal is recommended.. And the manifolds commonly crack too as well as seals leaning.
I'd buy the auto but again at this sort of miles you should really be looking at a fluid change.
As a 330d owner I was looking to change to a 335d but for that type of budget, you'll probably find a newer, better spec 330d over a 335d.
I think the E92 got a facelift in 2009 and the gearbox paddles changed around the same time, you might find your budget will put you into 330 facelift but not 335.
I think the E92 got a facelift in 2009 and the gearbox paddles changed around the same time, you might find your budget will put you into 330 facelift but not 335.
30d engine gorgeous.
35d engine sublime.
I drive an '09 plate 535d (therefore post LCI pre F10/11)
Advantage of 35 over 30 is twin turbo which means the engine is less stressed and also treated to larger cooling fan. downside is mpg on the 35d will always be low 30's if lots of urban.
35d torque is waves and waves of it; bi-turbo always ensures traffic lights are interesting...... There would be no real reason to re-chip it unless your hankering was killing you.
35d engine sublime.
I drive an '09 plate 535d (therefore post LCI pre F10/11)
Advantage of 35 over 30 is twin turbo which means the engine is less stressed and also treated to larger cooling fan. downside is mpg on the 35d will always be low 30's if lots of urban.
35d torque is waves and waves of it; bi-turbo always ensures traffic lights are interesting...... There would be no real reason to re-chip it unless your hankering was killing you.
JNW1 said:
It's each to their own where gearboxes are concerned but, much as I love a manual, I really think an auto suits the character of a big diesel rather better. You don't rev a diesel through the gears in the way you do a petrol and for me you're better with an auto that just keeps it in its relatively narrow power band.....
Agree with this and have had two diesel's mated to an auto and one mated to a manual and a diesel mated to a manual gearbox isn't my idea of a good time and for me a diesel engine mated to an auto is a good partnership. Thanks for the responses guys. I agree that a post LCI 330d would probably best match my requirements, but I can't find a vehicle that fits inside my budget.
I think I am leaning towards the 335d, partially because of the lower miles but also because of the auto box which, having read some comments here, seems to better suit the nature of the car.
If a 330d with an auto was nearby, that may complicate things again!
I think I am leaning towards the 335d, partially because of the lower miles but also because of the auto box which, having read some comments here, seems to better suit the nature of the car.
If a 330d with an auto was nearby, that may complicate things again!
Duncan McKay said:
Thanks for the responses guys. I agree that a post LCI 330d would probably best match my requirements, but I can't find a vehicle that fits inside my budget.
I think I am leaning towards the 335d, partially because of the lower miles but also because of the auto box which, having read some comments here, seems to better suit the nature of the car.
If a 330d with an auto was nearby, that may complicate things again!
time to maybe use your negotiating skills ? I think I am leaning towards the 335d, partially because of the lower miles but also because of the auto box which, having read some comments here, seems to better suit the nature of the car.
If a 330d with an auto was nearby, that may complicate things again!

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...
Smuler said:
You have picked a nice one out there, perfect colour combo for me and nice spec too. Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


