X5 3.0 SD HOW much fuel?
X5 3.0 SD HOW much fuel?
Author
Discussion

fredt

Original Poster:

847 posts

178 months

Wednesday 27th January 2016
quotequote all
Returns 21.5 mpg average (Computer not measured either...). Mostly school runs to be fair with a couple of longer journey / month.

Is this normal?

scenario8

8,011 posts

210 months

Wednesday 27th January 2016
quotequote all
What sort of return do you expect for a two ton car with a relatively large capacity Diesel engine covering mostly short distances? For reference my measly 1.6 litre diesel golf will happily consume at a rate of 35mpg or worse in short journeys in heavy traffic. It can also run at 60 plus very easily under different conditions. I average less than Foyt while colleagues with differing circumstances average just under that 60 figure.

Aren't there websites out there with real life consumption statistics? I'm mildly interested to find out if yours is broken or normal.

Luke.

12,052 posts

281 months

Wednesday 27th January 2016
quotequote all
I get a only little less than that in my 4.8i V8...

scenario8

8,011 posts

210 months

Wednesday 27th January 2016
quotequote all
I'm becoming more interested now. When in London (not in Kent or driving up to London) what would you get on a typical 5 mile journey (ie a school run) from cold? 15?

Luke.

12,052 posts

281 months

Wednesday 27th January 2016
quotequote all
scenario8 said:
I'm becoming more interested now. When in London (not in Kent or driving up to London) what would you get on a typical 5 mile journey (ie a school run) from cold? 15?
Me? 19-20.

28 mpg or so at 60..

Edited by Luke. on Wednesday 27th January 17:31

laingy

676 posts

272 months

Wednesday 27th January 2016
quotequote all
seems low, mine is 25 mpg - similar short journeys. doesnt go much above 30mpg on a run though.

scenario8

8,011 posts

210 months

Wednesday 27th January 2016
quotequote all
Luke. said:
scenario8 said:
I'm becoming more interested now. When in London (not in Kent or driving up to London) what would you get on a typical 5 mile journey (ie a school run) from cold? 15?
Me? 19-20.
Interesting. Plenty of V8 Range Rover owners boast of 12 or worse. 19 is a pleasant surprise.

I imagine the specific types of journey and driving style would make a massive difference to fuel consumption but it doesn't surprise me particularly that on very short journeys in heavy traffic a diesel unit is only a few percent more fuel efficient than a petrol near equivalent.

AB

20,680 posts

226 months

Wednesday 27th January 2016
quotequote all
The engine is probably a bit too wheezy for the bulk. Bet you'd get no worse in a 40d

Spuffington

1,355 posts

199 months

Wednesday 27th January 2016
quotequote all
Had a 3.0d pre-LCI and 40d LCI - both returned 26.4mpg on the nose with a mixture of long and urban cycles over a total of 3.5yrs.

I reckon your, mostly urban (or at least less economical) cycle is about right.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Wednesday 27th January 2016
quotequote all
Is this FredT from Muswell Hill?

If it is, the C320 I got from you that was averaging 29mpg over the last few thousand miles according to the OBC, is showing 38mpg over the 2000 miles I have done in it since December. But living in Norfolk helps a lot.

My X5 never managed more than 27mpg from a tank, and I was doing 30k miles a year at the time. Would often see 22/23, and only ever saw 30+ on trips to France.


I have to say, the F25 X3 keeps blowing me away in regard to MPG.
I managed 700 miles again from a tank last week doing my Norwich to London run and back 3x, that is sat at 75mph for 95% of the journey.
I got £67 in the tank when filling it back up, which works out at 50mpg.
Purely round town I get 480-500 miles from each tank, which is around 35mpg.

Having said that though, I really wish it was a petrol.


Guy

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Wednesday 27th January 2016
quotequote all
I have an E53 3.0 d and a 4.0 d one. Both average about 22-26 .

One thanks the Lord for the fuel card

AdamD

501 posts

251 months

Wednesday 27th January 2016
quotequote all
Luke. said:
I get a only little less than that in my 4.8i V8...
Useful to know, I rather want the v8 and assumed the diesel would be nearer 30mpg. biggrin I could live with 20mpg, my Z4M does 22 wink

Cheib

25,489 posts

206 months

Wednesday 27th January 2016
quotequote all
fredt said:
Returns 21.5 mpg average (Computer not measured either...). Mostly school runs to be fair with a couple of longer journey / month.

Is this normal?
That's about right. I have been running an X5 SD that I bought new 8 years ago. MPG is not one of its strong points especially on short urban journeys....on a run I might see 30 mpg but that is only is I stick religiously to the 70mph limit creep over that and it comes down relatively quickly.

The later 40d cars with the eight speed box are much better on mpg. I've thought about changing but my car is high spec has only just done 50,000 miles and is still under warranty.

8Tech

2,222 posts

229 months

Thursday 28th January 2016
quotequote all
AdamD said:
Luke. said:
I get a only little less than that in my 4.8i V8...
Useful to know, I rather want the v8 and assumed the diesel would be nearer 30mpg. biggrin I could live with 20mpg, my Z4M does 22 wink
My E53 4.8iS manages around 23mpg around town but if I put it on cruise at 60mph I get well over 30 mpg, nearing 36mpg. I never do that though cos its really boring so running at "normal" clear motorway speeds off cruise I will get 26+ mpg on a run.

My friends 35d X-Drive E70 X5 with half my cars mileage on a 2008 struggles with 20mpg.

I think that at this point in X5 production, the engineers aims were to get as much fuel economy from the 4.8i V8 petrol, and decent power from a 3.0D in such a heavy car and to hell with the mpg. I think they lost their way a bit when the economy's of the two crossed over!


Edited by 8Tech on Thursday 28th January 00:44

Cheib

25,489 posts

206 months

Thursday 28th January 2016
quotequote all
8Tech said:
My E53 4.8iS manages around 23mpg around town but if I put it on cruise at 60mph I get well over 30 mpg, nearing 36mpg. I never do that though cos its really boring so running at "normal" clear motorway speeds off cruise I will get 26+ mpg on a run.

My friends 35d X-Drive E70 X5 with half my cars mileage on a 2008 struggles with 20mpg.

I think that at this point in X5 production, the engineers aims were to get as much fuel economy from the 4.8i V8 petrol, and decent power from a 3.0D in such a heavy car and to hell with the mpg. I think they lost their way a bit when the economy's of the two crossed over!


Edited by 8Tech on Thursday 28th January 00:44
The main thing they were targetting with the diesels was the 225g/km CO2 target because Red Ken if he had won the vote for London Mayor (instead of Boris) was going to bring in a £30 charge for the London Congestion Charge over that threshold. The X5 diesels when I bought mine at the end of 2007 were the only large SUV's that beat that target...indeed the X5 was launched in May 2007 and when Red Ken launched his manifesto BMW quickly rushed through the Efficient Dynamics upgrades in Sep 2007 specifically because of the UK. Must be the quickest update to a model in BMW's history!

I was going to originally order my car in July 2007 but was told to wait by my friendly London based dealer who had been tipped off about the update....

The Livster

222 posts

147 months

Thursday 28th January 2016
quotequote all
Mmmm !!

Seems my M5 is reasonably efficient averaging 20 mostly stop start and 30 on a run, my man maths was correct when switching from a 640d wink;)

Vixpy1

42,699 posts

295 months

Thursday 28th January 2016
quotequote all
get the thermostats changed, we average 24 doing same sort of journeys

fredt

Original Poster:

847 posts

178 months

Thursday 28th January 2016
quotequote all
gizlaroc said:
Is this FredT from Muswell Hill?

If it is, the C320 I got from you that was averaging 29mpg over the last few thousand miles according to the OBC, is showing 38mpg over the 2000 miles I have done in it since December. But living in Norfolk helps a lot.

My X5 never managed more than 27mpg from a tank, and I was doing 30k miles a year at the time. Would often see 22/23, and only ever saw 30+ on trips to France.


I have to say, the F25 X3 keeps blowing me away in regard to MPG.
I managed 700 miles again from a tank last week doing my Norwich to London run and back 3x, that is sat at 75mph for 95% of the journey.
I got £67 in the tank when filling it back up, which works out at 50mpg.
Purely round town I get 480-500 miles from each tank, which is around 35mpg.

Having said that though, I really wish it was a petrol.


Guy
It is smile How is my old car doing? Did you tart it up or just running it as it was?


Thanks all for input, seems it is not completely ridiculous. I knew it wasn't going to be great on fuel but I hadn't researched it and I didn't think it'd be that far off official figures. I'd probably have a V8 over the SD knowing what I know, but I was buying on price/spec and at the time there was nothing near this one in that regard.


redneckLT

84 posts

172 months

Thursday 28th January 2016
quotequote all
40d. Got 22 mpg in similar conditions recently, in this cold weather. 26 mpg was best 50/50 long journeys/ town driving.

Luke.

12,052 posts

281 months

Thursday 28th January 2016
quotequote all
See, y'all shoulda gone V8 smile