E36: 323i vs 328i
Discussion
Hi, I´m having a bit of trouble with my 328i Touring (1996, 125,000 miles, a few former owners). Oil consumption is high, about 1 litre/600 miles, there is blue smoke when flooring the throttle, small black spots in the tailgate, spark plugs fouled with oil, a bit of "door shake" at idle (but it idles perfectly and starts first time) and in general I don´t see the engine as smooth as it should (through no flat spots or hesitate).
After a CCV change and a compression test that showed acceptable but not great figures, and as I suspect oil rings shot or even damaged nikasil bores, I´m tempted to buy a 1996, one owner, only 45,000 miles from new 323i saloon. I prefer the Touring styling (although I don´t need the big rear boot) and I would miss the sunroof, but the 323i seems in very good shape and it has leather and 18 button OBC (I like those extras). I haven´t tested the 323i for sale yet.
The bottom end is it would be cheaper to buy the 323i, save the 328i´s expensive repairs and sell pricing it accordingly. But is there a big difference in performance or driving pleasure between both? If so, would it be difficult to gain 10-15 bhp in a 323i? After all with 170 bhp the 2.5 litre engine seems very under stressed.
Thanks a lot!
After a CCV change and a compression test that showed acceptable but not great figures, and as I suspect oil rings shot or even damaged nikasil bores, I´m tempted to buy a 1996, one owner, only 45,000 miles from new 323i saloon. I prefer the Touring styling (although I don´t need the big rear boot) and I would miss the sunroof, but the 323i seems in very good shape and it has leather and 18 button OBC (I like those extras). I haven´t tested the 323i for sale yet.
The bottom end is it would be cheaper to buy the 323i, save the 328i´s expensive repairs and sell pricing it accordingly. But is there a big difference in performance or driving pleasure between both? If so, would it be difficult to gain 10-15 bhp in a 323i? After all with 170 bhp the 2.5 litre engine seems very under stressed.
Thanks a lot!
Dannbodge said:
Adding the M50 manifold + remap and 328i exhaust system would push the 323i up to standard 328i power anyway.
It´s good to know that it´s not difficult to get some extra power.I´ve been reading some magazines road test and the differences in performance are small, even CAR Magazine in 1997 timed the 323i doing the 0-60 in 7,3 seconds (!) so it seems isn´t slow unmodified.
Thanks.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


