1 series (E87)... 130 or 135i?
1 series (E87)... 130 or 135i?
Author
Discussion

jayemm89

Original Poster:

4,475 posts

161 months

Saturday 30th January 2016
quotequote all
Hi all

Someone I know is looking at getting a 1 series. They don't need the economy of diesel etc etc... and I talked them into going for a six pot. My natural instinct is to try and set them up with a 135i. The cars which fall in budget seem mostly to be the earlier twin-turbo models. However, I've read a few things regarding the 35i engine, it having a few issues. Given the fact that the 130i is going to be plenty of poke anyway, is it worth going for the 130i instead... or is the 135i still a solid motor and a LOT more fun, or just a little bit?

Thanks all!

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Saturday 30th January 2016
quotequote all
I've the N54 you're on about in E92 335i;fault wise, only had to replace fuel injectors. Car is @80k miles 2009/59 and is driven hard. I wouldn't be put off getting fastest car , if that's what is wanted.
130i is the hatchback only.
But I've read on here you can get 125i coupe and tune it up to 130 power levels.

Can't say I would dismiss this car, but like you my natural instinct was to go for fastest , in this case 135i coupe.

jayemm89

Original Poster:

4,475 posts

161 months

Saturday 30th January 2016
quotequote all
So they didn't make a 130i coupe? Curious.

My knowledge on the 1-series is very limited.

It's a bit frustrating because the car is for a female who loves the look of the one series and loves small cars. I recently had a 6 series with every option under the sun and a tasty V8 for about half what these 1 series are going for!

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Saturday 30th January 2016
quotequote all
No idea why no 130i coupe.
I googled brochure and 125i, stock, was 218bhp v 306 for 135i
There's a recent post on here, where advice is given on tuning up the 125i, but not everyone wants to mod. I wouldn't, I'd go for 135i.
They do , however, seem to cost a premium over the 3 series. I believe that's supply and demand. I don't like the look of any 1er, but if your friend finds 3 series too big , fair enough.

You don't mention budget but later 135i's come with the DCT. Okay, if she is die hard manual transmission fan, stick with that. But otherwise DCT much better than ordinary 6 speed auto in auto mode and even more so in manual mode, which I use and is a good compromise.

bodhi

14,839 posts

260 months

Saturday 30th January 2016
quotequote all
I wouldn't worry about modding the 125i, it's the exact same engine as the 130i, just had the wick turned down. Under 400 bucks will get it turned back up again.

Not driven a 135i but the 125 is superb, fantastic reliable engine, lots of great noises and never seems slow.

jayemm89

Original Poster:

4,475 posts

161 months

Saturday 30th January 2016
quotequote all
Given the fact she probably wants a coupe, and probably a 'vert, I will keep an eye out for 135i I think. It wouldn't bother her much to have a 125i but I would use the car too and I think I'd appreciate it. Will probably also help come resale time.

I just hope it doesn't wind up being quicker than my M3 :-S

Mr Tidy

31,949 posts

158 months

Monday 1st February 2016
quotequote all
jayemm89 said:
Given the fact she probably wants a coupe, and probably a 'vert, I will keep an eye out for 135i I think. It wouldn't bother her much to have a 125i but I would use the car too and I think I'd appreciate it. Will probably also help come resale time.

I just hope it doesn't wind up being quicker than my M3 :-S
Won't ever be quicker than your M3, unless yours is a girly convertible like "she" wants!laugh

Take the most focussed drivers' car ever, then cut the roof off and wonder why it doesn't handle too well!

Personally I would go for the 130i, but what do I know........

moffat

1,020 posts

256 months

Monday 1st February 2016
quotequote all
I had two 135i's - a Coupe and a Vert and loved both of them.

With the Vert I did some mild modding:

1. BMW Performance Exhaust
2. BMW Peformance Short Shift Kit
3. JB4 chip which puts out around 370bhp

Overall it was epic and slightly quicker than an E46 M3.

Highly recommend the exhaust.

135i also has BMW branded 6 pot Brembo brakes, hydraulic steering as opposed to electric - both really help the car.

So 135i ALL the way for me.

jayemm89

Original Poster:

4,475 posts

161 months

Monday 1st February 2016
quotequote all
Yeah I think the convertible is the preferred, or at least a coupe. The hatchback isn't on her radar.

If there was a 130i I think I would be strongly considering it but given the fact it doesn't exist for whatever reason I think it'll have to be a 135 when the time comes. Some really nice ones out there... although a worrying number of Cat Ds!

aeropilot

40,928 posts

258 months

Monday 1st February 2016
quotequote all
jayemm89 said:
Yeah I think the convertible is the preferred, or at least a coupe. The hatchback isn't on her radar.

If there was a 130i I think I would be strongly considering it but given the fact it doesn't exist for whatever reason I think it'll have to be a 135 when the time comes.
I'd point her in the direction of the 125i vert then rather than a 135i, if the vert is on her radar.

For a start, there's more of them to choose from, as there weren't a lot of 135i verts sold in the UK, and also the less torquey/less powerfull n/a six pot in the vert is better suited to the floppy bodyshell of the vert than 300+hp of the 135i.
If she wants coupe then the 135i is an option, but, yes, budget wise, if it's not got a warranty for those turbo's or they haven't been replaced already, the bullet-proof reliability of the N52 in the 125i is the much better bet.

Remster500

206 posts

248 months

Monday 1st February 2016
quotequote all
My wife has had her 135i Cabriolet for the last 2 years and it has been a joy to own. The sound of the engine and associated effortless performance is wonderful with the roof either up or down. Her car is a very high spec. with all options ticked including the rare black denim roof which is much better than std. It also has the gunmetal 18" alloys which look lovely against the Sapphire Black bodywork. Someone had paid a lot of money originally!

We've had no issues with the car in our ownership and have continued to service it with BMW (even brake fluid service). She only does 5k miles a year so fuel isn't an issue but it will do 30mpg on a run. I have just arranged its MOT for later this week and have planned for selling it in the next few months. Only reason for sale is mileage going up this year and we now have a dog and growing child to consider!

I am happy to provide further details and pics. if your friend is interested.


Edited by Remster500 on Tuesday 2nd February 08:25

Remster500

206 posts

248 months

Tuesday 2nd February 2016
quotequote all
Forgot to mention that given the rarity of the 135i Cabriolet, they are holding value better than the rest of the E87 range. We have been offered good money on 2 occasions to buy the car whilst in our ownership.