main dealer defeated?
main dealer defeated?
Author
Discussion

SimoN138

Original Poster:

223 posts

263 months

Monday 1st February 2016
quotequote all
Hi,

Our 2011 x3 3.0 has developed an annoying whistle on over run ... once it is warm if you lift completely off the throttle at low speed there's a squeaky, whistling noise that comes from the near side front ... not loud but annoying and definitely not correct. no other symptoms.

The car has been in 3 times to have the issue fixed, always to our local main dealer in north london, and they have failed completely. at first they claimed not to be able to replicate the issue and since then they have been trying to work out what is wrong.

they have replaced the alternator belt (twice), the water pump and the alternator itself ... nothing has worked and they are now at a loss as to what to try next.

the car has been with them for 12 days so far on this visit alone ... we have a loan car from them but we'd quite like ours back (because we want to sell it!).

we have BMW extended warrantee so not too worried about costs, but it's getting beyond funny now.

so, two questions ...

- any ideas what the issue might be?
- what happens if they cannot fix it and give up?


Si

Theophany

1,069 posts

161 months

Monday 1st February 2016
quotequote all
SimoN138 said:
Hi,

Our 2011 x3 3.0 has developed an annoying whistle on over run ... once it is warm if you lift completely off the throttle at low speed there's a squeaky, whistling noise that comes from the near side front ... not loud but annoying and definitely not correct. no other symptoms.

The car has been in 3 times to have the issue fixed, always to our local main dealer in north london, and they have failed completely. at first they claimed not to be able to replicate the issue and since then they have been trying to work out what is wrong.

they have replaced the alternator belt (twice), the water pump and the alternator itself ... nothing has worked and they are now at a loss as to what to try next.

the car has been with them for 12 days so far on this visit alone ... we have a loan car from them but we'd quite like ours back (because we want to sell it!).

we have BMW extended warrantee so not too worried about costs, but it's getting beyond funny now.

so, two questions ...

- any ideas what the issue might be?
- what happens if they cannot fix it and give up?


Si
Spire of Highgate (well, Kentish Town now)? They were pretty abysmal at fault finding on my car, so I went to another authorised workshop in North London who were far more competent.

SimoN138

Original Poster:

223 posts

263 months

Monday 1st February 2016
quotequote all
Theophany said:
Spire of Highgate (well, Kentish Town now)?
... i could not possibly comment


could i ask which one you used next?

Theophany

1,069 posts

161 months

Monday 1st February 2016
quotequote all
SimoN138 said:
... i could not possibly comment


could i ask which one you used next?
I tried H R Owen over in Park Royal just the other week I had a far superior experience. Everything was done much more quickly and I didn't once have the feeling that they were throwing fecal matter at a wall to see what stuck. I know that much of chasing DME fault codes can be trial and error, but they reached the ultimate conclusion with far less trial (and error) than the aforementioned service centre attempted to in December.

I know the previous keeper of my car had everything fastidiously done by Berry BMW over in Heathrow, which would suggest they were pleased with the service there too. Unfortunately, it's a bit out of my way for routine servicing needs.

jayemm89

4,475 posts

161 months

Monday 1st February 2016
quotequote all
Definitely worth trying another dealer. I have found even main dealers to be wildly inconsistent. When I had my E46 330, I took it to Cooper's of Ipswich for warranty corrosion work. They simply never got back to me, despite repeated reminders. I took the car to their sister site in Colchester, photographs taken and two days later the car was booked in for all of its work.