Z4 Coupe - Random misfire - read codes.... advice?
Discussion
Morning all,
My new Z4 Coupe is a little poorly. The other day, I put my foot down a bit (not WOT) and the car started to misfire and was down on power, engine warning light appeared. After restarting the engine, it was OK again.
I decided to get myself an OBD2 Bluetooth dongle off ebay, and bought the Torque Pro app for my phone.
This read the following codes:-
Current Fault - P1553 - Powertrain
Pending Fault - P0301 - Cylinder 1 Misfire Detected
Originally when it happened I suspected an ignition coil, but after googling the codes, it suggests this might be caused by sticky VANOS solenoids, and the first course of action should be to clean them and then swap them around to see if that resolves before ultimately replacing them.
I just wanted to make sure I was on the right track, as I'm new to this and very far from being good at fixing cars, but I'm willing to learn if it helps save on labour charges.
My new Z4 Coupe is a little poorly. The other day, I put my foot down a bit (not WOT) and the car started to misfire and was down on power, engine warning light appeared. After restarting the engine, it was OK again.
I decided to get myself an OBD2 Bluetooth dongle off ebay, and bought the Torque Pro app for my phone.
This read the following codes:-
Current Fault - P1553 - Powertrain
Pending Fault - P0301 - Cylinder 1 Misfire Detected
Originally when it happened I suspected an ignition coil, but after googling the codes, it suggests this might be caused by sticky VANOS solenoids, and the first course of action should be to clean them and then swap them around to see if that resolves before ultimately replacing them.
I just wanted to make sure I was on the right track, as I'm new to this and very far from being good at fixing cars, but I'm willing to learn if it helps save on labour charges.
Hi there. Sounds like you are on the right tracks in terms of Coil packs. I use a more BMW specific software for diagnostics such as INPA as it gives much clearer info than the generic ODB2 scanners. I would be tempted to swap the faulty cylinder coil pack with cylinder 2. if the fault reappears in cylinder 2, replace with a new coil pack.
I'm sure vanos solenoids throw up different codes to the ones your getting (Iv had experience with both these issues)
I'm sure vanos solenoids throw up different codes to the ones your getting (Iv had experience with both these issues)
Sorry to hear of your problem.
My 325ti started misfiring a few months ago and the EML came on, and I suspected a coil-pack but booked it in as I don't really have anywhere to take it apart and don't have OBD.
Turned out it was a Hydraulic Valve Actuator problem (or hydraulic tappet to us oldies)!
My indy thinks it may be because it must have been doing such short journeys and used infrequently before I bought it (less than 4,000 miles in 2 years) which lets the oil drain out.
So it got a flush and an oil change and has been fine ever since (fingers crossed).
Just a thought, but if you don't use it often and do mostly short journeys it could possibly be the same problem.
My 325ti started misfiring a few months ago and the EML came on, and I suspected a coil-pack but booked it in as I don't really have anywhere to take it apart and don't have OBD.
Turned out it was a Hydraulic Valve Actuator problem (or hydraulic tappet to us oldies)!
My indy thinks it may be because it must have been doing such short journeys and used infrequently before I bought it (less than 4,000 miles in 2 years) which lets the oil drain out.
So it got a flush and an oil change and has been fine ever since (fingers crossed).
Just a thought, but if you don't use it often and do mostly short journeys it could possibly be the same problem.
Cheers. The car gets used daily (well until this happened as I don't want to drive it with a problem if I can help it). 6 miles each way to work then a good long run at the weekend almost without fail. The oil was changed 4k miles ago.
I think what I will likely do tomorrow is clean the solenoids, swap them around and swap the injection coil to cylinder 2 and clear the codes and see where I am after that. I may get some o-rings for the solenoids in case they are worn.
It may be that this fixes it but if not I should have a clearer idea what might be wrong. I'm a little nervous as I'm not used to working on cars but looking at it I should be able to manage this and you gotta start somewhere right?
I think what I will likely do tomorrow is clean the solenoids, swap them around and swap the injection coil to cylinder 2 and clear the codes and see where I am after that. I may get some o-rings for the solenoids in case they are worn.
It may be that this fixes it but if not I should have a clearer idea what might be wrong. I'm a little nervous as I'm not used to working on cars but looking at it I should be able to manage this and you gotta start somewhere right?
TameRacingDriver said:
Cheers. The car gets used daily (well until this happened as I don't want to drive it with a problem if I can help it). 6 miles each way to work then a good long run at the weekend almost without fail. The oil was changed 4k miles ago.
I think what I will likely do tomorrow is clean the solenoids, swap them around and swap the injection coil to cylinder 2 and clear the codes and see where I am after that. I may get some o-rings for the solenoids in case they are worn.
It may be that this fixes it but if not I should have a clearer idea what might be wrong. I'm a little nervous as I'm not used to working on cars but looking at it I should be able to manage this and you gotta start somewhere right?
The solenoids are easy enough to get to and take out, just be careful not to lose the clips from the connectors, retreiving stuff from under the engine is impossible without magnets/luck/swearing. I think there is a guide on the other forum. Good luck, I did mine last month and I'm not at all experienced with working on cars. I think what I will likely do tomorrow is clean the solenoids, swap them around and swap the injection coil to cylinder 2 and clear the codes and see where I am after that. I may get some o-rings for the solenoids in case they are worn.
It may be that this fixes it but if not I should have a clearer idea what might be wrong. I'm a little nervous as I'm not used to working on cars but looking at it I should be able to manage this and you gotta start somewhere right?
Hope you're still enjoying the car though?
TameRacingDriver said:
Cheers Aquamatt. I am enjoying it very much, best car I've ever owned for all round enjoyment / ability / usability by a mile.
Great - they do get under your skin don't they? And the N52 engine just seems to goad you into exercising the rev counter before changing up! 
Hope it turns out to be a simple fix!
Edited to add if you do have problems diagnosing the fault it would be worth visiting Z4 Forum.
Edited by Mr Tidy on Friday 26th February 22:35
FLGirl said:
I had exactly the same problem on my Z4C and it was the ignition coils.
A lot of googling suggests it's a common fault
Mine has managed to have all of the common faults so watch out for the water pump and window regulators too!
I don't want to hear that! Mine had new springs before I bought it (another regular issue) and I just had to have a new water pump & thermostat!A lot of googling suggests it's a common fault

Mine has managed to have all of the common faults so watch out for the water pump and window regulators too!
I won't even try to open the windows any more - hopefully that only leaves potential coil and Vanos solenoid issues!

But when it works it is fantastic!
Mr Tidy said:
I don't want to hear that! Mine had new springs before I bought it (another regular issue) and I just had to have a new water pump & thermostat!
I won't even try to open the windows any more - hopefully that only leaves potential coil and Vanos solenoid issues!
But when it works it is fantastic!
I won't even try to open the windows any more - hopefully that only leaves potential coil and Vanos solenoid issues!

But when it works it is fantastic!

Sorry, but yes they are fantastic when working!
I love mine to bits so just consider it to be 'character '. Been driving everywhere in sports mode lately, the noise is sooooo addictive!
Hope you sort yours soon, coils were fairly reasonable at ECP.
Well I was planning to do something today but it was a mates birthday yesterday and I am so ill!
I did go down to BMW dealer today to try and get some O-rings for the Solenoids (may as well replace them thought I) but they don't have any and will have to order them in. I might still try and give them a clean tomorrow.
Agree with you all though I love the car, the noise is incredible
I did go down to BMW dealer today to try and get some O-rings for the Solenoids (may as well replace them thought I) but they don't have any and will have to order them in. I might still try and give them a clean tomorrow.Agree with you all though I love the car, the noise is incredible

Just enjoy the car if it happens it happens. I make sure I only start mine up when I am going to use it and when I do as soon as it's warm I drive it like I nicked it. The water pump could be an issue for me as my car as done 56k on an 08 plate, I have a few long journeys planned this year so may well take the bull by the horns and get it done,circa £350 all in no problem. These cars are just a joy to drive the low down torque is amazing, I for one will just drive it as it should be.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




