2004 - ish engine to avoid?
2004 - ish engine to avoid?
Author
Discussion

kurt535

Original Poster:

3,560 posts

148 months

Friday 26th February 2016
quotequote all
Hi,

Am toying with the idea of buying a 2004 6 cylinder - 2.2 320 CI. For this vintage, any well know problems with the engine??

many thanks

Mr Tidy

31,949 posts

158 months

Friday 26th February 2016
quotequote all
My local BMW specialist (ex-Sytner) suggested avoiding any 4 cylinder, and that petrol was a better bet than diesel (might be why his car is a 52 plate 530i)!

Anyway, the E46 320i/Ci has a version of the M54 engine (same as the afore-mentioned 530i) also the same as my 325ti.

They seem to suffer from radiators bowing at the bottom and failing (mine did this recently at 80K miles) and expansion tanks can split. So when I had the radiator replaced I got the rest of the cooling system refreshed (new expansion tank, radiator cap, thermostat and auxiliary drive belt) as changing just the radiator is likely to put more stress on the rest of the system that is under pressure.

Not engine related, but any body style other than the Compact (no idea why it doesn't) tends to suffer from "frilly" wheel-arches. Springs are also known to break.

Just out of curiosity, have you considered 325 or 330 options? All the 6 cylinder models cost around the same to run (and are all Band K for RFL). I know when I have looked 330s seem to command a price premium, but unless you have found a particularly good 320 I wouldn't rule out a 325.

Good luck, and let us know how you get on! Any straight 6 naturally aspirated RWD car is something we will never see again! And they are pretty entertaining if you happen to be in a hurry!

FWIW whatever model you go for I would look for Sport seats as they are so much better than the others - standard on Sport models (unsurprisingly) but optional on others - with the exception of the Compact where all 325ti models had Sport seats and suspension. Another oddity is that all 6 cylinder Coupes had electric memory seats (whether SE or Sport) and folding rear seats, both of which were an option on Saloons!

Edited to add they need to be used - mine recently had a misfire. OBD showed it had a hydraulic valve lifter problem. (Previous owner did less than 4K miles in the 2 years before I bought it!). It seems the oil drains down in time and if you don't go far enough the pressure doesn't have time to build up. Flushed and oil changed, OK now (fingers crossed)!

Edited by Mr Tidy on Friday 26th February 23:24

kurt535

Original Poster:

3,560 posts

148 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
Mr Tidy...car I had my eye on sold yesterday...dang! I take on board your comment ref 330 more desirable and would have preferred but this car was rather mint, etc.

And many thanks for your in-depth response too.

Mr Tidy

31,949 posts

158 months

Saturday 27th February 2016
quotequote all
Shame you missed it - I thought there might be a good reason for that specific one.

From what I have read, good 330s go pretty quickly too!

But there seem to be quite a lot of 325s around, and they tend to be a fair bit cheaper than 330s.

You were looking at an 04, so it would have been a facelift model (facelift was some time in 2003). The main difference is that manual ones got a 6 speed gearbox instead of a 5 speed.

Good luck!