Discussion
Apologise if this has been talked about before. New to the BMW Forum as I've recently purchased a 12 plate 5 Series M Sport with 36k on the clock with a FSH.
One of the main aspects which caught my attention with this car is the mpg. According to the Auto Trader I should be getting somewhere around the below stats. As you can see this BMW isn't getting anywhere near that. I do a 60 mile round trip for work, steady driver and use the Eco Pro mode. Previously I had a Mondeo ST TDCi, on paper it should achieve 46mpg and I usually got anywhere between 43 and 47 whilst not being particularly careful about the mpg. So now I'm seemingly driving in a less powerful motor than the Mondeo (whilst in Eco mode) and not getting a decent mpg in return for the efforts.
Question is then. Is it just my car/driving style or is this difference the norm?
Do others get anywhere near the quoted figures?
Urban mpg 47.9 mpg
Extra Urban mpg 65.7 mpg
Average mpg 57.6 mpg
Actual 42 mpg
On a side note, the car itself is just brilliant, love driving it. Just wish I could drive in Sport mode more often.
Thanks.
One of the main aspects which caught my attention with this car is the mpg. According to the Auto Trader I should be getting somewhere around the below stats. As you can see this BMW isn't getting anywhere near that. I do a 60 mile round trip for work, steady driver and use the Eco Pro mode. Previously I had a Mondeo ST TDCi, on paper it should achieve 46mpg and I usually got anywhere between 43 and 47 whilst not being particularly careful about the mpg. So now I'm seemingly driving in a less powerful motor than the Mondeo (whilst in Eco mode) and not getting a decent mpg in return for the efforts.
Question is then. Is it just my car/driving style or is this difference the norm?
Do others get anywhere near the quoted figures?
Urban mpg 47.9 mpg
Extra Urban mpg 65.7 mpg
Average mpg 57.6 mpg
Actual 42 mpg
On a side note, the car itself is just brilliant, love driving it. Just wish I could drive in Sport mode more often.
Thanks.
IIIRestorerIII said:
Parkers says 21mpg for my E46 M3. I averaged 26, upto 30 on a swifter longer journey. I enjoyed the power in this car.
Parker says 37mpg for my X40d X5. I average 27.5 and that's driving conservatively. It's never seen 37mpg, on any run.
Is it a diesel thing maybe?
My experience mirrors yours on the petrol/diesel issue! My E46 M3 also averaged better than the combined figure and beat it easily on a run and my E92 335i averaged about 10% less than the combined figure but would beat it on a run; however, the running average on my F31 335d is over 20% off the combined figure and it's never got close to it even on a run. However, none of this explains how the OP achieved roughly the combined figure from a diesel Mondeo but can't do the same in his BMW!Parker says 37mpg for my X40d X5. I average 27.5 and that's driving conservatively. It's never seen 37mpg, on any run.
Is it a diesel thing maybe?
You don't say if your car is petrol or diesel.
If diesel, you won't achieve very good MPG this weather, a diesel needs to be HOT before returning anything like advertised MPG.
My 6 series in summer months gives 45 MPG. Right now I'm lucky to get 35 MPG unless on a very long run when the MPG will creep up a little towards 40 MPG.
You could check which grade of oil you have, it could still have summer oil in it. My car spec oil for winter is 0-30, for summer 5-30, agree not much difference but "every little helps".
If diesel, you won't achieve very good MPG this weather, a diesel needs to be HOT before returning anything like advertised MPG.
My 6 series in summer months gives 45 MPG. Right now I'm lucky to get 35 MPG unless on a very long run when the MPG will creep up a little towards 40 MPG.
You could check which grade of oil you have, it could still have summer oil in it. My car spec oil for winter is 0-30, for summer 5-30, agree not much difference but "every little helps".
Every petrol BMW I've owned (330Ci, 530i, M5) can easily achieve their combined figure. I'm just back from Fort William (close to a 3 hour drive) and averaged a little under 27mpg in the M5.
The one diesel I owned (320Td) only ever achieved its official figure once and that was driving like a saint over the entire tank. I don't know whether something to do with turbocharged engines makes it harder to equal in real driving as it seems quite common to not achieve the official figures on their new engines.
The one diesel I owned (320Td) only ever achieved its official figure once and that was driving like a saint over the entire tank. I don't know whether something to do with turbocharged engines makes it harder to equal in real driving as it seems quite common to not achieve the official figures on their new engines.
Thanks for your input. There does appear to be some sort of pattern here. Accepted it's never going to be spot on as it's rare we have "perfect" conditions for our journeys but I still find it pretty shocking how far they can actually be.
It's a Diesel BB.
Honest John his this model particular models figures as...
520d 190 Automatic
62.8–68.9 mpg (Quoted)
46.0 mpg (Actual) 70%
So I'm not too far from the 46mpg.
Lastly (sorry). Kind of keeping it on topic. What kind of mpg differences do you get between the Eco, Comfort & Sport mode? (providing the driving style is the same). If it's marginal it'd probably not be worth not being so Eco minded.
It's a Diesel BB.
Honest John his this model particular models figures as...
520d 190 Automatic
62.8–68.9 mpg (Quoted)
46.0 mpg (Actual) 70%
So I'm not too far from the 46mpg.
Lastly (sorry). Kind of keeping it on topic. What kind of mpg differences do you get between the Eco, Comfort & Sport mode? (providing the driving style is the same). If it's marginal it'd probably not be worth not being so Eco minded.
I've averaged about 20% less than the advertised mpg on all of my previous BMWs (2 x E46 330Ci, E60 535d, E60 550i, E70 30d, E70 40d), barring the more recent ones (F20 and F25), which have diverged by around 25%.
I had a 2014 F10 520d as a courtesy car last year for a week and was averaging 49mpg but that was in the summer and I'm sure the warm weather helped.
But as stated in posts above - this isn't a problem limited to BMWs and seems to be more prevalent as more motors are skewed to passing the tests with better mpgs than replicating this in real driving conditions.
I had a 2014 F10 520d as a courtesy car last year for a week and was averaging 49mpg but that was in the summer and I'm sure the warm weather helped.
But as stated in posts above - this isn't a problem limited to BMWs and seems to be more prevalent as more motors are skewed to passing the tests with better mpgs than replicating this in real driving conditions.
Couple of things.
You are on winter diesel, you will loose around 15% on that stuff.
It is also winter, the car needs to get up to temp to get decent mpg, you may find that you simply are not.
Check your temperatures, do a search on how on google, you should be getting to 90ºc within 15 minutes and it shouldn't move. If it doesn't or if it waivers then replace your 'stats. If it isn't you also have the issue that your DPF will not regen, this will cause an issue with MPG and cost you big time if it needs replacing.
The other things is the official test is not kind to cars at they get heavier and less aerodynamic, hence why 4x4s tend to be so far off.
Then you have the issue of the combined and extra urban is calculated from an average speed of 39mph, which no one does, so it only tells you what a car does, in summer, already up to temperature, on summer fuel doing 39mph.
I think more people do more shorter journeys than they think, which is why petrol tends to achieve the figures where as diesel often falls short.
I used to have a 45 mile trip to our place up on the coast. My 535d got better MPG than the 335i touring in summer, but it wasn't until the 35 mile point where it started to look better. During winter the 335i would often get better MPG. It is was only 30 miles away the petrol did better.
On the 11 miles into the city on a morning the petrol won every time, only just in summer, but in winter it was around 10-20% better every day.
You are on winter diesel, you will loose around 15% on that stuff.
It is also winter, the car needs to get up to temp to get decent mpg, you may find that you simply are not.
Check your temperatures, do a search on how on google, you should be getting to 90ºc within 15 minutes and it shouldn't move. If it doesn't or if it waivers then replace your 'stats. If it isn't you also have the issue that your DPF will not regen, this will cause an issue with MPG and cost you big time if it needs replacing.
The other things is the official test is not kind to cars at they get heavier and less aerodynamic, hence why 4x4s tend to be so far off.
Then you have the issue of the combined and extra urban is calculated from an average speed of 39mph, which no one does, so it only tells you what a car does, in summer, already up to temperature, on summer fuel doing 39mph.
I think more people do more shorter journeys than they think, which is why petrol tends to achieve the figures where as diesel often falls short.
I used to have a 45 mile trip to our place up on the coast. My 535d got better MPG than the 335i touring in summer, but it wasn't until the 35 mile point where it started to look better. During winter the 335i would often get better MPG. It is was only 30 miles away the petrol did better.
On the 11 miles into the city on a morning the petrol won every time, only just in summer, but in winter it was around 10-20% better every day.
My 2013 320d Sport auto always does 45-46mpg, and I'd struggle to get that much lower without being arrested.
By contrast, the VW CC 170TDi auto that I test drove before ordering the BMW only managed 37mpg (one of the main reasons for getting the BMW).
It'll be interesting to see what my new 330d M Sport does when it arrives on Thursday. Can't wait!
By contrast, the VW CC 170TDi auto that I test drove before ordering the BMW only managed 37mpg (one of the main reasons for getting the BMW).
It'll be interesting to see what my new 330d M Sport does when it arrives on Thursday. Can't wait!
S7Paul said:
My 2013 320d Sport auto always does 45-46mpg, and I'd struggle to get that much lower without being arrested.
By contrast, the VW CC 170TDi auto that I test drove before ordering the BMW only managed 37mpg (one of the main reasons for getting the BMW).
It'll be interesting to see what my new 330d M Sport does when it arrives on Thursday. Can't wait!
Reckon you will be amazed ,I think my F30 330d is better MPG wise than my 57 plate 120d autoBy contrast, the VW CC 170TDi auto that I test drove before ordering the BMW only managed 37mpg (one of the main reasons for getting the BMW).
It'll be interesting to see what my new 330d M Sport does when it arrives on Thursday. Can't wait!
Cbull said:
So I'm not too far from the 46mpg.
It all depends on how you drive. Everyone drives "normally"
, but some are smooth and anticipate, others are constantly varying the throttle position and braking when not needed. Here is a histogram of real MPG for 520d 2011 onwards:
At 42mpg you are statistically quite normal!
Cbull said:
Lastly (sorry). Kind of keeping it on topic. What kind of mpg differences do you get between the Eco, Comfort & Sport mode? (providing the driving style is the same). If it's marginal it'd probably not be worth not being so Eco minded.
Eco pro doesn't change the power output of the car. It does four things:- Changes the throttle pedal so that the first bit doesn't do much. This helps you be gentle and precise. Full throttle is still full throttle.
- Makes the gearbox keep the engine at lower rpm where possible.
- Turns stuff off (or down) where possible - like aircon and GPS-gearbox functions.
- Nags you to slow down.
If you want more mpg, change your driving. If you want fun, then simply drive and ignore the mpg.
My 2005 manual 120d does not give the combined MPG taken from Autotrader which is 49.6mpg but it is quite close. The average over the last year is 45.87mpg over 14,100 miles and this is with new thermostats and the engine running at the correct temps and commuting 60 miles a day (30 each way). I classify this as perfectly acceptable.
bracken78 said:
My 2005 manual 120d does not give the combined MPG taken from Autotrader which is 49.6mpg but it is quite close. The average over the last year is 45.87mpg over 14,100 miles and this is with new thermostats and the engine running at the correct temps and commuting 60 miles a day (30 each way). I classify this as perfectly acceptable.
If you reset the obc, see what it says when you have reached 2 miles. then 5 miles and then 10 miles. I would be interested to see the difference.
I used to have a 120d and that averaged 34mpg, and everyone used to rave about their 40+ average, however I was only doing 9 miles everyday and 5 of that was across town even if it was going against the traffic.
gizlaroc said:
If you reset the obc, see what it says when you have reached 2 miles. then 5 miles and then 10 miles.
I would be interested to see the difference.
I used to have a 120d and that averaged 34mpg, and everyone used to rave about their 40+ average, however I was only doing 9 miles everyday and 5 of that was across town even if it was going against the traffic.
I will try to remember to do that. I would be interested to see the difference.
I used to have a 120d and that averaged 34mpg, and everyone used to rave about their 40+ average, however I was only doing 9 miles everyday and 5 of that was across town even if it was going against the traffic.
Before having both thermostats changed it was struggling to stay in the 40's MPG wise.
Well you learn something everyday. Being a bit stupid I was completely unaware of this "winter diesel"
. Not even sure if the premium stuff makes any effect to this motor, it did with the Mondeo. I was also recently told the price of a full set of new treds from BMW which was pretty frightening so I am refusing to look into this DPF that's been mentioned.
42mpg isn't that bad considering the size and weight of the car (even with me in it), however, it is still disappointing that these figures are not even close to what's being advertised. My own fault though for not doing a little more research before buying.
Thanks for the info. apotts. Over the next few weeks I'll be switching between the modes but it probably wouldn't be a true reading as my driving habits will undoubtedly change to suit. Just a case of trial and error, then go with what suits the individual the best. Will report back with some figures if I do it correctly.
So many questions with this car. Don't even get me started on why there are potentially 3 handbrakes??

. Not even sure if the premium stuff makes any effect to this motor, it did with the Mondeo. I was also recently told the price of a full set of new treds from BMW which was pretty frightening so I am refusing to look into this DPF that's been mentioned.42mpg isn't that bad considering the size and weight of the car (even with me in it), however, it is still disappointing that these figures are not even close to what's being advertised. My own fault though for not doing a little more research before buying.
Thanks for the info. apotts. Over the next few weeks I'll be switching between the modes but it probably wouldn't be a true reading as my driving habits will undoubtedly change to suit. Just a case of trial and error, then go with what suits the individual the best. Will report back with some figures if I do it correctly.
So many questions with this car. Don't even get me started on why there are potentially 3 handbrakes??


Cbull said:
the price of a full set of new treds from BMW

Tyres? They are the same price as any other car, and any normal car if you decide to go away from run flats.
Cbull said:
I am refusing to look into this DPF that's been mentioned.
It shouldn't be an issue. Just do an hour on the motorway and it will be back to normal. Expect lower mpg while it regenerates.Cbull said:
42mpg isn't that bad considering the size and weight of the car (even with me in it), however, it is still disappointing that these figures are not even close to what's being advertised. My own fault though for not doing a little more research before buying.
All cars have an mpg advertised for a simulated test. Real driving is very different from this test.Cbull said:
Don't even get me started on why there are potentially 3 handbrakes?? 

Only 1 on mine!

Cbull said:
Over the next few weeks I'll be switching between the modes but it probably wouldn't be a true reading as my driving habits will undoubtedly change to suit.
Of course, that is the point of the different modes. I find I can get better over all economy in comfort. ECO means I have to give it too much to get up to speed and sport just makes me want to drive it too hard.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


