Discussion
So i've been lurking on pistonheads for somewhile before creating an account. I'm after an e36, insurance is kind on anything up to the 325i, the prices and insurance on the 328i are a little much for my own budget.
I'm mainly after a coupe, but do some weekend riding so the estate could become an option!
What would be the best engine to go for? Roughly a 2k budget to purchase, dont want anything pristine but i dont fancy an old dog.
Is there a major difference between the 323 and the 325?
Any help would be amazing!
I'm mainly after a coupe, but do some weekend riding so the estate could become an option!
What would be the best engine to go for? Roughly a 2k budget to purchase, dont want anything pristine but i dont fancy an old dog.
Is there a major difference between the 323 and the 325?
Any help would be amazing!

IMHO the 325 is the best of them all anyway, so, if you can get the latest, lowest mileaqe, best historied car you can.
Check the jacking points for corrosion, check all the electrics, and ideally have a good read through the big wad of receipts/bills etc to see if it has had a cooling system refurb including rad/stat/stat housing/hoses as these are renowned to fail.
You will quite likely expect to have a leaky rocker cover gasket, which is an easy fix.
Pretty much everything else is mostly bulletproof.
The difference between the 323 & 325 IS noticeable in performance, but not in economy, so as I said, go for the 325 unless you get an offer you can't refuse.
Check the jacking points for corrosion, check all the electrics, and ideally have a good read through the big wad of receipts/bills etc to see if it has had a cooling system refurb including rad/stat/stat housing/hoses as these are renowned to fail.
You will quite likely expect to have a leaky rocker cover gasket, which is an easy fix.
Pretty much everything else is mostly bulletproof.
The difference between the 323 & 325 IS noticeable in performance, but not in economy, so as I said, go for the 325 unless you get an offer you can't refuse.
Just an enquiry....but did the 323s suffer from the Nikasil block problem ? Just asking because I 'inherited' an E36 328 cab from my uncle, and although the car was mint in all other respects, it did have the Nikasil block and developed subsequent oil issues. I have a feeling that the 323s were different blocks but just putting it out there in case it may be a potential issue. I am sure there are more knowlegeble folk on here that can answer that one !
To the OP, the E36s are really great cars if you get a decent one; I now have a mint 318iS which is as you may know the 2 door one. IMO the coupe looks quite modern even now but from what you have said you may need more space...! However the coupe does have folding rear seats which actually makes it a decent lead carrier ( certainly for a track day with a spare set of wheels which were a bit of a tight fit but got them in !)

To the OP, the E36s are really great cars if you get a decent one; I now have a mint 318iS which is as you may know the 2 door one. IMO the coupe looks quite modern even now but from what you have said you may need more space...! However the coupe does have folding rear seats which actually makes it a decent lead carrier ( certainly for a track day with a spare set of wheels which were a bit of a tight fit but got them in !)
cableguy said:
The earlier e36 325i had the M50 Motor which had the Cast Iron Block, probably BMW's finest NA 6 Cylinder. Very strong and very reliable if maintained correctly. The later 323 & 328 Motors were Alu Blocks and as mentioned above, some had Nikasil issues.
C.
After '97, when BMW finally realised what was going wrong with the engines, they became Alusil engines that didn't suffer the premature bore wear/oil burning issues that the Nikasil engines were prone to. C.
The funny thing about all of this is that there are plenty of BMW "experts" on here who will happily tell you that if an engine hasn't suffered a Nikasil failure by now then it never will!
My '97 328i Sport sat outside My house with a seized motor would argue otherwise!
Check for worn front wishbone bushes and balljoints, rear trailing arm bushes, leaking plastic thermostat housings, failed plastic water pump impellers, rusty arches, leaking expansion tanks, glove box lid which wont stay closed, failed electric window regulators, rattle from front of engine could be VANOS seals leaking. Still sort the cooling system weaknesses and rust proof underneath and they are pretty reliable simple and DIY-friendly cars compared to moderns.
I have the M50 2.5 motor (325), a revvy engine but needs to be revved to deliver good performance. I understand the 328 is much torquier at lower revs but a little choked at the top end by its restrictive inlet manifold (can be,replaced with the M50 manifold to liberate about 20hp). The 328 is also higher geared so makes a better motorway cruiser.
I'd swap my 325 for a good 328 coupe but the nikasil issue has put me off the 323/328 a bit....
I have the M50 2.5 motor (325), a revvy engine but needs to be revved to deliver good performance. I understand the 328 is much torquier at lower revs but a little choked at the top end by its restrictive inlet manifold (can be,replaced with the M50 manifold to liberate about 20hp). The 328 is also higher geared so makes a better motorway cruiser.
I'd swap my 325 for a good 328 coupe but the nikasil issue has put me off the 323/328 a bit....
BGarside said:
.....I'd swap my 325 for a good 328 coupe but the nikasil issue has put me off the 323/328 a bit....
You just need to track down an Alusil engined car (Late '97 onwards or a earlier car that has had the engine replaced with an Alusil engine).If you do a Google search on M52 Nikasil/Alusil engines there's plenty of information on how to spot an Alusil version.
cableguy said:
Nice upgrade and well documented on the internet is the M50 (2.5) Stroker. Drop an M54 Crank, Rods & Pistons into an M50 (2.5) and you have a Cast Iron blocked 3.0litre.
If anyone's interested I have a full M50 Motor & Stroker Kit ready to go.
C.
Sounds interesting, as I already have a nice M50 motor in my car with just 72k miles on it, but I assume the labour charge would cost the earth for someone who doesn't have the skills to dismantle and reassemble engines! The extra torque would require the ZF 'box from a 328 too, I think, and I guess a custom chip and maybe uprated injectors?If anyone's interested I have a full M50 Motor & Stroker Kit ready to go.

C.
BGarside said:
Sounds interesting, as I already have a nice M50 motor in my car with just 72k miles on it, but I assume the labour charge would cost the earth for someone who doesn't have the skills to dismantle and reassemble engines! The extra torque would require the ZF 'box from a 328 too, I think, and I guess a custom chip and maybe uprated injectors?
My local garage estimate was £1200 to £1500 to add the stroker kit with new piston rings, head gasket & seals etc.Plenty of info on the net about people doing it themselves.
C.
4rephill said:
You just need to track down an Alusil engined car (Late '97 onwards or a earlier car that has had the engine replaced with an Alusil engine).
If you do a Google search on M52 Nikasil/Alusil engines there's plenty of information on how to spot an Alusil version.
Finding it hard to find ANY decent 328 without starship miles, rust and/or 'drift' mods, let alone with an alusil engine!!If you do a Google search on M52 Nikasil/Alusil engines there's plenty of information on how to spot an Alusil version.
cableguy said:
The earlier e36 325i had the M50 Motor which had the Cast Iron Block, probably BMW's finest NA 6 Cylinder. Very strong and very reliable if maintained correctly. The later 323 & 328 Motors were Alu Blocks and as mentioned above, some had Nikasil issues.
C.
The M50 is tough, but makes most of its power over 4000rpm. The 2.8 M52 equals or exceeds the peak torque of the 2.5 M50 from 2000rpm upwards so is much more flexible.C.
swansea v6 said:
Looks a beaut! Funnily enough whenever I look there seem to be loads of good droptops for sale but not many good saloons or coupes....I've had my coupe for a year and like the way the e36 drives. Certainly doesn't feel like a 25 year old design😊
Higgs boson said:
I may not be remembering correctly, but was there an, occassional, issue with the rear dampers forcing their way through the mounting point.
The boot carpet had to be lifted to check properly.
possibly fronts as well but only on cars that had been lowered a lot, and driven very hard over potholes. It's certainly not a common issue like, say, subframe cracks on bigger power E46. The boot carpet had to be lifted to check properly.
Also I'll be selling my 328i SE Coupe at some point soon. It's got a leaky sump gasket to be fixed before I advertise it though. It's a well cared for example, nearly new Bilstien & H&R suspension, stainless cat back, induction kit, M50 manifold conversion, remapped ECU, rare 17" Hartge classic wheels, various other goodies. Any interest feel free to fire me a PM.
Barden52 said:
So i've been lurking on pistonheads for somewhile before creating an account. I'm after an e36, insurance is kind on anything up to the 325i, the prices and insurance on the 328i are a little much for my own budget.
I'm mainly after a coupe, but do some weekend riding so the estate could become an option!
What would be the best engine to go for? Roughly a 2k budget to purchase, dont want anything pristine but i dont fancy an old dog.
Is there a major difference between the 323 and the 325?
Any help would be amazing!
IMO (having owned both a 325 and 328s) I'd go for the latter. The M50 2.5 in the 325 is a lovely engine. It does however thrive on revs and needs to be worked hard to make it shift. The 2.8 can feel lazier but is notably more torquey and deceptively quick. It's also easy to mod to free up the upper rev range (M50 inlet manifold + BBTB +/- remap). The 2.5 is the better sounding unit (+ Gruppe M rep induction kit & Supersprint exhaust = I'm mainly after a coupe, but do some weekend riding so the estate could become an option!
What would be the best engine to go for? Roughly a 2k budget to purchase, dont want anything pristine but i dont fancy an old dog.
Is there a major difference between the 323 and the 325?
Any help would be amazing!

)
Budget a cooling system refresh (thermostat, rad, pump ad belts) and potentially some bit of the suspension (if they haven't been done already). Rust is the major issue, jacking points, sills and jacking points are known weak points.
I was originally looking for a Coupe but a Touring popped up on PH. Had it since Sept 2012 and I love it. It might not have the spaciousness of the equivalent Merc or Volvo but it is surprisingly practical and I've found it really useful for Ikea trips, house moving etc. Worth a look imo. yes:

Decent E36s are getting hard to find. If you can, get one with the 18 button (full) OBC, climate control and leather. I'm a big fan of having a sunroof too. Cruise and parking sensors are rare options.
4rephill said:
After '97, when BMW finally realised what was going wrong with the engines, they became Alusil engines that didn't suffer the premature bore wear/oil burning issues that the Nikasil engines were prone to.
The funny thing about all of this is that there are plenty of BMW "experts" on here who will happily tell you that if an engine hasn't suffered a Nikasil failure by now then it never will!
My '97 328i Sport sat outside My house with a seized motor would argue otherwise!
How many miles did yours fail on? The funny thing about all of this is that there are plenty of BMW "experts" on here who will happily tell you that if an engine hasn't suffered a Nikasil failure by now then it never will!
My '97 328i Sport sat outside My house with a seized motor would argue otherwise!
I'd say (unfortunately for you) yours is an exception to the general rule.

My 328 is an early 98 (with the Nikasil block), it didn't put my off purchase (had already done 120k miles, now on 174k).
I believe Nikasil blocks were changed to Alusil from week 10 (1998) onwards.
Higgs boson said:
I may not be remembering correctly, but was there an, occassional, issue with the rear dampers forcing their way through the mounting point.
The boot carpet had to be lifted to check properly.
Been there, done that! The boot carpet had to be lifted to check properly.


The issue is with the top mounts, a known weak point. IIRC, one can replace with M3 items which are much more substantial.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



