F10 520d Touring - possible next purchase - talk me into it!
Discussion
Mornng all,
The family bus is on its last legs (needs a cambelt/water pump, DMF making odd noises) and a replacement is needed.
We can live without 7 seats so a biggish estate should do the trick this time round.
Diesel makes sense for me here as there is a big price difference in DE, and I do plenty of long runs for work so haven't had DPF issues in the past.
2011 520d estates are just coming into budget. I can get high spec (basically everyting bar Nav) and low mileage (ca. 50k miles) for just shy of €19k.
Any thoughts? Talk me into it! I can link to the one I'm interested in too (ex-lease through Sixt).
I'm in a position to buy outright.
Thaks all
Simon
The family bus is on its last legs (needs a cambelt/water pump, DMF making odd noises) and a replacement is needed.
We can live without 7 seats so a biggish estate should do the trick this time round.
Diesel makes sense for me here as there is a big price difference in DE, and I do plenty of long runs for work so haven't had DPF issues in the past.
2011 520d estates are just coming into budget. I can get high spec (basically everyting bar Nav) and low mileage (ca. 50k miles) for just shy of €19k.
Any thoughts? Talk me into it! I can link to the one I'm interested in too (ex-lease through Sixt).
I'm in a position to buy outright.
Thaks all
Simon
I own a F10 530xd Touring now and I owned a F10 525d Touring before it but I have been using extensively a F10 520d sedan owned by my father, all of them with the 8 speed auto box.
I would rank the 520d as one of my favourite all around cars, with good performance and great economy considering the size and mass of the car.
It is a very relaxing car to drive for long journeys and very comfortable for the passengers, especially the rear ones, who can seat more comfortably than in E-Class. The boot could be a bit larger maybe but it is still a perfect car for travelling.
About the engines with the 30d you get the addcting sense of effortless performance but I would not recommend the 25d, which get a more wide charter over the rev range compared to the 20d but it doesn't give another level of performances and proved a lot more thirsty in my experience.
Compared to Audi conterparts the materials of the interior clearly feel of a lesser quality but I would always choose BMW, I just couldn't live with Audi A6 steering.
I would rank the 520d as one of my favourite all around cars, with good performance and great economy considering the size and mass of the car.
It is a very relaxing car to drive for long journeys and very comfortable for the passengers, especially the rear ones, who can seat more comfortably than in E-Class. The boot could be a bit larger maybe but it is still a perfect car for travelling.
About the engines with the 30d you get the addcting sense of effortless performance but I would not recommend the 25d, which get a more wide charter over the rev range compared to the 20d but it doesn't give another level of performances and proved a lot more thirsty in my experience.
Compared to Audi conterparts the materials of the interior clearly feel of a lesser quality but I would always choose BMW, I just couldn't live with Audi A6 steering.
Barchettaman said:
Thanks guys.
I'm not averse to changing gears myself, unless the 8-speed auto really is that good.
The one I listed has a combination of spec and low price that I'm not seeing elsewhere.
I would be another to recommend the auto, my E61 520d was a manual and for me it wasn't a great match for the engine(I don't really like autos either) but had a E90 330d and got a F13 640d both autos and they are a lovely match for the engine and the 8 speed auto is really good. I'm not averse to changing gears myself, unless the 8-speed auto really is that good.
The one I listed has a combination of spec and low price that I'm not seeing elsewhere.
I had the N47 engine in a F20 118d and a manual box. Was ok but geared for reasonable shove in any of the 6 gears, but too low for good fuel consumption on the motorway.
We now have the N47 2.0dXdrive in the F25 X3 with the 8-speed box and it works so much better as a package and gets fuel economy only 2-3mpg worse than the outgoing 1er, in spite of being 4x4 and extra weight, which I put down to the more efficient gearbox.
My first experience of the 8-speed box was in the E70 X5 40d and that was brilliant too, especially after coming from the 6-speed Auto in the pre LCI.
So, I am a big fan of the 8spd ZF and would certainly recommend it over the manual box.
We now have the N47 2.0dXdrive in the F25 X3 with the 8-speed box and it works so much better as a package and gets fuel economy only 2-3mpg worse than the outgoing 1er, in spite of being 4x4 and extra weight, which I put down to the more efficient gearbox.
My first experience of the 8-speed box was in the E70 X5 40d and that was brilliant too, especially after coming from the 6-speed Auto in the pre LCI.
So, I am a big fan of the 8spd ZF and would certainly recommend it over the manual box.
That's a nice car but I can't believe it doesn't have Navigation! You've got the iDrive controller, you've got the Nav button, you've got the 7" screen. Are you sure it doesn't have Nav? If it really doesn't, perhaps all you need to do is buy the navigation computer including hard drive separately and plug it in to some bay in the boot.
I personally wouldn't buy an Executive-class daily driver without Navigation because it's so useful, it affects resale value negatively (hopefully offset by lower purchase price) and in fact so many cars have it as standard now that you might even make it a difficult sell in a few years time. Plus, I HATE boxes stuck to my windscreen with suckers. Something you have to remember to remove when you park. If you only do local journeys or the same route maybe it's not an issue, but if you drive enough to want a diesel then perhaps you do use nav...
Oh, and a 5 series with a 4-cylinder engine? My last 3 dailies over the last 20 years have all had a BMW straight six motor, so perhaps I'm biased!
I personally wouldn't buy an Executive-class daily driver without Navigation because it's so useful, it affects resale value negatively (hopefully offset by lower purchase price) and in fact so many cars have it as standard now that you might even make it a difficult sell in a few years time. Plus, I HATE boxes stuck to my windscreen with suckers. Something you have to remember to remove when you park. If you only do local journeys or the same route maybe it's not an issue, but if you drive enough to want a diesel then perhaps you do use nav...
Oh, and a 5 series with a 4-cylinder engine? My last 3 dailies over the last 20 years have all had a BMW straight six motor, so perhaps I'm biased!
Bought my 62 plate (Sept 2012)in Sept 2015, F11 520D manual , came with full leather, idrive and Nav. I've been very pleased with it , great for use as dog transport. Gives me 45+ mpg. Mine had 90k miles on it at purchase, 99k now.
It didn't cost 17K Euros either
maybe UK prices are lower?
It didn't cost 17K Euros either
maybe UK prices are lower?cerb4.5lee said:
The 4 pot diesel engine in the 520d is pretty rough and ready, if it was me I would go slightly older(previous gen) and go for a 530d/535d.
Sorry that's not really talked you into it!
It's really not that bad!!!! As far as 4 pot diesels go in this segment, it is one of the best, certainly better than the A6 and the E220 CDI. There's a bit of noise intrusion at lower speeds but over about 30mph it dies down.Sorry that's not really talked you into it!

The Tourer is hugely practical and the electric tailgate is pretty handy. They're good cars if you spring for an Auto.
Yadizzle1 said:
cerb4.5lee said:
The 4 pot diesel engine in the 520d is pretty rough and ready, if it was me I would go slightly older(previous gen) and go for a 530d/535d.
Sorry that's not really talked you into it!
It's really not that bad!!!! As far as 4 pot diesels go in this segment, it is one of the best, certainly better than the A6 and the E220 CDI. There's a bit of noise intrusion at lower speeds but over about 30mph it dies down.Sorry that's not really talked you into it!

The Tourer is hugely practical and the electric tailgate is pretty handy. They're good cars if you spring for an Auto.

I wanted one to carry my Labrador and do tip runs so for that remit the engine should have been fine...but I have said though that if I had gone for the 530d touring instead I would more than likely still have it, I just found the engine not only gutless in that application but also pretty crude.
cerb4.5lee said:
I do tend to be a little too harsh on the 4 pot diesel to be fair, and if you are buying a 5 series touring it is a car to do a job of just being practical so my expectations shouldn't have been that high of the engine anyway...I did still think it was poor though! 
I guess it's all subjective, this was the second diesel car we owned the first of which was a i-Dtec Accord which was a lot louder and far less refined. Did try a 330d before sacrificing the 30d engine for the size and interior of the 5 series. On a day to day basis, you don't really feel like you miss out on much, especially when just cruising around. 
530D is next on the list however!
Yadizzle1 said:
cerb4.5lee said:
I do tend to be a little too harsh on the 4 pot diesel to be fair, and if you are buying a 5 series touring it is a car to do a job of just being practical so my expectations shouldn't have been that high of the engine anyway...I did still think it was poor though! 
I guess it's all subjective, this was the second diesel car we owned the first of which was a i-Dtec Accord which was a lot louder and far less refined. Did try a 330d before sacrificing the 30d engine for the size and interior of the 5 series. On a day to day basis, you don't really feel like you miss out on much, especially when just cruising around. 
530D is next on the list however!
It was knocking about daily in it when I tended to dislike its engine the most, my mrs still gets mad at me for getting rid of it though because it was immaculate and I looked after it too, plus it wasn't terrible on fuel and really practical for the family.
I do think if I hadn't have owned a 330d to compare it too then I would have been more than happy with the engine to be honest.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


