E46 330Ci Suspension Refresh Advice Needed
Discussion
Hi all,
I'm looking to refresh my suspension on my E46 330Ci facelift as I'm off on a tour around Europe in summer. I want to retain as much OEM as possible unless aftermarket is a significant improvement. The car doesn't get tracked and I'm not interested in lowering it. I take it a good place to start would be bushes, springs and dampeners? Anything else worth doing?
Currently looking at Bilstein B6 dampeners with OEM sachs springs, will this be a good set up? Or am I better off sticking to sachs springs and dampeners?
Also are polyurethane bushes worth fitting or shall I reserve them for the sub-frame bushes only?
Cheers in advance!
I'm looking to refresh my suspension on my E46 330Ci facelift as I'm off on a tour around Europe in summer. I want to retain as much OEM as possible unless aftermarket is a significant improvement. The car doesn't get tracked and I'm not interested in lowering it. I take it a good place to start would be bushes, springs and dampeners? Anything else worth doing?
Currently looking at Bilstein B6 dampeners with OEM sachs springs, will this be a good set up? Or am I better off sticking to sachs springs and dampeners?
Also are polyurethane bushes worth fitting or shall I reserve them for the sub-frame bushes only?
Cheers in advance!
I have just had some Powerflex bushes installed on the front with some new meyle control arms. It has noticeably sharpened up the steering (the old bushes were shot). The other difference I can feel on more rough road surfaces is a slight increase in road noise and vibration through the steering wheel, most noticeable on rough motorway surfaces. I guess its the trade off with having more direct steering.
If you enjoy the car in the corners then I would recommend the change to poly bushes. If you favour the cars smooth cruising ability, stick with OEM or traditional bushes. Having driven it with the new poly bushes for a few weeks now, I think I would pick them over OEM again for the greater steering feel they offer. For info, I'm just running the stock OEM dampers and springs.
If you enjoy the car in the corners then I would recommend the change to poly bushes. If you favour the cars smooth cruising ability, stick with OEM or traditional bushes. Having driven it with the new poly bushes for a few weeks now, I think I would pick them over OEM again for the greater steering feel they offer. For info, I'm just running the stock OEM dampers and springs.
Edited by downhillmalins on Thursday 10th March 13:39
Edited by downhillmalins on Thursday 10th March 13:40
BMW now do genuine parts for the E46 that are cheaper than GSF or Euro Car Parts.
Rear Trailing Arm Bushes, Front Control Arm Bushes, Anti-roll Bar bushes and Drop Links. Means you can accelerate out of corners without it trying to swap ends, and - if you do ever find yourself on the inside lane - it won't weave over the truck tyre ruts. The car with also ride a lot better.
Top mounts probably a good idea, but depends on age/mileage. The fronts are a pain.
Brake Hoses, disks and pads make an amazing difference. You can fit aftermarket if you want to, but when genuine bits are this cheap (and work so well away from the track) - why?
Brake fluid change - may as well after the above.
Full alignment, then:
Fresh tyres (from a BMW recommended make / range) in the correct sizes. It really doesn't like worn tyres, which all of the above being worn tends to cause/exaggerate.
Been there, done this.
I also refreshed the dampers, because the car was still on its original set after 150kmiles. But here I went for OEM as they were half the price of BMW. Not as nicely painted, but from the same manufacturer.
Now at 170k, and it's stil squeak and rattle free...
Rear Trailing Arm Bushes, Front Control Arm Bushes, Anti-roll Bar bushes and Drop Links. Means you can accelerate out of corners without it trying to swap ends, and - if you do ever find yourself on the inside lane - it won't weave over the truck tyre ruts. The car with also ride a lot better.
Top mounts probably a good idea, but depends on age/mileage. The fronts are a pain.
Brake Hoses, disks and pads make an amazing difference. You can fit aftermarket if you want to, but when genuine bits are this cheap (and work so well away from the track) - why?
Brake fluid change - may as well after the above.
Full alignment, then:
Fresh tyres (from a BMW recommended make / range) in the correct sizes. It really doesn't like worn tyres, which all of the above being worn tends to cause/exaggerate.
Been there, done this.
I also refreshed the dampers, because the car was still on its original set after 150kmiles. But here I went for OEM as they were half the price of BMW. Not as nicely painted, but from the same manufacturer.
Now at 170k, and it's stil squeak and rattle free...
You will only need lower arms if the balljoints are worn, there is nothing else to wear there so replacing them is a waste of money. The polyurethane bushes are a huge improvement over stock and are designed to be as quiet as NEW original rubber ones. You will always feel more through the steering using new bushes over the old sloppy ones, whichever you use.
Those subframe bushes are an epic to install needing the entire rear axle removed, so make sure you really need them before taking the plunge.
The most effective poly bushes are the front lower arm and rear arm on the front outside, most of the others are just replace as necessary bushes.
There are a huge number of shock absorbers available and you cannot really go wrong with any of the big brand names, Bilstein, Koni and Sachs to name a few.
Springs are either fine, or broken, so there is no need to replace them as a matter of course, but the BMW ones are poor quality and prone to breakage, so replacing with Eibach or similar would be good as they only lower the car marginally, not "slammed" as most of the budget sets do.
New rear top mounts and you are all done.
Those subframe bushes are an epic to install needing the entire rear axle removed, so make sure you really need them before taking the plunge.
The most effective poly bushes are the front lower arm and rear arm on the front outside, most of the others are just replace as necessary bushes.
There are a huge number of shock absorbers available and you cannot really go wrong with any of the big brand names, Bilstein, Koni and Sachs to name a few.
Springs are either fine, or broken, so there is no need to replace them as a matter of course, but the BMW ones are poor quality and prone to breakage, so replacing with Eibach or similar would be good as they only lower the car marginally, not "slammed" as most of the budget sets do.
New rear top mounts and you are all done.
Thanks for the replies so far, super helpful!
After doing some research I've decided that Bilstein B8 dampers with Eibach pro-kit springs. The kit is actually B12 if I'm correct. This should take my suspension to the same as the sport set up, if not slightly lower, and offer a slightly stiffer ride but without compromising the comfort too much?
From what downhill has said, I think I'll stick with OEM bushes unless the poly are truely better and offer no downside, 8Tech? I just had the bushes done on the front wishbone rear bushes. Are these the ones that benefit most? Also what are the lower arms, the rear or front? Apologies 8Tech this is all new to me. My friend also mentioned not to touch the subframe ones unless they need doing for the reason you stated haha.
Just had front pagid pads and discs fitted, worth doing the back as well? Also are brake lines and fluid change easy to do?
As for tyres I'm currently running continental sport contact 3 all round, 225 front, 255 rear. When I come to replace them is it worth going for the new sport contact 5 or sticking with the 3's? I'm happy with them now and they seem to be recommend by a lot of people.
After doing some research I've decided that Bilstein B8 dampers with Eibach pro-kit springs. The kit is actually B12 if I'm correct. This should take my suspension to the same as the sport set up, if not slightly lower, and offer a slightly stiffer ride but without compromising the comfort too much?
From what downhill has said, I think I'll stick with OEM bushes unless the poly are truely better and offer no downside, 8Tech? I just had the bushes done on the front wishbone rear bushes. Are these the ones that benefit most? Also what are the lower arms, the rear or front? Apologies 8Tech this is all new to me. My friend also mentioned not to touch the subframe ones unless they need doing for the reason you stated haha.
Just had front pagid pads and discs fitted, worth doing the back as well? Also are brake lines and fluid change easy to do?
As for tyres I'm currently running continental sport contact 3 all round, 225 front, 255 rear. When I come to replace them is it worth going for the new sport contact 5 or sticking with the 3's? I'm happy with them now and they seem to be recommend by a lot of people.
AB57 said:
Thanks for the replies so far, super helpful!
After doing some research I've decided that Bilstein B8 dampers with Eibach pro-kit springs. The kit is actually B12 if I'm correct. This should take my suspension to the same as the sport set up, if not slightly lower, and offer a slightly stiffer ride but without compromising the comfort too much?
From what downhill has said, I think I'll stick with OEM bushes unless the poly are truely better and offer no downside, 8Tech? I just had the bushes done on the front wishbone rear bushes. Are these the ones that benefit most? Also what are the lower arms, the rear or front? Apologies 8Tech this is all new to me. My friend also mentioned not to touch the subframe ones unless they need doing for the reason you stated haha.
Just had front pagid pads and discs fitted, worth doing the back as well? Also are brake lines and fluid change easy to do?
As for tyres I'm currently running continental sport contact 3 all round, 225 front, 255 rear. When I come to replace them is it worth going for the new sport contact 5 or sticking with the 3's? I'm happy with them now and they seem to be recommend by a lot of people.
After talking to a few people it seems that sticking with OEM dampers and springs is the way to go. However I'm completely baffled on which are the correct ones to get!? Sachs dampers and springs are the OEM as far as I'm aware but then I'm lost on which are the correct ones for the sport set up on my car. Anyone got an idea? After doing some research I've decided that Bilstein B8 dampers with Eibach pro-kit springs. The kit is actually B12 if I'm correct. This should take my suspension to the same as the sport set up, if not slightly lower, and offer a slightly stiffer ride but without compromising the comfort too much?
From what downhill has said, I think I'll stick with OEM bushes unless the poly are truely better and offer no downside, 8Tech? I just had the bushes done on the front wishbone rear bushes. Are these the ones that benefit most? Also what are the lower arms, the rear or front? Apologies 8Tech this is all new to me. My friend also mentioned not to touch the subframe ones unless they need doing for the reason you stated haha.
Just had front pagid pads and discs fitted, worth doing the back as well? Also are brake lines and fluid change easy to do?
As for tyres I'm currently running continental sport contact 3 all round, 225 front, 255 rear. When I come to replace them is it worth going for the new sport contact 5 or sticking with the 3's? I'm happy with them now and they seem to be recommend by a lot of people.

AB57 said:
From what downhill has said, I think I'll stick with OEM bushes unless the poly are truely better and offer no downside, 8Tech? I just had the bushes done on the front wishbone rear bushes. Are these the ones that benefit most?
I did a fair bit of reading on the pro's and cons of poly bushes before buying them, I would really recommend them from my experience with them so far. The other advantage is that poly bushes should last far longer than the OEM style that dry out over time. By the sound of it you have just had the main ones changed so maybe not the best use of cash changing them again so soon. The lower arms are the front control arms/ wishbone, as 8Tech mentioned no real point changing these unless you have play in the ball joints.
AB57 said:
After talking to a few people it seems that sticking with OEM dampers and springs is the way to go. However I'm completely baffled on which are the correct ones to get!? Sachs dampers and springs are the OEM as far as I'm aware but then I'm lost on which are the correct ones for the sport set up on my car. Anyone got an idea? 
The oem dampers are made by Sachs. For replacements Sachs used to supply a choice of standard (blue label) or sport (red label) spec dampers. They no longer make the sports dampers. The standard dampers on your car are the sport spec Sachs. I have the standard Sachs on the rear of mine and they are fine. I would still recommend the Eibach springs and the B8s work well on the front. 
These should be changed with the rear dampers:
This is a spare pair of top mount washers and reinforcement plates. Send me a pm if you want to make an offer for them.
Edited by helix402 on Friday 11th March 16:08
If I have understood things correctly you like the way your car handles but want to refresh things. I would seriously consider koni FSD dampers. They are an OEM replacement and adapt to the frequency of bumps giving you a very good ride, but will then stiffen when you press on. They are not cheap, but you could use OEM springs or eibachs. Bilsteins are great but generally are firm. A b8 will be firmer again from the B6's which will be stiffer than b4's and b4's are OEM damping.
I would replace bushes with OEM the difference will be significant if your old bushes are worn. Poly bushes are excellent, but will transmit more noise of bumps into the car. The flip side is more direct steering and better durability.
I would replace bushes with OEM the difference will be significant if your old bushes are worn. Poly bushes are excellent, but will transmit more noise of bumps into the car. The flip side is more direct steering and better durability.
Ah ok thanks Helix, when I make my mind up I'll drop you a pm, although it may not be anytime soon. When I replace them I'll do them as a set of 4 dampers,I don't want to have them different front to rear. Will the b6 bilstein with sachs springs be a better set up? From what people mention on the eibach is that they cause quite a bit of bounce, which is not what I want. Will the sachs sport springs fit onto the b6 or will I have to use the b8 set up?
Would that spare set of top mounts work with bilstein or Konis?
Yeah sohl, although now I've found that they don't do the Sach sport dampeners I'm definitely going aftermarket for them. I'll look into the Konis. Are they are softer setup than the bilstein?
In my head I want bilstein b6 with sachs sport springs - will that combo work?
Polybushes on the key points which 8Tech mentioned and oem on the rest.
Would that spare set of top mounts work with bilstein or Konis?
Yeah sohl, although now I've found that they don't do the Sach sport dampeners I'm definitely going aftermarket for them. I'll look into the Konis. Are they are softer setup than the bilstein?
In my head I want bilstein b6 with sachs sport springs - will that combo work?
Polybushes on the key points which 8Tech mentioned and oem on the rest.
AB57 said:
Ah ok thanks Helix, when I make my mind up I'll drop you a pm, although it may not be anytime soon. When I replace them I'll do them as a set of 4 dampers,I don't want to have them different front to rear. Will the b6 bilstein with sachs springs be a better set up? From what people mention on the eibach is that they cause quite a bit of bounce, which is not what I want. Will the sachs sport springs fit onto the b6 or will I have to use the b8 set up?
Would that spare set of top mounts work with bilstein or Konis?
Yeah sohl, although now I've found that they don't do the Sach sport dampeners I'm definitely going aftermarket for them. I'll look into the Konis. Are they are softer setup than the bilstein?
In my head I want bilstein b6 with sachs sport springs - will that combo work?
Polybushes on the key points which 8Tech mentioned and oem on the rest.
The B6s are designed for standard springs and up to 30mm lowering. I haven't used them so can't give a review based on experience. The B8s are only designed for shorter springs. Eibachs don't give a bouncy ride. The Sachs sport springs and B6s would probably be good-as long as the rear dampers are more forgiving than the B8s. The pictured items I have spare are reinforcement plates and top mount washers, they fit the rear dampers you mentioned. BMW modified the design with a rubber spacer to make the top mount work better and last longer. You would still need to buy a pair of top mounts.Would that spare set of top mounts work with bilstein or Konis?
Yeah sohl, although now I've found that they don't do the Sach sport dampeners I'm definitely going aftermarket for them. I'll look into the Konis. Are they are softer setup than the bilstein?
In my head I want bilstein b6 with sachs sport springs - will that combo work?
Polybushes on the key points which 8Tech mentioned and oem on the rest.
I don't use Koni anymore after I had several dampers fail in a short space of time.
Edited by helix402 on Friday 11th March 17:03
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



