Bmw 116i es misfire and dsc flashes no fault codes.
Bmw 116i es misfire and dsc flashes no fault codes.
Author
Discussion

harleywilma

Original Poster:

526 posts

274 months

Sunday 13th March 2016
quotequote all
Hi all, My daughters bmw 116 es occasionally misfires and the dsc light flashes around the same time then occasionally goes into limp mode,so she then has to turn engine off restart then its OK for a while,My local bm indy said it was rear reluctor rings and sensors,but to make sure drive the car with the dsc off by way of holding down the button till the light illuminates and if the car then drives OK it will be that fault. Alas the car is still losing power and jolting whilst dsc isolated,and still no fault codes.The car is a 2008 with 63000 miles,My indy now says to wait till the car fails then look further but this is so annoying and awful to drive not knowing when it will happen,Has anyone else experienced these same symptoms? as we are almost ready to throw in the towel on this dreadful car!!

Firing order

93 posts

186 months

Sunday 13th March 2016
quotequote all
Firstly I would get a diagnostic at a dealer they can carry out
A misfire detection test and then take it on from there the day
Is a secondary fault .

Kawasicki

14,428 posts

266 months

Sunday 13th March 2016
quotequote all
The misfire is probably the esp system believing it is necessary to start traction control.

no fault codes is possibly due to it being considered normal operation.

The switch may not have control over the part of the system that is causing the issue.

Check the wheel speed sensors, check the sensor ring, disconnect the esp ecru and reconnect it a few times. Also, I have seen odd issues where a failing wheel bearing caused the wheel speed sensor to pick up incorrect wheel speeds.


harleywilma

Original Poster:

526 posts

274 months

Monday 14th March 2016
quotequote all
Kawasicki said:
The misfire is probably the esp system believing it is necessary to start traction control.

no fault codes is possibly due to it being considered normal operation.

The switch may not have control over the part of the system that is causing the issue.

Check the wheel speed sensors, check the sensor ring, disconnect the esp ecru and reconnect it a few times. Also, I have seen odd issues where a failing wheel bearing caused the wheel speed sensor to pick up incorrect wheel speeds.
Indy said they looked a bit rusty but Im worried about spending £400 on replacing rings and sensors then the fault is still there as he insists that disabling with button pressed would stop car misfiring if it was that particular fault? but you seem to be making sense.

Kawasicki

14,428 posts

266 months

Monday 14th March 2016
quotequote all
looks like others may have had the same problem as you....

http://www.autoinform.co.uk/half-truth-is-lie/

My advice is to find a good mechanic, they are out there.

Good luck with your issue.


Kawasicki

14,428 posts

266 months

Monday 14th March 2016
quotequote all
also...ask around and I'm sure you will get someone to look at a live diagnostics readout while you drive the car. I've done this in the past, you can usually see the dodgy wheel speed signal which is causing the unwanted traction control intervention. Both front wheels will probably be used as the reference speed signal in your car, and the rears wills be constantly monitored/compared. If one or both of the rears signal shows significantly higher speed than the front when you are on the throttle, for whatever reason, then the system will cut in. If you get the misfire when driving gently the system will probably have estimated you are driving on ice or snow.

harleywilma

Original Poster:

526 posts

274 months

Tuesday 15th March 2016
quotequote all
Kawasicki said:
also...ask around and I'm sure you will get someone to look at a live diagnostics readout while you drive the car. I've done this in the past, you can usually see the dodgy wheel speed signal which is causing the unwanted traction control intervention. Both front wheels will probably be used as the reference speed signal in your car, and the rears wills be constantly monitored/compared. If one or both of the rears signal shows significantly higher speed than the front when you are on the throttle, for whatever reason, then the system will cut in. If you get the misfire when driving gently the system will probably have estimated you are driving on ice or snow.
Many thanks for your input,
we had so much trouble when buying a Vaux antara from a large dealer ship and had to get them to have it back as it kept going into limp mode and even Vauxhall couldn't fix it,So I thought to buy this little 08 bmw 116i to get her out of trouble,after a few days she noticed it misbehaving and occasionally going to limp mode on extended runs, Seems all these cars are riddled with inherent Faults and no one can fix them so they just get passed on from person to person,Bmw should hold there head in shame for building such terrible cars.

buggalugs

9,297 posts

268 months

Tuesday 15th March 2016
quotequote all
I'm really surprised there's no fault codes if it's going into limp mode, maybe they don't have the right software to read them or maybe there are codes and they say rear reluctor rings.

harleywilma

Original Poster:

526 posts

274 months

Tuesday 15th March 2016
quotequote all
buggalugs said:
I'm really surprised there's no fault codes if it's going into limp mode, maybe they don't have the right software to read them or maybe there are codes and they say rear reluctor rings.
They are BMW specialists Ive been using them on and off for years when I sometimes make the stupid mistake of buying a bmw,They have all the latest up to date diagnostics gear.I think that the Bmw 1 series is just a crap car and looking at various forums Im not the only one that thinks this, as they are all riddled with gremlins.We will trade it in and the dealer can sell it on to some other poor suspecting misguided idiot, I recently stupidly bought a 525d m sport tourer with lowish miles and that awful car didn't like changing gear very much,And that is probably why the first owner got rid,I called Bmw main dealer about the problem and they couldn't even be bothered to get back to me about it,loads about that on forums also,So Im going back to Mercedes, as a used Bmw makes no sense at all.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 15th March 2016
quotequote all
harleywilma said:
buggalugs said:
I'm really surprised there's no fault codes if it's going into limp mode, maybe they don't have the right software to read them or maybe there are codes and they say rear reluctor rings.
They are BMW specialists Ive been using them on and off for years when I sometimes make the stupid mistake of buying a bmw,They have all the latest up to date diagnostics gear.I think that the Bmw 1 series is just a crap car and looking at various forums Im not the only one that thinks this, as they are all riddled with gremlins.We will trade it in and the dealer can sell it on to some other poor suspecting misguided idiot, I recently stupidly bought a 525d m sport tourer with lowish miles and that awful car didn't like changing gear very much,And that is probably why the first owner got rid,I called Bmw main dealer about the problem and they couldn't even be bothered to get back to me about it,loads about that on forums also,So Im going back to Mercedes, as a used Bmw makes no sense at all.

I feel your pain but lots of Mercedes owners aren't overjoyed by the quality of their cars or the service they receive.

I've got one of each. So far the BMW's been the better car.

buggalugs

9,297 posts

268 months

Tuesday 15th March 2016
quotequote all
Yup I was £750 down and no car for 3 week last year with my C220 because the little electric motor in the steering lock packed up. rolleyes Key in, no buzz, computer says walk. Car's only done 100k.

harleywilma

Original Poster:

526 posts

274 months

Tuesday 15th March 2016
quotequote all
buggalugs said:
Yup I was £750 down and no car for 3 week last year with my C220 because the little electric motor in the steering lock packed up. rolleyes Key in, no buzz, computer says walk. Car's only done 100k.
st me Ill stick to driving an old 2003 Honda accord tourer I bought recently to get me out of trouble and that's been totally reliable and cant fault the old thing apart from the remote is crap till you get right to the car window, forget about so called descent car's .
Seems the manufacturers are building these cars with the faults in them ,so they are a ticking time bomb..

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 15th March 2016
quotequote all
harleywilma said:
buggalugs said:
Yup I was £750 down and no car for 3 week last year with my C220 because the little electric motor in the steering lock packed up. rolleyes Key in, no buzz, computer says walk. Car's only done 100k.
st me Ill stick to driving an old 2003 Honda accord tourer I bought recently to get me out of trouble and that's been totally reliable and cant fault the old thing apart from the remote is crap till you get right to the car window, forget about so called descent car's .
Seems the manufacturers are building these cars with the faults in them ,so they are a ticking time bomb..
In all honesty and in my experience most of the Japanese or far eastern brands other than Chinese will be more reliable and cheaper to run than any of the 'prestige' brand from Europe including the UK.

buggalugs

9,297 posts

268 months

Tuesday 15th March 2016
quotequote all
Yep I've spent a lot of time in bangers and I can't say I've had a steering lock leave me stranded before. I was really loving my merc experience but that has really marred it for me. The guy at the main dealers was enthusing about how I now had a two year warranty on my steering lock and key reader thingy, whoop de do, didn't realise I needed one.

Not that BMW has any room to talk about electronic keys on recent models... hehe

Edited by buggalugs on Tuesday 15th March 19:58