BMW 130i advice
BMW 130i advice
Author
Discussion

briantherobot

Original Poster:

39 posts

154 months

Wednesday 16th March 2016
quotequote all
Hi all,

New poster to the BMW area..
130i Owner for just over a year and what a capable little car this really is! Had a year of trouble free motoring until last week when hit with a dreaded VANOS / camshaft correlation fault - 900 quid later shes fixed and back home.


Some advice required please:
- Should we consider selling up in fear of more frequent pricey repair bills? Prices seem to be holding for models under 100k and can get good money if we sell now. Currently we are on 97k.

- Keep her as the N52 is generally bulletproof and really I have nothing to worry about!? And the recent issues are just a minor blip and part of BMW ownership..

1st choice if we sell is back to the trusty Honda Type R as an interim whilst saving up the pennies..

Thanks for any advice on this.

xxChrisxx

538 posts

152 months

Wednesday 16th March 2016
quotequote all
Why sell up just after fixing an expensive fault? Is there any other indication that anything else is wrong?

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 16th March 2016
quotequote all
Seems daft to get rid now, you're not going to recoup the £900 in the sale so you're effectively giving that away (granted, it might make the sale a bit easier, but you can wave goodbye to that £900).

It's not a car that's going to throw massive bills anyway so it's worth "making your money" out of the recent repair and enjoying the car for yourself.

I've recently deliberated a similar scenario myself. I'd spent £500 on tyres, £250 on an a service and £1,000 on bills in the past 5 months and I was looking to trade up to an M135i. They offered me £3k for my 330Ci (which, to be honest, isn't a bad deal for me), however they'd have given me the same before I'd done the work to it. I figure I might as well get at least another year to 18 months out of it to make that money I've invested into it back.

There's no real right or wrong answer but I can understand the logic behind both options.

briantherobot

Original Poster:

39 posts

154 months

Wednesday 16th March 2016
quotequote all
Thanks chaps,
Nothing to suggest any other issues except it's suddenly developed the N52 ticking noise - annoying but I've read it's nothing to worry about and common on all of these engines.

Guess after an expensive bill such as this it's worth keeping for at least another year to as you say enjoy the car some more...And if anything else goes wrong it's going!


Mr Tidy

31,941 posts

158 months

Thursday 17th March 2016
quotequote all
OP, I know what you mean!

I have a Z4 Coupe with the same N52 engine as your 130i and have just paid £800ish for a new electric water pump and thermostat to be fitted! eek

Wonderful as the N52 engine is, I am still trying to decide whether to keep it and get some use out of it or bail out before I get kicked in the nuts again!

I have a 325Ti as a daily driver with the previous generation M54 engine and got a new radiator, temperature sensor, expansion tank and aux drive belt fitted for not much more than half as much!

And then I keep thinking maybe I should sell them both and get a 130i............confused!

S3_Graham

12,835 posts

230 months

Thursday 17th March 2016
quotequote all
briantherobot said:
Thanks chaps,
Nothing to suggest any other issues except it's suddenly developed the N52 ticking noise - annoying but I've read it's nothing to worry about and common on all of these engines.

Guess after an expensive bill such as this it's worth keeping for at least another year to as you say enjoy the car some more...And if anything else goes wrong it's going!
My 130 had the ticking thing on start up. That was when it was 3 years old with 45k on it. I'd start up, it would tick and id turn it off and back on. tick gone smile