135i LSD - WaveTrac or Quaife
135i LSD - WaveTrac or Quaife
Author
Discussion

mikeyscott

Original Poster:

1,200 posts

239 months

Thursday 17th March 2016
quotequote all
Keep mulling a LSD in my 135i if I keep it, anyone gone down the Wavetrac route Vs Quaife?

Huskyman

655 posts

158 months

Saturday 19th March 2016
quotequote all
They are both torque sensing diffs and both claim to be maintenance free unlike plate diffs, and they both have good reputations. However Birds who do lots of testing use the Quaife diff and swear by it, and they know what they are talking about when it comes to making a Bimmer handle

VerySideways

10,272 posts

303 months

Sunday 20th March 2016
quotequote all
I have experience of Birds and the Quaife and can heartily recommend both.
Quaife in my 130i transformed the drive, especially out of tighter corners in the dry and generally in the wet.

Not that I've heard anything bad about the other.

aeropilot

40,919 posts

258 months

Monday 21st March 2016
quotequote all
Both units are excellent, the Wavetrack by a smidgen is technically the better unit......but, a bit more hassle in getting fitted in the UK.

Then again, unless you are in the south of the country, Bird's drive in - drive out service might mean a very long day or an overnight....although still less hassle than getting a Wavetrack installed (unless you get hold of another matching diff pumkin and get that sent away to Wavetrack and then swap over, which would be the way to do it?)


mikeyscott

Original Poster:

1,200 posts

239 months

Monday 21st March 2016
quotequote all
aeropilot said:
Both units are excellent, the Wavetrack by a smidgen is technically the better unit......but, a bit more hassle in getting fitted in the UK.

Then again, unless you are in the south of the country, Bird's drive in - drive out service might mean a very long day or an overnight....although still less hassle than getting a Wavetrack installed (unless you get hold of another matching diff pumkin and get that sent away to Wavetrack and then swap over, which would be the way to do it?)
Regal Autosport are just down the road from me.

aeropilot

40,919 posts

258 months

Monday 21st March 2016
quotequote all
mikeyscott said:
aeropilot said:
Both units are excellent, the Wavetrack by a smidgen is technically the better unit......but, a bit more hassle in getting fitted in the UK.

Then again, unless you are in the south of the country, Bird's drive in - drive out service might mean a very long day or an overnight....although still less hassle than getting a Wavetrack installed (unless you get hold of another matching diff pumkin and get that sent away to Wavetrack and then swap over, which would be the way to do it?)
Regal Autosport are just down the road from me.
Are they just a supplier (as listed on the Wavetrack website, not listed as an installer) or can they install as well?

mikeyscott

Original Poster:

1,200 posts

239 months

Monday 21st March 2016
quotequote all
aeropilot said:
mikeyscott said:
aeropilot said:
Both units are excellent, the Wavetrack by a smidgen is technically the better unit......but, a bit more hassle in getting fitted in the UK.

Then again, unless you are in the south of the country, Bird's drive in - drive out service might mean a very long day or an overnight....although still less hassle than getting a Wavetrack installed (unless you get hold of another matching diff pumkin and get that sent away to Wavetrack and then swap over, which would be the way to do it?)
Regal Autosport are just down the road from me.
Are they just a supplier (as listed on the Wavetrack website, not listed as an installer) or can they install as well?
They can do both.

aeropilot

40,919 posts

258 months

Monday 21st March 2016
quotequote all
mikeyscott said:
aeropilot said:
mikeyscott said:
aeropilot said:
Both units are excellent, the Wavetrack by a smidgen is technically the better unit......but, a bit more hassle in getting fitted in the UK.

Then again, unless you are in the south of the country, Bird's drive in - drive out service might mean a very long day or an overnight....although still less hassle than getting a Wavetrack installed (unless you get hold of another matching diff pumkin and get that sent away to Wavetrack and then swap over, which would be the way to do it?)
Regal Autosport are just down the road from me.
Are they just a supplier (as listed on the Wavetrack website, not listed as an installer) or can they install as well?
They can do both.
Sorted then.

mikeyscott

Original Poster:

1,200 posts

239 months

Monday 21st March 2016
quotequote all
aeropilot said:
mikeyscott said:
aeropilot said:
mikeyscott said:
aeropilot said:
Both units are excellent, the Wavetrack by a smidgen is technically the better unit......but, a bit more hassle in getting fitted in the UK.

Then again, unless you are in the south of the country, Bird's drive in - drive out service might mean a very long day or an overnight....although still less hassle than getting a Wavetrack installed (unless you get hold of another matching diff pumkin and get that sent away to Wavetrack and then swap over, which would be the way to do it?)
Regal Autosport are just down the road from me.
Are they just a supplier (as listed on the Wavetrack website, not listed as an installer) or can they install as well?
They can do both.
Sorted then.
Yeah will get pricing as part of me semi feels, sell 135i and save for a DCT M3, don't know TBH

aeropilot

40,919 posts

258 months

Monday 21st March 2016
quotequote all
mikeyscott said:
aeropilot said:
mikeyscott said:
aeropilot said:
mikeyscott said:
aeropilot said:
Both units are excellent, the Wavetrack by a smidgen is technically the better unit......but, a bit more hassle in getting fitted in the UK.

Then again, unless you are in the south of the country, Bird's drive in - drive out service might mean a very long day or an overnight....although still less hassle than getting a Wavetrack installed (unless you get hold of another matching diff pumkin and get that sent away to Wavetrack and then swap over, which would be the way to do it?)
Regal Autosport are just down the road from me.
Are they just a supplier (as listed on the Wavetrack website, not listed as an installer) or can they install as well?
They can do both.
Sorted then.
Yeah will get pricing as part of me semi feels, sell 135i and save for a DCT M3, don't know TBH
E92 I presume?

Nice, nearly bought one new myself instead of the 135i.....but, at the time I was doing 18k per miles, so the M3 would have been a very costly option (to run, not so to buy though) and also, as great as that engine is.....I just prefer a turbo for a daily driver. I'd take the M3 over the 135i every day of the week to drive on a track, but the 135i won me over as a daily driver.



mikeyscott

Original Poster:

1,200 posts

239 months

Monday 21st March 2016
quotequote all
E90 or E92, like both.
I walk to work as a whole, so prob do 300 miles a month.

One thing I do regret is not going DCT on 135i.

Think balance and ride of E90/92 will be better.

Not sure yet as M3 I'd have to get circa £8k diff to get one I'd like.

Just don't know TBH.

aeropilot

40,919 posts

258 months

Monday 21st March 2016
quotequote all
mikeyscott said:
Think balance and ride of E90/92 will be better.
Absolutely.

E92 did feel 'big' to me though (test drove it after the 135i) and I got out of the 135i test grinning like I did after my Sunbeam-Lotus test drive 25 years earlier....whilst the 135i doesn't have the out of the box chassis of the M3, it actually felt a lot more raw and hooligan-like to me, whereas, I didn't get out of the E92 grinning in the same way. Perhaps, it's greater ability and development for counted against it as a road. Don't get me wrong, the M3 was a brilliant car.....but not a daily driver for me. Probably my age biggrin


mikeyscott

Original Poster:

1,200 posts

239 months

Monday 21st March 2016
quotequote all
aeropilot said:
mikeyscott said:
Think balance and ride of E90/92 will be better.
Absolutely.

E92 did feel 'big' to me though (test drove it after the 135i) and I got out of the 135i test grinning like I did after my Sunbeam-Lotus test drive 25 years earlier....whilst the 135i doesn't have the out of the box chassis of the M3, it actually felt a lot more raw and hooligan-like to me, whereas, I didn't get out of the E92 grinning in the same way. Perhaps, it's greater ability and development for counted against it as a road. Don't get me wrong, the M3 was a brilliant car.....but not a daily driver for me. Probably my age biggrin
Will def be having a think re both options over the coming weeks.

Stay in 135i keep ££ or sell up and save for the next step

mikeyscott

Original Poster:

1,200 posts

239 months

Thursday 24th March 2016
quotequote all
Test drive a 335i DCT tomorrow, however... It's on dreaded 19s with RFT...

Still mulling LSD options and also TBH keeping an eye out for similar spec car to mine inc colour, but DCT.

Think circa £100 ish, maybe slightly more between the Quaife and WaveTrac

Edited by mikeyscott on Thursday 24th March 21:15

mikeyscott

Original Poster:

1,200 posts

239 months

Friday 25th March 2016
quotequote all
Test drove 335i, v nice, but keeping my 135i.

Only change I'd go for at this stage DCT.

Christian-fo2ke

19 posts

136 months

Saturday 26th March 2016
quotequote all
M3 e92 everytime , Evolve DCT tune and a oem mod can't beat it.

windymissile

287 posts

160 months

Sunday 3rd April 2016
quotequote all
There is another option.
MFACTORY supply lsd for our cars. The one in my 335i is superb.

WM

Liamst

168 posts

146 months

Wednesday 6th April 2016
quotequote all
I was in a similar situation looking at e92 m3 or e82 135i but at the time I also needed to use the car for work so went for the 135i more for its discreet appearance than anything else.
Its now remapped with a couple of other bits, changing the RFT for Michellin PS2 has done wonders for both the comfort and the handling. I also went one size up on the fronts to 225 which has helped it feel more neutral. Removal of Camber pins helped again with turn in and general front end confidence.

I now have M3 LCA and TS which will be fitted in next couple of weeks. With these fitted I will be able to have alignment to M3 specs which should help with turn in / handling in general. I got all 4 pieces and the Xenon leveller for less than £150 brand new!

I was looking at saloon m3 (e90) but it just feels too weak in comparison. So I am sticking with the little 1er for now. Also I havent seen one advertised for less than I paid for mine with similar spec so while its not costing me in depreciation it makes sense to hold on.