Cheap 330i, potential money-pit of decent shed?
Cheap 330i, potential money-pit of decent shed?
Author
Discussion

GreenArrow

Original Poster:

4,599 posts

148 months

Saturday 19th March 2016
quotequote all
Ok, here is my dilemma. For the past two and a half years I have run a Mk1 Mazda 6 as a cheap family car. It has never failed to start, doesn't use oil/water and does the job...but with 119,000 miles on the clock it has started to feel very baggy lately and its enough to annoy me and contemplate changing springs/shocks. So, the thought of spending a few hundred on a car worth buttons has seen me looking at a car that I have a couple of times almost owned, the E46 330i...namely the touring model.

There is one particular ebay ad I am reading and two things occurred to me. Firstly the owner seems to have replaced some important and costly items recently. Secondly, is this an indication that I will get regular bills, given the age and mileage of the car?

So, feedback needed from current or former E46 330i owners...are they money pits as they get older? I know they frequently rust, but its things like electronics, suspension bits and so on that concern me.

So, should I stick with my reliable Japanese shed and upgrade a few suspension bits, or take the plunge and buy something more satisfying on a daily basis, but potentially costly.

I should add that buying an old MX-5 last October hasn't helped the Mazda 6s cause, because it introduced me to the delights of RWD handling after 22 years driving FWD cars!!

The ebay ad I am reading is below

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/121923230248?_trksid=p20...

Edited by GreenArrow on Saturday 19th March 13:34

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Saturday 19th March 2016
quotequote all
GreenArrow said:
Ok, here is my dilemma. For the past two and a half years I have run a Mk1 Mazda 6 as a cheap family car. It has never failed to start, doesn't use oil/water and does the job...but with 119,000 miles on the clock it has started to feel very baggy lately and its enough to annoy me and contemplate changing springs/shocks. So, the thought of spending a few hundred on a car worth buttons has seen me looking at a car that I have a couple of times almost owned, the E46 330i...namely the touring model.

There is one particular ebay ad I am reading and two things occurred to me. Firstly the owner seems to have replaced some important and costly items recently. Secondly, is this an indication that I will get regular bills, given the age and mileage of the car?

So, feedback needed from current or former E46 330i owners...are they money pits as they get older? I know they frequently rust, but its things like electronics, suspension bits and so on that concern me.

So, should I stick with my reliable Japanese shed and upgrade a few suspension bits, or take the plunge and buy something more satisfying on a daily basis, but potentially costly.

I should add that buying an old MX-5 last October hasn't helped the Mazda 6s cause, because it introduced me to the delights of RWD handling after 22 years driving FWD cars!!

The ebay ad I am reading is below

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/121923230248?_trksid=p20...

Edited by GreenArrow on Saturday 19th March 13:34
I ran mine to 136k (it's 2005,55 tho) and I would say overall NOT a money pit; biggest job was CCV breather, other than that wear and tear items. However, oil consumption (sometimes not great on these) was always poor and then an oil leak was discovered. that meant a head gasket off job and the cost wasn't, in my opinion, economically viable so it was time to trade.


MOT history on 'yours' was a pretty good read, no major failures; that would give me some optimism, but buying at this price point, is surely a punt whatever others' experience.

Still, in your position, this is where I'd be looking, E46's are great wink













Rsdop

458 posts

148 months

Saturday 19th March 2016
quotequote all
My experience has been good, bought a cheap 330ci with 146k on the clock expecting some problems and its been almost faultless. All its needed is tyres, brakes and a couple of bushes. Recently developed an oil leak from the rocker cover, so whilst I'm doing that im going to change the CCV, Vanos seals and Disa valve which are all common issues on the 330. All the bits to do this cost £230 and will hopefully keep it running well for a while yet.

I think any car this age has the potential for failures but the E46s are known to be reliable and capable of big miles if looked after, parts are not expensive and they are nice to work on. Common faults are the cooling system (check radiator for sagging), front wishbones/bushes, Disa valve (rattles at idle). Not sure about the auto boxes and if they are reliable but the manuals are good. Great cars though so I'd recommend getting one.







JakeT

6,002 posts

151 months

Saturday 19th March 2016
quotequote all
I've seen worse fr more money, that's for sure. Doesn't look all too bad to me and has been cared for. I would stick a bid or two on it and see what happens. Over £2000 might be a little steep, though.

GreenArrow

Original Poster:

4,599 posts

148 months

Saturday 19th March 2016
quotequote all
JakeT said:
I've seen worse fr more money, that's for sure. Doesn't look all too bad to me and has been cared for. I would stick a bid or two on it and see what happens. Over £2000 might be a little steep, though.
Yeah, I think when someone has owned a car for four years and replaced parts like bushes and wishbones (which most people neglect until it comes up as an MOT advisory/fail) its a good sign!

With a day to go, I'd be surprised if it went over 2k, but you can never tell with ebay!!

Another one not too far from me, hasn't a single bid yet, starting at £1000....looks clean under the bonnet and bodywise, as far as one can tell....a few tiny rust bubbles, but really, at this price, who cares....both my Mazdas have rust on them, it goes without saying!

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/BMW-3-Series-330i-SE-Tou...


Edited by GreenArrow on Saturday 19th March 15:29

NiceCupOfTea

25,608 posts

282 months

Saturday 19th March 2016
quotequote all
I really like these - looking myself (although hoping to get a newer manual sport for more money). That first one in particular looks like a very honest car and truth be told probably a better buy than the sort of thing I'm looking for.

Pick that up for 1500 and you'd be doing well I think.let us know how you go!

E-bmw

13,661 posts

183 months

Saturday 19th March 2016
quotequote all
My only reservation with both of those would be the seats, Sport seats are SO much better than SE seats.

There are plenty of SEs out there with Sport seats.

Dr Jekyll

23,820 posts

292 months

Saturday 19th March 2016
quotequote all
GreenArrow said:
I should add that buying an old MX-5 last October hasn't helped the Mazda 6s cause, because it introduced me to the delights of RWD handling after 22 years driving FWD cars!!
Don't expect the BMW to handle like an MX5, early E46s have noticeably vague steering. I went from a Peugeot 306 to a year 2000 BMW 323 and the handling was certainly no improvement, the appeal of the 323/325/330 is the engine. Mind you I don't get the RWD vs FWD thing anyway so perhaps it's just me.

NiceCupOfTea

25,608 posts

282 months

Saturday 19th March 2016
quotequote all
E-bmw said:
My only reservation with both of those would be the seats, Sport seats are SO much better than SE seats.

There are plenty of SEs out there with Sport seats.
I agree but I have had an e36 with a tan non-sport interior and have spent 2 years searching for a sports interior. Recently found one but in much worse condition than mine and seats would need recovering. Worth considering unless its a common colour.

Fwiw the seats are the main reason I wanted a sport...

GreenArrow

Original Poster:

4,599 posts

148 months

Saturday 19th March 2016
quotequote all
Not bothered about the seats, the mechanical integrity is of more concern. I contacted the seller who seems straightforward.he says an abs sensor failed this week which cost 110 quid. This is both reassuring but also scary in that I wonder if sensors and the like will fail regularly at this age and mileage. The wishbone and bushes were done for the mot. It's a cheap car but am I brave enough to risk it after two years of cheap to run jap cars. Oh and by the way I have driven these cars and know they don't handle like an mx5. Still a well balanced machine though compared with most front driven family cars.

JakeT

6,002 posts

151 months

Sunday 20th March 2016
quotequote all
Sold for £1200. Someone got a bit of a bargain I think. Hopefully it was OP.

Kettmark

929 posts

184 months

Sunday 20th March 2016
quotequote all
Had my 330ci sport for 11.5 years and it's on 193k. I have it serviced by an Indi every 6 months so I've got 25 stamps in the book. Been really reliable and indi knows the car inside out and are really good and reasonable price wise. Had 1 new front wing due to rust and had all 4 arches re-waxoiled a couple of years back as a precaution.
Had a few items needed replacement such as thermostat, rocker cover gaskets etc but at reasonable prices.
Was going to get rid when I got my Maserati but can't bring myself to sell..
Buy one. Fantastic all-round cars for the money. Adequate performance and economy and affordable servicing at a good indi.

NiceCupOfTea

25,608 posts

282 months

Monday 21st March 2016
quotequote all
What are the auto boxes like? Personal preference would be for a manual but if everything else is right about the car I could be swayed by an auto I think - but I understand the e39 has some issues with the auto box with the same engine. Is it the same box? What are they like to drive?

tgr

1,256 posts

202 months

Monday 21st March 2016
quotequote all
Both autoboxes (GM and ZF) can be weak at high mileages. Luck of the draw

GreenArrow

Original Poster:

4,599 posts

148 months

Monday 21st March 2016
quotequote all
JakeT said:
Sold for £1200. Someone got a bit of a bargain I think. Hopefully it was OP.
.

Well, I was in the bidding, but just before the end of the auction my head was turned by an ad for a very local E39 540i which came up. Similar miles, slightly pricier with 12 months MOT, I decided to let the 3 go and went to view the 5 today, because tbh I have always fancied an E39, even ahead of an E46 and a 4.4 litre V8 for £1750 seemed to good to pass up. I was close to buying the E39, as it did drive well and seemed so clean, but when I examined the MOT details it had a long list of advisories so I decided to let it go. I sort of got the impression, the previous owner had traded it in just as a lot of jobs needed doing. As they say, best not to buy the first car you view.....so I will keep looking!

Kettmark

929 posts

184 months

Monday 21st March 2016
quotequote all
Lots of conflicting opinions on the auto gearbox. Mines auto and never had the oil changed. Sea!ed for life so BMW say. Surely they tested these for a few 100 thousand miles?
Mines on 193k with no auto issues touch wood. One of the lucky ones?

NiceCupOfTea

25,608 posts

282 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2016
quotequote all
While we're talking 330s, I have a couple of questions!

I'm after a 330 Touring - ideally a Sport with a manual gearbox.

Most of the options that I want (leather, climate+a/c, cruise, auto lights/wipers) seem to be standard on these, certainly the later cars, so that's good.

However, really keen on heated seats and xenons. How easy are these to retrofit? Is the wiring there for the seats so they are plug and play? I know xenons need "coding" to the car, but are they plug and play, & easy to find.

At the moment I'm torn between getting a slightly sheddy £2k one to rur for a couple of years and spending more money on a really nice one and making it a "keeper" family car...

corozin

2,680 posts

302 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2016
quotequote all
NOt wishing to upset anyone but whilst my own 330ci has been pretty good reliability wise a Mazda 6 is on another planet of low cost motoring altogether. If cheap running is your key criteria you'd be mad not to get another Mazda. They even have BOSE stereos in them if you look about for one

helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2016
quotequote all
Mazda? Anyway, retrofit heated seats, this needs a loom which runs to each seat and to the fuse box and switches. You then need to replace the seat covers for heated ones, if fit second hand seats. Not plug and play, but doable. And you need the switches.

Xenon aren't plug and play.

NiceCupOfTea

25,608 posts

282 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2016
quotequote all
helix402 said:
Mazda? Anyway, retrofit heated seats, this needs a loom which runs to each seat and to the fuse box and switches. You then need to replace the seat covers for heated ones, if fit second hand seats. Not plug and play, but doable. And you need the switches.

Xenon aren't plug and play.
I understood it was a case of adding some sort of sensor for the height adjustment, but otherwise fairly easy? I've found it quite difficult to get any detailed info though...