Dealer won't refund deposit for PCP - backed out of a deal
Dealer won't refund deposit for PCP - backed out of a deal
Author
Discussion

Mo D

Original Poster:

274 posts

186 months

Tuesday 29th March 2016
quotequote all
Afternoon all,

My friend is in a bit of a tight spot. He was going for a new 420d on a 4 year PCP from a main dealer in the east Midland, decent price, £420 a month. However, after the deposit has been paid, and after the delivery was delayed, he got cold feet and backed out from the deal, before delivery.

The dealer offered a second hand 318d on PCP, but refuse to give him the option of buying a brand new car with his deposit (£1k intial deposit, he was due to pay the rest of the £4k when collecting the car). Basically saying he won't get his deposit unless he goes for the second hand 1 year old 318d, which is at £19k.

Where does he stand? Is the dealer entitled to keep the deposit? He now decided he wants a 320i (seen a deal at Stratstone which has a 320i at a very competitive rate). Basically this dealer is trying to force him on buying the second hand car.

Any advice would be appreciated, he is understandably anxious.


daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Tuesday 29th March 2016
quotequote all
Mo D said:
Afternoon all,

My friend is in a bit of a tight spot. He was going for a new 420d on a 4 year PCP from a main dealer in the east Midland, decent price, £420 a month. However, after the deposit has been paid, and after the delivery was delayed, he got cold feet and backed out from the deal, before delivery.

The dealer offered a second hand 318d on PCP, but refuse to give him the option of buying a brand new car with his deposit (£1k intial deposit, he was due to pay the rest of the £4k when collecting the car). Basically saying he won't get his deposit unless he goes for the second hand 1 year old 318d, which is at £19k.

Where does he stand? Is the dealer entitled to keep the deposit? He now decided he wants a 320i (seen a deal at Stratstone which has a 320i at a very competitive rate). Basically this dealer is trying to force him on buying the second hand car.

Any advice would be appreciated, he is understandably anxious.
The dealer would be within their rights to with hold the deposit assuming they can show that they are now out that amount of money.

I guess that wouldnt be hard - they now have to stock a car thats being built and sent to them that they probably didnt otherwise want.


MrBarry123

6,109 posts

152 months

Tuesday 29th March 2016
quotequote all
The dealer is entitled to keep the deposit and quite rightly so. By paying a deposit your friend has pledged commitment to an agreement for the supply of goods which the dealer has now invested time and money in fulfilling.

My advice to your friend would be to negotiate with the dealer who has his deposit on the car he now wants and see what they can do in terms of a deal to compensate for the "lost" £1k.

My feeling however is that the relationship between your friend and the original dealer is now non-existent due to your friend not understanding the concept of a deposit.

Mo D

Original Poster:

274 posts

186 months

Tuesday 29th March 2016
quotequote all
MrBarry123 said:
The dealer is entitled to keep the deposit and quite rightly so. By paying a deposit your friend has pledged commitment to an agreement for the supply of goods which the dealer has now invested time and money in fulfilling.

My advice to your friend would be to negotiate with the dealer who has his deposit on the car he now wants and see what they can do in terms of a deal to compensate for the "lost" £1k.

My feeling however is that the relationship between your friend and the original dealer is now non-existent due to your friend not understanding the concept of a deposit.
daemon said:
The dealer would be within their rights to with hold the deposit assuming they can show that they are now out that amount of money.

I guess that wouldnt be hard - they now have to stock a car thats being built and sent to them that they probably didnt otherwise want.
Thanks for advising both. That sounds reasonable, even if I'm told that the car (well specced 420d m-sport) was quickly sold, the one he didn't proceed with the PCP deal. Never mind, we sometimes learn the hard way.


Thanks again.


nickfrog

25,489 posts

248 months

Tuesday 29th March 2016
quotequote all
Contractually they are bound to be within their right however if by selling the car immediately they haven't suffered any detriment, a court might see it differently. Sorry I can't quote which legal constraint this would fall under but I am pretty sure it exists!

PorkInsider

6,646 posts

172 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
I'm once again wondering what some people think a 'deposit' is?

If you can just change your mind and get it back then its pointless.

Amazing that this question pops up so many times on PH, really.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
420 a month for a 420D over 4 years!! And a balloon no doubt to spank you at the end.

Get thee to the lease deals thread my son.

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
Mo D said:
Thanks for advising both. That sounds reasonable, even if I'm told that the car (well specced 420d m-sport) was quickly sold, the one he didn't proceed with the PCP deal. Never mind, we sometimes learn the hard way.


Thanks again.
They could have had to sell it off at £1,000 less to sell it quickly?

Just after the E70 X5 came out in 07 and when there were practically no discounts available i got £5,000 off the price of one that was a cancelled order and sitting in their showroom. The intimation being from the sales manager at the time was that they were discounting it only because the customer who had ordered it cancelled the order pretty much when it was on the transporter to the dealers. So either they were using the customers unrefunded deposit to sweeten the deal or were selling it cheaper to get it moved on quickly.



Edited by daemon on Wednesday 30th March 09:02

nickfrog

25,489 posts

248 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
PorkInsider said:
I'm once again wondering what some people think a 'deposit' is?

If you can just change your mind and get it back then its pointless.

Amazing that this question pops up so many times on PH, really.
Not really if they haven't suffered a loss, they would be legally obliged to refund it. But the added effort required might amount to £500 of course. The subject is not quite as black and white as it seems. There will be potential situation when the deposit has to be returned.

Mo D

Original Poster:

274 posts

186 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
420 a month for a 420D over 4 years!! And a balloon no doubt to spank you at the end.

Get thee to the lease deals thread my son.
Over 4 years as well! Not a great deal. big balloon of £13k if I recall correctly. I've relayed the message to my friend, to pretty much take the hit for the lost £1k.

Stratstone is offering him a PCP for a 320i at £279 a month (£30k list price) for 3 years (£3995 customer deposit ant £5995 Dealer deposit contribution), £13,485 GFV. I have told him is a good deal (I think anyway!), I believe he's going for that one instead now. Its a much better deal than 420d deal anyway (which he backed off from), and better than a diesel - as others have said, and my own experience in a 320d confirms, the 2 litre diesel is horrible, apart from decent economy).

I'm more tempted by the 340i deals with £10k discount on Coast2Coast cars! A proper PH car. Or a £7k 2006 Z4 (I kind of took an oath a few years back not to get another car on finance, but this looks like a cracking deal).

Thanks also to the others who Dealer is within their right to keep the deposit, further research yesterday confirmed that.




johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
daemon said:
Mo D said:
Afternoon all,

My friend is in a bit of a tight spot. He was going for a new 420d on a 4 year PCP from a main dealer in the east Midland, decent price, £420 a month. However, after the deposit has been paid, and after the delivery was delayed, he got cold feet and backed out from the deal, before delivery.

The dealer offered a second hand 318d on PCP, but refuse to give him the option of buying a brand new car with his deposit (£1k intial deposit, he was due to pay the rest of the £4k when collecting the car). Basically saying he won't get his deposit unless he goes for the second hand 1 year old 318d, which is at £19k.

Where does he stand? Is the dealer entitled to keep the deposit? He now decided he wants a 320i (seen a deal at Stratstone which has a 320i at a very competitive rate). Basically this dealer is trying to force him on buying the second hand car.

Any advice would be appreciated, he is understandably anxious.
The dealer would be within their rights to with hold the deposit assuming they can show that they are now out that amount of money.

I guess that wouldnt be hard - they now have to stock a car thats being built and sent to them that they probably didnt otherwise want.
How would you possibly know that without sight of the terms of the contract?

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
MrBarry123 said:
The dealer is entitled to keep the deposit and quite rightly so. By paying a deposit your friend has pledged commitment to an agreement for the supply of goods which the dealer has now invested time and money in fulfilling.

My advice to your friend would be to negotiate with the dealer who has his deposit on the car he now wants and see what they can do in terms of a deal to compensate for the "lost" £1k.

My feeling however is that the relationship between your friend and the original dealer is now non-existent due to your friend not understanding the concept of a deposit.
As with the other legal guru, how cold you possibly know what the dealer is entitled to do without sight of the terms of the contract?


johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
Mo D said:
Afternoon all,

My friend is in a bit of a tight spot. He was going for a new 420d on a 4 year PCP from a main dealer in the east Midland, decent price, £420 a month. However, after the deposit has been paid, and after the delivery was delayed, he got cold feet and backed out from the deal, before delivery.

The dealer offered a second hand 318d on PCP, but refuse to give him the option of buying a brand new car with his deposit (£1k intial deposit, he was due to pay the rest of the £4k when collecting the car). Basically saying he won't get his deposit unless he goes for the second hand 1 year old 318d, which is at £19k.

Where does he stand? Is the dealer entitled to keep the deposit? He now decided he wants a 320i (seen a deal at Stratstone which has a 320i at a very competitive rate). Basically this dealer is trying to force him on buying the second hand car.

Any advice would be appreciated, he is understandably anxious.
Which party delayed the delivery? Dealer or customer?

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
johnfm said:
Mo D said:
Afternoon all,

My friend is in a bit of a tight spot. He was going for a new 420d on a 4 year PCP from a main dealer in the east Midland, decent price, £420 a month. However, after the deposit has been paid, and after the delivery was delayed, he got cold feet and backed out from the deal, before delivery.

The dealer offered a second hand 318d on PCP, but refuse to give him the option of buying a brand new car with his deposit (£1k intial deposit, he was due to pay the rest of the £4k when collecting the car). Basically saying he won't get his deposit unless he goes for the second hand 1 year old 318d, which is at £19k.

Where does he stand? Is the dealer entitled to keep the deposit? He now decided he wants a 320i (seen a deal at Stratstone which has a 320i at a very competitive rate). Basically this dealer is trying to force him on buying the second hand car.

Any advice would be appreciated, he is understandably anxious.
Which party delayed the delivery? Dealer or customer?
IME dealer don't commit to specific delivery dates in written contracts. More likely the OP's mate got fed up of waiting or simply found a better deal and decided to back out.

It sounds like the original car's been delivered to someone but the OPs mate still hasn't got a car so lead time couldn't have been that important to him.

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
REALIST123 said:
johnfm said:
Mo D said:
Afternoon all,

My friend is in a bit of a tight spot. He was going for a new 420d on a 4 year PCP from a main dealer in the east Midland, decent price, £420 a month. However, after the deposit has been paid, and after the delivery was delayed, he got cold feet and backed out from the deal, before delivery.

The dealer offered a second hand 318d on PCP, but refuse to give him the option of buying a brand new car with his deposit (£1k intial deposit, he was due to pay the rest of the £4k when collecting the car). Basically saying he won't get his deposit unless he goes for the second hand 1 year old 318d, which is at £19k.

Where does he stand? Is the dealer entitled to keep the deposit? He now decided he wants a 320i (seen a deal at Stratstone which has a 320i at a very competitive rate). Basically this dealer is trying to force him on buying the second hand car.

Any advice would be appreciated, he is understandably anxious.
Which party delayed the delivery? Dealer or customer?
IME dealer don't commit to specific delivery dates in written contracts. More likely the OP's mate got fed up of waiting or simply found a better deal and decided to back out.

It sounds like the original car's been delivered to someone but the OPs mate still hasn't got a car so lead time couldn't have been that important to him.
Maybe. All ifs and speculation though. Terms of agreement and party responsible for delay needed to assess if OP has any right to return of 'deposit'.

Mo D

Original Poster:

274 posts

186 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
johnfm said:
REALIST123 said:
johnfm said:
Mo D said:
Afternoon all,

My friend is in a bit of a tight spot. He was going for a new 420d on a 4 year PCP from a main dealer in the east Midland, decent price, £420 a month. However, after the deposit has been paid, and after the delivery was delayed, he got cold feet and backed out from the deal, before delivery.

The dealer offered a second hand 318d on PCP, but refuse to give him the option of buying a brand new car with his deposit (£1k intial deposit, he was due to pay the rest of the £4k when collecting the car). Basically saying he won't get his deposit unless he goes for the second hand 1 year old 318d, which is at £19k.

Where does he stand? Is the dealer entitled to keep the deposit? He now decided he wants a 320i (seen a deal at Stratstone which has a 320i at a very competitive rate). Basically this dealer is trying to force him on buying the second hand car.

Any advice would be appreciated, he is understandably anxious.
Which party delayed the delivery? Dealer or customer?
IME dealer don't commit to specific delivery dates in written contracts. More likely the OP's mate got fed up of waiting or simply found a better deal and decided to back out.

It sounds like the original car's been delivered to someone but the OPs mate still hasn't got a car so lead time couldn't have been that important to him.
Maybe. All ifs and speculation though. Terms of agreement and party responsible for delay needed to assess if OP has any right to return of 'deposit'.
I believe the dealer delayed the delivery by more than a month (car was due to be delivered in December), after that, my friend got cold feet and decided to back out of it (in December). He already waited around 6 weeks to two months (contract signed end of September). The dealer replied to him by email in Mid January saying he has forfeited his deposit, as it will go ' to pay towards any costs or losses made by Sytner and we would not peruse you for additional moneys lost in selling your ordered Vehicle'.

They then say they'll put his £1k initial deposit towards a new car if he wants to by a new car within 6 months (from Jan). However they now seem to back track, saying he either buys the 318d (second hand, 2015, 10k miles £19k - he said he wanted to go for that one, but backed out of it too after thinking about it over the weekend, and I also said it didn't sound like a good deal and that he'd be better off getting a new car if he was going to spend that much money) or lose the deposit entirely, so they seem to have shifted the goal posts since the mid Jan email to him (re the option of buying a new car). That's why he's now going with another dealer that has a much better PCP deal, and seemingly given up (upon advice on here and elsewhere that the deposit is gone).

Edited by Mo D on Wednesday 30th March 14:07

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
Mo D said:
johnfm said:
REALIST123 said:
johnfm said:
Mo D said:
Afternoon all,

My friend is in a bit of a tight spot. He was going for a new 420d on a 4 year PCP from a main dealer in the east Midland, decent price, £420 a month. However, after the deposit has been paid, and after the delivery was delayed, he got cold feet and backed out from the deal, before delivery.

The dealer offered a second hand 318d on PCP, but refuse to give him the option of buying a brand new car with his deposit (£1k intial deposit, he was due to pay the rest of the £4k when collecting the car). Basically saying he won't get his deposit unless he goes for the second hand 1 year old 318d, which is at £19k.

Where does he stand? Is the dealer entitled to keep the deposit? He now decided he wants a 320i (seen a deal at Stratstone which has a 320i at a very competitive rate). Basically this dealer is trying to force him on buying the second hand car.

Any advice would be appreciated, he is understandably anxious.
Which party delayed the delivery? Dealer or customer?
IME dealer don't commit to specific delivery dates in written contracts. More likely the OP's mate got fed up of waiting or simply found a better deal and decided to back out.

It sounds like the original car's been delivered to someone but the OPs mate still hasn't got a car so lead time couldn't have been that important to him.
Maybe. All ifs and speculation though. Terms of agreement and party responsible for delay needed to assess if OP has any right to return of 'deposit'.
I believe the dealer delayed the delivery by more than a month (car was due to be delivered in December), after that, my friend got cold feet and decided to back out of it (in December). He already waited around 6 weeks to two months (contract signed end of September). The dealer replied to him by email in Mid January saying he has forfeited his deposit, as it will go ' to pay towards any costs or losses made by Sytner and we would not peruse you for additional moneys lost in selling your ordered Vehicle'.

They then say they'll put his £1k initial deposit towards a new car if he wants to by a new car within 6 months (from Jan). However they now seem to back track, saying he either buys the 318d (second hand, 2015, 10k miles £19k - he said he wanted to go for that one, but backed out of it too after thinking about it over the weekend, and I also said it didn't sound like a good deal and that he'd be better off getting a new car if he was going to spend that much money) or lose the deposit entirely, so they seem to have shifted the goal posts since the mid Jan email to him (re the option of buying a new car). That's why he's now going with another dealer that has a much better PCP deal, and seemingly given up (upon advice on here and elsewhere that the deposit is gone).

Edited by Mo D on Wednesday 30th March 14:07
He needs to push them a lot harder if they emailed him specifically saying the retained funds can be used against a new car. Again, impossible to give useful advice without seeing the terms he signed - but you mate could do with being a bit more demanding. Push come to shove, the dealer has the cash and possession is 9/10ths etc. But a lot depends on what they promised to do in the agreement. They probably have a lot of leeway with delayed delivery, but the devil is in the detail. If your mate values £1k he will read the contract and figure out whether they were in breach or not.

Dealer sounds typically piss poor.

Mo D

Original Poster:

274 posts

186 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
johnfm said:
He needs to push them a lot harder if they emailed him specifically saying the retained funds can be used against a new car. Again, impossible to give useful advice without seeing the terms he signed - but you mate could do with being a bit more demanding. Push come to shove, the dealer has the cash and possession is 9/10ths etc. But a lot depends on what they promised to do in the agreement. They probably have a lot of leeway with delayed delivery, but the devil is in the detail. If your mate values £1k he will read the contract and figure out whether they were in breach or not.

Dealer sounds typically piss poor.
Thanks Johnfm! Good advice, I've relayed this to him (re checking the contract for a breach, and to push the dealer harder re their email), and given him a link to the topic too. the email (forwarded to me yesterday by a manager at the dealership) explicitly says his deposit can be used towards a new car in the next 6 months, and now they backtracked (now saying only towards a used one). I guess also them being willing to match Stratstone's deal (320i for £279 with £6k deposit contribution as mentioned above) is another question, which is what he really wants now.

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
johnfm said:
daemon said:
Mo D said:
Afternoon all,

My friend is in a bit of a tight spot. He was going for a new 420d on a 4 year PCP from a main dealer in the east Midland, decent price, £420 a month. However, after the deposit has been paid, and after the delivery was delayed, he got cold feet and backed out from the deal, before delivery.

The dealer offered a second hand 318d on PCP, but refuse to give him the option of buying a brand new car with his deposit (£1k intial deposit, he was due to pay the rest of the £4k when collecting the car). Basically saying he won't get his deposit unless he goes for the second hand 1 year old 318d, which is at £19k.

Where does he stand? Is the dealer entitled to keep the deposit? He now decided he wants a 320i (seen a deal at Stratstone which has a 320i at a very competitive rate). Basically this dealer is trying to force him on buying the second hand car.

Any advice would be appreciated, he is understandably anxious.
The dealer would be within their rights to with hold the deposit assuming they can show that they are now out that amount of money.

I guess that wouldnt be hard - they now have to stock a car thats being built and sent to them that they probably didnt otherwise want.
How would you possibly know that without sight of the terms of the contract?
Common practice and common law. Its how it works. Lets be honest, no BMW dealer is going to have a "full refund of deposit if you try to weedle out" clause, so they'll have "something" relating to the non return of deposit, however, as i've said already, no matter what other caveats they have put in the contract thats what they can legally withhold.

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
johnfm said:
Mo D said:
Afternoon all,

My friend is in a bit of a tight spot. He was going for a new 420d on a 4 year PCP from a main dealer in the east Midland, decent price, £420 a month. However, after the deposit has been paid, and after the delivery was delayed, he got cold feet and backed out from the deal, before delivery.

The dealer offered a second hand 318d on PCP, but refuse to give him the option of buying a brand new car with his deposit (£1k intial deposit, he was due to pay the rest of the £4k when collecting the car). Basically saying he won't get his deposit unless he goes for the second hand 1 year old 318d, which is at £19k.

Where does he stand? Is the dealer entitled to keep the deposit? He now decided he wants a 320i (seen a deal at Stratstone which has a 320i at a very competitive rate). Basically this dealer is trying to force him on buying the second hand car.

Any advice would be appreciated, he is understandably anxious.
Which party delayed the delivery? Dealer or customer?
And likewise, contractually, no dealer - BMW or otherwise - is going to commit to a specific delivery date in the contract.

Surprised you dont know that.