Z4 E89 Hydraulic Tappets
Z4 E89 Hydraulic Tappets
Author
Discussion

Rex Rexroth

Original Poster:

17 posts

138 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
Hi, first post to this forum. I test drove this 23i the other day:

http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/b...

On start-up there was a significant tic-tic noise which the salesman explained was the hydraulic tappets which would decrease after the engine warmed. After a 15 min test drive, where I didn't exactly spank it, the noise was still very evident but the salesman said the vehicle hadn't had much use of late and just needed a good hoofing.

Is there an element of truth to what he says or should I run a mile? Overall, I liked the 2.5 engine which was very revvy and, I think, probably fun to drive over the longer term.

As an aside I drove a 2.9 PDK Boxter today which is a very different animal. Lovely gearbox, felt heavier than the Zed. Much more expensive but the interior felt less refined. PDK ideal on busy (UK) roads. Overall probably better engineered than the Z4 but I had more fun in the Z4. Apologies for digressing.

ruggedscotty

6,001 posts

240 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all


I bought one a while back a 2009 and paid 15k for it - mine has the sat nav but its basically same as yours manual and 23sdrive. love it.

Drove the porsche interior is way under the quality of the Z. performace was more than the Z. but the Z won me over hard top that retracts so best of both worlds.

Really enjoy the Z but the noisy engine would be making me walk... plenty out there.

Rex Rexroth

Original Poster:

17 posts

138 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
ruggedscotty][url said:
|http://thumbsnap.com/RLz6XqXM[/url

Really enjoy the Z but the noisy engine would be making me walk... plenty out there.
Probably the sensible thing, Thanks. PS think grey with red upholstery is the classiest looking combo, but this is obviously a personal thing.

ruggedscotty

6,001 posts

240 months

Thursday 31st March 2016
quotequote all






spent an afternoon cleaning it inside and outside and then as it started to get dark it beckoned me to take
it for a run.

The interior is a great place to spend time. Im over 6 foot and a bit podgy but it copes pretty well. As said had a test drive in the porsche and then the bmw back to back and came out happy with taking the bmw. If performance is your thing try the 35is....

Rex Rexroth

Original Poster:

17 posts

138 months

Friday 1st April 2016
quotequote all
notice you have the Idrive. We have it on our X3 and find it useful. I also spoke to a mechanic friend about the noisy tappets. He said if the car has been sat for a while the oil will drain to the sump and it will take a little while for the oil pressure to sufficiently circulate the oil throughout the engine, especially if the oil is a bit sludgy. Option would be to ask for an engine flush then new oil and filter before purchase. Also ensure it is covered under warranty. Might give it a go.

Mr Tidy

31,941 posts

158 months

Friday 1st April 2016
quotequote all
OP the ticking noise you mention is not unusual, and at least in Z4 circles does not seem to be an issue (maybe have a look at Z4 Forum)?

Assuming you do get one, enjoy it - but why buy a 2.3 when you could have a 3.0 for more or less the same running costs?

Confession time, I have a 3.0Si Sport Coupe so am (very/totally un-)biased!








ruggedscotty

6,001 posts

240 months

Friday 1st April 2016
quotequote all
http://e89.zpost.com/forums/showthread.php?t=35331...

the link below is more interesting....

http://blog.bavauto.com/6565/bmw-6-cylinder-engine...

Ive the 23sdrive and dont have any tap tap tapping....

Rex Rexroth

Original Poster:

17 posts

138 months

Sunday 3rd April 2016
quotequote all
After all said and done I am collecting my new Boxter 2.7 manual this afternoon. I drove it yesterday and thought the engine and gearbox were great and it felt really planted on the road. It's a 2005 model with full history, in outstanding condition with 42K on the clock from a private seller just down the road (Durham).

If it hadn't been for the ticking engine in the Z4 I would have put a deposit down on that. I think both the Boxter and the Zed are great cars. It was just a case of right car at the the right time.

Thanks to those that kindly responded to my query and happy motoring.

Mr Tidy

31,941 posts

158 months

Sunday 3rd April 2016
quotequote all
Hope you enjoy the Boxter thumbup - that sounds like a good one you have found!

Rex Rexroth

Original Poster:

17 posts

138 months

Sunday 3rd April 2016
quotequote all


Can just squeeze it in the garage next to the motorbike!