Do I risk the 125i?
Do I risk the 125i?
Author
Discussion

SpazaB

Original Poster:

29 posts

142 months

Tuesday 5th April 2016
quotequote all
As previously mentioned in another thread, a friend and I are going on a euro-trip 1 month today!

The original plan was to take my friend's Z4 and I would take the 125i, simple, done, let's go... Or so we thought.

Some quick (relevant) background - My friend and I both work for MINI Plant Oxford "The Home Of Mini"; therefore, we're both part of a 'scheme' which essentially means we can drive anyone's work car who is part of this 'scheme'. We can also lease brand new cars from work for free... Anyway, more on that later, back to the dilemma!

A little while back, we both decided we wouldn't take the Z4 and the 125i - downsides to previously being part of the aforementioned 'scheme', and also some personal experience with a crappy Cayman, is that we're in a terrible mindset that anything over 10,000 miles is going to explode and die. My friend has since sold the Z4 after it "exploded and died" (thermostat went) - leaving me to ponder, do I risk taking the 125i, or do I play safe and lease a car from work?

I can lease a new MINI from work (various spec's and engines - probably a Cooper SD in some sort of guise), with insurance, breakdown etc... essentially everything covered and worry free driving. My friend can then take his dad's 'scheme' car (F54 Cooper S MINI Clubman) - lovely job. Except, spanner in the works (shock!) they aren't letting us have the car for the period of time we want it. After we'd explained to them what we were doing months in advance, they've "changed their policy" so the maximum lease period is 10 days, and naturally we want it for 10 days and 12 hours - they're power happy and being difficult for the sake of it - thus, leaving us with 2 options:

1) Shorten the trip to meet their new demands so we can have a lease car - missing some stops during the trip.

2) Take the 125i - in the mindset that I'll be worrying the whole time, thinking something will go wrong somewhere along the 3,500 mile journey. My luck with car's is not great, if something can go wrong, it usually does.

The 125i is only at 46,000 miles and as part of the AUC contract, I have BMW European breakdown cover and BMW warranty - plus points for the BMW! Negative points - fuel, no cruise control, sat nav etc... and it'll need a new set of tyres before the trip.

My friend is trying to talk me into the 125i, but I just cant seem to agree with him. I was hoping you gents could offer some advice into what we should do!?

Shirt587

360 posts

166 months

Tuesday 5th April 2016
quotequote all
Buy my 545i so you can have a proper grand tourer (ish) with a great engine instead?

More seriously, you admit that you've been conned into believing anything over 10k miles is going to die. You know it's bonkers, the 125i has European cover and God knows you'll do some time in Germany where if anything does go it'll be a doddle to get parts. Take the BMW not a Mini with awkward Ts&Cs.

Mammasaid

5,665 posts

128 months

Tuesday 5th April 2016
quotequote all
SpazaB said:
we're in a terrible mindset that anything over 10,000 miles is going to explode and die.
What?? Are you serious? You do realise that most cars can get to 6 figure mileage easily?

MTFU, and take the BMW, it will NOT die, if you're concerned get it serviced 1st.

SpazaB

Original Poster:

29 posts

142 months

Tuesday 5th April 2016
quotequote all
Mammasaid said:
What?? Are you serious? You do realise that most cars can get to 6 figure mileage easily?

MTFU, and take the BMW, it will NOT die, if you're concerned get it serviced 1st.
Hahaha, I was exaggerating at 10,000 miles! But I take your point of MTFU...

5harp3y

1,966 posts

230 months

Tuesday 5th April 2016
quotequote all
Shirt587 said:
Buy my 545i so you can have a proper grand tourer (ish) with a great engine instead?

More seriously, you admit that you've been conned into believing anything over 10k miles is going to die. You know it's bonkers, the 125i has European cover and God knows you'll do some time in Germany where if anything does go it'll be a doddle to get parts. Take the BMW not a Mini with awkward Ts&Cs.
this

would you be worried that the car would explode if you did 3,500 miles in multiple trips in the Uk? just drive the bloody thing.

i'd be more worried about a brand new MINI pool car going pop than a 50,000 miler.

Dave350

359 posts

149 months

Tuesday 5th April 2016
quotequote all
I'd shorten the trip by 12 hours and take a lease car!

Spuffington

1,355 posts

199 months

Tuesday 5th April 2016
quotequote all
Such a daft concern that I can't be bothered to write anything more than "take it & stop fretting"!

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 5th April 2016
quotequote all
SpazaB said:
As previously mentioned in another thread, a friend and I are going on a euro-trip 1 month today!

The original plan was to take my friend's Z4 and I would take the 125i, simple, done, let's go... Or so we thought.

Some quick (relevant) background - My friend and I both work for MINI Plant Oxford "The Home Of Mini"; therefore, we're both part of a 'scheme' which essentially means we can drive anyone's work car who is part of this 'scheme'. We can also lease brand new cars from work for free... Anyway, more on that later, back to the dilemma!

A little while back, we both decided we wouldn't take the Z4 and the 125i - downsides to previously being part of the aforementioned 'scheme', and also some personal experience with a crappy Cayman, is that we're in a terrible mindset that anything over 10,000 miles is going to explode and die. My friend has since sold the Z4 after it "exploded and died" (thermostat went) - leaving me to ponder, do I risk taking the 125i, or do I play safe and lease a car from work?

I can lease a new MINI from work (various spec's and engines - probably a Cooper SD in some sort of guise), with insurance, breakdown etc... essentially everything covered and worry free driving. My friend can then take his dad's 'scheme' car (F54 Cooper S MINI Clubman) - lovely job. Except, spanner in the works (shock!) they aren't letting us have the car for the period of time we want it. After we'd explained to them what we were doing months in advance, they've "changed their policy" so the maximum lease period is 10 days, and naturally we want it for 10 days and 12 hours - they're power happy and being difficult for the sake of it - thus, leaving us with 2 options:

1) Shorten the trip to meet their new demands so we can have a lease car - missing some stops during the trip.

2) Take the 125i - in the mindset that I'll be worrying the whole time, thinking something will go wrong somewhere along the 3,500 mile journey. My luck with car's is not great, if something can go wrong, it usually does.

The 125i is only at 46,000 miles and as part of the AUC contract, I have BMW European breakdown cover and BMW warranty - plus points for the BMW! Negative points - fuel, no cruise control, sat nav etc... and it'll need a new set of tyres before the trip.

My friend is trying to talk me into the 125i, but I just cant seem to agree with him. I was hoping you gents could offer some advice into what we should do!?
How's that work then, leasing a car for free? Do you mean borrowing a car?

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Tuesday 5th April 2016
quotequote all
Did I read amongst all these ramblings that you can have any mini and you choose a diesel !!
Get a JCW wink


p1stonhead

30,691 posts

198 months

Tuesday 5th April 2016
quotequote all
SpazaB said:
Mammasaid said:
What?? Are you serious? You do realise that most cars can get to 6 figure mileage easily?

MTFU, and take the BMW, it will NOT die, if you're concerned get it serviced 1st.
Hahaha, I was exaggerating at 10,000 miles! But I take your point of MTFU...
I took my 120k mile 11 year old fabia VRS up the alps snowboarding last year and it didnt put a foot wrong. That was about 1500 miles all in.

You will be fine. As said, pay £50 for european breakdown cover and MFTU! hehe

Sohlman

590 posts

285 months

Tuesday 5th April 2016
quotequote all
I used to live in Barcelona and would regularly drive to Barcelona in a day in our e34 190k mile 530. In total the car did 14 return trips over 3 years. That's 1000 miles each way. Or to put it in other words 28k in 3 years doing just that journey.

I think a 50k BMW will have no issue. Not only that I suspect it will feel better after the trip. If the car is well maintained you will not have an issue.

Also this sort of road trip is more exciting with some risk of break down as these are the stories that you remember.

SidewaysSi

10,742 posts

265 months

Tuesday 5th April 2016
quotequote all
Is this a reflection of st MINI build quality? I can't quite belive what I am reading to be honest. Works in the car industry, on PH and seems really quite clueless.

SpazaB

Original Poster:

29 posts

142 months

Wednesday 6th April 2016
quotequote all
SidewaysSi said:
Is this a reflection of st MINI build quality? ..... seems really quite clueless.
Not clueless, just cautious! MINI build quality is actually pretty good from personal experience, and because the parent company is obviously BMW, they're included on the scheme too. As a matter of fact, I've had more issues with BMW's than I have done with any MINI during my time here.

Either way, I'm just playing on arguably the wrong side of cautious as to whether I "risk" my car, or whether to cut the trip short but "borrow" a car and not have a care in the world.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Wednesday 6th April 2016
quotequote all
SpazaB said:
The 125i is only at 46,000 miles and as part of the AUC contract, I have BMW European breakdown cover and BMW warranty
So what's the problem? Even if something went wrong it'd cost you nothing and they'd sort you a rental car.

I did 3200 miles in a 200,000 mile 530i Sport so I'm sure a 46k 125i can manage.

s m

24,494 posts

234 months

Thursday 7th April 2016
quotequote all
Is it the 2-door coupe 125i or the later 3/5 door 125i hatch?

pvogue

904 posts

145 months

Sunday 10th April 2016
quotequote all
125i has nearly the same engine as the 130i, it will be decent enough car! One of the PH carpool took a 130i on trek and didnt miss a beat.

http://www.pistonheads.com/regulars/ph-carpool/bmw...

rb5er

11,657 posts

203 months

Monday 11th April 2016
quotequote all
This thread is just ridiculous

*Al*

3,830 posts

253 months

Monday 11th April 2016
quotequote all
pvogue said:
125i has nearly the same engine as the 130i, it will be decent enough car! One of the PH carpool took a 130i on trek and didnt miss a beat.

http://www.pistonheads.com/regulars/ph-carpool/bmw...
My 125i is remapped so is up with the BHP of a 130i, goes very well! I'd confidently drive it any distance!!

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Monday 11th April 2016
quotequote all
SpazaB said:
I'm just playing on arguably the wrong side of cautious as to whether I "risk" my car.....
What risk??

I just don't get the question?

If your car did break down, you would be lent a new car until yours was repaired, would this in some way ruin your trip?



SpazaB

Original Poster:

29 posts

142 months

Tuesday 12th April 2016
quotequote all
Okay, so.... I think I was being majorly paranoid. I've taken my 'man-up' pills, come to my senses and booked to take the 125i on the trip. You're all right, I bought the car to drive and to enjoy, plus it'll be a hell of a lot nicer listening to that straight 6 bounce off the walls of the Alps, than a 4 pot diesel!

I think it was one of those things where, I had fallen out of love with my car because I hadn't driven it for a while, and I wasn't fussed about whether I took it or not, thinking of only the negatives, rather than all the many positives.

It's a shame that it looks like some of the best roads in Switzerland will be closed (Grimsel Pass still isn't due to open until mid-June according to the official website). Gotthard Pass looks feasible and open, so might explore that way - anyone got any experience on that road?

Again, sorry for the massive flap and long-winded thread. It's been interesting hearing your thoughts though!