E53 X5 v E70 X5 - Used Purchase??
Discussion
Evening,
At the back end of last year I was looking for an E53 X5, didn't manage to find a car that ticked all the boxes and then was offered an E46 M3 at dealer p/ex price so couldn't resist! Drove that through the winter and have just sold it on and money is back in the bank
Returning to the for sale ads I was looking at the price differential between the E53 and E70 which is slowly closing and with money in hand I am starting to wonder whether a 115k E70 might be a better buy than a 90k E53 - but this might be man maths so looking for some advice.
The car will be used for family trips, days out, holiday, mountain biking, visiting family up and down the country so general family duties but in a year will probably be lucky if it covers more than 6/7k. With that in mind the higher mileage examples aren't such an issue for me as in effect the mileage will average out with my minimal use.
So can anyone that has gone from an E53 to an E70 give me some opinions and advice on which might be the better buy. The market for the E53 still appears to be strong given its age now so wondering if they will just slowly depreciate from here on in??
How different is the ownership prospect of the E53 and E70??
Any info would be most welcome.
Si
At the back end of last year I was looking for an E53 X5, didn't manage to find a car that ticked all the boxes and then was offered an E46 M3 at dealer p/ex price so couldn't resist! Drove that through the winter and have just sold it on and money is back in the bank

Returning to the for sale ads I was looking at the price differential between the E53 and E70 which is slowly closing and with money in hand I am starting to wonder whether a 115k E70 might be a better buy than a 90k E53 - but this might be man maths so looking for some advice.
The car will be used for family trips, days out, holiday, mountain biking, visiting family up and down the country so general family duties but in a year will probably be lucky if it covers more than 6/7k. With that in mind the higher mileage examples aren't such an issue for me as in effect the mileage will average out with my minimal use.
So can anyone that has gone from an E53 to an E70 give me some opinions and advice on which might be the better buy. The market for the E53 still appears to be strong given its age now so wondering if they will just slowly depreciate from here on in??
How different is the ownership prospect of the E53 and E70??
Any info would be most welcome.
Si
While I do not own one, my dad has owned am E53 3.0i from new, and the thing now has 196,000 miles on it. Before he had it he bought a 4.6is for my mum, but it was truly terrible on fuel and my mum didn't like the all black combo with tinted windows. But I digress...
His has been an excellent car and has only 'broken down' once due to a failed alternator. It costs about £2000 in repairs each year, and does 23mpg, which is pretty much all motorway. Get an auto with the petrol six I would suggest. While the V8s are as terrible on fuel as the six cylinder petrol, the sixes are cheaper to fix. The V8s run mega hot anyway, and have silly things like a water cooled alternator. The 6cyl model has none of that, and has the half of the top end bits that the V8 models have like Valve cover gaskets and camshaft position sensors.
They like to eat suspension components and brakes. My dads has now been polybushed, and is a lot better for it I feel. The E53 rides FIRM in standard guise, so a sport only gets you even harder suspension and slightly more sporty seats. Interiors are a nice place to be, with many E39 bits stolen, as is the drive train. Pre facelift models have the same transfer case as the L322 Rangie, and same Hill Descent control. While I've not driven it offroad it does well on some bits you would typically do, and will slide really well on a snowy field. Proper fun there.
They drive well also, better than the Disco 3 I had a brief go on. The X5 was the first of he SUVs that drive like a car, and they still feel good even compared to new stuff. Not full on throw it about like a lunatic, but does that BMW thing of shrinking around you.
In short I would recommend a 3.0i SE model, either facelift or pre facelift. Dads has been good to him and every single year he says 'oh I'll keep it another year, it owes me nothing'.
Unfortunately I've not really lived with an E70, so can't help you there. Sorry.
Finally, here's a pic of it on a low loader. Just to show you what it looks like. Its a Pearl Beige metallic model with beige leather and some options. In PH style it was paid for in cash, when new.

His has been an excellent car and has only 'broken down' once due to a failed alternator. It costs about £2000 in repairs each year, and does 23mpg, which is pretty much all motorway. Get an auto with the petrol six I would suggest. While the V8s are as terrible on fuel as the six cylinder petrol, the sixes are cheaper to fix. The V8s run mega hot anyway, and have silly things like a water cooled alternator. The 6cyl model has none of that, and has the half of the top end bits that the V8 models have like Valve cover gaskets and camshaft position sensors.
They like to eat suspension components and brakes. My dads has now been polybushed, and is a lot better for it I feel. The E53 rides FIRM in standard guise, so a sport only gets you even harder suspension and slightly more sporty seats. Interiors are a nice place to be, with many E39 bits stolen, as is the drive train. Pre facelift models have the same transfer case as the L322 Rangie, and same Hill Descent control. While I've not driven it offroad it does well on some bits you would typically do, and will slide really well on a snowy field. Proper fun there.
They drive well also, better than the Disco 3 I had a brief go on. The X5 was the first of he SUVs that drive like a car, and they still feel good even compared to new stuff. Not full on throw it about like a lunatic, but does that BMW thing of shrinking around you.
In short I would recommend a 3.0i SE model, either facelift or pre facelift. Dads has been good to him and every single year he says 'oh I'll keep it another year, it owes me nothing'.
Unfortunately I've not really lived with an E70, so can't help you there. Sorry.
Finally, here's a pic of it on a low loader. Just to show you what it looks like. Its a Pearl Beige metallic model with beige leather and some options. In PH style it was paid for in cash, when new.

roofer said:
I currently have an E53 with 90 odd k on it,

and an E70 with 112k on it. Night and day, get the E70. The E53 is a clunk in comparison.

E70 looks lovely! Interesting that you have summed it up as simply as that - does the E70 really do an all round better job than the E53 then?
and an E70 with 112k on it. Night and day, get the E70. The E53 is a clunk in comparison.

The E79 'looks' much bigger than the E53, is that a bit ad an illusion or is it a lot bigger?
Having researched E53's extensively when I was looking to buy one, I am aware of their gearbox and turbo issues - is the E70 plagued by any similar problems?
Si
Not had an E53 but had two E70s and would happily have another.
I had a pre-LCI 3.0d and a post-LCI 4.0d and both were brilliant cars to live with. They were also my most reliable BMWs, having had E46s, E60s prior to those cars.
They're not cheap to run (think tyres, mid-25mpg regardless of derv engine and insurance given they get nicked a lot!) but very rewarding - belie their size when pushing on; handling very well for such a big lump and very easy to cross continents in.
E70 all the way IMO.
I had a pre-LCI 3.0d and a post-LCI 4.0d and both were brilliant cars to live with. They were also my most reliable BMWs, having had E46s, E60s prior to those cars.
They're not cheap to run (think tyres, mid-25mpg regardless of derv engine and insurance given they get nicked a lot!) but very rewarding - belie their size when pushing on; handling very well for such a big lump and very easy to cross continents in.
E70 all the way IMO.
I went from a 55-plate E53 3.0d to a 57-plate 3.0d E70.
Overall, I preferred the E53. The 'why' of that is hard to put my finger on - it's certainly more dated inside and out, but was quicker and more economical.
For me, the ease-of-use of everything on the E53 trumped the E70's iDrive and various nanny features. One example: I do a lot of towing, and you can't reverse an E70 with the driver's door open. Makes it harder to see when you're reversing up to the trailer. Small niggle, but annoying.
In the end I sold the E70 as I didn't really get on with it. I've been considering going back to an X5, but if I do it'd be an E53.
Overall, I preferred the E53. The 'why' of that is hard to put my finger on - it's certainly more dated inside and out, but was quicker and more economical.
For me, the ease-of-use of everything on the E53 trumped the E70's iDrive and various nanny features. One example: I do a lot of towing, and you can't reverse an E70 with the driver's door open. Makes it harder to see when you're reversing up to the trailer. Small niggle, but annoying.
In the end I sold the E70 as I didn't really get on with it. I've been considering going back to an X5, but if I do it'd be an E53.
Output Flange said:
One example: I do a lot of towing, and you can't reverse an E70 with the driver's door open. Makes it harder to see when you're reversing up to the trailer. Small niggle, but annoying.
Agreed, although i've clouted a door reversing up a drive looking at the back of the car and not where the door was heading (a brick post!!)I had an E53 3.0d sport and now have an E70 35d. Have done a few miles in each of them, the E53 from 30 to 60k miles and the E70 from 38 to curremtiy 62k miles. No mechanical issues with either.
A big difference in performance, 218 v 286 hp, so the E53 a bit of a slug against the E70, although the E70 3.0d closer. The biggest difference for me is the more modern feel of the E70, and the better handling.
For me, the E70 is just a better overall car, I suppose that's gradual development.
A big difference in performance, 218 v 286 hp, so the E53 a bit of a slug against the E70, although the E70 3.0d closer. The biggest difference for me is the more modern feel of the E70, and the better handling.
For me, the E70 is just a better overall car, I suppose that's gradual development.
SiT said:
E70 looks lovely! Interesting that you have summed it up as simply as that - does the E70 really do an all round better job than the E53 then?
The E79 'looks' much bigger than the E53, is that a bit ad an illusion or is it a lot bigger?
Having researched E53's extensively when I was looking to buy one, I am aware of their gearbox and turbo issues - is the E70 plagued by any similar problems?
Si
It drives more like a a car. The E53 steering is heavier, and just feels a bigger lump while driving. As mentioned , tyres are expensive, and mpg is nowt to write home about.The E79 'looks' much bigger than the E53, is that a bit ad an illusion or is it a lot bigger?
Having researched E53's extensively when I was looking to buy one, I am aware of their gearbox and turbo issues - is the E70 plagued by any similar problems?
Si
DPF won't be an issue if lots of motorway, but will clog on short trips if that's all it does.
I'm with Roofer on this, I went from a facelift E53 3.0d, which I took up to 115k miles, to a facelift E70 40d which had 20k miles when I bought it They don't even begin to compare, the E70 is by far the better vehicle in every respect and I loved my E53 when I had it. I did three European trips in the E53 covering over 3500 miles each time and it was very capable, however, the same trip last year in the E70 made the older car seem very dated in comparison.
E70 is a lot bigger, E53 is pretty much the same size as the current X3.
I've owned an E70 since new in 2007, longest I have owned a car by a considerable margin. Great family car, currently in Switzerland with it, can't think of anything better for taking a family on a long trip.
I test drove a new one recently and sure all the tech is more advanced but it's only a small evolution over the E70.
Ours was supremely reliable until a year ago, with not a single problem. Since last summer we've had sunroof, wheel bearing, suspension air bag and comfort access issues. The sunroof and rear suspension airbag are common issues. Mine is still under warranty thankfully!
I've owned an E70 since new in 2007, longest I have owned a car by a considerable margin. Great family car, currently in Switzerland with it, can't think of anything better for taking a family on a long trip.
I test drove a new one recently and sure all the tech is more advanced but it's only a small evolution over the E70.
Ours was supremely reliable until a year ago, with not a single problem. Since last summer we've had sunroof, wheel bearing, suspension air bag and comfort access issues. The sunroof and rear suspension airbag are common issues. Mine is still under warranty thankfully!
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


