X1 Xdrive traction and transmission weirdness
X1 Xdrive traction and transmission weirdness
Author
Discussion

blueST

Original Poster:

4,910 posts

247 months

Wednesday 6th April 2016
quotequote all
I'm stuck out in France on holiday and on the way out here my X1 Xdrive Auto has started to play up. The traction control keeps cutting in, seemingly caused by minor bumps or rough Tarmac or moderately swift cornering. After a reasonable length drive the transmission gets "shunty" at low speed with some vibration, but seems fine when cruising. Very unpleasant all round.

I have very recently had two new rear tyres, but I've checked pressures and wheel nut tightness several times, all is fine. The only thing is they are not run flats, I can't think why, but could that be the cause? There are no warning lights and nothing in the "check control" display on the dash.

Obviously, it'll be going in the garage when I get home, but any suggestions for anything I can check here?

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Wednesday 6th April 2016
quotequote all
blueST said:
I'm stuck out in France on holiday and on the way out here my X1 Xdrive Auto has started to play up. The traction control keeps cutting in, seemingly caused by minor bumps or rough Tarmac or moderately swift cornering. After a reasonable length drive the transmission gets "shunty" at low speed with some vibration, but seems fine when cruising. Very unpleasant all round.

I have very recently had two new rear tyres, but I've checked pressures and wheel nut tightness several times, all is fine. The only thing is they are not run flats, I can't think why, but could that be the cause? There are no warning lights and nothing in the "check control" display on the dash.

Obviously, it'll be going in the garage when I get home, but any suggestions for anything I can check here?
I was going to ask about tyres.

What are the tyres fitted?

Also what is the depth of the tyres you haven't replaced.

On am AWD you can't mix thread patterns as it causes issues, and you definitely can't put on tyres that are more than about 2-3mm difference on each axle.
You will slowly lock up the transfer case and get what you are getting, if you are feeling it while driving I would stop and get two new tyres on the other axle asap or you might have a serious bill to come.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Wednesday 6th April 2016
quotequote all
BTW, whatever you do, don't take it in for warranty work with mixed tyres on, they will not pay out as you haven't swapped all 4 tyres. It says in the book all 4 must be the same, same depth and correct pressures.



Reading your post again you need to stop driving until you can get new tyres on the other axle. You will shag the transfer case if you continue. A new transfer case is thousands to replace.

Just search google for 'awd transfer case tyres'

Edited by gizlaroc on Wednesday 6th April 08:38

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Wednesday 6th April 2016
quotequote all
Just to add, the fact they are not run flats is not an issue btw.
I had non run flats on our x1 from the factory and on our X3.

But you do need to get new tyres on the other axle before driving any more. Trust me.

blueST

Original Poster:

4,910 posts

247 months

Wednesday 6th April 2016
quotequote all
Ooff, that's all very depressing. The good news is I haven't driven it for a few days, but I did do 600 miles here at high speed! I can't measure the tread, but the rears are brand new less about 700 miles. That he fronts have loads left on them but are over three years old, be shame to chuck em. Plus I'm miles from anywhere in the French outback.

Fronts are 225/45/18 Goodyear EfficientGrip ROF
Rears 255/40/18 Hankook Ventus S1 Evo 2 not run flat.

blueST

Original Poster:

4,910 posts

247 months

Wednesday 6th April 2016
quotequote all
I've been through the handbook over a glass of vin rouge. No mention of changing tyres at the same time or having similar amounts of tread front and rear. It does say they recommend the same tread pattern all round, but that seems to be in relation to handling, like with most cars.

mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Wednesday 6th April 2016
quotequote all
If you've got a mix of runflats at the front and non-runflats at the rear you'll get this (or the other way round)

Had the same thing on Mrs Mondeomans X1: brand new set of boots on the front, run flats on the rear, all sorts of traction problems and power cutting etc... Thought we'd screwed the front diff , transfer box and all sorts.

Swapped back to used run-flats all round (with similar tread patterns) - problem solved.

These cars are very sensitive to grip levels/tread patterns, so if the tyres aren't matched, you'll get problems.


I've now got 4 tyres sitting in the shed .... and a car that works well.


Edited by mondeoman on Wednesday 6th April 20:54

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Thursday 7th April 2016
quotequote all
blueST said:
Ooff, that's all very depressing. The good news is I haven't driven it for a few days, but I did do 600 miles here at high speed! I can't measure the tread, but the rears are brand new less about 700 miles. That he fronts have loads left on them but are over three years old, be shame to chuck em. Plus I'm miles from anywhere in the French outback.

Fronts are 225/45/18 Goodyear EfficientGrip ROF
Rears 255/40/18 Hankook Ventus S1 Evo 2 not run flat.
I would get camskill to delivery you 2 more ears 255/40/18 Hankook Ventus S1 Evo 2 not run flat and get somewhere local to fit them.

You are winding the transfer case up at the moment, and could cause serious damage.


blueST

Original Poster:

4,910 posts

247 months

Thursday 7th April 2016
quotequote all
gizlaroc said:
I would get camskill to delivery you 2 more ears 255/40/18 Hankook Ventus S1 Evo 2 not run flat and get somewhere local to fit them.

You are winding the transfer case up at the moment, and could cause serious damage.
Isnt it the fronts I would need? 225/45s? Can't fit 255s on the front as the wheels are narrower.

Edited by blueST on Thursday 7th April 07:43

Mr E

23,108 posts

290 months

Thursday 7th April 2016
quotequote all
gizlaroc said:
Just to add, the fact they are not run flats is not an issue btw.
I had non run flats on our x1 from the factory and on our X3.
It might if you have run flats on the front and not on the back.

rassi

2,519 posts

282 months

Thursday 7th April 2016
quotequote all
As the others have already stated, it is the difference in circumference that is causing the problems, compounded by the fact that you have staggered wheels, which makes the possible difference between front and back even bigger.

New front tyres needed, I am afraid.

blueST

Original Poster:

4,910 posts

247 months

Thursday 7th April 2016
quotequote all
This could be tricky. I'm off out with the French phrase book in hand to try to find a garage that does tyres in rural France, which necessitates much driving frown. And then I can't imagine anyone will have the right one in stock and my ferry home is Saturday. Holiday has suddenly got a lot less enjoyable.

blueST

Original Poster:

4,910 posts

247 months

Thursday 7th April 2016
quotequote all
By the power of Google Translate and sign language I've got two massively overpriced Hankooks being fitted to the front tomorrow. Hope it does the trick.

Ranger 6

7,736 posts

280 months

Thursday 7th April 2016
quotequote all
I hate to be the bringer of doom here as you've arranged new tyres, but.....

With staggered tyres you do need to have 'star marked' tyres. These are BMW OEM spec tyres which even though they're different sizes have the same rolling radius (and weight?). This has nothing to do with runflats and if you had an 'all square' setup then the star marking wouldn't be an issue.

Even though there are only millimetres difference in the radius of your new tyres you may still have the transmission windup. I'm very happy to be proved wrong here so please let us know how you get on.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Thursday 7th April 2016
quotequote all
I have used non star marked staggered set up, and was fine.

I think he will be fine with the ones he has chosen.

It can cause issues on some tyres as they only offer different load rated tyres in different sizes, so you get a much heavier rear and a much lighter front, but this is quite rare.


He will be OK with the new Hankooks fitted.

Plus the joy of being off run flats!!

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Thursday 7th April 2016
quotequote all
blueST said:
Isnt it the fronts I would need? 225/45s? Can't fit 255s on the front as the wheels are narrower.

Edited by blueST on Thursday 7th April 07:43
Sorry, I meant just get the fronts to match the rears.

I didn't know yours were staggered.

Ranger 6

7,736 posts

280 months

Thursday 7th April 2016
quotequote all
gizlaroc said:
I have used non star marked staggered set up, and was fine.
On an F25? There's hope for me yet smile

gizlaroc said:
....Plus the joy of being off run flats!!
Oh yus </churchilldog>

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Thursday 7th April 2016
quotequote all
Ranger 6 said:
gizlaroc said:
I have used non star marked staggered set up, and was fine.
On an F25? There's hope for me yet smile
I used these....

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/245-45-R19-PIRELLI-P-ZER...

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/275-40-R19-PIRELLI-P-ZER...

blueST

Original Poster:

4,910 posts

247 months

Friday 8th April 2016
quotequote all
Well in true French style, the tyres are still in a van somewhere near Alencon, so I'm burning time in a bar. Not all bad.

Seeing as I've nothing else to do, I may as well mention these tyres are costing €508! No wonder the guy is so friendly and helpful. Hope this works.

To end up on four star marked tyres would have cost me more money than I have in my account, so that's not an option. If this doesn't work it's getting recovered home... or set alight in a ditch.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Friday 8th April 2016
quotequote all
blueST said:
Well in true French style, the tyres are still in a van somewhere near Alencon, so I'm burning time in a bar. Not all bad.

Seeing as I've nothing else to do, I may as well mention these tyres are costing €508! No wonder the guy is so friendly and helpful. Hope this works.

To end up on four star marked tyres would have cost me more money than I have in my account, so that's not an option. If this doesn't work it's getting recovered home... or set alight in a ditch.
You will be fine, and at least you can sell the front run flats when you get back to recover some of the cost. They sell well on eBay.

Especially if you put "only selling as I needed to replace the rears and was told I had to do all 4 at once."