Which brake pads?
Which brake pads?
Author
Discussion

menor95

Original Poster:

201 posts

157 months

Saturday 9th April 2016
quotequote all
My brake pads on my 03 Z4 need to be changed however the last two sets that I have had have both been cheap (eurocarparts) and left deposits on the discs under high temps (trackday) etc.

I am looking for something a little bit better than stock BMW ones that can cope with light track work.

Pas

E-bmw

13,660 posts

183 months

Saturday 9th April 2016
quotequote all
I am in an e36 for my track days & have tried 'em all over the years.

Ever since coming to my senses I only ever now use either Pagid RS29 of Ferodo DS uno.

Both last well brake fantastically especially on track and don't damage the discs unduly.

Yes, they are expensive, but for the other advantages I consider them a no-brainer.

Don't know what they would cost for me as I use a 4-pot/2-pot AP front/rear set up, so mine will be much more than yours.

menor95

Original Poster:

201 posts

157 months

Saturday 9th April 2016
quotequote all
Thanks for the recommendation, I just took a quick look and found that they cost £200 for my car, I am also running stock calipers and its my daily driver for 90% of the time. I should really get different pads for the street and track but track days are a rare occasion for me now so I am not sure if I can justify a second set like the r29's.

Pas

E-bmw

13,660 posts

183 months

Sunday 10th April 2016
quotequote all
If you do, they will literally last forever doing the occasional days, just some data from my experience:-

DS2500 £100 - last 1.5 track days at Cadwell.
EBC Yellow plasticine £100 - didn't make it the full day.
EBC Red putty £100 - didn't make it the full day.
Mintex 1144 £120 - Day & 1/5 again.
DS3000 £120 - nearly 2 days.
RS29 £230+vat - Last more than a year (8-10) of track days & out perform all with discs lasting 2 to 3 years instead of 1.
DS uno £180+vat - Very similar but just not quite the same feel.

Sohlman

590 posts

285 months

Sunday 10th April 2016
quotequote all
You need to be careful what you choose. A road pad is quiet, works well from cold and can sustain some repeated abuse.

A track/race pad does not care about noise, dust, just its ability to deal with temperature and some are significantly less affective when cold.

To be fair stock BMW pads are very good. Your cheap euro car parts pads may be an inferior quality pad to OEM. Generally BMW uses Textar, and I find Pagid are good too, all be it dustier. Check how much pads are from BMW direct. They may be cheaper than you think.

Also how you use the car on track is a major factor. If you are chasing a lap time and braking very late with a powerful heavy car you need all the brakes you can get and on a road car I would not recommend this as sooner or later you will have no brakes and have a moment. You need to drive around the brakes. Brake slightly earlier, be sensitive to when they start grumbling and give them a cool down lap.

I have used genuine BMW pads and they did remarkably well on my heavy road car. On my track car I Have used red stuff and they were an improvement, but harder on the discs. Yellow stuff are a level up again, but from cold are not great and I would not be keen to have so little braking performance for the first application of the brakes.

For what you want 90% road usage and the odd track day a mild fast road pad will probable give what you need. Something like a greenstuff or equivalent. My advice is don't go too extreme as you want good cold use bite.