F10 530D or 530D GT?
F10 530D or 530D GT?
Author
Discussion

CIS121

Original Poster:

1,273 posts

244 months

Monday 11th April 2016
quotequote all
Very un Pistonheads but in my ageing years I'm not as keen on chucking a car around anymore and looking for comfort. Looks wise I think the GT is flakey, but apart from that it seems to have a larger boot and more space inside plus a little more luxury inside. Also the Exec model looks tempting and I never take 5 people

Has anyone bought a GT and regretted getting it over a standard 5 series?

BOR

5,154 posts

286 months

Monday 11th April 2016
quotequote all
My GT was far more desirable/enjoyable than my F11's

The GT is based partly on the 7 series, and feels better than the F10/F11 in my opinion.


Andehh

7,623 posts

237 months

Monday 11th April 2016
quotequote all
No they are all based off the 7 series!

Fundamentally they are the same car, GT just has the bigger boot but more controversial styling!

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Monday 11th April 2016
quotequote all
Are they?

The F10 feels alot smaller, and has a 5 series interior, the 5GT feels like a slightly raised 7 series, same interior and feel.


Andehh

7,623 posts

237 months

Tuesday 12th April 2016
quotequote all
I could be wrong but I know the 5 series is built off a modified 7 series platform, so I'd be surprised if they then remodified a 7/5 series platform again just for the GT. Just seems like excessive engineering vs using the same f10 platform and changing the rear 1/3 "top hat".

JMBMWM5

2,410 posts

229 months

Tuesday 12th April 2016
quotequote all
New 5 series on the way, so great discounts on this current one, I was offered £35K off one, but of course it will be worth a lot less when PXing as it will be the old model. Make sure you get a massive discount.

creampuff

6,511 posts

174 months

Tuesday 12th April 2016
quotequote all
JMBMWM5 said:
New 5 series on the way, so great discounts on this current one, I was offered £35K off one, but of course it will be worth a lot less when PXing as it will be the old model. Make sure you get a massive discount.
Oh I could be persuaded to buy a 5-series if the price is right. What did you get offered a £35k discount on?

northpolar

137 posts

167 months

Tuesday 12th April 2016
quotequote all
Just my opinion but when I bought my old F11 530d estate I looked briefly at a GT model in the same dealer. It seemed much bulkier to me and the proportions just didn't look right. I think the GT was one of BMW's greatest flunks with appalling residuals. I suspect you would be well served getting the F10/ F11 with adaptive suspension. I had this on the 530d and it made a very noticeable difference to comfort when put in Comfort+. Must say it reminded me of how I would imagine one of the old big French cars would waft around and at the press of a button hey presto back in a sporty German wagon when Sport was selected. Very impressive option, particularly if comfort is a priority.

Peter

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 12th April 2016
quotequote all
northpolar said:
Just my opinion but when I bought my old F11 530d estate I looked briefly at a GT model in the same dealer. It seemed much bulkier to me and the proportions just didn't look right. I think the GT was one of BMW's greatest flunks with appalling residuals. I suspect you would be well served getting the F10/ F11 with adaptive suspension. I had this on the 530d and it made a very noticeable difference to comfort when put in Comfort+. Must say it reminded me of how I would imagine one of the old big French cars would waft around and at the press of a button hey presto back in a sporty German wagon when Sport was selected. Very impressive option, particularly if comfort is a priority.

Peter
I wouldn't argue with that. What was it Top Gear said about a facelift? "Like putting make up on a pig"?

Edited by anonymous-user on Tuesday 12th April 23:04

JMBMWM5

2,410 posts

229 months

Wednesday 13th April 2016
quotequote all
creampuff said:
Oh I could be persuaded to buy a 5-series if the price is right. What did you get offered a £35k discount on?
535D M Sport all extras.

creampuff

6,511 posts

174 months

Wednesday 13th April 2016
quotequote all
JMBMWM5 said:
35D M Sport all extras.
Thanks. Was that factory build or car in stock?

Spuffington

1,355 posts

199 months

Wednesday 13th April 2016
quotequote all
Largely depends on what you want....

I love the F10/11 for its combination of ride & handling - with more emphasis on the handling over the F07.

But the F07 is superb at bridging the gap between limo & SUV and is a very competent machine, even in spite of its bulk. The problem I found with it when I had one for a week was the sheer width of it. It felt very unwieldy down country lanes, moreso than my E70 X5, bizarrely, even though I think they're the same width.

The ride was very good though as was the perception of the build quality inside; far better than the F10 IMO and can definitely see how it's linked to the F01 7er.

And that's the point, it a more practical 7er than just a badge engineered 5er.

Most people don't get them and don't try and get them. I was very sceptical to start with, but after a week with one, if it hadn't have felt so wide, I'd have been very convinced about buying one. Exactly because the depreciation has hit it so badly, it makes a superb used buy and is a lot of car for the money.