118d suspected timing belt/cam failure. Help please!
118d suspected timing belt/cam failure. Help please!
Author
Discussion

pressman

Original Poster:

8 posts

127 months

Monday 18th April 2016
quotequote all
Hi,

My 2008 118d died yesterday. I was driving about 25-30mph when it felt like something gave way/snapped and I lost power and coated to the side of the road. I can turn the engine over but nothing kicks in to action. The car had been making a slightly throaty sound for the last 2 months which I hadn't acted on - stupid I know. A garage has looked at it this morning and suspects the cam chain has gone and needs replacement. However, its not a job they can do.

I've spoken to a bmw specialist (who also don't do this kind of job) and they suggested that given the engine has to be,lifted out to replace the cam belt, i should consider replacing the engine due to possible damage i may have caused the engine when the cam chain went (assuming that is what has happened). My engine has done around 125,000 miles so replacing the engine with a lower mileage one seems sensible to me if the price is reasonable.

So as i see it, i either:
replace the cam belt
replace the engine
replace the engine with something more fun than the 118d (if this is feasible). I'd still want decent mpg.


Essentially, I'd love your advice on what to do. I'd also be grateful for recommendations on garages that deal with this in the southampton area. Ask me any questions

Thanks in advance.

E-bmw

13,660 posts

183 months

Monday 18th April 2016
quotequote all
Garage SUSPECTS the cam chain may be broken, can't they check? Is that not why you engaged their services?

Job list:

1. Find out what is the problem before trying to work out what is the best solution.

pressman

Original Poster:

8 posts

127 months

Monday 18th April 2016
quotequote all
That's why I'm posting here - advice on the issue would be good. The garage has run the diagnostic which shows the cam chain sensor and fuel pump sensor. Based on this, coupled with historic issues with bmw cam chains they are confident the chain needs replacement.

I'm open to suggestions about what else it may be. But given I can't drive my car to 10 different garages, I can't do much else to find out what the problem is.


gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Monday 18th April 2016
quotequote all
Is it full BMW SH? If it is call BMW as they may sort it for you.

If it was making a noise for 2 months why ever didn't you get it looked at?

There is a place in Essex that does a recon engine for around £2500, then look at around £600-1000 to fit it depending where you are.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 18th April 2016
quotequote all
gizlaroc said:
Is it full BMW SH? If it is call BMW as they may sort it for you.

If it was making a noise for 2 months why ever didn't you get it looked at?

.
Do you really think BMW would be that interested in an 8 yo car with 125k and, presumably, no warranty?

I have to echo your next comment though; why would one not do that?

pressman

Original Poster:

8 posts

127 months

Monday 18th April 2016
quotequote all
Thanks. It doesn't have a full service history and is long overdue one. I didn't think the rattling was too severe and it was only when starting from cold so i put it off. I appreciate I may well have contributed to this problem and I will learn from it.

Assuming the cam chain is the problem, I'm being quoted a little under £2000(inc VAT) to remove the engine and replace the cam chain, header cover(? if cracked), damaged components, replacement of filters, engine flush etc. Does this seem a little steep?

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Monday 18th April 2016
quotequote all
REALIST123 said:
Do you really think BMW would be that interested in an 8 yo car with 125k and, presumably, no warranty?
They have been replacing them though, out of warranty, up to that age, but only with full BMWSH.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Monday 18th April 2016
quotequote all
pressman said:
Thanks. It doesn't have a full service history and is long overdue one. I didn't think the rattling was too severe and it was only when starting from cold so i put it off. I appreciate I may well have contributed to this problem and I will learn from it.

Assuming the cam chain is the problem, I'm being quoted a little under £2000(inc VAT) to remove the engine and replace the cam chain, header cover(? if cracked), damaged components, replacement of filters, engine flush etc. Does this seem a little steep?
And what if the engine is shagged when they put it all back together?

Will you get your £2k back?

I think the only sensible choice here is get a recon engine unless you can get someone to look at the engine before starting any work.


helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Monday 18th April 2016
quotequote all
Have a look on babybmw forum for advice.

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Monday 18th April 2016
quotequote all
pressman said:
Thanks. It doesn't have a full service history and is long overdue one.
Then you don't have a prayer of BMW assisting in any way.

The engine needs to come out, and the head removed. You will have bent valves but only a strip down will tell you if the head is buggered. Until then hope for the best, but expect the worst.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 18th April 2016
quotequote all
gizlaroc said:
REALIST123 said:
Do you really think BMW would be that interested in an 8 yo car with 125k and, presumably, no warranty?
They have been replacing them though, out of warranty, up to that age, but only with full BMWSH.
Fair enough. Not relevant any more though!

pressman

Original Poster:

8 posts

127 months

Monday 18th April 2016
quotequote all
iSore said:
Then you don't have a prayer of BMW assisting in any way.

The engine needs to come out, and the head removed. You will have bent valves but only a strip down will tell you if the head is buggered. Until then hope for the best, but expect the worst.
Thanks. Just to clarify, I haven't said I expect BMW to assist. Is it certain I will have bent valves? I had also thought that but a couple of people I've spoken with have said that the tops of the valves in this engine are sacrificial and designed to break off to prevent bending of the rods? And I've also been told that fact I was going quite slowly will likely have limited damage to the valves.

pressman

Original Poster:

8 posts

127 months

Monday 18th April 2016
quotequote all
gizlaroc said:
And what if the engine is shagged when they put it all back together?

Will you get your £2k back?

I think the only sensible choice here is get a recon engine unless you can get someone to look at the engine before starting any work.
I will seek assurances over quality of workmanship/warranty etc. so don't worry to much about that.

The reason I am here is more to ask about the practice and value of what I've been advised and quoted for. Is what I have been told and quoted for i.e. replacement of a cam chain and associated components a reasonably normal practice?

If so, how much would you generally expect it to cost?

If no one ever does it due to it being far too risky then fine, I can accept that. If however it can be successfully undertaken but there are a few pitfalls to be wary of, let me know.

Please bear in mind my knowledge on this subject is limited but any technical explanation would be good to help me understand.

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Monday 18th April 2016
quotequote all
You won't bend the rods. But I've seen these where the cam bearing caps have been smashed and another with a split block.

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Monday 18th April 2016
quotequote all
Just put another engine in, job jobbed.

Mr Tidy

31,940 posts

158 months

Tuesday 19th April 2016
quotequote all
I'm guessing your 118d is a facelift model (07 onwards) in which case it will have the N47 diesel engine, which is prone to cam-chain failure (try search N47 cam-chain for examples of it).

One of the issues is that the cam-chain is at the back of the engine so the engine needs to come out of the car for access to it. Plus early models sometimes also require a crankshaft change - some on here have been quoted £7K repair costs by BMW agents (before BMW started to pay for cars with full main agent SH). Main reason I bailed out of my 123d at 81K miles!

As the car was moving when it failed there is sure to be other damage, so in your situation I would go for a 2nd hand engine as has been suggested.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Tuesday 19th April 2016
quotequote all
pressman said:
I will seek assurances over quality of workmanship/warranty etc. so don't worry to much about that.
You're missing the point.

They will only know when they have finished the work, will they then say "Oh the engine is shagged, don't worry about the £2k mate." ??

Unless they strip it apart to check, but from what I have heard this then works out more expensive than a refurbed engine.



pressman

Original Poster:

8 posts

127 months

Tuesday 19th April 2016
quotequote all
gizlaroc said:
You're missing the point.

They will only know when they have finished the work, will they then say "Oh the engine is shagged, don't worry about the £2k mate." ??

Unless they strip it apart to check, but from what I have heard this then works out more expensive than a refurbed engine.
I'm not missing the point. My interest is the remainder of my post where I've asked about the value of repairing my current engine, and if there is merit in doing so.

I can't make an informed decision based on an opinion which is essentially: "but what if it goes wrong?". That adds nothing to the discussion.

I appreciate there may be risks with repair rather than replacement but i would like to understand them before spending £3,500 on a factory refurbed engine (of which i imagine there are also risks, albeit to a lesser extent).

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Tuesday 19th April 2016
quotequote all
pressman said:
I'm not missing the point. My interest is the remainder of my post where I've asked about the value of repairing my current engine, and if there is merit in doing so.

I can't make an informed decision based on an opinion which is essentially: "but what if it goes wrong?". That adds nothing to the discussion.

I appreciate there may be risks with repair rather than replacement but i would like to understand them before spending £3,500 on a factory refurbed engine (of which i imagine there are also risks, albeit to a lesser extent).
And once again:

Neither you, nor anyone else, will know how much the engine will cost to repair UNTIL the head comes off. Before this point comes, you are merely guessing.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Tuesday 19th April 2016
quotequote all
pressman said:
I'm not missing the point. My interest is the remainder of my post where I've asked about the value of repairing my current engine, and if there is merit in doing so.

I can't make an informed decision based on an opinion which is essentially: "but what if it goes wrong?". That adds nothing to the discussion.

I appreciate there may be risks with repair rather than replacement but i would like to understand them before spending £3,500 on a factory refurbed engine (of which i imagine there are also risks, albeit to a lesser extent).
Have you looked on eBay?

Thee are loads of people offering to fit engines in these.

One example....

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/BMW-320D-N47D20A-N47D20C...