130i - replacing run flats but confused by lack of choice
130i - replacing run flats but confused by lack of choice
Author
Discussion

hotchilidamo

Original Poster:

53 posts

165 months

Tuesday 19th April 2016
quotequote all
Hey everyone,

I've not had my 130i that long and have noticed the two rear run flats need replacing. I want to go the non run flat route for obvious reasons, but when I look up the tyre sizes and speak to my local tyre place I'm getting a very limited choice available.

Looking at other threads and forums there seems to be a common solution to change the size of the tyres. But I really don't know enough aboout what difference or risk this might present. I'm worried about replacing all 4 and making the car unsafe.

So, can you please enlighten me on what my options are and what the pitfalls might be

current sizes are:

Front: 205/45/ r18 88y
Rear: 225/40 r18 88y

Also, any recommendations for a good puncture kit?

w1ntermut3

99 posts

130 months

Tuesday 19th April 2016
quotequote all
Just buy them online and have them fitted in person, you'll find loads of options.

Puncture solutions from most reliable to least:
Space saver + jack (or spare winter wheel)
RAC
'Poke it in' tubeless repair kit + 9v dc pump
Can of slime eg holts tyreweld (make sure you get the 'big cars / 4x4' one, bogof at halfords atm)



Dannbodge

2,393 posts

152 months

Tuesday 19th April 2016
quotequote all
Getting rid of the RFts is the best thing you can do.

Don't worry about the 88Y part, as long as the new ones are that or a higher rating it doesn't matter.
Most decent tyres will be a 91 or 95Y rating.

I replaced mine around a year ago and don't carry round anything, I've got the full breakdown cover though. I keep meaning to buy the BMW mobility kit but still haven't got round to it.

hotchilidamo

Original Poster:

53 posts

165 months

Tuesday 19th April 2016
quotequote all
Dannbodge said:
Getting rid of the RFts is the best thing you can do.

Don't worry about the 88Y part, as long as the new ones are that or a higher rating it doesn't matter.
Most decent tyres will be a 91 or 95Y rating.

I replaced mine around a year ago and don't carry round anything, I've got the full breakdown cover though. I keep meaning to buy the BMW mobility kit but still haven't got round to it.
Thanks. Did you replace with the same size as the RFLs?

I'm not able to match them so am considering 225/40 all round which gives me plenty of choices

Dannbodge

2,393 posts

152 months

Tuesday 19th April 2016
quotequote all
hotchilidamo said:
Thanks. Did you replace with the same size as the RFLs?

I'm not able to match them so am considering 225/40 all round which gives me plenty of choices
I have a 335i so my tyre sizes are different to those that you have.

My replacements are the same width and profile but a higher load and speed rating than the rfts

sixpistons

188 posts

154 months

Tuesday 19th April 2016
quotequote all
I've also got a 130i, and replaced all four tyres with Goodyear eagle F1s in 225/40/18 92Y. The standard front tyres are a bit of an odd size so your easiest option is to go to a more usual 225/40. You can either run the same tyre size at each end without any issue, or go up to a 245/35 on the rear. Personally I wouldn't bother with any more rubber on the rear as it's got loads of grip anyway and the handling is fine. You're best off going for 92 load rating as the sidewalls will be a bit floppy on anything less.

The car will be much improved with proper tyres on

silent ninja

867 posts

131 months

Tuesday 19th April 2016
quotequote all
If the car is tuned with RFTs in mind, surely there must be a trade-off in going with normal rubber? The suspension and associated fixtures in particular.

I have RFTs on my 430d but in all honesty, the ride is very compliant and I have no complaints.

Heathwood

3,044 posts

233 months

Tuesday 19th April 2016
quotequote all
Yep, pretty much as suggested, you either go 225/40 all round or keep the staggered set up but go wider front and rear. Personally I think 225s all round give a better handling balance, so I went with the former using Michelin pilot sport 2's, albeit that was a couple of years ago. I'd probably go for pilot super sports if I was to change them again now. Just make sure you go for an XL load rating.

Dannbodge

2,393 posts

152 months

Wednesday 20th April 2016
quotequote all
silent ninja said:
If the car is tuned with RFTs in mind, surely there must be a trade-off in going with normal rubber? The suspension and associated fixtures in particular.

I have RFTs on my 430d but in all honesty, the ride is very compliant and I have no complaints.
Not that I have found yet.

The ride is about 200% more comfortable and I have about 100% more grip, in both wet and dry conditions.

The one part that suffers is initial turn in as RFTs have rock hard sidewalls and normal tyres don't

stef1808

1,036 posts

188 months

Wednesday 20th April 2016
quotequote all
there is pss then there is the rest tongue out

Heathwood

3,044 posts

233 months

Wednesday 20th April 2016
quotequote all
Dannbodge said:
silent ninja said:
If the car is tuned with RFTs in mind, surely there must be a trade-off in going with normal rubber? The suspension and associated fixtures in particular.

I have RFTs on my 430d but in all honesty, the ride is very compliant and I have no complaints.
Not that I have found yet.

The ride is about 200% more comfortable and I have about 100% more grip, in both wet and dry conditions.

The one part that suffers is initial turn in as RFTs have rock hard sidewalls and normal tyres don't
I expected a slightly dulled turn in when I changed from rft's but I didn't really notice a difference. I think as long as you go for XL load rating you don't need to worry about this

sixpistons

188 posts

154 months

Thursday 21st April 2016
quotequote all
Heathwood said:
Dannbodge said:
silent ninja said:
If the car is tuned with RFTs in mind, surely there must be a trade-off in going with normal rubber? The suspension and associated fixtures in particular.

I have RFTs on my 430d but in all honesty, the ride is very compliant and I have no complaints.
Not that I have found yet.

The ride is about 200% more comfortable and I have about 100% more grip, in both wet and dry conditions.

The one part that suffers is initial turn in as RFTs have rock hard sidewalls and normal tyres don't
I expected a slightly dulled turn in when I changed from rft's but I didn't really notice a difference. I think as long as you go for XL load rating you don't need to worry about this
I don't know whether BMW have got better at tuning the suspension for run flats, or if the tyres have improved (probably both) as recent cars I've been in with them have been ok. I know that on the M135i if you order it with run flats they put extra bushes between the front subframe and the main body to isolate it better.

The first generation 1 series on run flats however is rubbish, so if there was any attempt at tuning it for run flats it wasn't down very well.