Going from E39 to E46
Going from E39 to E46
Author
Discussion

sparks_E39

Original Poster:

12,738 posts

244 months

Saturday 23rd April 2016
quotequote all
Looks like I need a cheaper car to run than my 530i, with the commute being 30 miles a day the petrol costs at 30 mpg are becoming hard to justify. Probably do 100 personal miles a week too. I'd like to stick with BMW if possible and was thinking about E46 330d's. The E39 530d doesn't really have the increase in MPG I'm looking for, but the E46 being smaller and lighter may do, I've heard they are really quite impressive. What I'd like to know is what sort of MPG can they get on a run?

E-bmw

13,660 posts

183 months

Saturday 23rd April 2016
quotequote all
Try honest johns website for real world mileage figures from real people rather than test robots.

Sohlman

590 posts

285 months

Saturday 23rd April 2016
quotequote all
I ran a late 204 bhp 330d on the 6 speed manual a few years back.

Very punchy car, good handling. Had full service history and ran from 40k -70k.

Worst I had was 32mpg for a tank. Found out the breather was blocked. This improved matters once fixed and would then achieve around 37mpg to a tank of mixed driving. On a run it would go up to around 42mpg.

Drove it to Barcelona and back a day's driving each way and achieved 39mpg fully loaded and crushing at high speed 90+ cruise that you could get away with. Now you would need to trim 10mph back as the French police love to nick an English plate.

They are great cars, but not amazing on fuel. Also getting a well maintained car could prove difficult as they are a few years old now.

I would suggest a e90 330i manual petrol. You can get an SE for not much money. It's a lovely beast and will achieve 2-3 mph better than the e39 under normal conditions. Probable 5 better on a run and interior wise they are about the same size. Let's not forget they handle great, sound epic and are reliable.




vsonix

3,865 posts

194 months

Saturday 23rd April 2016
quotequote all
Sohlman]I ran a late 204 bhp 330d on the 6 speed manual a few years back. [... said:
They are great cars, but not amazing on fuel. Also getting a well maintained car could prove difficult as they are a few years old now.
I was inclined to agree with you until I got a 'blend' (power + economy) remap on my 53 plate Touring. Now 46-48 on a run in the UK, when driving on the continent I see high fifties. If I drive on traffic free D roads (dead straight in the part of France I hang out in) and stick to the posted limits, I can even break 60mpg (driving like a gran) over distances of 30km between roundabouts. The car LOVES it out there. Even just pootling around town it never drops below 34 mpg. I'm lucky if my Z3 ever sees 34 let alone return it regularly.

NiceCupOfTea

25,608 posts

282 months

Saturday 23rd April 2016
quotequote all
Interesting thread as I've been considering e39s and e46s as a family car, specifically 3.0i tourings.

Sohlman said:
I would suggest a e90 330i manual petrol. You can get an SE for not much money. It's a lovely beast and will achieve 2-3 mph better than the e39 under normal conditions. Probable 5 better on a run and interior wise they are about the same size. Let's not forget they handle great, sound epic and are reliable.
Not looked at the e90 range much. I do worry that they are that perfect storm of new enough to be a significant amount to buy and complicated and expensive to mend, but old enough to throw huge bills (and because they are pricey they are not throwaway). Nice looking example of a blue e90 330 M sport touring on autotrader, but needs a service and a front bumper respray. Nearly £6k. All those toys and satnav and sensors and idrive - the gadget freak in me starts salivating, but if something packs up then "bend over"!!

LordHaveMurci

12,338 posts

200 months

Saturday 23rd April 2016
quotequote all
Had a 51 plate Touring 184bhp 5sp manual for 4 yrs, remapped by DMS to approx 225bhp.

OBC average 44mog on a run, 30's in town.

Wasn't an exciting car to own to be honest & touring was not very practical.

to3m

1,228 posts

201 months

Saturday 23rd April 2016
quotequote all
I've got a 184hp 330d Sport 5sp manual. Economy I get is 29-30mpg for stop-start town driving and 45-46mpg on the motorway. The 204hp ones are supposed to be better.

sparks_E39

Original Poster:

12,738 posts

244 months

Saturday 23rd April 2016
quotequote all
Thank you guys.

stevesuk

1,377 posts

213 months

Saturday 23rd April 2016
quotequote all
To give some idea of what the same 3.0L petrol engine you have in your E39 can do in an E46 - when not in a hurry, my previous car (330 Ci, 5 speed manual) could achieve 37-38 MPG on a motorway run when driven at the speed limit (according to the OBC). I dare say that if you tried, you could probably coax 40 MPG out of it - but how boring would that be smile My only concern over choosing a diesel to save money, would be there's more to go wrong - so anything you save with slightly better MPG might be lost in extra maintenance?

gregs656

12,438 posts

212 months

Saturday 23rd April 2016
quotequote all
Is you commute 30 miles e/w? If not you are doing less than 9000 miles a year.

I'd be inclined to look for savings elsewhere if you like your car.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Saturday 23rd April 2016
quotequote all
If it matters to you the E46 is a lot less refined than the 39. There's a fair amount more road and wind noise.

to3m

1,228 posts

201 months

Saturday 23rd April 2016
quotequote all
Put that way, it sounds vaguely threatening if you ask me! But it's a good point. The cost of changing should always be borne in mind, and offset against what you'd save.

That only gives you a number, though wink - there's no right answer to the question of whether to change car and/or which car to go for if you do.

I note in particular that the OP doesn't say to whom the fuel costs have to be justified.

Edited by to3m on Saturday 23 April 22:06

jboy72

383 posts

212 months

Saturday 23rd April 2016
quotequote all
I have owned both an e39 530i sport touring and an e46 330d sport 4 door. I don't think you will regret the change. I didn't miss my e39 once rid. I averaged about 25mpg in the e39 and 41mpg in the e46. More importantly the (admittedly remapped by DMS) e46 felt much livelier in real world traffic situations.

jboy72

383 posts

212 months

Saturday 23rd April 2016
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
If it matters to you the E46 is a lot less refined than the 39. There's a fair amount more road and wind noise.
I do agree with that. The e39 is legendary. But the e46 330d is a very good blend of pace and frugality.

sparks_E39

Original Poster:

12,738 posts

244 months

Sunday 24th April 2016
quotequote all
The E39 was entirely justifiable when I was single and had more disposable cash, now I have responsibilities the fuel money is better used elsewhere. I can still afford it, but it's an unnecessary expense. Sure I'll miss the E39, I've only had them for the past 8 years as a daily drive.

miniman

30,238 posts

293 months

Sunday 24th April 2016
quotequote all
I had an 184 330d auto and struggled to get it into the 30s on my commute. Nice car, but the wings were starting to bubble and it needed suspension bits so I chopped it in.

Mr Tidy

31,927 posts

158 months

Sunday 24th April 2016
quotequote all
My first BMW was an 04 plate 320td back in 2005. Did 43K miles with it and it averaged just over 46 mpg, so with the 63 litre tank 600+ miles was easily do-able without a fill-up.

I know the 4 and 6 cylinder options of that era have a reputation for swirl-flap issues but mine behaved and I understand it's a fairly easy fix, but you probably would find a 320d a bit disappointing!

I now have a 325ti as a daily, and although it only manage 33 mpg I wish I had tried one before I bought the 320td (because I would have had a 325ti in the first place)!

You may be right with your concerns about the E9* - early ones have an N52 engine which is great, but has an electric water pump. OEM ones cost £500 + fitting (just had one on my Z4 Coupe with the same engine)! Later ones use the N53, but that has a reputation for injector and high pressure fuel pump issues!

My local BMW indy recommends 6 cylinders, petrol and not too new - and guess what, his daily is an E39 330i so you may have the right car already! At the end of the day economy is only one aspect of overall running costs.

Good luck whatever you decide. thumbup