E46 radiator issues
E46 radiator issues
Author
Discussion

Rsdop

Original Poster:

458 posts

148 months

Saturday 23rd April 2016
quotequote all
Anyone have experience of aftermarket radiators? Recently done the full cooling system refresh and I have a small leak where the expansio tank bracket joins the radiator (manual car but where the transmission cooler goes on the autos).
Now the new rad came with two adjustment screws, short for manual and long for auto and I assume it must be leaking past the screw, which was fitted with a new o ring. Also a new o ring on the bracket where it joins the rad so basically it's getting past two separate o rings.

The radiator is a Hella/Behr, made a point of not buying a really cheap one. Does anybody have any suggestions or had similar issues? Cheers.

mark.c

1,090 posts

211 months

Saturday 23rd April 2016
quotequote all
If it's the original expansion tank you have used, it's not uncommon to crack them on removal from the old radiator. If you did the job then you will know how they can sometimes be tricky to get off without stressing them too much.

First job I would do is dry it all off, get it in the air with the underway off and see where it's coming from and go from there. i would suspect that before the plug.

Edited by mark.c on Saturday 23 April 20:22

Rsdop

Original Poster:

458 posts

148 months

Saturday 23rd April 2016
quotequote all
mark.c said:
If it's the original expansion tank you have used, it's not uncommon to crack them on removal from the old radiator. If you did the job then you will know how they can sometimes be tricky to get off without stressing them too much.

First job I would do is dry it all off, get it in the air with the underway off and see where it's coming from and go from there. i would suspect that before the plug.
M
Edited by mark.c on Saturday 23 April 20:22
Yeah your right the tank was a nightmare to remove! Everything has been replaced though, expansion tank, rad, hoses, water pump, belts, pulleys, tensioners etc.
The new tank has sealed perfectly on its bottom connections, it's just a small leak between the bracket the tank sits on and the radiatior itself. Undertray is off and it's definitely dripping from the bottom of the tank bracket where it pushes into the radiator.

Mr Tidy

31,927 posts

158 months

Sunday 24th April 2016
quotequote all
Might be why my local BMW Indy recommended a new expansion tank, temperature sensor, etc. when he replaced the radiator on my E46 that was bowed like a banana at the bottom!

Only reason to have a 320td (unless you are a tight-a*se) as the intercooler stops the bottom of the radiator bowing apparently. Well at least until it ingests its swirl flaps!!laugh

Jefferson Steelflex

1,609 posts

130 months

Sunday 24th April 2016
quotequote all
It just sounds like you haven't fitted it together properly , or possibly the leak is coming from higher up (e.g. Top hose). When I'd done mine the rad came with the expansion tank fitted already, so I didn't have the need to reassemble it.

Also, iirc the adjuster screw/ drain plug at the bottom of the expansion tank is a sort of sacrificial connection, so if you turn it too much it snaps. Any chance you have done this when fitting? I don't have my car anymore, but I'm sure these things had a smaller screw inside the plug, and you only had to do the outer one up when fitting. Something like that.

Jefferson Steelflex

1,609 posts

130 months

Sunday 24th April 2016
quotequote all
This might help.

http://forum.e46fanatics.com/showthread.php?t=7671...

The outer piece only turns 1/4 way. The blue plug is the drain. You have to counter one against the other when removing the blue plus, and it's a common issue when people over tighter the blue plug and the "wings" on the black piece snap. st design.

Maybe this is your issue??

Rsdop

Original Poster:

458 posts

148 months

Sunday 24th April 2016
quotequote all
Mr Tidy said:
Might be why my local BMW Indy recommended a new expansion tank, temperature sensor, etc. when he replaced the radiator on my E46 that was bowed like a banana at the bottom!

Only reason to have a 320td (unless you are a tight-a*se) as the intercooler stops the bottom of the radiator bowing apparently. Well at least until it ingests its swirl flaps!!laugh
Defo worth changing the whole lot I think mine was also like a banana at the bottom and rotten everywhere else. Was amazed to find it was the original when I pulled it out so it hadn't done bad at 14 years and 152k!

Rsdop

Original Poster:

458 posts

148 months

Sunday 24th April 2016
quotequote all
Jefferson Steelflex said:
It just sounds like you haven't fitted it together properly , or possibly the leak is coming from higher up (e.g. Top hose). When I'd done mine the rad came with the expansion tank fitted already, so I didn't have the need to reassemble it.

Also, iirc the adjuster screw/ drain plug at the bottom of the expansion tank is a sort of sacrificial connection, so if you turn it too much it snaps. Any chance you have done this when fitting? I don't have my car anymore, but I'm sure these things had a smaller screw inside the plug, and you only had to do the outer one up when fitting. Something like that.

Thanks for the input, had it up on ramps with a torch and it's definitely coming from the bracket. The drain screws that came with my rad are threaded not twist fit so doubt it could have snapped, although worth checking when I strip it down again. Possible the o ring on the screw hasn't seated properly though, that's all I can think off if not looks like the rad is faulty.


It's leaking from the first hole above the screw where the o ring goes in the rad. In theory being a manual, with the right screw it shouldn't even need an o ring on the join.

clabcon

325 posts

236 months

Sunday 24th April 2016
quotequote all
Modine make the Radiators for BMW in this application, not Behr. Out of interest, was this radiator made in China or Germany?

Rsdop

Original Poster:

458 posts

148 months

Sunday 24th April 2016
quotequote all
clabcon said:
Modine make the Radiators for BMW in this application, not Behr. Out of interest, was this radiator made in China or Germany?
Don't know, although the Behr/Hella expansion tank fitted at the same time came with a made in China sticker on it. P***ed me off tbh as they are advertised as Behr Germany.
I knew the radiator wasn't OEM but after plenty of research it seemed the best option. Plenty been fitted successfully, and I made a point of avoiding the really cheap ones.

clabcon

325 posts

236 months

Sunday 24th April 2016
quotequote all
You need flat rather than round edged washers for those parts to fit apparently.