E89 Z4 - what are they like?
Discussion
I'll be changing from my 2004 645 in the next month or two and pretty much narrowed down my choices to either a ~2012 640(i/d - as 650s appear to be as rare as hens teeth) or for the same budget a newer E89 Z4. Does any one have experience of the Z4 to share? They don't seem to get much press or mentioned much but I understand the higher-capacity engined variants are pretty solid.
Ideally I'm primarily after a GT-sort of experience (hence looking at the 6 again) opposed to balls-out speed and razor-sharp handling; I just want something that rides well and has decent poke. I looked at the older 3.0Si a few years ago and was tempted but ended up with my 6 as it was more powerful and insurance was strangely cheaper. Not adverse to looking at these again but I'd like something a bit more modern for a while as my 645 is starting to cost a lot of maintenance due to its age
Ideally I'm primarily after a GT-sort of experience (hence looking at the 6 again) opposed to balls-out speed and razor-sharp handling; I just want something that rides well and has decent poke. I looked at the older 3.0Si a few years ago and was tempted but ended up with my 6 as it was more powerful and insurance was strangely cheaper. Not adverse to looking at these again but I'd like something a bit more modern for a while as my 645 is starting to cost a lot of maintenance due to its age

I got mine coming from a 335d. (not mapped).
I made the conscious decision (my first ever convertible) to use it roof down where possible.
positives:
compared to the 335d, the (deep breath) s-drive35i is a peach of an engine. It keeps the twin-turbo n54 engine, where the newer 3-series and others went to the single turbo n55.
it's an "exclusive" club, they're quite rare (but then so is a 6).
it's a convertible.
negatives:
electric pas. nope, don't like it.
ride is firm, when compared to the 3-series, both non-rft, both on 19" (in both cases i've changed from the std 225/35/19f & 255/30/19r to 235/265.
for what it is, the boot space is good, but have a look at the way the roof limits access once down - it's limiting in that regard - i can live with it though.
I do like the car & overall am happy with it. The biggest issue is space. Obviously it's a strict 2-seater, but while I'm taller than average at 6'3", I've got the seat hard back against the bulkhead, and flat to the floor, I couldn't get comfy with the clutch in a manual (I've got the dct). So, if you're tall, you might not fit.
Personally, it's not as good a distance mile-muncher as the 335d, it's that little bit noiser all the time, and with the harder ride, this becomes a little more wearing on me. Still hasn't stopped me going to Germany (it's stable (roof-up) at 150), and Marseilles so far this year though.
If you're going to do big distances regularly, I'd get the 6, it's a much better car for that (they were on my shortlist too), but if you're a 5k a year person, I'd say it's worth considering.
I made the conscious decision (my first ever convertible) to use it roof down where possible.
positives:
compared to the 335d, the (deep breath) s-drive35i is a peach of an engine. It keeps the twin-turbo n54 engine, where the newer 3-series and others went to the single turbo n55.
it's an "exclusive" club, they're quite rare (but then so is a 6).
it's a convertible.
negatives:
electric pas. nope, don't like it.
ride is firm, when compared to the 3-series, both non-rft, both on 19" (in both cases i've changed from the std 225/35/19f & 255/30/19r to 235/265.
for what it is, the boot space is good, but have a look at the way the roof limits access once down - it's limiting in that regard - i can live with it though.
I do like the car & overall am happy with it. The biggest issue is space. Obviously it's a strict 2-seater, but while I'm taller than average at 6'3", I've got the seat hard back against the bulkhead, and flat to the floor, I couldn't get comfy with the clutch in a manual (I've got the dct). So, if you're tall, you might not fit.
Personally, it's not as good a distance mile-muncher as the 335d, it's that little bit noiser all the time, and with the harder ride, this becomes a little more wearing on me. Still hasn't stopped me going to Germany (it's stable (roof-up) at 150), and Marseilles so far this year though.
If you're going to do big distances regularly, I'd get the 6, it's a much better car for that (they were on my shortlist too), but if you're a 5k a year person, I'd say it's worth considering.
OP, you don't mention whether you like roof-down motoring.
If that isn't a priority you could try the earlier generation Coupe (E86). I've had mine nearly 2 years and love it. The 3 litre N52 straight 6 is just fantastic and to my mind the Coupe works better as a GT than the E85 or E89. Plus it has much more boot space if you are planning a longer trip.
Downside is you still get EPAS (unless you buy the M model) but BMW are fitting that to everything now!
Good luck anyway.
If that isn't a priority you could try the earlier generation Coupe (E86). I've had mine nearly 2 years and love it. The 3 litre N52 straight 6 is just fantastic and to my mind the Coupe works better as a GT than the E85 or E89. Plus it has much more boot space if you are planning a longer trip.
Downside is you still get EPAS (unless you buy the M model) but BMW are fitting that to everything now!
Good luck anyway.
Not really a fan of convertibles but I was considering the current gen Z4 due to its tin roof. E86 3.0Si is on the list, but towards the back as I'm looking for something a bit more modern having spent the last 3 years contending with the maintenance that comes with a 12 year old complex car.
I know what you mean - before the Z4C I has a 123d.
It had stop/start (probably why I needed a new battery and starter motor) and some wonderful louvres behind the grille that stayed closed so it warmed up quicker then opened once it was hot - but that was always a worry in a car with no temperature gauge!
The problem is that the newer you get the more complicated features there are, which as time goes by are more likely to fail expensively!
That is why I now run a nice simple 325ti as a daily.
It had stop/start (probably why I needed a new battery and starter motor) and some wonderful louvres behind the grille that stayed closed so it warmed up quicker then opened once it was hot - but that was always a worry in a car with no temperature gauge!
The problem is that the newer you get the more complicated features there are, which as time goes by are more likely to fail expensively!
That is why I now run a nice simple 325ti as a daily.
I've just bought one, after a while weighing up whether to go Z4 or Boxster and once Z4, whether to go 23i or 30i straight six versions.
In the end I went 23i and have no regrets.
It's not "pants on fire" quick but has a decent turn of speed, good balance and grip (albeit somewhat choppy ride on some surfaces) and an engine to melt even the hardest of souls.
Have blogged my thoughts during testdrive phase here...
https://www.bmwlander.co.uk/index.php?threads/any-...
And my newly created running report here....
https://www.bmwlander.co.uk/index.php?threads/e89-...
In the end I went 23i and have no regrets.
It's not "pants on fire" quick but has a decent turn of speed, good balance and grip (albeit somewhat choppy ride on some surfaces) and an engine to melt even the hardest of souls.
Have blogged my thoughts during testdrive phase here...
https://www.bmwlander.co.uk/index.php?threads/any-...
And my newly created running report here....
https://www.bmwlander.co.uk/index.php?threads/e89-...
They are frigging awesome cars. I loved mine (35i M Sport) and it's the only car I've ever regretted selling. The boot is pretty big, the DCT gearbox is slicker than Magnum PI and it's matched perfectly to the N54. The handling isn't razor sharp like an M3 but it is still reasonably weighty and direct. The roof works well but with the roof down you need the wind deflector above 50 mph, but it can be retrofitted. The exhaust note on the 35i is pretty meaty and you can do the "golf tee" mod to keep the exhaust flaps open. Make sure you get a sub 60k car so you can put a BMW warranty on it, then it's happy days 

I have a 28i quite nice, gets some looks but normally left alone.
I understand that compared to some cars its a bit harsh but not as bad as some would tell you.
If id of known i would of ensured it had parking sensors, assumed these were standard as all i looked at had them bought mine without seeing it and yep you guessed it it doesnt have the sensors so parking can be a mystery.
If you care at all about audio then you will need the upgraded stereo, granted i am spolied with my ofhers cars either by having great systems or not needing it but the standard system in mine is not as good as the Alpine system in my elise (seriously).
All in i wouldnt hesitate to replace with another or an slk as to be honest theyre similar enough to me to just go by which one has the best deal at the time. Would either go 28i again or full on mad 35is/amg 55
I understand that compared to some cars its a bit harsh but not as bad as some would tell you.
If id of known i would of ensured it had parking sensors, assumed these were standard as all i looked at had them bought mine without seeing it and yep you guessed it it doesnt have the sensors so parking can be a mystery.
If you care at all about audio then you will need the upgraded stereo, granted i am spolied with my ofhers cars either by having great systems or not needing it but the standard system in mine is not as good as the Alpine system in my elise (seriously).
All in i wouldnt hesitate to replace with another or an slk as to be honest theyre similar enough to me to just go by which one has the best deal at the time. Would either go 28i again or full on mad 35is/amg 55
Based on your reply OP, I'd be going for the newer 6. It does feel a lot more 'special' inside than the zed, and if you're not really a convertible person, then that removes the primary reason for getting the zed! (imo).
Agree though that the 6series with interesting petrol engines are like the proverbial to find, but as diesels go, the 3l unit is as good as they come, and suits the autobox & grand tourer theme well, it's just limited in aural stimulation...
For non-BMW suggestions, assuming £20k+trade in:
Rawer than the 6 = 370z
Cultured = Jag XK (5.0 v8 of course)
My pick - Merc. E-class coupe
Scope Creep = Maserati Granturismo.
Do let us know how you get on though!
Agree though that the 6series with interesting petrol engines are like the proverbial to find, but as diesels go, the 3l unit is as good as they come, and suits the autobox & grand tourer theme well, it's just limited in aural stimulation...
For non-BMW suggestions, assuming £20k+trade in:
Rawer than the 6 = 370z
Cultured = Jag XK (5.0 v8 of course)
My pick - Merc. E-class coupe
Scope Creep = Maserati Granturismo.

Do let us know how you get on though!
Well my 645 passed its MOT today so it going up for sale this weekend and I can start looking seriously 
640 is leading the way as the interior looks pretty darn good and oddly once again, ins ischeaper more reasonable than the Z4
I've always loved the proportions of the Z4 though; big engine in a small body appeals to me.
Trust me I've considered almost every other alternative!
370 - never liked the look of them compared to the 350 - always looked 'tinny' to me
XK - was a serious contender but for the same budget the interior doesn't appear to be on par. Gorgeous though.
TT/A5 - meh. And expensive for what you get.
Merc - but too wide boi for my liking - living in London I see plenty of these being ragged about the streets.
335i - can look smart, but too similar (esp inside) to every other 3 series
Z4M - seriously considered, but similar age to my current 6 so mounting maintenance puts it down the list.
GranTurismo - not brave enough; if mounting maintenance on my 645 scared me, I stand no chance. Same with a DB9.
Elise/Exige - seriously considered, but after the honeymoon period I'd struggle with its rawness.
Caterham - see above. Still tempted though, but wary of leaving it parked on the street.
New Mustang - seriously tempted (brand new V8) but it's the most expensive option.
Considered barges and hot hatches too, but kept coming back to loving the GT, relaxed nature of my 6.

640 is leading the way as the interior looks pretty darn good and oddly once again, ins is
I've always loved the proportions of the Z4 though; big engine in a small body appeals to me. Trust me I've considered almost every other alternative!
370 - never liked the look of them compared to the 350 - always looked 'tinny' to me
XK - was a serious contender but for the same budget the interior doesn't appear to be on par. Gorgeous though.
TT/A5 - meh. And expensive for what you get.
Merc - but too wide boi for my liking - living in London I see plenty of these being ragged about the streets.
335i - can look smart, but too similar (esp inside) to every other 3 series
Z4M - seriously considered, but similar age to my current 6 so mounting maintenance puts it down the list.
GranTurismo - not brave enough; if mounting maintenance on my 645 scared me, I stand no chance. Same with a DB9.
Elise/Exige - seriously considered, but after the honeymoon period I'd struggle with its rawness.
Caterham - see above. Still tempted though, but wary of leaving it parked on the street.
New Mustang - seriously tempted (brand new V8) but it's the most expensive option.
Considered barges and hot hatches too, but kept coming back to loving the GT, relaxed nature of my 6.
Sounds like you've thought it all through, and can't fault your justifications/ considerations as stated. (I didn't even think to consider Audi!)
Best of luck with the search. (if you see something in the NW you're potentially interested in, - I presume you're looking BMW AUC - or not, I'm happy to have a quick lookover for you, gets me out of the house!)
Best of luck with the search. (if you see something in the NW you're potentially interested in, - I presume you're looking BMW AUC - or not, I'm happy to have a quick lookover for you, gets me out of the house!)
Good news with the MOT!
I sold my first Z4C on Sunday - collected it's replacement yesterday.
Another Z4C - they really do get under your skin!
Not in any way wafty like a 645i probably is, but at least as quick and decent boot space for longer trips - just no rear seats! (But I don't need them anyway).
I collected the current one from over 100 miles away - it made me realise just how good they are.
I sold my first Z4C on Sunday - collected it's replacement yesterday.
Another Z4C - they really do get under your skin!
Not in any way wafty like a 645i probably is, but at least as quick and decent boot space for longer trips - just no rear seats! (But I don't need them anyway).
I collected the current one from over 100 miles away - it made me realise just how good they are.

parabolica said:
Well my 645 passed its MOT today so it going up for sale this weekend and I can start looking seriously 
I've always loved the proportions of the Z4 though; big engine in a small body appeals to me.
This is one of the things which appealed to me and still does (albeit I've had the car less than a week).
I've always loved the proportions of the Z4 though; big engine in a small body appeals to me.
It's amazing how few photos can do the car justice though. In the flesh there's a purposeful look to it which I seldom see in press pics. The contours, dimensions and proportions are every bit the sports car IMO. I'm definitely in the honeymoon phase, I'm happy to admit that, but I can't stop turning around to look at it and visiting the garage for a peek when it's parked up at home. I don't think I'd do the same with the 6er.
But it all comes down to what you want from a car. The Z4, for me anyway, livens the most mundane journey. Mine is my station & airport car - neither of which journeys I ever used to look forward to making. Now every journey is an event; particularly if the roof is down. But as one poster said - if roof down motoring is not for us, perhaps a coupe is the better option as that would be missing the point of the Zed.
Panthro said:
......the DCT gearbox is slicker than Magnum PI....
Does the "pull/push" paddle operation take much getting used to? (It seems strange that BMW opted for this gear change arrangement when the "pull the right paddle for an up-shift/pull the left paddle for a down-shift" seems to be a more natural operation for some reason)
Here is my 2014 35is, I bought it new and have put 6k miles on it.
After having a car history that has included E46 M3 , Boxster S, 3 911's and Ferrari 360 to name but a few I can honestly say that in it's own way the Z4 is equally as much fun as any of those cars.
With the DCT box and paddles it is a 4.5 seconds to 60mph rocket, so more than fast enough for normal fun driving. It handles very well unless you really push it when it can become a bit wooly which is where it loses to the likes of the Boxster.
What do I love about it:
Getting the roof off at every opportunity.
I love the interior design.
The pops and bangs on upshift and overun.
The engine is sublime, smooth and creamy with power everywhere and it sounds awesome at full chat.
On a motorway run it'll get 40mpg.
The DCT and paddles for me really do make it more fun (all my other cars were manual).
It stays under the radar as most people don't realise how fast it can be.
What don't I Like about it:
The RFT are really harsh on poor surfaces, potholes are lethal.
MPG around town is harsh... 17mpg
Electric assisted steering feels strange but you get used to it.


After having a car history that has included E46 M3 , Boxster S, 3 911's and Ferrari 360 to name but a few I can honestly say that in it's own way the Z4 is equally as much fun as any of those cars.
With the DCT box and paddles it is a 4.5 seconds to 60mph rocket, so more than fast enough for normal fun driving. It handles very well unless you really push it when it can become a bit wooly which is where it loses to the likes of the Boxster.
What do I love about it:
Getting the roof off at every opportunity.
I love the interior design.
The pops and bangs on upshift and overun.
The engine is sublime, smooth and creamy with power everywhere and it sounds awesome at full chat.
On a motorway run it'll get 40mpg.
The DCT and paddles for me really do make it more fun (all my other cars were manual).
It stays under the radar as most people don't realise how fast it can be.
What don't I Like about it:
The RFT are really harsh on poor surfaces, potholes are lethal.
MPG around town is harsh... 17mpg
Electric assisted steering feels strange but you get used to it.
Edited by taaffy on Wednesday 11th May 13:36
4rephill said:
Does the "pull/push" paddle operation take much getting used to?
(It seems strange that BMW opted for this gear change arrangement when the "pull the right paddle for an up-shift/pull the left paddle for a down-shift" seems to be a more natural operation for some reason)
It's very easy to get used to and I actually preferred it eventually over the newer +/- paddles. (It seems strange that BMW opted for this gear change arrangement when the "pull the right paddle for an up-shift/pull the left paddle for a down-shift" seems to be a more natural operation for some reason)
Panthro said:
4rephill said:
Does the "pull/push" paddle operation take much getting used to?
(It seems strange that BMW opted for this gear change arrangement when the "pull the right paddle for an up-shift/pull the left paddle for a down-shift" seems to be a more natural operation for some reason)
It's very easy to get used to and I actually preferred it eventually over the newer +/- paddles. (It seems strange that BMW opted for this gear change arrangement when the "pull the right paddle for an up-shift/pull the left paddle for a down-shift" seems to be a more natural operation for some reason)
N54 engine is tuneable but does have the odd vice. And the roof has the odd problem with sensors but no worse than any other car. We've run the wife's for over 4 years and had an oil leak (big job, circa £700, nearly all labour) and new boot lock (£400) at dealer friendly prices. I don't feel that's bad for a 6 year old 65k mile car, the oil leak is a relatively common issue.
I'd be buying the cheapest but decent 35i you can find - £16k might do it, and depreciation will be slow as it's not bring replaced. One thing worth noting, it's the last of the E series cars and so some of the tech is getting old. I might just have one for sale soon...
taaffy said:
Here is my 2014 35is, I bought it new and have put 6k miles on it.
After having a car history that has included E46 M3 , Boxster S, 3 911's and Ferrari 360 to name but a few I can honestly say that in it's own way the Z4 is equally as much fun as any of those cars.
With the DCT box and paddles it is a 4.5 seconds to 60mph rocket, so more than fast enough for normal fun driving. It handles very well unless you really push it when it can become a bit wooly which is where it loses to the likes of the Boxster.
What do I love about it:
Getting the roof off at every opportunity.
I love the interior design.
The pops and bangs on upshift and overun.
The engine is sublime, smooth and creamy with power everywhere and it sounds awesome at full chat.
On a motorway run it'll get 40mpg.
The DCT and paddles for me really do make it more fun (all my other cars were manual).
It stays under the radar as most people don't realise how fast it can be.
What don't I Like about it:
The RFT are really harsh on poor surfaces, potholes are lethal.
MPG around town is harsh... 17mpg
Electric assisted steering feels strange but you get used to it.
Excellent, saved me a alot of typing! I have a very similar type of car history to you and bought my 35iS new last July. I don't need to repeat the pros and cons as I think you've nailed it.After having a car history that has included E46 M3 , Boxster S, 3 911's and Ferrari 360 to name but a few I can honestly say that in it's own way the Z4 is equally as much fun as any of those cars.
With the DCT box and paddles it is a 4.5 seconds to 60mph rocket, so more than fast enough for normal fun driving. It handles very well unless you really push it when it can become a bit wooly which is where it loses to the likes of the Boxster.
What do I love about it:
Getting the roof off at every opportunity.
I love the interior design.
The pops and bangs on upshift and overun.
The engine is sublime, smooth and creamy with power everywhere and it sounds awesome at full chat.
On a motorway run it'll get 40mpg.
The DCT and paddles for me really do make it more fun (all my other cars were manual).
It stays under the radar as most people don't realise how fast it can be.
What don't I Like about it:
The RFT are really harsh on poor surfaces, potholes are lethal.
MPG around town is harsh... 17mpg
Electric assisted steering feels strange but you get used to it.
I binned the run flats after 6 days and put a set of Michelin Pilot Supersports on. I genuinely couldn't believe the improvement in ride and more importantly for me (as it's only a toy) grip. Runflats must be made out of concrete and the weight of them is incredible!!
Anyway, I'm a big fan. Gratuitous pic from Spain where the car was "run in"


I've had 2 x 35iS .... one, a 2011 model drove great but had so many faults I rejected it after 3 months. I loved it though so bought another which I kept 18 months before recently selling as I needed something more practical - it was a superb car and only 2 minor faults in 18 months. It has all been said above really - superb build, looks, awesome acceleration and great noise from the exhaust on over run - sport mode on the adaptive suspension makes it give more noise !!
I do miss is and can really recommend the 35iS as it is that bit more special than the others in the range - the extra power (35bhp) and standard BMW sports exhaust sort that ! I would still have mine if practicality issues hadn't of reared their head.
My 2nd 35iS was an LCI 2013 model and I would say the LCI has sorted any N54 engine issues still left .... certainly the BMW tech that came out when I had a roof switch issue said there are almost no issues with the N54 3L engine now it has been about so long .... only the older cars and especially 335i's from 2007 ish gave major problems - not the new stuff.
FWIW I never saw more than 34mpg on the display ... urban I was getting maybe 15mpg but only doing 4 mile each way trips so to be expected I guess. On average months it was at 22-23mpg most of the time.
I do miss is and can really recommend the 35iS as it is that bit more special than the others in the range - the extra power (35bhp) and standard BMW sports exhaust sort that ! I would still have mine if practicality issues hadn't of reared their head.
My 2nd 35iS was an LCI 2013 model and I would say the LCI has sorted any N54 engine issues still left .... certainly the BMW tech that came out when I had a roof switch issue said there are almost no issues with the N54 3L engine now it has been about so long .... only the older cars and especially 335i's from 2007 ish gave major problems - not the new stuff.
FWIW I never saw more than 34mpg on the display ... urban I was getting maybe 15mpg but only doing 4 mile each way trips so to be expected I guess. On average months it was at 22-23mpg most of the time.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff






