BMW 318i - burning oil, replace piston valve seals for 1k?
BMW 318i - burning oil, replace piston valve seals for 1k?
Author
Discussion

jamesthunderbolt

Original Poster:

7 posts

126 months

Monday 16th May 2016
quotequote all
Hi all,

I have a 2006 Petrol Saloon, BMW 318i ES (Manual).

It has several problems and I believe they are all related (but they could separate;)

i) When the car is hot (not on startup) - excessive blue smoke comes out of the exhaust – clearly burning oil.
ii) The other day while driving it completely lost power – it wasn’t revving past 3000rpm and took about 10 seconds just to get to 20mph. It was fine again the next morning.
iii) There is an engine light on (yellow half engine)
iv) I’ve also recently been told that the exhaust emissions carbon monoxide content after 2nd fast idle excessive.

I’m don’t know if these are related problems, I’m not an expert but my initial thoughts tell me I need new piston valve seals or PCV valves – have been speaking to a few garages to guage prices, but I'm only going to get 1 inspection (so need an honest inspection from a UK garage) as a diagnostic + compression test is looking at £100-£150.

Been told by 3 garages so far that new valves could cost £1000 - £1500, whereas one guy has said £2500 (which is much higher than the other 3). Another professional advised I get an oil change and see if that makes a difference (but I doubt that would have this much of an affect)

Wondering if anyone has been in a similar position and what likely costs are to be, I can live with 1500 but 2500 is not something I can work with. From the sounds of the problems do you reckon Piston Valves / PCV is the most likely cause ? Also if anyone can reccomend good, well priced & reliable mechanics in London (or essex/kent) that would be much appreciated.

Many Thanks
James

WilsonWilson

897 posts

180 months

Monday 16th May 2016
quotequote all
Could be piston rings or valve stem seals, to be honest either might make the repair uneconomical.

In the short term you could change the spark plugs (maybe with a cheap £10-15 set), if it has been burning oil for a while these are likely to be in a sorry state and contributing to the poor running.

Locknut

653 posts

168 months

Tuesday 17th May 2016
quotequote all
As Wilson has pointed out, piston rings and valve stem oil seals are two different things and you seem to be combining the two. New piston rings would probably be uneconomic and you might do better if you explored the possibility of a new engine. How many miles is it doing per litre of oil? When the "professional" recommended trying an oil change, he probably meant changing to a heavier grade. This might help but would not cure the problem.

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Wednesday 18th May 2016
quotequote all
If its valve stem oil seals, you'll get blue smoke on startup or sometimes if the car is idling as the oil is leaking past the seals on the valves and dripping DOWN into the combustion chambers.

Blue smoke when hot is more than likely piston rings as when the engine is hot the rings are no longer sealing correctly in the bores and allowing oil past UP into the combustion chambers.

I would say, as yours is when the car is hot, its piston ring related. Far too expensive on a car that age to start pulling the engine apart to resolve.


528Sport

1,470 posts

265 months

Wednesday 18th May 2016
quotequote all
Hang fire....

Get the crank case vent system/oil seperator checked out, part no 1 on the diagram below (see link)

http://www.realoem.com/bmw/enUS/showparts?id=VA52-...

My old 528 started burning oil. The crank case valve was blocked, there is a drain pipe on the bottom of the valve that goes to the dipstick and mine was blocked solid. This results in oil being sucked back into the intake and being burned.







Edited by 528Sport on Wednesday 18th May 09:47