BMW 2.0 X1 USED 18d x-line or 20d SE
BMW 2.0 X1 USED 18d x-line or 20d SE
Author
Discussion

Shaz10

Original Poster:

13 posts

149 months

Sunday 29th May 2016
quotequote all
Hi Guys

Please try to help me to decide.

I am planning to buy a BMW X1, and I am confused to decide between following 2 models:

1. BMW X1 xDrive 2.0 18D xLine
2. BMW X1 xDrive 2.0 20D SE

Both cars are used and around 20K miles on them. xLine is leather and SE is not but the engine difference is there.

Could you please shed some light on which one will remain better for future use, annual millage of 12K.

Thanks a lot in advance for your replies. looking forward

Trabi601

4,865 posts

126 months

Sunday 29th May 2016
quotequote all
Shaz10 said:
Hi Guys

Please try to help me to decide.

I am planning to buy a BMW X1, and I am confused to decide between following 2 models:

1. BMW X1 xDrive 2.0 18D xLine
2. BMW X1 xDrive 2.0 20D SE

Both cars are used and around 20K miles on them. xLine is leather and SE is not but the engine difference is there.

Could you please shed some light on which one will remain better for future use, annual millage of 12K.

Thanks a lot in advance for your replies. looking forward
New or old X1? The old one was awful and best avoided. New one looks better, but it's lost the BMW feel as it's now based on the Mini Countryman.

There's no difference between engines other than the map in the ECU - 18d is, I recall, 150bhp and the 20d is 180bhp. Only you can decide if you need the extra power.

Shaz10

Original Poster:

13 posts

149 months

Sunday 29th May 2016
quotequote all
they both are 2013 (62 reg) ... selling for around 15K

are they not a good buy at all ?

Trabi601

4,865 posts

126 months

Sunday 29th May 2016
quotequote all
Shaz10 said:
they both are 2013 (62 reg) ... selling for around 15K

are they not a good buy at all ?
I wouldn't have one - looked at them when I last chose a company car, but thought the interiors were cheap and nasty.

They also have some serious issues with the engines, so I wouldn't buy with my own money.

Shaz10

Original Poster:

13 posts

149 months

Sunday 29th May 2016
quotequote all
Trabi601 said:
New or old X1? The old one was awful and best avoided. New one looks better, but it's lost the BMW feel as it's now based on the Mini Countryman.

There's no difference between engines other than the map in the ECU - 18d is, I recall, 150bhp and the 20d is 180bhp. Only you can decide if you need the extra power.
For some dealers 18d xLine is expensive than 20D SE edition

Hence i was confused if 20D is more bhp and same MPG than why its not expensive

any ways thanks for the comments

Trabi601

4,865 posts

126 months

Sunday 29th May 2016
quotequote all
Shaz10 said:
For some dealers 18d xLine is expensive than 20D SE edition

Hence i was confused if 20D is more bhp and same MPG than why its not expensive

any ways thanks for the comments
That's because SE is the basic spec / trip - whilst XLine is 'top of the range'.

Shaz10

Original Poster:

13 posts

149 months

Sunday 29th May 2016
quotequote all
IS there a way i can check the engine is free of problem .. its got 17k miles on it and its 2013 model.

i am happy with 18d just not getting much confidence of buying a used car. i am going to see it again tomorrow

any tips will be much appreciated

Sohlman

590 posts

285 months

Monday 30th May 2016
quotequote all
My general advice is always buy a BMW with leather. Non leather BMW's just don't sell.

They drive very nicely and all have the same engine in different states of tune.

Also consider a BMW X3 of 2004-2011 vintage. You will be able toget a late model 3litre diesel for your budget with slightly more miles. They are very good cars, reliable and are bigger and more substantial inside and out without feeling big on the road.

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Monday 30th May 2016
quotequote all
Shaz10 said:
IS there a way i can check the engine is free of problem .. its got 17k miles on it and its 2013 model.

i am happy with 18d just not getting much confidence of buying a used car. i am going to see it again tomorrow

any tips will be much appreciated
I used to drive my father's 20d SE S drive (i.e. 2 wheel drive), it's a face lift 64 so some differences with yours.

the 18d is same engine, but lower powered and he found it underpowered when he test drove.

I don't think the X Line has the sports seats (that would be the M Sport), if it doesn't then whilst leather is nicer it's likely the same seat which is decent, but not brilliant if you need back support.

I would go for the more power.

At the age of the car, I would get the VIN last seven digits and ask the last BMW dealer to service it to look as much as possible into it's past to see if there are any problems. My father's has been reliable for 20 months or so, so I've no reason to think they're not solid.

I do agree the new X1 looks better, but then it's a more conventional SUV and baby bro to X3. Old X1 was a niche, an alternative to a 3 series touring for those who wanted a higher seating position.








Shaz10

Original Poster:

13 posts

149 months

Monday 30th May 2016
quotequote all
Thanks a lot

Smuler said:
I used to drive my father's 20d SE S drive (i.e. 2 wheel drive), it's a face lift 64 so some differences with yours.

the 18d is same engine, but lower powered and he found it underpowered when he test drove.

I don't think the X Line has the sports seats (that would be the M Sport), if it doesn't then whilst leather is nicer it's likely the same seat which is decent, but not brilliant if you need back support.

I would go for the more power.

At the age of the car, I would get the VIN last seven digits and ask the last BMW dealer to service it to look as much as possible into it's past to see if there are any problems. My father's has been reliable for 20 months or so, so I've no reason to think they're not solid.

I do agree the new X1 looks better, but then it's a more conventional SUV and baby bro to X3. Old X1 was a niche, an alternative to a 3 series touring for those who wanted a higher seating position.







Shaz10

Original Poster:

13 posts

149 months

Monday 30th May 2016
quotequote all
just came on market a BMW X1 drive 20D M sport for 16k with 28k millage and the one i am looking at now is BMW X1 drive 20D SE with 15K millage

same price almost

tempted to to go for M sport but millage is not good enough .... confused





Shaz10 said:
Thanks a lot

Smuler said:
I used to drive my father's 20d SE S drive (i.e. 2 wheel drive), it's a face lift 64 so some differences with yours.

the 18d is same engine, but lower powered and he found it underpowered when he test drove.

I don't think the X Line has the sports seats (that would be the M Sport), if it doesn't then whilst leather is nicer it's likely the same seat which is decent, but not brilliant if you need back support.

I would go for the more power.

At the age of the car, I would get the VIN last seven digits and ask the last BMW dealer to service it to look as much as possible into it's past to see if there are any problems. My father's has been reliable for 20 months or so, so I've no reason to think they're not solid.

I do agree the new X1 looks better, but then it's a more conventional SUV and baby bro to X3. Old X1 was a niche, an alternative to a 3 series touring for those who wanted a higher seating position.







Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Monday 30th May 2016
quotequote all
I think you need to test drive them; for me 13k miles would not put me off a M Sport because of the sport seats in particular.

However, it is possible that the SE could have had sport seats fitted. Can you get last 7 digits of VIN plates and put it in the below site to get exact build?

http://bimmer.work/

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Monday 30th May 2016
quotequote all
I don't know where you're based, but with budget of £15,000 seeking low mileage X1 this M Sport stood out.

http://usedcars.bmw.co.uk/X/2.0TD-sDrive20d-M-Spor...

would have warranty from BMW so peace of mind.

Is manual trans, not sure if you had a preference?


Shaz10

Original Poster:

13 posts

149 months

Monday 30th May 2016
quotequote all
Hi

Thanks a lot for your replies

Yes, an auto gear is for sure a must from wife side

I am based in midlands,

SE does not have leather or sport seats its 15k and the m sport is 16k

Thanks

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Monday 30th May 2016
quotequote all
In the 3 series , auto changed to the ZF 8 speed in 2012.
I assume the X1 changed same time.

I don't like autos but that is a good one.