New X3 / X4 ... 2.0 vs 3.0 ?
New X3 / X4 ... 2.0 vs 3.0 ?
Author
Discussion

LDN

Original Poster:

9,314 posts

234 months

Monday 30th May 2016
quotequote all
My wife has just bought an Evoque with Land Rovers new 2.0 diesel Ingenium engine. I've become somewhat used to driving it. The seat is not comfy for me though and I need a seat who's base will tilt very far.

I sat in a new X3 and an X4 yesterday and the tilt is great / whilst the seats were not electric, I could - after some fiddling - get very comfortable.

The let down was the 2.0 engine... it's a BMW I thought, so it's be on a par with, or even better than the Land Rover effort - but alas, no. It felt very slow and underpowered. It had the smallest bit of pole but really felt lacking.

Would anyone else agree with this and is it worth trying to find a 3.0 ? The issue being they had a couple of models with spec I liked - but both were 2.0. Does the 2.0 run out of grunt at all on a long haul?

cerb4.5lee

45,342 posts

211 months

Monday 30th May 2016
quotequote all
LDN said:
Would anyone else agree with this and is it worth trying to find a 3.0 ? The issue being they had a couple of models with spec I liked - but both were 2.0. Does the 2.0 run out of grunt at all on a long haul?
I prefer petrols but out of the three diesels I've had(330d/520d/640d) it was the 520d's engine I disliked the most for exactly the reasons you mention(heavy car/underpowered engine).

I wouldn't entertain a 4 pot diesel again unless it's in a 1 series perhaps, I have always thought it's better to have a bigger engine that's not working hard rather than a small engine that's working it's butt off.

The 3.0d engine is also slightly smoother and sounds a little better plus it offers genuine shove over the 2.0d.

Spuffington

1,355 posts

199 months

Monday 30th May 2016
quotequote all
My missus has the xDrive20d X3 and we find it perfect for what it needs to do.

We do around 15k p.a. in it; we live on a fairly isolated property about 0.5mile from a main road, so everywhere we go is at least a 7mile journey.....even just going to school. The X3 is averaging just shy of 40mpg since we got it and will happily get up to 50mpg on a long motorway run, which I don't think is bad considering the lack of aerodynamics and weight when start:stop driving in the local town.

Matched to the 8-sp ZF Auto, I think the 20d is pretty good for what it is. It has enough shove to deal with 90% of ours (and I would argue, most peoples) driving but it is a little noisey / agricultural and I've heard the mpg can almost be matched with the 30d so if you can find one and afford it, then I'd probably go with that.

But I really don't find it dreadful. And that's me coming from a range of 6 and 8 cylinder petrol and diesels. If we were regularly travelling on the continent or very long UK journeys then I would've gone for the 6 cylinder, but for our uses, it's perfect.