M135i lateral movement / looseness at rear
Discussion
As much as I've been enjoying my M135i for the last 8 months or so, there is one characteristic that is bugging me - keen to hear if this is one of those "they all do that, sir" behaviours - or if I need the car looking at.
The car tracks straight and true, feels great around town and on the motorway.
But: (mostly) out on B roads - where I may be travelling quicker than in town, say 30-60mph on bumpier roads than motorways - the car occasionally exhibits an odd-feeling behaviour that completely saps confidence. I can best describe it as a seat-of-the-pants feeling of lateral looseness at the rear. It feels as if there is some sideways movement of the rear axle, when some off-camber bumps are experienced in a bend. It can happen in town too, if there is an odd ripple in the surface of an otherwise smooth bend (one bend in particular, that I'd estimate is driven between 30-40mph in the suburbs).
It's not that the tyres are losing grip due to wheel spin, and it's not even that the bumps I am referring to are enough to have the rear tyres skipping off the surface. It's more of a left-right see-sawing motion, whilst the suspension is (relatively lightly) loaded in a bend. As I said, it does feel like movement that you just wouldn't expect in those conditions and feels horrible.
Tyre pressures are all good and checked regularly.
Is this an acknowledged characteristic of the car ? I've found some mentions of something similar - combined with a suspension knocking - but that appears to be an adaptive quirk, and my car is bum-basic manual spec.
I'm minded to take it to an independent garage somewhere for a check that everything is physically OK at the back, but I feel it so rarely (and the car drives so well 95% of the time) that it makes me doubt what I'm feeling...
The car tracks straight and true, feels great around town and on the motorway.
But: (mostly) out on B roads - where I may be travelling quicker than in town, say 30-60mph on bumpier roads than motorways - the car occasionally exhibits an odd-feeling behaviour that completely saps confidence. I can best describe it as a seat-of-the-pants feeling of lateral looseness at the rear. It feels as if there is some sideways movement of the rear axle, when some off-camber bumps are experienced in a bend. It can happen in town too, if there is an odd ripple in the surface of an otherwise smooth bend (one bend in particular, that I'd estimate is driven between 30-40mph in the suburbs).
It's not that the tyres are losing grip due to wheel spin, and it's not even that the bumps I am referring to are enough to have the rear tyres skipping off the surface. It's more of a left-right see-sawing motion, whilst the suspension is (relatively lightly) loaded in a bend. As I said, it does feel like movement that you just wouldn't expect in those conditions and feels horrible.
Tyre pressures are all good and checked regularly.
Is this an acknowledged characteristic of the car ? I've found some mentions of something similar - combined with a suspension knocking - but that appears to be an adaptive quirk, and my car is bum-basic manual spec.
I'm minded to take it to an independent garage somewhere for a check that everything is physically OK at the back, but I feel it so rarely (and the car drives so well 95% of the time) that it makes me doubt what I'm feeling...
I don't know about the 1 series, but this does sound similar to the symptoms of crappy rear trailing arm bushes on the Z4, E46 and earlier cars.
They move so much and give that loose feeling, particularly powering out of slow corners. You can fit bush limiters or poly replacements. They make a massive difference.
Perhaps try the baby beemer forum?
They move so much and give that loose feeling, particularly powering out of slow corners. You can fit bush limiters or poly replacements. They make a massive difference.
Perhaps try the baby beemer forum?
I am willing to bet this issue you have is worn or torn sub-frame bushes. I had a similar feeling on my E92 2006 335i and was solved with solid rubber bushes. Much more planted now. Mine would be ok when cold, but after warming up due to car movement, the lose feeling got worse at the rear end.
Non-M cars have hollow rear sub-frame bushes which are inadequate for 300+hp IMHO and are the same mounts at least on the E92 as a 320d!
Non-M cars have hollow rear sub-frame bushes which are inadequate for 300+hp IMHO and are the same mounts at least on the E92 as a 320d!
I've passive / standard susp;ension.
One or two sympathisers over on babybmw.net; one suggestion being possibly a worn bush in one of the linkage arms or rear subframe.
Going to take it to a local place I've used before to get it up in the air and look for any evidence of undesirable movement.
One or two sympathisers over on babybmw.net; one suggestion being possibly a worn bush in one of the linkage arms or rear subframe.
Going to take it to a local place I've used before to get it up in the air and look for any evidence of undesirable movement.
Monkey_boy said:
I am willing to bet this issue you have is worn or torn sub-frame bushes. I had a similar feeling on my E92 2006 335i and was solved with solid rubber bushes. Much more planted now. Mine would be ok when cold, but after warming up due to car movement, the lose feeling got worse at the rear end.
Non-M cars have hollow rear sub-frame bushes which are inadequate for 300+hp IMHO and are the same mounts at least on the E92 as a 320d!
^^ This sounds possible (I think my last post was at the same time as yours!)Non-M cars have hollow rear sub-frame bushes which are inadequate for 300+hp IMHO and are the same mounts at least on the E92 as a 320d!
As I said in my previous post, bushes were cited as a potential source of the issue over on the other forum.
Will get it looked at & report back.
ETA - just found this not dissimilar discussion:
http://www.babybmw.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=34594
cheers,
Nick
Edited by nckr55 on Tuesday 7th June 09:06
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


