Fast, petrol BMW hatchback?
Fast, petrol BMW hatchback?
Author
Discussion

rusnam

Original Poster:

10 posts

147 months

Thursday 16th June 2016
quotequote all
Hi all, so I have long been contemplating getting a fast-ish hatchback that would be of a German variety, which has meant I've been looking at the MK5 Golf GTI and Audi A3 2.0 - I believe these have the same engines, making around 200 horsepower each...
The 1-series seems an obvious car to compare/consider however from what I've been reading, the 120 only has around 170 horsepower and a considerably slower 0-60 - am I comparing the wrong model or do BMW just not really make a perfect equivalent?
I'm looking for something for around £7-8k, with around 200 ish horsepower, but really this is just a thread looking for info on the 120 rather than buying advice - that may follow.

Thanks.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

rusnam

Original Poster:

10 posts

147 months

Thursday 16th June 2016
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
I take it there are no in-betweens, then? I don't think I'll be cross-shopping the 130 unfortunately.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Thursday 16th June 2016
quotequote all
There's a 125i but a) it's still a 3 litre I6 and b) they only appear to be coupes and convertibles.

The 130i is a great engine mind. You shouldn't dismiss it.

stevesuk

1,377 posts

213 months

Thursday 16th June 2016
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
The 130i is a great engine mind. You shouldn't dismiss it.
Absolutely. The N52 engine is not that bad on fuel, and has a reputation for being a lot more reliable than the 4-pot petrol engines in the 1 series - plus it makes a much nicer noise.

If you're looking for a fast petrol hatchback, and you're considering BMW, it's pretty much the only option in your price range - unless you start looking at something older, in which case the E46 3 Series Compact (325 Ti) has a good rep?

What specifically would put you off the 130i over say the 120i? They're pretty much the same car underneath, just with a different engine (and maybe the 130i has larger brakes?)

Gruber

6,313 posts

245 months

Thursday 16th June 2016
quotequote all
rusnam said:
I take it there are no in-betweens, then? I don't think I'll be cross-shopping the 130 unfortunately.
Why? More power, a more engaging drive, similar running costs, and lots more power... what's not to like?

helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Thursday 16th June 2016
quotequote all
What's cross shopping? Is it trolley rage? Why can't you do in a 130?

Gruber

6,313 posts

245 months

Thursday 16th June 2016
quotequote all
It's a bit like cross dressing, but you have to carry a shopping basket.

helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Thursday 16th June 2016
quotequote all
I see. Moving back to point, do not buy a 120i. The 120i has a very bad engine, noisy and unreliable.

Mr Tidy

31,921 posts

158 months

Thursday 16th June 2016
quotequote all
I always wondered why they didn't make a 125i Hatch - that would have fitted the bill for the OP about right with 218 bhp, but for some reason BMW didn't offer it.

My daily is an E46 325ti which is great fun, but my toy is a Z4 Coupe with the same N52 3 litre engine as the 130i, and that is just fantastic (but I am obviously biased)!

If the OP can cope without a hatch a 125i Coupe would work pretty well - it has the same 3 litre N52 engine as the 130i but detuned from 265bhp to 218bhp, but a forum member who had one got his re-mapped to nearer the 265bhp level!

Nobody seems to rate the 4 cylinder petrols, including my local independent BMW specialist so personally I would give them a wide berth.

Anyway OP I hope you manage to find something you like. thumbup

nickfrog

25,478 posts

248 months

Friday 17th June 2016
quotequote all
I did cheaply derestrict my 125i back to 130i power. OP, you will be missing out if you don't consider the 130i. It's surprisingly frugal if you need it to be yet is a classic engine. The 4-cylinder are hardly more economical yet are unreliable.

stevesuk

1,377 posts

213 months

Friday 17th June 2016
quotequote all
nickfrog said:
The 4-cylinder are hardly more economical yet are unreliable.
And before the 130i arrived (it wasn't available from launch) the performance choice of the 1 series range was the 120d - not knocking the 120d (we had one), but I think that says all you need to know about the pace and dynamics of the 120i smile

s m

24,494 posts

234 months

Friday 17th June 2016
quotequote all
They do a 123d hatch with around 200 bhp

Sadly, not petrol though

325ti available on 05 plates ....but rare

Mr Tidy

31,921 posts

158 months

Friday 17th June 2016
quotequote all
I had a 123d for over 6 years and didn't have too much trouble with it, but my 325ti is just so much nicer to drive!

PapaJohns

1,064 posts

184 months

Friday 17th June 2016
quotequote all
s m said:
They do a 123d hatch with around 200 bhp

Sadly, not petrol though

325ti available on 05 plates ....but rare
Remaps to around 280bhp apparently, twin turbo

130i wasn't a bad steer,as stated makes all the right noises, will average 25-26mpg about town,I recall 40ish mpg with the cruise set at 60mph quietly ticking over at around 1500rpm ,shouldn't lose to much if any money onit either come sale time.


DukeDickson

5,081 posts

244 months

Saturday 18th June 2016
quotequote all
Gruber said:
rusnam said:
I take it there are no in-betweens, then? I don't think I'll be cross-shopping the 130 unfortunately.
Why? More power, a more engaging drive, similar running costs, and lots more power... what's not to like?
Unless insurance is an issue and/or a central Baghdad postcode, total no-brainer unless the 130s have done moon miles. Decent power, nice sound, N/A and so on.

Mr Tidy

31,921 posts

158 months

Sunday 19th June 2016
quotequote all
PapaJohns said:
Remaps to around 280bhp apparently, twin turbo

130i wasn't a bad steer,as stated makes all the right noises, will average 25-26mpg about town,I recall 40ish mpg with the cruise set at 60mph quietly ticking over at around 1500rpm ,shouldn't lose to much if any money onit either come sale time.
Possibly, but 2 turbos to fail plus potential dpf issues and it's still going to sound like a tractor even if it is a quick one! Oh yes, and those N47 "Quality Enhancement" issues would be enough to put me off - which is mostly why I sold my 123d before it all went horribly wrong! laugh

Having discovered N/A Straight 6 petrol loveliness belatedly I'd head straight for a 130i - 265bhp as released and it was designed to produce that instead of needing to be "fettled" (or possibly f*cked up) to do it!