BMW 3 series diesel engine with 118K miles on it.
BMW 3 series diesel engine with 118K miles on it.
Author
Discussion

O_Relly

Original Poster:

15 posts

124 months

Tuesday 5th July 2016
quotequote all
Hi,

Am going to be test driving a 2011 model BMW 3 series diesel engine that has run over 118K miles. It does seem to have run a lot of miles in roughly about 5 years (avg 24k miles a year).

Reading up, I see some say that a well serviced car with over a 100K miles is no problems at all and can reliably run upto 200K to 300K with no problems.

However there are others that say anything over 100K miles are a risk and you can run into oil leak problems Timing belt replacement required etc ?

I am assured that the car has full service history and has had only a single owner.

Thoughts / Suggestions ? Are there other things that that I should be wary about ?

Cheers,
OR



JakeT

6,002 posts

151 months

Tuesday 5th July 2016
quotequote all
Well, to start you 118k if it has been taken care of is genuinely nothing. Being a 2011 car you can imagine its been a fleet car, and done motorway mileage. So it should be pretty good. BMW engines of that age had a timing chain so nothing will need replacing there. Again, should have no oil leaks at that sort of age. I would check for:

Worn suspension components. BMWs drive very well, but need their suspension to be in tip top condition to do so. If suspension bushes are worn there is potential for the car not to drive as well as it could do.

Depending on the engine there could be issues. I would imagine that it is a 2.0 diesel. If that is the case, google 'N47 issues'. Things can go wrong, but listen for any chain rattle, or have an inspection by an independent BMW specialist carried out. They know the cars well, and it can make all the difference.

Post some more details of the car, like is it a 320d SE, and any options on it or such? There are much more knowlegable people out there than me who can help, and there's a lot of info on these cars on the 'webs anyway. Do some research

But in a word, no. 118k is not an issue. Not at all.

Mr Tidy

31,913 posts

158 months

Tuesday 5th July 2016
quotequote all
Yes, if it is a 318d or 302d it will have the N47 engine which has been known to have major camchain (no cam-belt on these) wear problems. It doesn't help that the chain is at the rear of the engine so major labour cost just to get at it!

The problems were reportedly fixed by March 2011, so check the build date. I would also try to find out if it had already had remedial work, and if not look closely at service history - BMW are reputedly picking up the tab for the fix (google N47 Quality Enhancement for more detail) but may not if service history is sketchy.

This is one of the reasons I sold my 123d (twin-turbo version of the same engine) at 81K miles in 2014 - BMW weren't paying for the fix at the time and on early cars like mine a new crankshaft could also be required resulting in a total cost of £8K +! eek (Someone on here scrapped his 120d when it broke because it wasn't economically viable to spend that sort of money on it).

Saying that you only hear about the ones that broke, but at least it helps to know what the possible risks may be!

Good luck (ideally hope it is post March 2011, or is a 6 cylinder)!

O_Relly

Original Poster:

15 posts

124 months

Tuesday 5th July 2016
quotequote all
Thanks Jake! Much appreciate the quick response and the reassurance on the 118 miles and all the other information.

It is a 318d. This is the car: http://www.evanshalshaw.com/search/vehicledetails/...
which is priced £6 shy of £7k. It is a October 2011 model.

Yes, I was thinking of taking along someone who knows cars well, but had not considered a BMW specialist and was not aware I could hire someone to come with me to inspect the vehicle.

I was thinking of suspension as well, and I will keep an eye out for engine rattle and other points you have mentioned.

More opinions/thoughts/advise welcome :-)

Cheers,
OR

O_Relly

Original Poster:

15 posts

124 months

Tuesday 5th July 2016
quotequote all
Mr Tidy said:
Yes, if it is a 318d or 302d it will have the N47 engine which has been known to have major camchain (no cam-belt on these) wear problems. It doesn't help that the chain is at the rear of the engine so major labour cost just to get at it!

The problems were reportedly fixed by March 2011, so check the build date. I would also try to find out if it had already had remedial work, and if not look closely at service history - BMW are reputedly picking up the tab for the fix (google N47 Quality Enhancement for more detail) but may not if service history is sketchy.

This is one of the reasons I sold my 123d (twin-turbo version of the same engine) at 81K miles in 2014 - BMW weren't paying for the fix at the time and on early cars like mine a new crankshaft could also be required resulting in a total cost of £8K +! eek (Someone on here scrapped his 120d when it broke because it wasn't economically viable to spend that sort of money on it).

Saying that you only hear about the ones that broke, but at least it helps to know what the possible risks may be!

Good luck (ideally hope it is post March 2011, or is a 6 cylinder)!
Thanks for sharing this Mr.Tidy ! I have posted the link to the car in the previous link, it is a October 2011 make, so hopefully had those N47 issues resolved.

It would be a shame if I run into something like that within a year of buying the car where it's going to cost me 5K to fix it, there is no point. I would rather spend 10 to 12K and buy a 2011/12 model with sub 60K miles on it.

So most importantly, the car comes with 3 month warranty and I am told I could have 12 months for £350, so if I do run into engine trouble within a year, that would be dealers responsibility to have resolved for me ?


mon the fish

1,577 posts

179 months

Wednesday 6th July 2016
quotequote all
O_Relly said:
Thanks for sharing this Mr.Tidy ! I have posted the link to the car in the previous link, it is a October 2011 make, so hopefully had those N47 issues resolved.

It would be a shame if I run into something like that within a year of buying the car where it's going to cost me 5K to fix it, there is no point. I would rather spend 10 to 12K and buy a 2011/12 model with sub 60K miles on it.

So most importantly, the car comes with 3 month warranty and I am told I could have 12 months for £350, so if I do run into engine trouble within a year, that would be dealers responsibility to have resolved for me ?
Check the small print of the warranty very carefully - that's cheap IMO for a years warranty for a car of that mileage. It's possible it may not cover big-ticket items, or have a payout limit

helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Wednesday 6th July 2016
quotequote all
Heard an F30 320d 62 yesterday with a noisy timing chain.

ForzaGilles

565 posts

255 months

Wednesday 6th July 2016
quotequote all
helix402 said:
Heard an F30 320d 62 yesterday with a noisy timing chain.
What does it sound like?

smashy

3,108 posts

189 months

Wednesday 6th July 2016
quotequote all
They were still having problems with this N47 engine in 2012 ,certainly on the new shape one series...when I once spoke to a service manager of a large BMW dealership he said "it is only now (sept 2014 ) I would ever spend my own money on that engine" .....just as they were bringing out the B47 replacement

O_Relly

Original Poster:

15 posts

124 months

Wednesday 6th July 2016
quotequote all
Thanks everyone. I will have a detailed read of the service history and also of the 1 year warranty cover from the dealer.

And hopefully take a BMW specialist to review the car along with me. Anyone knows where I can hire such a person to be available for a couple of hours doing the test drive and inspecting the vehicle ?

The same dealership also has this Petrol engine:
http://www.evanshalshaw.com/search/vehicledetails/...

Tbh, I don't believe my annual mileage would cross 10K miles, and I probably don't need a diesel. But would a 2009 Petrol with 41K miles on it be a better bet in this case ? It's just I like the former better in terms of looks, interiors, MPG, road tax etc.





laingy

676 posts

272 months

Wednesday 6th July 2016
quotequote all
ForzaGilles said:
helix402 said:
Heard an F30 320d 62 yesterday with a noisy timing chain.
What does it sound like?
like a timing chain just louder

Sheepshanks

41,378 posts

150 months

Wednesday 6th July 2016
quotequote all
Are swirl flaps and turbo good on this engine?

bodhi

14,834 posts

260 months

Wednesday 6th July 2016
quotequote all
I know it's a completely different engine, but I took an E46 330d from 106k to 167k over 3 years with no issues at all, not engine related anyway. If you listen to internet folklore it should have exploded in a cloud of turbos and swirl flaps at least 3 times in that period, however it never missed a beat.

I would be more tempted to maybe look a little older and see if you can get a 325d/330d, as they are more solid engines, and much nicer things to use. The 6 cylinder petrols are even nicer, you'd need to find a pre-08 to get them in saloon format however.

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Wednesday 6th July 2016
quotequote all
laingy said:
like a timing chain just louder
With the engine running, crouch down by the drivers door and listen for a shh - shhh - shhh noise. The N47 was never cured and F10/F30 cars can suffer. It's not the disaster it's painted to be, but be prepared for a £1000 bill to remove the engine and replace the chain and guides. Main dealers will barge much, mush more.

Mr Tidy

31,913 posts

158 months

Thursday 7th July 2016
quotequote all
O_Relly said:
Thanks everyone. I will have a detailed read of the service history and also of the 1 year warranty cover from the dealer.

And hopefully take a BMW specialist to review the car along with me. Anyone knows where I can hire such a person to be available for a couple of hours doing the test drive and inspecting the vehicle ?

The same dealership also has this Petrol engine:
http://www.evanshalshaw.com/search/vehicledetails/...

Tbh, I don't believe my annual mileage would cross 10K miles, and I probably don't need a diesel. But would a 2009 Petrol with 41K miles on it be a better bet in this case ? It's just I like the former better in terms of looks, interiors, MPG, road tax etc.
OP, the link to the diesel says it isn't available any more, but the petrol one works - that looks good (but I may be biased as my 325ti is Red)!

Given your likely annual mileage then personally I don't think a diesel would make sense (I had 2 diesel BMs for nearly 10 years when I was doing business mileage with a car allowance) but I wouldn't buy a 4 cylinder petrol either!

Now I don't do high mileage I have naturally-aspirated straight 6 petrol loveliness and it is just so much better - and still manages well over 30mpg!

My local independent BM specialist (who is ex-Sytner) recommends 6 cylinder petrol for hassle-free longevity - might be why his daily is an E39 530i!

If you do decide to try one just be aware that nothing else will come close!

O_Relly

Original Poster:

15 posts

124 months

Thursday 7th July 2016
quotequote all
Thanks @iSore, I will keep a keen ear out for Shhh...shh...shh...noice from the engine. Infact, I have a colleague at work who drives a Vauxhall Astra and everytime he drives past, I hear that muffled but distinct periodic sound, and have wondered what that might be.

Now I will tell him it is his timing belt about to snap :-) or perhaps he already knows.

And thanks @Mr. Tidy, the petrol I posted earlier turns out to be a non-option as when I ran a report on it, it still has outstanding finance and has had 2 number plate changes, which seems a bit dodgy.


ForzaGilles

565 posts

255 months

Thursday 7th July 2016
quotequote all
iSore said:
laingy said:
like a timing chain just louder
With the engine running, crouch down by the drivers door and listen for a shh - shhh - shhh noise. The N47 was never cured and F10/F30 cars can suffer. It's not the disaster it's painted to be, but be prepared for a £1000 bill to remove the engine and replace the chain and guides. Main dealers will barge much, mush more.
Thanks smile

ForzaGilles

565 posts

255 months

Thursday 7th July 2016
quotequote all
My 2012 320d with 52k miles is making this noise frown I'm glad I have 18 months left on a two year warranty, although it could fail at any time...

O_Relly

Original Poster:

15 posts

124 months

Thursday 7th July 2016
quotequote all
ForzaGilles said:
My 2012 320d with 52k miles is making this noise frown I'm glad I have 18 months left on a two year warranty, although it could fail at any time...
Aww bugger! I take it this is in-spite of you doing the service (including oil-change) on time every 10K miles etc. Sorry to hear that. Hope you are covered by the warranty.

I have asked the manager at Evans to get me the service history of the car in prior and specifically also asked if it had had timing belt replacement, and haven't heard back from them yet.

ForzaGilles

565 posts

255 months

Thursday 7th July 2016
quotequote all
O_Relly said:
Aww bugger! I take it this is in-spite of you doing the service (including oil-change) on time every 10K miles etc. Sorry to hear that. Hope you are covered by the warranty.

I have asked the manager at Evans to get me the service history of the car in prior and specifically also asked if it had had timing belt replacement, and haven't heard back from them yet.
I only got the car in February, but it's got a full BMW service history. It had services at 19k and 38k miles. The next one is due in 5k miles. I bought the car from Ridgeway, so it's their warranty, but I remember that a BMW dealer can carry out any warranty work if I choose. I'll bet they wouldn't replace the timing chain under warranty unless it snapped though rolleyes

As an aside, the nearside rear window is playing up as well, it goes up and down about an inch at a time. Quality products, BMW's...