M2. Manual or auto?
M2. Manual or auto?
Author
Discussion

flowman

Original Poster:

107 posts

240 months

Sunday 10th July 2016
quotequote all
The time has come to firm up my order for an M2. I paid my deposit last November and delivery should be this December. I have been waiting for a definitive verdict from the motoring press but there are conflicting opinions.
I had an E30 M3 and feel the M2 is its spiritual successor so favour the manual at the moment, and it's lighter. My spec at the moment favours lightness so no electric seats or sunroof, but....the auto is quicker.
My other problem is I have never driven anything with a DSG gearbox. I've had plenty of autos but mainly luxo barges used for comfort rather than speed.
Surely a weekend fun car should have a manual.
What do you PH experts think?

Chainsaw Rebuild

2,138 posts

133 months

Sunday 10th July 2016
quotequote all
Manual every time for me please.

JakeT

6,002 posts

151 months

Sunday 10th July 2016
quotequote all
It depends what you want. Raw speed and must be as fast as can be, DCT. Want to feel more like you're driving and enjoy some of the smaller aspects, manual. For me it would be a manual.

flowman

Original Poster:

107 posts

240 months

Sunday 10th July 2016
quotequote all
EVO drag battle here with a 5.0 Mustang:
https://youtu.be/2JuNcF2X54g
Could a manual do that?

bigmowley

2,702 posts

207 months

Sunday 10th July 2016
quotequote all
Having the same agony of decision making as the OP. Mine is due for Sept delivery so it's a bit critical to decide. It's down for DCT at the mo but it's a close call. My missus will use the M2 most of the time so it's auto all the way for her although she is happy with a manual it drives me mad as she never gets into a gear higher than 4th! I prefer DCT as I love flappy paddles and like to go as fast as possible especially on track. However the interaction with the box is nice, I have a Cayman GT4 so that itch is scratched for now.
The downside is the price, I just don't see the M2 as a £50K car especially post Brexit and with a few extras mine is mighty close to £50K. Go for a manual and it's a lump less which makes it easier to swallow. Any thoughts on second hand values of DCT vs manual? Cheers

flowman

Original Poster:

107 posts

240 months

Sunday 10th July 2016
quotequote all
I won't be tracking mine so maybe one less argument for DCT. Does anyone actually use launch control on public roads? Blipping downshifts on tha manual sounds cooler.
Resalevalues seem to be broadly similar, making the return on a manual better. Sounds like your missus has already decided for you though. End game!

DoubleD

22,154 posts

139 months

Sunday 10th July 2016
quotequote all
The important question to ask is which box is more fun.

flowman

Original Poster:

107 posts

240 months

Sunday 10th July 2016
quotequote all
Yes. So which one is that?
Outright speed or more involvement?

flowman

Original Poster:

107 posts

240 months

Sunday 10th July 2016
quotequote all
Has anyone here actually driven one? There was a time when you could test drive a car before deciding, but if you want something like a Cayman GT4 or an M2 or an Aston GT8 that is out of the question. Hand over your money and hope you like what you have ordered seems to be the only option.
....and don't get me started on the colour. Only 4 to choose from. I went for blue.

Edited by flowman on Sunday 10th July 21:37

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Sunday 10th July 2016
quotequote all
I'd say residuals will be better with a manual. And it will be more fun to drive, if a few seconds slower around the ring.

flowman

Original Poster:

107 posts

240 months

Sunday 10th July 2016
quotequote all
The other thing is that a manual gearbox is what differentiates the M2 from the other M cars, its USP if you like. Think I'm sold on the manual.
Now, electric seats with memory or save a few kgs? Not that anybody else will get to drive it so why have memory, think I've just answered my own question.

DocSteve

731 posts

253 months

Sunday 10th July 2016
quotequote all
I think (if you take finances out of the equation) that it is an entirely personal choice.

Personally, I don't lament the loss of the clutch pedal. A good modern system is far better at changing gear than the driver and, for me, prancing about with my foot heel and toeing is not an enjoyable part of driving - on track or road. However, some people really enjoy getting this right. Otherwise, when driving on the road using a clutch pedal in traffic is just a nuisance IMHO and doesn't add to the driving experience.

If you've never driven a good modern DCT then you should do this before making up your mind. A torque converter auto (even a good modern "sport" ZF or similar box) won't come close and the older single clutch SMGs are a different animal altogether.

flowman

Original Poster:

107 posts

240 months

Sunday 10th July 2016
quotequote all
Good advice DocSteve. I will take advantage of the PH offer to test drive an M3, I have already applied to my local dealer. Then I will at least know if I like the DSG.

bigmowley

2,702 posts

207 months

Sunday 10th July 2016
quotequote all
Which box is most fun is a difficult one!
The GT4 is brilliant fun but it has got beautiful control weights. I had a 991Gt3 before that and it's an equally brilliant box but mainly because it works so well with the engine, it's an absolute blast flat out. The driving experiences that I have read for the manual M2 have been a bit mixed with regard to longish clutch pedal travel and gearshift quality, however that prob varies from car to car. I have driven both auto and manual M235 and just about prefer the auto as the manual shift wasn't the best in the car I drove.

The cost of the DCT might be better spent on a deeper trawl of the options list if there is no resale difference.

Decisions decisions rolleyes

flowman

Original Poster:

107 posts

240 months

Sunday 10th July 2016
quotequote all
Yes, I could have worse things to worry about. Chris Harris, in his bizarre Top Gear test, mumbled something about getting the manual but was hardly convincing. All the motoring journalists seem to have been given an auto by BMW so no straight comparisons. There must be a BMW employee out there somewhere who has been given the keys to both, so if anyone has I would be interested to hear.

V8A*ndy

3,703 posts

222 months

Sunday 10th July 2016
quotequote all


I've said this elsewhere....

You won't take it out of third anyway wink so buy a manual.

If you want even more fun buy a 1M.


Evolved

4,079 posts

218 months

Sunday 10th July 2016
quotequote all
flowman said:
EVO drag battle here with a 5.0 Mustang:
https://youtu.be/2JuNcF2X54g
Could a manual do that?
Drag times? Live your life a quarter mile at a time. biggrin

flowman

Original Poster:

107 posts

240 months

Monday 11th July 2016
quotequote all
This could be a clincher. From those great guys at MotorTrend, a manual M2 giving an M4 a spanking on track!
https://youtu.be/wP5z2cJ5aqk
But somebody needs to do an M2 v M2 comparison. PH guys?

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Monday 11th July 2016
quotequote all
flowman said:
This could be a clincher. From those great guys at MotorTrend, a manual M2 giving an M4 a spanking on track!
https://youtu.be/wP5z2cJ5aqk
But somebody needs to do an M2 v M2 comparison. PH guys?
This guy drove both, manual road, DCT track. I don't think he talks too much about pros and cons though, at least when driving, but his conclusion is go manual as it's good and more fun. I am no way an expert, but although DCT is great, driven it in E92 M3 and my old daily 335i, I love the whole gear change experience of a manual. It's fun, it's more involving. Much happier back to manual in a M3 and also very happy with a 5 speed manual in my ordinary e46 daily.


https://youtu.be/yA8U7a3dQNU

bigmowley

2,702 posts

207 months

Monday 11th July 2016
quotequote all
Smuler said:
flowman said:
This could be a clincher. From those great guys at MotorTrend, a manual M2 giving an M4 a spanking on track!
https://youtu.be/wP5z2cJ5aqk
But somebody needs to do an M2 v M2 comparison. PH guys?
This guy drove both, manual road, DCT track. I don't think he talks too much about pros and cons though, at least when driving, but his conclusion is go manual as it's good and more fun. I am no way an expert, but although DCT is great, driven it in E92 M3 and my old daily 335i, I love the whole gear change experience of a manual. It's fun, it's more involving. Much happier back to manual in a M3 and also very happy with a 5 speed manual in my ordinary e46 daily.


https://youtu.be/yA8U7a3dQNU
Gosh do you think his stiffy has gone down yet, bless him smile I'm just popping upstairs to find some silk to rip (how does that work?).
I would like to see him keeping up with the black one on track with a manual.

I will Definatly track ours so it's edging me to a DCT with as few weighty options as possible. Wonder what it would be like on Cup 2 tyres?