Early / High Mileage E92
Discussion
Going to be in the market soon for an early E92, needs to be a 3 litre oil burner variant, preferably the 330d I think (will be remapping).
Is something like this a good buy? http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
Good history/bills, looks in good clean condition, decent spec. I've never bought a car this old before, part of me thinks spending 6.5k on a car that might not see out the year is a poor move, but on the other hand if it would last a couple of years with minor maintenance and then sell on for 2-3k it would be a lot of car for the money.
Thoughts? Would a 325 or 335 be preferable for any reliability reasons?
ETA: Also gearbox wise, would prefer auto but would manual be less prone to bork?
Is something like this a good buy? http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
Good history/bills, looks in good clean condition, decent spec. I've never bought a car this old before, part of me thinks spending 6.5k on a car that might not see out the year is a poor move, but on the other hand if it would last a couple of years with minor maintenance and then sell on for 2-3k it would be a lot of car for the money.
Thoughts? Would a 325 or 335 be preferable for any reliability reasons?
ETA: Also gearbox wise, would prefer auto but would manual be less prone to bork?
Edited by rsbmw on Tuesday 12th July 09:03
I was looking for the same as you earlier this year and went for a 2008 101k miles 325d E92 (full history, loads of bills, 2 owners) for my daily.
Its been a mixed experience, loved it for a start but its required regular maintenance and in 5 months/12k I've replaced the following:
EGR Thermostat
Main Thermostat
Front Coil Spring (left the car unusable for a day)
Windscreen
Rear Caliper
Rear Pads
I've also serviced it and fitted 4 new tyres, 2 of which are down to the wear bars in 12k already!
It has returned bang on 45mpg and the performance is more than enough for daily commuting, however the maintenance required at this age/mileage has wiped out any fuel savings over a petrol barge.
325d doesn't have problems with swirl flaps, but will be prone to any DPF, Clutch/DMF issues just the same as the 330d manual. If I were in the same position again I'd spend more on a newer, lower mileage one with at least a few months warranty to iron out the niggles.
Its been a mixed experience, loved it for a start but its required regular maintenance and in 5 months/12k I've replaced the following:
EGR Thermostat
Main Thermostat
Front Coil Spring (left the car unusable for a day)
Windscreen
Rear Caliper
Rear Pads
I've also serviced it and fitted 4 new tyres, 2 of which are down to the wear bars in 12k already!
It has returned bang on 45mpg and the performance is more than enough for daily commuting, however the maintenance required at this age/mileage has wiped out any fuel savings over a petrol barge.
325d doesn't have problems with swirl flaps, but will be prone to any DPF, Clutch/DMF issues just the same as the 330d manual. If I were in the same position again I'd spend more on a newer, lower mileage one with at least a few months warranty to iron out the niggles.
I've got an E91 325d. 2009 LCI model. Auto. Bought on 54k miles. Currently on 63k.
I'd definitely recommend getting a good warranty. I paid £600 extra for a 3 yr one from the supplying dealer group.
Mine has already had a new nav/entertainment system fitted because the CD/DVD drive was broken upon collection from the dealer. Cost them about £1k. And it's going in tomorrow because both key fobs have stopped working. I suspect it's the antenna. Probably another £400-£500.
I'd definitely recommend getting a good warranty. I paid £600 extra for a 3 yr one from the supplying dealer group.
Mine has already had a new nav/entertainment system fitted because the CD/DVD drive was broken upon collection from the dealer. Cost them about £1k. And it's going in tomorrow because both key fobs have stopped working. I suspect it's the antenna. Probably another £400-£500.
I can't comment on the diesels, or the high mileage. But, age wise, we have a early E91 (2005) 325i which we've owned since 2009. Can't believe it'll be 11 years old this November!
We're currently looking at 80k miles, but so far, the only repair required in the last 7 years (apart from routine servicing) has been a rear wheel bearing. We haven't even had to replace the battery (yet!)
I did read somewhere that the differential is a common failure (on the 1, 3 and 5 series of this era), which is a bit of a worry longer term. But then again, the internet often makes you think that these problems are more common than they actually are (for every forum poster with an issue, there's probably another 100 cars with no problem). On the plus side, 7 years is the longest I've ever owned a car without getting bored. So even if it does throw up £1,000 of bork, I won't regret paying out to have it fixed
We're currently looking at 80k miles, but so far, the only repair required in the last 7 years (apart from routine servicing) has been a rear wheel bearing. We haven't even had to replace the battery (yet!)
I did read somewhere that the differential is a common failure (on the 1, 3 and 5 series of this era), which is a bit of a worry longer term. But then again, the internet often makes you think that these problems are more common than they actually are (for every forum poster with an issue, there's probably another 100 cars with no problem). On the plus side, 7 years is the longest I've ever owned a car without getting bored. So even if it does throw up £1,000 of bork, I won't regret paying out to have it fixed

From my perspective, it's definitely not a bad thing! You just have to ensure that there is a bit in the war chest for the odds and sods that might need replacing.
My 2005 330i is on 181k and it's fundamentally sound as a pound. However, on Monday, it failed to start as, it transpires, the starter motor is caput. Not a huge issue, but just one of those things. It's also had a full suspension refresh last year.
If it stacks up on condition and history, then I'd say go for it.
My 2005 330i is on 181k and it's fundamentally sound as a pound. However, on Monday, it failed to start as, it transpires, the starter motor is caput. Not a huge issue, but just one of those things. It's also had a full suspension refresh last year.
If it stacks up on condition and history, then I'd say go for it.
My opinion based on a well maintainted 335d that I took from 40-135k - bad idea.
Higher mileage diesels have issues which are a headache to deal with.
From 80k I encountered the following . . .
2x crank pulleys
Both thermostats
Vacuum hoses & actuators / bypass valves
Swirl flap oil leaks
Rear main seal leaking (auto)
Dpf requiring cleaning
Suspension wears out
Glow plugs
Glow plug controller
Fuel vent pipe leaking when you brim the tank
Every single one of these is a common problem in the 3.0 diesel
You can add injector issues to that too
I gave up on mine when it started using a litre of oil every 300 miles due to a cracked piston ring. Replaced it with an N52 330i to run around in.
If you are set on a diesel, get one with even higher miles for less money and budget on getting the above items done.
Higher mileage diesels have issues which are a headache to deal with.
From 80k I encountered the following . . .
2x crank pulleys
Both thermostats
Vacuum hoses & actuators / bypass valves
Swirl flap oil leaks
Rear main seal leaking (auto)
Dpf requiring cleaning
Suspension wears out
Glow plugs
Glow plug controller
Fuel vent pipe leaking when you brim the tank
Every single one of these is a common problem in the 3.0 diesel
You can add injector issues to that too
I gave up on mine when it started using a litre of oil every 300 miles due to a cracked piston ring. Replaced it with an N52 330i to run around in.
If you are set on a diesel, get one with even higher miles for less money and budget on getting the above items done.
Edited by Vee on Thursday 14th July 14:01
PTF said:
I've got an E91 325d. 2009 LCI model. Auto. Bought on 54k miles. Currently on 63k.
I'd definitely recommend getting a good warranty. I paid £600 extra for a 3 yr one from the supplying dealer group.
Mine has already had a new nav/entertainment system fitted because the CD/DVD drive was broken upon collection from the dealer. Cost them about £1k. And it's going in tomorrow because both key fobs have stopped working. I suspect it's the antenna. Probably another £400-£500.
Spoke too soon. Just found out it is the antenna. Unfortunately not covered by the warranty due to water damage.I'd definitely recommend getting a good warranty. I paid £600 extra for a 3 yr one from the supplying dealer group.
Mine has already had a new nav/entertainment system fitted because the CD/DVD drive was broken upon collection from the dealer. Cost them about £1k. And it's going in tomorrow because both key fobs have stopped working. I suspect it's the antenna. Probably another £400-£500.
FFS
Bye bye BMW.
Vee said:
From 80k I encountered the following . . .
2x crank pulleys
Both thermostats
Vacuum hoses & actuators / bypass valves
Swirl flap oil leaks
Rear main seal leaking (auto)
Dpf requiring cleaning
Suspension wears out
Glow plugs
Glow plug controller
Fuel vent pipe leaking when you brim the tank
Every single one of these is a common problem in the 3.0 diesel
You can add injector issues to that too
Makes me even more nervous now! 2x crank pulleys
Both thermostats
Vacuum hoses & actuators / bypass valves
Swirl flap oil leaks
Rear main seal leaking (auto)
Dpf requiring cleaning
Suspension wears out
Glow plugs
Glow plug controller
Fuel vent pipe leaking when you brim the tank
Every single one of these is a common problem in the 3.0 diesel
You can add injector issues to that too
Edited by Vee on Thursday 14th July 14:01
I made a thread on my 2007 330D Auto, which I ran from 64k up to 88.5K, which details all the costs that I encountered.
BMW's know how to give a bill, so if you think you can run one properly on a shoestring, and I don't mean any disrespect with that at all, you may be in for an unpleasant surprise. However, if you go into it with your eyes open and be prepared to spend accordingly, the mileage wouldn't put me off.
The lesson I learnt with mine was that buying cheaper parts from ECP and similar, certainly brake disks and thermostats, which will need changing, is often a false economy as you'll end up replacing them again.
BMW's know how to give a bill, so if you think you can run one properly on a shoestring, and I don't mean any disrespect with that at all, you may be in for an unpleasant surprise. However, if you go into it with your eyes open and be prepared to spend accordingly, the mileage wouldn't put me off.
The lesson I learnt with mine was that buying cheaper parts from ECP and similar, certainly brake disks and thermostats, which will need changing, is often a false economy as you'll end up replacing them again.
PTF said:
Spoke too soon. Just found out it is the antenna. Unfortunately not covered by the warranty due to water damage.
FFS
Bye bye BMW.
Try taking it out and giving it a clean as in this thread? http://forum.bmw5.co.uk/topic/58717-remote-keys-no... I assume the E91 part is fitted in the same place as the E60.FFS
Bye bye BMW.
Otherwise, good used ones seem really cheap on eBay (assuming its the diversity antenna?) - don't know if it needs coding to the car or not?
If it was mine, I'd probably have a go at fixing it myself before giving up on the car or throwing out £500 for a brand new part.
I know this is a BMW thread but OP for your budget I'd buy a CLK they're more robust & lower mileage examples are easier to find.
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
ZX10R NIN said:
I know this is a BMW thread but OP for your budget I'd buy a CLK they're more robust & lower mileage examples are easier to find.
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
Haha - nice hijack!http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
Had a W123 280e - great car!
Then a W201 190e - fantastic car!
Then a W202 C280 "Sport" - miserable, shonky POS!
I'd never go back to anything MB thanks after that! And they didn't get better........
Only reason I can think of for CLKs having low mileage is because owners didn't really enjoy driving them!
I wouldn't with yours as they say.............
I can't recommend high mileage or old E9X-series BMW. Our 2.0 diesel is insanely expensive to run, easily the most expensive in our fleet. Some bills are related to diesel engine but most are from suspension and chassis (joints, bearings, bushes etc). All the bills from this year is going to be about 4k euros. In a one year. Car is small and not that much fun/engaging to drive. Quite boring tbh.
I bet that 3.0 diesel/petrol is even more expensive
I bet that 3.0 diesel/petrol is even more expensive

My goodness there's a lot of negativity on this thread.
Maybe I could add my experience that I've owned 4 E92/93 diesel 320d and 330d's, covering in total well over 400,000 miles and I never had a major issue with any of them. One of the 330d's had an engine management ECU failure under warranty, but other than that routine maintenance is all they've needed.
The point is OP not every 320d or 330d is an unreliable money pit, sure there are problems, but you tend not to hear about the other 99.5% of cars that don't give trouble.
We've also got an E91 320d on fleet that is currently over 200k miles and again no bills other than normal servicing.
Just saying, for a bit of balance.
Maybe I could add my experience that I've owned 4 E92/93 diesel 320d and 330d's, covering in total well over 400,000 miles and I never had a major issue with any of them. One of the 330d's had an engine management ECU failure under warranty, but other than that routine maintenance is all they've needed.
The point is OP not every 320d or 330d is an unreliable money pit, sure there are problems, but you tend not to hear about the other 99.5% of cars that don't give trouble.
We've also got an E91 320d on fleet that is currently over 200k miles and again no bills other than normal servicing.
Just saying, for a bit of balance.
Edited by GTEYE on Friday 15th July 09:17
GTEYE said:
My goodness there's a lot of negativity on this thread.
Maybe I could add my experience that I've owned 4 E92/93 diesel 320d and 330d's, covering in total well over 400,000 miles and I never had a major issue with any of them. One of the 330d's had an engine management ECU failure under warranty, but other than that routine maintenance is all they've needed.
The point is OP not every 320d or 330d is an unreliable money pit, sure there are problems, but you tend not to hear about the other 99.5% of cars that don't give trouble.
We've also got an E91 320d on fleet that is currently over 200k miles and again no bills other than normal servicing.
Just saying, for a bit of balance.
We put 154k miles on a E90 330d over a 6 year period and nothing went wrong with it in that time, so I agree they don't always end up bankrupting you if looked after/serviced regularly. Maybe I could add my experience that I've owned 4 E92/93 diesel 320d and 330d's, covering in total well over 400,000 miles and I never had a major issue with any of them. One of the 330d's had an engine management ECU failure under warranty, but other than that routine maintenance is all they've needed.
The point is OP not every 320d or 330d is an unreliable money pit, sure there are problems, but you tend not to hear about the other 99.5% of cars that don't give trouble.
We've also got an E91 320d on fleet that is currently over 200k miles and again no bills other than normal servicing.
Just saying, for a bit of balance.
Edited by GTEYE on Friday 15th July 09:17
Mr Tidy said:
ZX10R NIN said:
I know this is a BMW thread but OP for your budget I'd buy a CLK they're more robust & lower mileage examples are easier to find.
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
Haha - nice hijack!http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2016...
Had a W123 280e - great car!
Then a W201 190e - fantastic car!
Then a W202 C280 "Sport" - miserable, shonky POS!
I'd never go back to anything MB thanks after that! And they didn't get better........
Only reason I can think of for CLKs having low mileage is because owners didn't really enjoy driving them!
I wouldn't with yours as they say.............
Lol the reason they tend to be lower miles is because they weren't the reps choice
they tended to be bought by the more mature/old person. 
Decided to sack off the idea for now. Reason I typically stick with new or nearly new cars is the reliability factor and known cost. Frankly a 10 yo car could cost just as much over X years as a brand new one, possibly more if you get unlucky. Just fancied a motor that I could throw about a bit and not care so much if it picked up car park dings etc, but dot really fancy being back in the garage every month or two for a new issue (however minor). I'll keep the f10 for now!
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




