Petrol cars and trade in values
Petrol cars and trade in values
Author
Discussion

SBN

Original Poster:

1,030 posts

183 months

Sunday 17th July 2016
quotequote all
So I'm considering changing cars again.

The car we have is a really big spec 335i touring f31 shape, as far as I can see there is only one other for sale in the country below £28k. Wbac is actually an insult offer as it's literally over £10k less than my settlement figure meaning I only have a choice to sell privately. Because of that offer I'm loathed to even trade it in as one trader said lovely it's a great spec but not for us 😩

Is it really worth all the hassle I'm thinking now...

Because they are rare does it deserve a premium or is it literally much less desirable with all the 335d and 30d that flooded the market.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Sunday 17th July 2016
quotequote all
Advertise it and see how it goes. Trouble is 30 odd k is a hefty wedge for a private sale of a 3 series.

What are you changing to? Had any trade in prices against what you want?

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Sunday 17th July 2016
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
Advertise it and see how it goes. Trouble is 30 odd k is a hefty wedge for a private sale of a 3 series.

What are you changing to? Had any trade in prices against what you want?
This is the nub of it - selling privately is a problem with high value cars. You cannot offer people finance plus there is more risk bank tiring over £30k to an individual than to a company.

I'm sure many do it all the time but it's not the same as flogging a £500csr for cash is it.

SBN

Original Poster:

1,030 posts

183 months

Sunday 17th July 2016
quotequote all
I actually think mine is mid 20's but in a sea of diesels.

Changing it as my wife needs the estate but would prefer something a little more economical. Let's me then go and get something less practical... Wishing I never sold my m3 a year ago now!

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Sunday 17th July 2016
quotequote all
Don't want to teach you to suck eggs but I'd advise doing your calcs carefully. If you're taking a bath on trade in you'll need to be changing to something that offers serious empeegees to make the money back.

tomic

720 posts

176 months

Monday 18th July 2016
quotequote all
I'm more surprised that people are still buying Diesels. I thought they were about as popular as a hedgehog in a condom factory with all the negative publicity about them recently.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Monday 18th July 2016
quotequote all
tomic said:
I'm more surprised that people are still buying Diesels. I thought they were about as popular as a hedgehog in a condom factory with all the negative publicity about them recently.
A few friends I have who have company car schemes both opted out to run their own cars BUT one key term is that the car they had to use was a diesel under X CO2 even their own car. Annoyingly one had recently bought a newish petrol car before joining so managed to agree 9 months grace OR take the co car instead.

So companies are buying derv cars constantly

This is one reason - if the govt changes the rules then companies will change otherwise nope.

SBN

Original Poster:

1,030 posts

183 months

Monday 18th July 2016
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
Don't want to teach you to suck eggs but I'd advise doing your calcs carefully. If you're taking a bath on trade in you'll need to be changing to something that offers serious empeegees to make the money back.
My only real option is to sell privately looking at the numbers. Even then I'm gonna have to find someone who wants a fast rwd petrol over a 4x4 diesel. Then you've got the lure of the finance deals which won't be much more a month then taking a loan so add in finding someone who actually wants to own a car the end of the term and it's gonna be a limited audience

philmots

4,666 posts

291 months

Monday 18th July 2016
quotequote all
What doesn't help is around 20% discounts available on brand new 340's, you could probably pick one up with a nice bit of spec for around 34k..

I don't know how old yours is etc but it would to be a fair chunk cheaper to move on IMO.

Having said that, if they're rare and there's only one other car up I'd get it up there and see, you only need that one guy who wants that car.

Vroomer

1,889 posts

211 months

Monday 18th July 2016
quotequote all
SBN said:
Changing it as my wife needs the estate but would prefer something a little more economical.
Sorry, but this is illogical. You will lose much more on the change than you will save on fuel.

Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Monday 18th July 2016
quotequote all
tomic said:
I'm more surprised that people are still buying Diesels. I thought they were about as popular as a hedgehog in a condom factory with all the negative publicity about them recently.
I think people are still being taken in by the "economy" argument, coupled with a healthy degree of cynicism of anything that the government spouts at the moment. I'm looking to change to petrol but because they're few and far between it's not that easy.

dartissimus

954 posts

205 months

Monday 18th July 2016
quotequote all
Whilst we love performance cars, we all know that they cost more in depreciation, tyres, fuel, insurance and servicing.

You should have bought a diesel.

Now you're complaining about the cost.

Bite the bullet, learn the lesson.

12TS

2,262 posts

241 months

Monday 18th July 2016
quotequote all
philmots said:
What doesn't help is around 20% discounts available on brand new 340's, you could probably pick one up with a nice bit of spec for around 34k..

I don't know how old yours is etc but it would to be a fair chunk cheaper to move on IMO.

Having said that, if they're rare and there's only one other car up I'd get it up there and see, you only need that one guy who wants that car.

This. Pretty much what a paid for my new 340.

You may get a better p/ex for a newish BMW, but without looking at your numbers a change doesn't feel to make sense. I reckon on 50% depreciation every 3 years, this is where you loose money on a car.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Monday 18th July 2016
quotequote all
Monty Python said:
I think people are still being taken in by the "economy" argument
I'm not sure why you've put economy in quotes there. They may be more unsatisfactory to drive but diesels are, in the main, far more efficient than petrols.

335d

758 posts

149 months

Monday 18th July 2016
quotequote all
I agree that it is unlikely to make sense to change, particularly if it's a car the Op still likes.

There have been reports of WBAC paying well for diesel BMWs and very poorly for petrol BMWs. How old, how many miles is the 335i?

GTEYE

2,511 posts

241 months

Monday 18th July 2016
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
Monty Python said:
I think people are still being taken in by the "economy" argument
I'm not sure why you've put economy in quotes there. They may be more unsatisfactory to drive but diesels are, in the main, far more efficient than petrols.
Indeed, the economy argument isn't just about the mpg, its also about the residual value too. Whilst a very desirable car in isolation, a 335i Touring is not what 99% of the market wants (unfortunately), and trade-in prices are deflated accordingly. The big spec is always a tricky one too - if you purchase new, you will need to write the additional cost off as it mostly doesn't translate into an enhanced residual.

Not saying its right, but at the moment that's the UK market.

irocfan

49,417 posts

221 months

Monday 18th July 2016
quotequote all
I feel your pain - we had this when we were looking to sell our RRS last year. Good spec, good miles, excellent condition over 4k lower than a dealer and yet there were no takers, ended up px'ing it (for 2k more than wbac) and took a real bath on that frown

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Monday 18th July 2016
quotequote all
irocfan said:
I feel your pain - we had this when we were looking to sell our RRS last year. Good spec, good miles, excellent condition over 4k lower than a dealer and yet there were no takers, ended up px'ing it (for 2k more than wbac) and took a real bath on that frown
This is where GFV is a must on the big vehicles sure you pay an insurance policy for it but avoids the bath situation.



OP do you have GAP insurance? Could be your friend here

Vroomer

1,889 posts

211 months

Monday 18th July 2016
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
OP do you have GAP insurance? Could be your friend here
How?

Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Monday 18th July 2016
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
I'm not sure why you've put economy in quotes there. They may be more unsatisfactory to drive but diesels are, in the main, far more efficient than petrols.
They are if you drive them over long distances, but if you buy a diesel and use it for short runs then the economy is no better than petrol (plus the associated potential DPF issues).