My sunroof exploded :(
My sunroof exploded :(
Author
Discussion

parabolica

Original Poster:

7,030 posts

215 months

Tuesday 2nd August 2016
quotequote all
Driving down the A3 heading out to Surrey this lunchtime when the sunroof on my 6 series exploded and showered my car (and me) in glass. No warnings, the roof was closed and I don't recall seeing a crack or bulge in the glass since i got it 2 months ago (wash the car every other weekend so would have seen something). Luckily I was around 500 meters from the Cobham sliproad so pulled into BMW Cobham (also happens to be who I bought the car from) and they're looking into it.

A bit in shock to be honest; the noise it made reminded me of my first (and only) accident where someone rear ended me and the back window popped; unfortunate this time I was sitting underneath the window and the sun shade was open frown

Anyone experienced anything like this before? I'm hoping the dealer will replace FOC as I only bought the car (2012 model) 2 months ago from them, plus the remains of the glass pane was bent upwards indicating that it wasn't something hitting it from outside that caused this (I hope). I've had a look online and it appears there are a few cases of this happening (mainly US) and its 50/50 if the dealership will cover the cost.

Equilibrium25

689 posts

165 months

Tuesday 2nd August 2016
quotequote all
We had a glass shower screen do exactly the same a couple of years back...no warning, just exploded. Luckily no-one was in the room at the time, and what research I did indicated that hidden (and dormant) manufacturing flaws can cause this.

The shower screen went with enough force to splinter wood in the bathroom door and take chunks out of tiles over a metre away. I found cases on the net where people were quite badly injured from this happening.

I can imagine that it must have been terrifying to happen when driving. Glad you are unhurt, that's the main thing :-)


smashy

3,108 posts

189 months

Tuesday 2nd August 2016
quotequote all
Reminds me of being in my dads hillman minx going to Devon when the front windscreen smashed into a million pieces the noise was amazing ,happened twice actually no shock factor second time we knew what was happening

Theophany

1,069 posts

161 months

Tuesday 2nd August 2016
quotequote all
smashy said:
Reminds me of being in my dads hillman minx going to Devon when the front windscreen smashed into a million pieces the noise was amazing ,happened twice actually no shock factor second time we knew what was happening
Appropriate username is appropriate.

silent ninja

867 posts

131 months

Tuesday 2nd August 2016
quotequote all
Happened to a friend'sRange Rover.

I don't understand why the glass isn't shatter proof and at least stays together eg using a film. It's unacceptable for glass to shower passengers it could easily blind kids! Major design flaw

I'd look to BMW to compensate you. My friend returned the car to Land Rover and threatened legal action. They settled and he got a replacement newer car at the same rate - this equated to a massive discount.

Hoofy

80,186 posts

313 months

Tuesday 2nd August 2016
quotequote all
Equilibrium25 said:
We had a glass shower screen do exactly the same a couple of years back...no warning, just exploded. Luckily no-one was in the room at the time, and what research I did indicated that hidden (and dormant) manufacturing flaws can cause this.

The shower screen went with enough force to splinter wood in the bathroom door and take chunks out of tiles over a metre away. I found cases on the net where people were quite badly injured from this happening.
yikes

How do you prevent this?

335d

758 posts

149 months

Tuesday 2nd August 2016
quotequote all
Hoofy said:
How do you prevent this?
Quite! Sounds dreadful. Can we know the make of the one which shattered so we know what to avoid?

Teocali

238 posts

218 months

Tuesday 2nd August 2016
quotequote all
Hoofy said:
Equilibrium25 said:
We had a glass shower screen do exactly the same a couple of years back...no warning, just exploded. Luckily no-one was in the room at the time, and what research I did indicated that hidden (and dormant) manufacturing flaws can cause this.

The shower screen went with enough force to splinter wood in the bathroom door and take chunks out of tiles over a metre away. I found cases on the net where people were quite badly injured from this happening.
yikes

How do you prevent this?
Take no chances - break the screen before entering the shower.

Hoofy

80,186 posts

313 months

Tuesday 2nd August 2016
quotequote all
Teocali said:
Hoofy said:
Equilibrium25 said:
We had a glass shower screen do exactly the same a couple of years back...no warning, just exploded. Luckily no-one was in the room at the time, and what research I did indicated that hidden (and dormant) manufacturing flaws can cause this.

The shower screen went with enough force to splinter wood in the bathroom door and take chunks out of tiles over a metre away. I found cases on the net where people were quite badly injured from this happening.
yikes

How do you prevent this?
Take no chances - break the screen before entering the shower.
thumbup Done! A literal pre-emptive strike.

Sheepshanks

41,378 posts

150 months

Tuesday 2nd August 2016
quotequote all
silent ninja said:
I'd look to BMW to compensate you. My friend returned the car to Land Rover and threatened legal action. They settled and he got a replacement newer car at the same rate - this equated to a massive discount.
I'm amazed the replaced the car - glass roofs shattering in not unheard of. I've seen it suggested that birds drop stones on them. I got a big crack in a windscreen from a stone when there wasn't another vehicle anywhere near me in either direction and assumed a bird had done it.

Huff

3,449 posts

222 months

Tuesday 2nd August 2016
quotequote all
Toughened glass can suffer from nickel sulphide inclusions; these are invisibly-small, but expand as they grow and one day - bang. Its amajor consideration in specifying glazing in buildings and where large amounts are used, or failure would cause problems, it's normal to specify a heatsoak period - basically , this accelerates the growth of the inclusion and the sheet will fail in the oven in a day or two, not years later. Even without such treatment failure rate from most top suppliers (Pilkington, Saint-Gobain etc) is perhaps 1 in 10 thousand sq.m, ball-park.

I'd not be surprised it also occurs in toughened glass for cars.

PS my story was the glass boardroom table that went up spontaneously in my place of work years ago and, had it not been lunchtime or happened 10mins earlier, would have cut a colleague in two. very loud thump that shook teh office, and the mess/damage it made in room was unbeleivable; but then, in a sheet basically 3.6 x 1.8m x 18mm thk there's c. half a megajoule of stored strain energy! Pulling 18" long glass spears out of the pin board around the room, where bits of the beveled edges had flown off entire, was sobering. The supplier came out and swpt it all up very carefully for analysis.

Edited by Huff on Tuesday 2nd August 19:14

Equilibrium25

689 posts

165 months

Tuesday 2nd August 2016
quotequote all
335d said:
Quite! Sounds dreadful. Can we know the make of the one which shattered so we know what to avoid?
We didn't fit the screen, it was in the house when we bought it, so I can't say who supplied/manufactured it (and would be impossible to tell from the pieces remaining). The rest of the bathroom fittings appeared to be IKEA, but that doesn't mean that the screen was of course.

We swore never to fit another, then bought a new house earlier this year - it has two full glass shower screens - eek.

The explanations I found at the time were exactly as described by Huff in the post above this.



Phon_E87

200 posts

124 months

Friday 5th August 2016
quotequote all
Equilibrium25 said:
We didn't fit the screen, it was in the house when we bought it, so I can't say who supplied/manufactured it (and would be impossible to tell from the pieces remaining). The rest of the bathroom fittings appeared to be IKEA, but that doesn't mean that the screen was of course.

We swore never to fit another, then bought a new house earlier this year - it has two full glass shower screens - eek.

The explanations I found at the time were exactly as described by Huff in the post above this.
eek
I am never going in our bathroom again.

juan king

1,093 posts

220 months

Friday 5th August 2016
quotequote all
Don't mind me, just taking a dump in the woods


parabolica

Original Poster:

7,030 posts

215 months

Friday 5th August 2016
quotequote all
Equilibrium25 said:
We didn't fit the screen, it was in the house when we bought it, so I can't say who supplied/manufactured it (and would be impossible to tell from the pieces remaining). The rest of the bathroom fittings appeared to be IKEA, but that doesn't mean that the screen was of course.

We swore never to fit another, then bought a new house earlier this year - it has two full glass shower screens - eek.

The explanations I found at the time were exactly as described by Huff in the post above this.
Ironically I've had the same experience, living in Tanzania in 2014 and I stayed in a brand new, Chinese-built apartment block that, on the surface, looked very nice; however there are such little building controls over there that it's scary (cooker wasn't earthed so it shocked you every time you touched it, same with the the inside of the washing machine; shower fittings were handling loose from the wall, allowing beasties in, etc etc).

Biggest issue was they had not left enough of a gap when laying the floors and the porcelain tiles started to bow upwards. Came home from work one evening to find 4 tiles in the main living area had shattered under pressure and it was like a grenade had gone off - shrapnel and shards everywhere - TV was abosolutely destroyed, windows smashed, walls scared and pitted, sofa ripped to shreds. Scared the st out of me! Builders came in and smashed up the tiles in all the other rooms to makes sure the same didn't happen again.

Anyway, the dealership got back to me - no noticeable defect therefore claiming it was a foreign object like a rock causing the damage. I've no way to contest as I can't prove what it was - they want £1700 to replace. Found a specialist in London for cheaper but they can't get the glass for almost 3 weeks where as BMW will have it fixed within a week.

Sheepshanks

41,378 posts

150 months

Friday 5th August 2016
quotequote all
parabolica said:
Anyway, the dealership got back to me - no noticeable defect therefore claiming it was a foreign object like a rock causing the damage. I've no way to contest as I can't prove what it was - they want £1700 to replace. Found a specialist in London for cheaper but they can't get the glass for almost 3 weeks where as BMW will have it fixed within a week.
Have you checked your insurance? Most used to replace as part of glass cover although as more cars get glass roofs they are increasingly being excluded.

Mine (LV=) appears to cover it.

Equilibrium25

689 posts

165 months

Friday 5th August 2016
quotequote all
parabolica said:
Ironically I've had the same experience, living in Tanzania in 2014 and I stayed in a brand new, Chinese-built apartment block that, on the surface, looked very nice; however there are such little building controls over there that it's scary (cooker wasn't earthed so it shocked you every time you touched it, same with the the inside of the washing machine; shower fittings were handling loose from the wall, allowing beasties in, etc etc).

Biggest issue was they had not left enough of a gap when laying the floors and the porcelain tiles started to bow upwards. Came home from work one evening to find 4 tiles in the main living area had shattered under pressure and it was like a grenade had gone off - shrapnel and shards everywhere - TV was abosolutely destroyed, windows smashed, walls scared and pitted, sofa ripped to shreds. Scared the st out of me! Builders came in and smashed up the tiles in all the other rooms to makes sure the same didn't happen again.

Anyway, the dealership got back to me - no noticeable defect therefore claiming it was a foreign object like a rock causing the damage. I've no way to contest as I can't prove what it was - they want £1700 to replace. Found a specialist in London for cheaper but they can't get the glass for almost 3 weeks where as BMW will have it fixed within a week.
Wow, your luck sounds as bad as ours. If it can happen it will happen!

Bad news about the 'roof. Interesting that they can assess it well enough to say 'no noticeable defect'. Worth pushing them for a 50/50?

eybic

9,212 posts

205 months

Friday 5th August 2016
quotequote all
I'd be very surprised if they replace it at no cost to you unless they can see an obvious defect. It will be considered the same as a side window/ windscreen in that it's probably not covered under warranty unless it's a known issue.

silent ninja said:
Happened to a friend'sRange Rover.

I don't understand why the glass isn't shatter proof and at least stays together eg using a film. It's unacceptable for glass to shower passengers it could easily blind kids! Major design flaw

I'd look to BMW to compensate you. My friend returned the car to Land Rover and threatened legal action. They settled and he got a replacement newer car at the same rate - this equated to a massive discount.
What should the OP be compensated for? Nobody was injured and I don't think he's suffered any losses (apart from the sunroof)

I'd say it's probably the same glass as used in the side windows and it broke as they are designed to go, not showering big sharp bits of glass everywhere (but smaller bits instead)

Edited by eybic on Friday 5th August 11:49

parabolica

Original Poster:

7,030 posts

215 months

Friday 5th August 2016
quotequote all
eybic said:
I'd be very surprised if they replace it at no cost to you unless they can see an obvious defect. It will be considered the same as a side window/ windscreen in that it's probably not covered under warranty unless it's a known issue.

What should the OP be compensated for? Nobody was injured and I don't think he's suffered any losses (apart from the sunroof)
Agree on all counts; not looking for compo (they offered a courtesy car but I turned it down as I need a permit for parking where I live and I don't need to use my car for anything anytime soon) and they came back saying what I figured they might - no obvs defect therefore pay up to have it fixed. I've no way to prove what caused it so just one of those things.

The 12 month warranty doesn't include glass (which I'm pretty sure would include the sunroof even though it's more than just glass - but it's the glass part that's shattered) and I ran some ins quotes to see what would happen if I made a claim and they doubled my annual. So time to pay up :-| the things we do for nice cars.

eybic

9,212 posts

205 months

Friday 5th August 2016
quotequote all
parabolica said:
Agree on all counts; not looking for compo (they offered a courtesy car but I turned it down as I need a permit for parking where I live and I don't need to use my car for anything anytime soon) and they came back saying what I figured they might - no obvs defect therefore pay up to have it fixed. I've no way to prove what caused it so just one of those things.

The 12 month warranty doesn't include glass (which I'm pretty sure would include the sunroof even though it's more than just glass - but it's the glass part that's shattered) and I ran some ins quotes to see what would happen if I made a claim and they doubled my annual. So time to pay up :-| the things we do for nice cars.
'Tis a shame and not really anything you can do about it unfortunately. If the frame was obviously bent then you could pass it back to BMW but I think it needs chalking up as "one of those things" that life throws our way.