Buying Advice changing from 330D
Buying Advice changing from 330D
Author
Discussion

xrrr

Original Poster:

440 posts

197 months

Saturday 6th August 2016
quotequote all
I have a dilemma and so I would like to quiz the collective to see if it helps me make a decision.

I have a 2014 330D saloon which is leased via work and due for renewal in April 2017. I need to make a new car selection by the end of December this year so I need to start the thinking process now :-)

My circumstances have changed (+1 to the family) since I ordered the 330D and now I need to upsize the car but keep the cost roughly the same (or cheaper). I want to stick with BMW largely because you get more for your money on the company scheme with BMW and because I have an affinity with the brand. Also, because of the lack of hassle and fixed cost I am highly likely to stay in the company scheme rather than take the cash and go for a private buy.

My short list is:

  • Another 330D saloon - we want something bigger though as, even though there are only the 3 of us, it could have more interior space
  • 320D Touring - more of the same but with more space, need to get the smaller engine for cost/tax purposes because of the CO2
  • X3 2.0D - this was winning for quite some time until I realised that it is getting end of life and new one will be out in Sept 2017. This fact has put me off somewhat.
  • X1 2.0D - gets great reviews, questions whether the X3 is worth the extra money for little extra and is sometimes compared with a 3er touring replacement. But there is something about the X1 that I am not comfortable with - Either because the X1 is essentially the bottom of the range BMW SUV or maybe it is a bit of a girly looking car?
  • As a curveball, despite the BMW comment above, a mate of mine has been raving about the Macan he has just ordered. I would have to try and find a used one for circa £40-45k if I had a Macan and then have the insurance, tyres, VED cost on top. The Macan is not a slam dunk because of the cost. It is likely to be significantly more expensive per month and so is probably more fantasy than reality.
  • One final option is to extend the 330D lease for a year (not yet checked if that is possible) and see what the new 2017 X3 is like and then repeat this exercise in a year.
5 series and X5 ruled out due to cost and size. X4 ruled out cos it is fugly.

So that is my dilemma. I know it is a first world problem, but has anyone had a similar dilemma and what did you do?

I am also interested in hearing from people who swapped a 3er for an X1 or X3 this year. Happy with the swap? Is the X1 too girly now you have it?