I love RFTs - am I weird?
Discussion
There is many a thread in this section of the PH forum which exorts owners and buyers of BMWs to "ditch the runflats".
So when I picked up my 2011 X5 with 21inch wheels and runflat tyres (325/30 on the rear) a little over a week ago, my first car with runflats, I was expecting to be less than impressed.
But I love it. I love the ride, over country roads, speed bumps in London, whatever is thrown at it - and the car handles fantastically well.
Am I weird? What am I not feeling that everyone else is feeling?
So when I picked up my 2011 X5 with 21inch wheels and runflat tyres (325/30 on the rear) a little over a week ago, my first car with runflats, I was expecting to be less than impressed.
But I love it. I love the ride, over country roads, speed bumps in London, whatever is thrown at it - and the car handles fantastically well.
Am I weird? What am I not feeling that everyone else is feeling?
Edited by jboy72 on Monday 8th August 13:48
I dislike them with a passion and I just think we all see things differently that's all, it transformed the ride/handling on the 640d on 20" rims when I put normal tyres on it when compared to the run flats.
I think sometimes you just get used to things and I was a passenger in a friends Land Rover Discovery the other week and I was amazed how lovely the ride was and it made me realise how poor BMW's ride is.
I think sometimes you just get used to things and I was a passenger in a friends Land Rover Discovery the other week and I was amazed how lovely the ride was and it made me realise how poor BMW's ride is.
smashy said:
It would certainly be interesting to try 4 non runflats all round.Maybe the fact that my other car is a 15 year old Alfa Romeo 156 with Veloce suspension also makes me a little more tolerant of ride imperfections...!
jboy72 said:
It would certainly be interesting to try 4 non runflats all round.
Maybe the fact that my other car is a 15 year old Alfa Romeo 156 with Veloce suspension also makes me a little more tolerant of ride imperfections...!
Jboy im in a dilemma to be honest. My F30 has acs shocks and springs they recco michelin sports non runflat and since been on they actually feel like I have rubber between me and the road.I do 800 miles a week and had them filled with ultraseal and in fact that recently saved me ,nail on corner and the tyre acted like a run flat allowed me to get home.Maybe the fact that my other car is a 15 year old Alfa Romeo 156 with Veloce suspension also makes me a little more tolerant of ride imperfections...!
That ultraseal thing is not an option anymore too far way. I will need fronts soon and I am going to try Bridgestones latest Run Flats called drive guard a lot softer wall than previous, a 4th generation I guess. I will see how they go,
Funnily enough, I just bought the same car at the weekend although with 20" wheels and non-run flat tyres. It's AUC, they pointed them out but other than that, they haven't alluded to the fact that this means the alloy wheels may not be covered under warranty (apparently).
Having driven a 2011 X5 30d last weekend with RFT and my X5 40d with normal tyres back to back, there's not a HUGE amount of difference but it's there. Mine is a touch softer on initial turn in but feels more planted over ruts and imperfections through the corner; definitely absorbs bumps more dynamically around town and avoids that crashy jolt that goes hand in hand with RFTs.
The tyres on the 333Ms are expensive regardless so I guess it really comes down to personal choice.
Having driven a 2011 X5 30d last weekend with RFT and my X5 40d with normal tyres back to back, there's not a HUGE amount of difference but it's there. Mine is a touch softer on initial turn in but feels more planted over ruts and imperfections through the corner; definitely absorbs bumps more dynamically around town and avoids that crashy jolt that goes hand in hand with RFTs.
The tyres on the 333Ms are expensive regardless so I guess it really comes down to personal choice.
I don't mind RFTs on my 430d. However, I do think they make the car/handling a bit jittery if that makes sense. The safety benefits are welcomed especially that my wife borrows my car a lot and has two kids as cargo. I know she won't have to pull over on a dodgy hard shoulder and there's no chance of an exploding flat (though that's not common with normal tyres either)
I think they are brilliant.
I think people really exaggeate the difference because the majority said it many moons ago when the 1st gen of run flats were out which were of course not that great.
Since then they have moved forward leaps and bounds and the difference is minimal at best.
However many have decided to jump on the bang wagon of the past and some how feel a HUUUGE difference.
I would love to see a test done on the same road, same car, Non RFT and RFT. I am sure people would really really struggle to tell.
I think people really exaggeate the difference because the majority said it many moons ago when the 1st gen of run flats were out which were of course not that great.
Since then they have moved forward leaps and bounds and the difference is minimal at best.
However many have decided to jump on the bang wagon of the past and some how feel a HUUUGE difference.
I would love to see a test done on the same road, same car, Non RFT and RFT. I am sure people would really really struggle to tell.
Monkeylegend said:
You might not like the cost of like for like replacements quite so much.
Indeed not - 285 each for the rears I think. The 'same' non runflats though are 245, not a great differential. Having said that there is a non runflat by Accelera for 95. As the fronts are cheaper, I could replace all tyres with Accelera non runflats for only about 70 more than the cost of one runflat rear tyre. The Stiglet said:
Funnily enough, I just bought the same car at the weekend although with 20" wheels and non-run flat tyres. It's AUC, they pointed them out but other than that, they haven't alluded to the fact that this means the alloy wheels may not be covered under warranty (apparently).
Having driven a 2011 X5 30d last weekend with RFT and my X5 40d with normal tyres back to back, there's not a HUGE amount of difference but it's there. Mine is a touch softer on initial turn in but feels more planted over ruts and imperfections through the corner; definitely absorbs bumps more dynamically around town and avoids that crashy jolt that goes hand in hand with RFTs.
The tyres on the 333Ms are expensive regardless so I guess it really comes down to personal choice.
I didn't try a 30d - did you find the 40d noticeably poker or just a little brisker?Having driven a 2011 X5 30d last weekend with RFT and my X5 40d with normal tyres back to back, there's not a HUGE amount of difference but it's there. Mine is a touch softer on initial turn in but feels more planted over ruts and imperfections through the corner; definitely absorbs bumps more dynamically around town and avoids that crashy jolt that goes hand in hand with RFTs.
The tyres on the 333Ms are expensive regardless so I guess it really comes down to personal choice.
My e46 330d sport felt pretty crashy and tramlined very badly and that was with non runflats, the 40d doesn't really feel that different over holes and is far better composed in corners with more steering feel and less tramlining...
jboy72 said:
I didn't try a 30d - did you find the 40d noticeably poker or just a little brisker?
My e46 330d sport felt pretty crashy and tramlined very badly and that was with non runflats, the 40d doesn't really feel that different over holes and is far better composed in corners with more steering feel and less tramlining...
I think the 40d is perkier off the line and a bit smoother without having to press the accelerator as hard. I'm sure the extra HP will be more evident as the speed and wind resistance increase but I was certainly impressed with the 30d's performance given the disparity in power. My e46 330d sport felt pretty crashy and tramlined very badly and that was with non runflats, the 40d doesn't really feel that different over holes and is far better composed in corners with more steering feel and less tramlining...
We used to own an e46 330ci sport and that tramlined badly too but was exciting back in the day
I just got rid of an F10 535d M Sport for the X5 40d M Sport and I think the X5 drives better and I much prefer it...
The Stiglet said:
I think the 40d is perkier off the line and a bit smoother without having to press the accelerator as hard. I'm sure the extra HP will be more evident as the speed and wind resistance increase but I was certainly impressed with the 30d's performance given the disparity in power.
We used to own an e46 330ci sport and that tramlined badly too but was exciting back in the day
I just got rid of an F10 535d M Sport for the X5 40d M Sport and I think the X5 drives better and I much prefer it...
Interesting - an F10 530d or 535d coupled with a £2k Grand Voyager to fulfil 7 seat duties was my other option....We used to own an e46 330ci sport and that tramlined badly too but was exciting back in the day
I just got rid of an F10 535d M Sport for the X5 40d M Sport and I think the X5 drives better and I much prefer it...
My next door neighbours x6 30d stolen replaced with 40d version as an F30 30d owner asked him if there was much difference he said it felt "whizzier" make of that what you will. As a high mileage bod I dont think id ever go 335d over my 30d because i believe there is quite a difference MPG wise and that 30d in sport and lever to the left has as much power as you could ever use in real life I got out of an Audi RS7 a couple of weeks ago (550bhp) it was just too much, ridiculous really on our roads a relief to get back in my saddle
Back on topic these are the run flats im going to try
http://www.tyrereviews.co.uk/Article/Bridgestone-D...
Back on topic these are the run flats im going to try
http://www.tyrereviews.co.uk/Article/Bridgestone-D...
Edited by smashy on Tuesday 9th August 14:02
smashy said:
My next door neighbours x6 30d stolen replaced with 40d version as an F30 30d owner asked him if there was much difference he said it felt "whizzier" make of that what you will. As a high mileage bod I dont think id ever go 335d over my 30d because i believe there is quite a difference MPG wise and that 30d in sport and lever to the left has as much power as you could ever use in real life I got out of an Audi RS7 a couple of weeks ago (550bhp) it was just too much, ridiculous really on our roads a relief to get back in my saddle
I actually also looked at an F31 330d x drive. I realise that this makes me seem very fickle but really I was just looking for a nice non-silver BMW with light leather and the 8 speed auto and as many toys as I could find. I did not drive it, but I found one and it was lovely - black sapphire, beige leather, M performance package, 2.5 years old, Harman Kardon, sunroof. Before you ask it did have adaptive as well! A far more sensible choice than a 5 year old X5 I have no doubt. I have a penchant for old school saloons though and so rather than consign myself to an old 7 seater in the end I decided to spend more money on the x5 and leave myself with change for a nice e46 330i or something like that...We recently tried a new BMW X1 for my wife. Test drove one for a day with 18s and non-RF tyres (standard on 18s). Absolutely fine.
Then reserved unseen a slightly used one with 19s and standard RF tyres. Went to buy it and... absolutely horrid. Ruined the ride completely and we both independently reached this conclusion. Deposit refunded.
I'd tried a 2 series a few years back with another awful ride. Back at the showroom the BMW salesman said "Ah... that'll be the run flats."
Picked up her brand new X1 today. On 18s and normal tyres. Perfect!
Then reserved unseen a slightly used one with 19s and standard RF tyres. Went to buy it and... absolutely horrid. Ruined the ride completely and we both independently reached this conclusion. Deposit refunded.
I'd tried a 2 series a few years back with another awful ride. Back at the showroom the BMW salesman said "Ah... that'll be the run flats."
Picked up her brand new X1 today. On 18s and normal tyres. Perfect!
I've ditched the run flats on my F11 (with 17" wheels and adaptive drive) as even in comfort mode bumps would come crashing through the cabin. It's much better on normal tyres. On the flip side I drove a 320d M Sport the other day on 18" run flats and was very impressed with the lack of crash's and bangs over bumps and it felt very solid and well damped, however the ride was very choppy and it was not something I would like to make a long journey in.
jboy72 said:
I actually also looked at an F31 330d x drive. I realise that this makes me seem very fickle but really I was just looking for a nice non-silver BMW with light leather and the 8 speed auto and as many toys as I could find. I did not drive it, but I found one and it was lovely - black sapphire, beige leather, M performance package, 2.5 years old, Harman Kardon, sunroof. Before you ask it did have adaptive as well! A far more sensible choice than a 5 year old X5 I have no doubt. I have a penchant for old school saloons though and so rather than consign myself to an old 7 seater in the end I decided to spend more money on the x5 and leave myself with change for a nice e46 330i or something like that...
My father has a well specced F31 330d M Sport and I had the F10 535d M Sport so I've had a good opportunity to compare them. F31
Much louder road noise from the tyres, probably because it's a touring. Some extra wind noise too
More nimble, smaller, nicer steering feel
Supportive/tight seats depending on your preference
Engine sounds a bit rattly at low RPM
Good performance, particularly in Sport mode
Cabin looks modern but interior is a bit plasticy
F10
Quieter, more refined, far superior interior
More comfortable, larger, less dynamic - rolls more, I personally think it's too big
Offset pedals make the driving position awkward, larger sport steering wheel is bus like.
Engine is smoother, has noticeably more torque from low revs, sounds better
Good performance
Whilst both have paddles, I think the 8 speed has too many gears to play with in the narrow power bands. I wouldn't call either 'fun'.
Edited by The Stiglet on Wednesday 10th August 13:35
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


