Alloy Wheel corrosion
Alloy Wheel corrosion
Author
Discussion

shep1001

Original Poster:

4,620 posts

220 months

Friday 2nd September 2016
quotequote all
I will be on my third set of wheels next week on my F10 5 series Lux, all 4 wheels have had to be replaced twice already in the last 20 months as they have corroded round the centre cap. Is this a known BMW fault with this style of wheel? The garage says not but I have a suspicion they are pulling my chain.




Its got a coolant leak too that they can't find, 1.5 litres lost in the last 3 months/6k miles. They are adamant they have checked it and can't find a leak anywhere, their standpoint is...... maybe it was not topped up right in the first place. Rubbish answer as they had to replace a hose that was rubbing on the alternator pulley back in June & I checked it was full several times after they had done the work to make sure it was still not leaking from somewhere.

Edited by shep1001 on Friday 2nd September 18:30

pattyg

1,385 posts

258 months

Saturday 3rd September 2016
quotequote all
Looks like someone has tried to pinch your centre caps.

V8A*ndy

3,703 posts

222 months

Saturday 3rd September 2016
quotequote all
pattyg said:
Looks like someone has tried to pinch your centre caps.
That happened to my missus. The thieving little scamps couldn't get the caps of but took the Msport badges.

However by the look of the wheel stud there has been some fairly heavy duty wheel cleaner going on there.

It gets trapped behind/around the center caps and begins to corrode.

MrC986

3,755 posts

222 months

Saturday 3rd September 2016
quotequote all
If you use a wheel cleaner its likely the cleaner will at some point start to eat the finish around the centre/hub - it's also a particular issue if you have a 3rd party cleaning the car who use unknown chemicals. Diamond cut wheels are more prone to wheel cleaning solutions than normal painted wheels as the slightest blemish to the clear coat will be attacked by the cleaning solution.

mark.c

1,090 posts

211 months

Saturday 3rd September 2016
quotequote all
Diamond cut, nature of the beast in my experience. Have them on the family bus C-Class, got fed up in the end and had them powder coated.

Elliot2000

786 posts

207 months

Sunday 4th September 2016
quotequote all
Yeh I would say wheel acid when cleaning - generally gets sprayed on and left for a few minutes and it seeps behind the centre cap, then when it's rinsed off at the end there is still a bit of acid left behind the cap and it seeps back out and eats away at the lacquer. They have modified all the wheel hubs on the latest cars to be more bowl shaped behind the cap to help stop any liquid sitting behind there. I think u can buy the later hub 'bowls' and just pop it on when the wheels removed

Coolant leak which they can't find? Diesel? The probably the egr cooler unit - they leak internally slowly and then just burn it off in the engine. Normally not a big enough leak to cause any white smoke from the exhaust

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Sunday 4th September 2016
quotequote all
Elliot2000 said:
Yeh I would say wheel acid when cleaning - generally gets sprayed on and left for a few minutes and it seeps behind the centre cap, then when it's rinsed off at the end there is still a bit of acid left behind the cap and it seeps back out and eats away at the lacquer. They have modified all the wheel hubs on the latest cars to be more bowl shaped behind the cap to help stop any liquid sitting behind there. I think u can buy the later hub 'bowls' and just pop it on when the wheels removed

Coolant leak which they can't find? Diesel? The probably the egr cooler unit - they leak internally slowly and then just burn it off in the engine. Normally not a big enough leak to cause any white smoke from the exhaust
We've never used wheel acid on any diamond cut alloys that we've had on cars and invariably they do start to "go" around the centre caps.

Chances are the laquer is little thinner round there and the slight movement of the centre cap breaks the surface of the lacquer. Once thats done, then road dirt, road salt, corrosive brake dust and water penetrates and allows the alloy to oxidise on the surface. Power hoses also dont help either.

The big killer of diamond cut wheels in the uk is road salt during the winter and the use of power hoses on them.

Avoiding the use of power hoses on the wheels, wheel acid, keeping the alloys well washed with a good wash / wax and keeping them well polished with alloy wheel polish will help prevent problems

shep1001

Original Poster:

4,620 posts

220 months

Sunday 4th September 2016
quotequote all
Elliot2000 said:
Yeh I would say wheel acid when cleaning - generally gets sprayed on and left for a few minutes and it seeps behind the centre cap, then when it's rinsed off at the end there is still a bit of acid left behind the cap and it seeps back out and eats away at the lacquer. They have modified all the wheel hubs on the latest cars to be more bowl shaped behind the cap to help stop any liquid sitting behind there. I think u can buy the later hub 'bowls' and just pop it on when the wheels removed

Coolant leak which they can't find? Diesel? The probably the egr cooler unit - they leak internally slowly and then just burn it off in the engine. Normally not a big enough leak to cause any white smoke from the exhaust
Thanks for this & yes it is a diesel. Don't use a wheel cleaner, I sealed the wheels when they were new so they are easy to clean but I do use a pressure washer. It has taken about 3 months/7k for the coolant problem to occur. I will mention it when it goes in for its new wheels & door handles next week

Sheepshanks

41,377 posts

150 months

Sunday 4th September 2016
quotequote all
pattyg said:
Looks like someone has tried to pinch your centre caps.
That's what VW said for the same damage on the ridiculous diamond cut wheels on daughter's cheapy Golf. Unlikely, I think - if someone had wanted them they'd be gone, and there was no damage to the centre caps themselves.

At least BMW changed them on the OPs car - I hit a complete brick wall with the dealer and VW UK.

ashway

533 posts

196 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
shep1001 said:
I will be on my third set of wheels next week on my F10 5 series Lux, all 4 wheels have had to be replaced twice already in the last 20 months as they have corroded round the centre cap. Is this a known BMW fault with this style of wheel? The garage says not but I have a suspicion they are pulling my chain.
You've answered your own question, it is a known issue with diamond cut wheels, the fact they've replaced them twice already confirms this. Had exactly the same on my E70 X5 all 4 wheels swapped twice during my ownership, no questions asked