Should I extend the warranty....
Should I extend the warranty....
Author
Discussion

gizard

Original Poster:

2,272 posts

314 months

Monday 12th September 2016
quotequote all
Just paid off the final payment on my 3 year old 535d and had the end of warranty check - car has only done 20k and has been 100% - except the changed the aircon compressor at the end of warranty check - didn't notice it not working but there we go.

I am wondering whether I should extend the warranty for a further year or on a monthly basis and whether to have the option of a claim excess of either 100 or 250 to make the cost of warranty less. I guess what I am really asking is should I expect at issues in the near future that would be requiring a decent warranty cover?

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Monday 12th September 2016
quotequote all
I don't think the F10 is particularly unreliable but it is sufficiently complex that my personal policy is to always run it with the warranty to continue to give it that 'new car' peace of mind that anything that happens is just sorted.

It's about £850 with a £100r excess including about £100 worth of breakdown cover. I think this is just about acceptable - if it gets much more expensive it begins to price itself out of contention.

You could reduce the price by opting out of the Emergency Service cover but IMHO that aspect is very well priced against the equivalent AA/RAC cover given it includes full onward travel, hotels, hire cars, etc.

northwest monkey

6,370 posts

220 months

Monday 12th September 2016
quotequote all
Depends how risk averse you are really and only you can answer that.

How would you feel if the ABS module failed next July & landed you with a bill for £2k?

gizard

Original Poster:

2,272 posts

314 months

Monday 12th September 2016
quotequote all
Well I guess I would be very annoyed if I had a 2k bill in a years time - but this is the gamble isn't it!

I have quoted:
952 a year with 0 excess or 97.47 a month
759 a year with 100 excess or 78.37 a month
579 a year with 250 excess or 62.28 a month...

I am thinking I will do something but the question is which option to go for....

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Monday 12th September 2016
quotequote all
Is that inclusive of Emergency Service or without?

You'd need to make three claims for the £0 excess to be materially cheaper than the £100 excess option, so that seems like the sweet spot to me.

gizard

Original Poster:

2,272 posts

314 months

Monday 12th September 2016
quotequote all
Fox- said:
Is that inclusive of Emergency Service or without?

You'd need to make three claims for the £0 excess to be materially cheaper than the £100 excess option, so that seems like the sweet spot to me.
Ahh - can't remember I have lost the bit of paper with the detail regarding break down - but I would not be needing it as a do have a similar policy with my bank account - so no point in paying for both!

Osinjak

5,453 posts

152 months

Monday 12th September 2016
quotequote all
I paid for two years worth of warranty on my old 335d which cost nearly £1000 and not a thing went wrong with it. Still, peace of mind and all that.

PhilRS

264 posts

262 months

Tuesday 13th September 2016
quotequote all
No brainer AFAIK, BMW parts and labour costs (plus peace of mind) make these insurances look cheap.

On my 640d, headlight clusters became porous, one rear shock (adaptive susp) failed, a water coolant leak developed, self-parking needed recalibration, and so forth... I let you imagine the total costs without extended warranty...


Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Tuesday 13th September 2016
quotequote all
Osinjak said:
I paid for two years worth of warranty on my old 335d which cost nearly £1000 and not a thing went wrong with it. Still, peace of mind and all that.
It's quite irritating how much cheaper the 3 Series warranty is than the 5 Series warranty when you consider all the mechanical bits that go wrong are the same parts!

xjay1337

15,966 posts

149 months

Tuesday 13th September 2016
quotequote all
Sods law is though, that while your 335d was flawless this poor chaps 535d would implode in about 2 months if he didn't have the warranty.

You're basically insuring anything going wrong on the car for £750ish, seems well worth it to me, although for 1 year's warranty on a 20k car it does seem a little steep.

I would go with the £100 excess.

gizard

Original Poster:

2,272 posts

314 months

Tuesday 13th September 2016
quotequote all
went for the 759 option with 100 excess.... it would have been 840 with roadside assistance. Thanks for the replies and advice. Hope it is worth it - but wait I hope it isn't!!!! if you know what I mean... it is an insurance policy at the end of the day.

Osinjak

5,453 posts

152 months

Tuesday 13th September 2016
quotequote all
xjay1337 said:
Sods law is though, that while your 335d was flawless this poor chaps 535d would implode in about 2 months if he didn't have the warranty.
So true!

tonymor

1,554 posts

203 months

Tuesday 13th September 2016
quotequote all
I decided to extend the warranty on my E 89 zed 4. I've used warranty direct before but their quote was double the bmw one amazingly so that was an easy choice . Again what price peace of mind ?

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 13th September 2016
quotequote all
My 530D will be three next March and will have done about 30/32K miles. I won't be taking out a warranty for the 4th year after which I'll be replacing it.

Wife's Z4, bought new in 2008, had a failure of the ABS module at 26K miles in 2014. We never bothered with extended warranty for that either. The bill was £2300 but BMW contributed 70%.

So I figure that if I get a problem in the 530's 4th year it won't be too pricy unless we're very unfortunate.

Of course, the mileage and 'lifestyle' of the car makes a difference.


gizard

Original Poster:

2,272 posts

314 months

Tuesday 13th September 2016
quotequote all
Well that's another view as well and looks like you did well to get such a reduction on the ABS etc. My cars do have a good life and live in a garage when they are not being used, but sadly I don't think this would help much preventing anything expensive going wrong unless I lived in an extreme climate but I don't wink

xjay1337

15,966 posts

149 months

Tuesday 13th September 2016
quotequote all
I think things are down to luck.

I abuse my current car (in a fair way when it's up to temp etc) and as such service it often. Never broken down or given me any troubles.

My last car was literally babied everywhere and had so many issues with reliability and bits failing that while I did eventually get it running spot on, I sold it eventually.

I think it is pure luck of the draw but in this day and age, huge engine failures are quite uncommon and it tends to be niggly electrical issues.
If you are very hands on and don't mind doing your own work (for example if you are handy with spanners and have your own OEM type diagnostic equipment) you'll probably manage on your own.
But I suspect as cars get more complex the issue isn't so much the labour but often the price of components on their own.

I am not sure about BMW but early Golf's had common ABS failure. Originally was £1200 to repair (replacement unit OEM).
But as it was common aftermarket suppliers soon brought it down and now you can get a repair kit and take it to any decent garage and it will cost you £350 all inclusive to be fixed.
So I'm sure costs will come down.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 13th September 2016
quotequote all
gizard said:
Well that's another view as well and looks like you did well to get such a reduction on the ABS etc. My cars do have a good life and live in a garage when they are not being used, but sadly I don't think this would help much preventing anything expensive going wrong unless I lived in an extreme climate but I don't wink

I don't think it's unusual to get a significant contribution on a major fault in a 5/6 year old car as long as there's a FBMWSH and the mileage is reasonable. Wear and tear items excepted, of course.