Running an M135i out of warranty
Running an M135i out of warranty
Author
Discussion

PTF

Original Poster:

4,456 posts

255 months

Wednesday 21st September 2016
quotequote all
Been offered an M135i through a friend-of-a-friend. It's a great spec and it's tempting me away from my E91 325d that i absolutely love. So that's up for sale to see what interest i get.

I had a manual M135i for a couple of years when the cheap lease deals were around. I only had one issue which was the infamous fan/limp-mode issue, which happened a few times. I never bothered getting it in to be sorted. I remember thinking that i'd never have anything like that without the peace of mind of a good warranty. So the 325d is currently 1 year through a 3 yr warranty.

The car i've been offered is an automatic. I've heard these can have issues with some odd noises?

Other than that, there have been a few occasions of engines going POP, but these seem to be very rare.

BMW seem to do warranties at about £500/year comprehensive without breakdown cover. Would it be insane to just plonk the £500 per year in a war chest and hope for the best!??

Your thoughts welcome!!

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Wednesday 21st September 2016
quotequote all
PTF said:
Been offered an M135i through a friend-of-a-friend. It's a great spec and it's tempting me away from my E91 325d that i absolutely love. So that's up for sale to see what interest i get.

I had a manual M135i for a couple of years when the cheap lease deals were around. I only had one issue which was the infamous fan/limp-mode issue, which happened a few times. I never bothered getting it in to be sorted. I remember thinking that i'd never have anything like that without the peace of mind of a good warranty. So the 325d is currently 1 year through a 3 yr warranty.

The car i've been offered is an automatic. I've heard these can have issues with some odd noises?

Other than that, there have been a few occasions of engines going POP, but these seem to be very rare.

BMW seem to do warranties at about £500/year comprehensive without breakdown cover. Would it be insane to just plonk the £500 per year in a war chest and hope for the best!??

Your thoughts welcome!!
it wouldn't be insane, if it's a good clean car with reasonable mileage then there are decent odds that nothing will break other than wear and tear which 'aint covered anyways.

However, if something does go wrong, 500£ may not cover it. On my 335i, which was otherwise solid I still had injectors go, not exactly major and yet I've read on the forums of others who weren't under warranty paid over 1,000£ for the job!

If it were me I'd look to pay about 46-56£ p/month with breakdown cover for the BMW warranty; this is based on a quote for a 3.5 year old M135i with 100 or 250 excess. <60k miles

I'd rather lose this fixed cost monthly than get hit with a big bill. That's the way my finances work.

One other thought, if you delete the BMW breakdown cover option, are you sure another breakdown cover provider will take your car to a BMW Main Dealer in the event it can't be driven, or will they just take it to the nearest suitable garage?

If they don't take it to BMW, then I believe you'd have to get it to BMW yourself or pay the repair bill yourself. In my opinion, if getting a warranty add breakdown cover.














PTF

Original Poster:

4,456 posts

255 months

Wednesday 21st September 2016
quotequote all
Smuler said:
it wouldn't be insane, if it's a good clean car with reasonable mileage then there are decent odds that nothing will break other than wear and tear which 'aint covered anyways.

However, if something does go wrong, 500£ may not cover it. On my 335i, which was otherwise solid I still had injectors go, not exactly major and yet I've read on the forums of others who weren't under warranty paid over 1,000£ for the job!

If it were me I'd look to pay about 46-56£ p/month with breakdown cover for the BMW warranty; this is based on a quote for a 3.5 year old M135i with 100 or 250 excess. <60k miles

I'd rather lose this fixed cost monthly than get hit with a big bill. That's the way my finances work.

One other thought, if you delete the BMW breakdown cover option, are you sure another breakdown cover provider will take your car to a BMW Main Dealer in the event it can't be driven, or will they just take it to the nearest suitable garage?

If they don't take it to BMW, then I believe you'd have to get it to BMW yourself or pay the repair bill yourself. In my opinion, if getting a warranty add breakdown cover.
Thanks. That does make sense about the breakdown cover.

Dannbodge

2,393 posts

152 months

Wednesday 21st September 2016
quotequote all
Most breakdown places would take you where you want to go.
They can't force you to use a garage of their choosing.

I've got extended warranty on my 335i at a cost of £50 a month. I'm yet to make a claim but I will be getting new turbos and waterpump/thermostat on it at some point.

The M135i should be pretty reliable as it's N55 not N54 and iirc they are quite reliable.

I was unfortunate as to having to replace the injectors on mine before my warranty kicked in and left me with a £1300 parts bill

PTF

Original Poster:

4,456 posts

255 months

Wednesday 21st September 2016
quotequote all
I managed to get the 3 year warranty on my 325d for about £600 in total. So paying £50/month for it is going to sting a little

It's a good warranty too. They've spent nearly a grand putting in a whole new nav/infotainment system because the CD/DVD drive was broken!

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Wednesday 21st September 2016
quotequote all
Dannbodge said:
Most breakdown places would take you where you want to go.
They can't force you to use a garage of their choosing.

I've got extended warranty on my 335i at a cost of £50 a month. I'm yet to make a claim but I will be getting new turbos and waterpump/thermostat on it at some point.

The M135i should be pretty reliable as it's N55 not N54 and iirc they are quite reliable.

I was unfortunate as to having to replace the injectors on mine before my warranty kicked in and left me with a £1300 parts bill
My understanding of the terms and conditions of breakdown companies is that, first of all, they will try and repair at roadside and secondly try and effect a local repair; it's when these options are not successful (or not plausible in the first place) that they will take you to any destination you want, so yes your preferred BMW garage.

I did't know that if you tell the breakdown company you have a BMW warranty they'll forego the attempt to repair at roadside and/ or locally and go straight to relay or whatever the option is called. Although ironically, that could be a disadvantage as maybe they could have repaired at roadside and without using any parts at all! Just seems messy having a warranty and not having breakdown cover by BMW too.












Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Wednesday 21st September 2016
quotequote all
Smuler said:
it wouldn't be insane, if it's a good clean car with reasonable mileage then there are decent odds that nothing will break other than wear and tear which 'aint covered anyways.
Failure of covered parts due to wear and tear is included in the comprehensive warranty.


Smuler said:
One other thought, if you delete the BMW breakdown cover option, are you sure another breakdown cover provider will take your car to a BMW Main Dealer in the event it can't be driven, or will they just take it to the nearest suitable garage?

If they don't take it to BMW, then I believe you'd have to get it to BMW yourself or pay the repair bill yourself. In my opinion, if getting a warranty add breakdown cover.
IF you take the warranty without Emergency Service you still get warranty assist - where they will recover you only to the nearest franchised dealer.

nw942

469 posts

136 months

Wednesday 21st September 2016
quotequote all

What are you trying to protect yourself against? If it's just big items then upping the excess to £250 is £30pm without breakdown cover.

When I took out my warranty it had lapsed, which meant I paid more for the first year or so. About eleven months in I phoned to 'renew' and it came down by £23 (£117 -> £94 IIRC), which is 20%.

As Fox- said, they will take your car to the nearest BMW dealer even without the emergency service.

sp222

203 posts

180 months

Thursday 22nd September 2016
quotequote all
I'm not normally a fan of extended warranties, but on my 135i I extended it when it was 3 years old last October.

In January I noticed the steering was suddenly really heavy and took it in - needed a new steering column - I never saw an invoice but read on baby bmw that someone else with the same issue would have had a £2k bill.

The only issue was that it took bloody ages to fix - I was mostly travelling though so I didn't bother with the 116d they offered me for courtesy ;-)

5678

6,146 posts

258 months

Thursday 22nd September 2016
quotequote all
BMW extended warranty is excellent from my experience, for the cost I think it's a no brainer.

Re: M135i, some people report issues with the gearbox. Some seem to get replaced, others just put up with it (minor whine in low gears and reverse.)
I've not read anything on BabyBMW about them actually failing though.