Suspension difference between E91 and E92
Suspension difference between E91 and E92
Author
Discussion

PTF

Original Poster:

4,456 posts

255 months

Wednesday 12th October 2016
quotequote all
Something is puzzling me about my recent change of E9X from E91 to E92 and the difference between the ride and handling of both cars. They are/were both LCI models. E91 was 2009. E92 is 2010.

Let's start with the 325d E91. It was an SE spec car without sports suspension option, on 17" non-staggered wheels. When i got it it was on conti run-flats and was appalling to drive. It tramlined everywhere to the point of being dangerous on the inside lane of the A1 where it would leap from left to right and back again across the channels cut by the lorries. The ride was "jiggly" - it transmitted every little ripple in the road up through the cabin, where it didn't meet with much damping. A bumpy back road would really have it dancing around all over the place.

I ditched the run-flats and opted for michelin pilot sport 4s. What a revelation! The tramlining had gone and the edge was taken off the "jiggly" ride. It still felt like it was over-sprung and under-damped IMO, but at least it didn't make me shout at it when i had the steering wheel yanked left/right.

So now i've moved onto a 325i E92. Again, it's SE spec, but with a few M-sport options such as heated elec sports seats (yum), black exterior trim and, crucially, 18" staggered wheels. I put a deposit on it without seeing it or driving it, but i had used the VIN to check the spec. I couldn't see sports suspension as an option. It is on michelin pilot sport 3 run-flats.

I fully expected this to be like the E91, but WORSE. I expected tramlining again, along with an even more "jiggly" ride thanks to the lower profile tyres.

But to my complete shock, it's better, MUCH better! It doesn't tramline at all, not even a little bit. There is very little harshness coming through the cabin and i'd say the "jiggly" factor is definitely there a little bit, but not as bad as the E91 was on those conti run-flats.

But what's really, really noticable is the damping. It's on another level completely and reminds me of my Impreza WRX for being able to hit a series of rolling bumps in the road and have the car soak them up without rebounding all over the place.

So what's the reason for this?

Why is the harshness less bad on 18" wheels with michelin run flats compared to 17" wheels on conti run flats? In fact it's on a par, if not better than when i had the E91 on PS4s.

And why is the damping so noticeably better on the E92 compared to the E91?

Confused!

f1nn

2,694 posts

223 months

Wednesday 12th October 2016
quotequote all
I'm not sure, but my experience is similar.

I went from a E90 330D Msport on 18"s with non run flats, to an E92 335I SE (I'm pretty sure these still use Msport spec suspension) with 19's and run flats and I would say the ride is at least as comfortable, if not more so.

That's relative of course, as I'm yet to drive an E9x platform car that's rides properly.

Age and condition of dampers will play a part of course, perhaps maybe the E92 is a tad stiffer in structure? Possibly the suspension was designed with run flats taken into account?

Either way, I'm not in the desperate hurry to ditch the run flats that everyone else seems to be.

PTF

Original Poster:

4,456 posts

255 months

Wednesday 12th October 2016
quotequote all
f1nn said:
I'm not sure, but my experience is similar.

I went from a E90 330D Msport on 18"s with non run flats, to an E92 335I SE (I'm pretty sure these still use Msport spec suspension) with 19's and run flats and I would say the ride is at least as comfortable, if not more so.

That's relative of course, as I'm yet to drive an E9x platform car that's rides properly.

Age and condition of dampers will play a part of course, perhaps maybe the E92 is a tad stiffer in structure? Possibly the suspension was designed with run flats taken into account?

Either way, I'm not in the desperate hurry to ditch the run flats that everyone else seems to be.
Yep

Ditching the run flats on the E91 was essential. It was downright dangerous on them because of tramlining, though this may of course be down to the specific brand of tyre.

But on the E92 i can't see me wanting to change from run flats. The ride is lovely.

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Wednesday 12th October 2016
quotequote all
Interesting, this. 335i SE's I do know by default do have the M sport suspension, that's not the case with other iterations.

Is it possible that the sport seats, excellent compared to the dreadful SE seats, are making everything feel better because they are so much more supportive?

It's not a like for like, but:-

X1, SE seats, 17s RFTs I find woeful overall ride compared to my 335i, even on 19s, with non RFT widening the gap. with RFTs, still better save for potholes.

I've not had a 18s RFT combo, in any car, but put 17s non RFT Michelin PS4's onto my 335i M Sport and the balance of sport handling and comfort was awesome!

Other thoughts, there is a M Sport suspension on your 325i, but missed of the build sheet?
Better condition suspension on this car, the X1 actually had a faulty shock absorber, that made it even worse?










RafflesNH

115 posts

151 months

Wednesday 12th October 2016
quotequote all
PTF said:
Something is puzzling me about my recent change of E9X from E91 to E92 and the difference between the ride and handling of both cars. They are/were both LCI models. E91 was 2009. E92 is 2010.

Let's start with the 325d E91. It was an SE spec car without sports suspension option, on 17" non-staggered wheels. When i got it it was on conti run-flats and was appalling to drive. It tramlined everywhere to the point of being dangerous on the inside lane of the A1 where it would leap from left to right and back again across the channels cut by the lorries. The ride was "jiggly" - it transmitted every little ripple in the road up through the cabin, where it didn't meet with much damping. A bumpy back road would really have it dancing around all over the place.

8<
Confused!
Interesting. I have had a 2008 LCI E91 330 SE spec for almost 3 years now, and have been driving on the original tyres fitted since the car was new (although I am the second owner). The tyres are Michelin PS2 runflats on staggered 18 inchers. Apart from the harsh ride over lumps and bumps, and potholes that would make the car shudder excruciatingly, I suffered none of the tramlining or directional stability you appear to have experienced.

Are you sure you hadn't got worn control arm bushes? They are a regular service item it seems for higher mileage BMs.

ps. I have just changed the two front tyres to regular non-runflat Michelin PS4s owing to a bulge in the sidewall of the NSF and the MOT is due soon. But I will go the whole hog after Xmas and get the rears on PS4s so I can see if there is any appreciable difference in ride quality. I do hope so!