e91 325i engine trouble
e91 325i engine trouble
Author
Discussion

TheGreatSoprendo

Original Poster:

5,288 posts

280 months

Sunday 30th October 2016
quotequote all
I've owned my e91 for about 3 years. It's a 2005 model and currently has 108k on the clock.

Last summer, I noticed the engine management light kept coming on, then going off again. I took it into my local garage and they diagnosed a misfire on cylinder 5 and thought a new coil pack would be likely to cure it. Having fitted the new coils, there was no change, so they checked the variable valve timing gubbins and all was well.

They pressure tested cylinder 5 and found it was well down on compression (only at about 35 psi from memory). They examined inside the cylinder with an boroscope and could see no obvious damage and the valves appeared to be in good order. They then put some cleaning substance into the cylinder and left it overnight. Next day, all the fluid had seeped through and when they did the pressure test, it had increased to 100 psi - still too low but a significant improvement. They did an oil flush and an oil change and suggested I drove it for a while to see how it went, suggesting the issue was caused by a build up of carbon deposits.

The engine light continued to come on and off intermittently and I put some ignition cleaning additive in with every few tanks of petrol. Then I took it to an indy BMW specialist for a Terraclean (http://www.terraclean.co.uk/), more in hope than expectation. However, after the treatment, the engine seemed much smoother. I did a 400 mile round trip to Wales and back immediately afterwards and the engine light didn't come on once and hasn't ever since.

However, a week or two later I noticed the engine had developed a distinct ticking noise. It was a tappety sounding noise which increased in frequency with engine speed. Unlike most tappet related noise (in my experience at least), the noise didn't go away or quieten at all once the engine got up to temperature.

I took it back to my local garage and they looked at it but were unable to diagnose the cause without stripping down the engine. I've been driving the car ever since although I don't do a huge number of miles (that's a whole different story). The noise is still there and doesn't seem to have got much worse (possibly not any worse, it's hard to tell). It doesn't seem to affect the way the car drives but it is annoying me more and more!

So I'm now wondering what to do about it. The 3 options as I see them:

1. Let the garage strip down the engine to diagnose and (hopefully) fix the problem. Downside being that it will be a large and open ended bill with no guarantee of a cure.
2. Have a recon engine fitted. Expensive but a pretty much guaranteed cure as long as I can source a sound engine.
3. Stick it on eBay with the faults declared and wash my hands of the bloody thing!

Any thoughts or advice much appreciated!

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Sunday 30th October 2016
quotequote all
i would get shot of it. Try WBAC.

When I considered a new engine on my E46, Quarry Motors a breakers in Sheffield were great.