Running on new car
Running on new car
Author
Discussion

rb5201

Original Poster:

285 posts

124 months

Tuesday 8th November 2016
quotequote all
Apologies if this has been answered before but I'm taking delivery of a new 335d on Thursday.
I am feeling like a kid at Xmas!
What's thoughts / opinions on running in car? Do new cars need it so much now?

Thanks.

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Tuesday 8th November 2016
quotequote all
Nope, thrash the bks off it, its under warranty!

smashy

3,108 posts

189 months

Tuesday 8th November 2016
quotequote all
Hello OP this will give you some ideas to chew over

http://f30.bimmerpost.com/forums/showthread.php?t=...


http://www.honestjohn.co.uk/faq/running-in-a-diese...

Edited by smashy on Tuesday 8th November 23:06

rb5201

Original Poster:

285 posts

124 months

Wednesday 9th November 2016
quotequote all
Sounds like everyone has a different opinion on what the right thing to do is.

It's on a lease for 2 years so I think I'm going for the drive it hard from the off. Don't think I'll be able to wait 1200 miles before doing this either!

stevesingo

5,048 posts

253 months

Wednesday 9th November 2016
quotequote all
Bedding in the rings to the bores is the most critical aspect on a modern engine as the tolerances throughout are designed for two parts to run together separated by a film of oil (think cam lobe and follower). The rings/bore are designed for minimal oil separation to prevent oil consumption and are designed to bed in to their running tolerance. The surface finish and material of the bore surface and the ring material are chosen to allow them to initially wear to give a consistent sealing finish on the full circumference, essentially removing the high spots on the bores and rings. The wear is a function of speed and pressure.

The speed is rpm, simple. The pressure is combustion pressure and this is generated by load (combustion pressure forcing the rings against the cylinder wall). We need to be careful not to apply too much of either as we will get too much localised hear on the high spots of the rings and this can affect the properties of the ring material and prevent the bedding in process. Likewise insufficient load will cause glazing of the material surfaces and prevent any further bedding in to the surface being too smooth. Adding a little more load and little more speed incrementally is the best way to go.

Start engine and drive off normally towards a decent mile plus long well sighted, quiet straight road.

Select a fixed gear if auto, or 3/4th if manual.

Accelerate at 50% throttle from 1200rpm to 2/3 of peak rpm, lift off, change down and coast back to 1200rpm. Repeat 5 times
Accelerate at 60% throttle from 1200rpm to 2/3 of peak rpm, lift off, change down and coast back to 1200rpm. Repeat 5 times
Accelerate at 70% throttle from 1200rpm to 2/3 of peak rpm, lift off, change down and coast back to 1200rpm. Repeat 5 times
Accelerate at 70% throttle from 1200rpm to 3/4 of peak rpm, lift off, change down and coast back to 1200rpm. Repeat 5 times
Accelerate at 80% throttle from 1200rpm to 3/4 of peak rpm, lift off, change down and coast back to 1200rpm. Repeat 5 times

The coast down is important as this removes pressure from the rings and oil past the oil control ring to aid lubrication and cooling

That should be 50 or so miles

Then use normally gradually increasing load and rpm over the next 250 miles.

I would then change the oils as all the particles which have worn off your bores are now in your oil and filter.

Anecdote 1; A couple of years ago I built a BMW S14 engine and fitted a magnetic sump plug. After the break in period, I dropped the oil and found the magnetic sump plug looked like a Christmas tree! Mag sump plug obviously of limited use in an ally blocked engine!

Anecdote 2; Earlier this year I bought a 2007 330i daily driver with N52 engine which have a reputation of using a drop of oil. Turns out the first owner was BMW UK. Guess what, doesn’t use any oil! My guess is that it was not babied from new due to the user not being the owner.

apotts

254 posts

238 months

Wednesday 9th November 2016
quotequote all
^ Wot he said.

Done this for years on new cars and engines that I have built, and it works.

The only caveat - for a turbocharged diesel at 1200 rpm, 50% throttle may well give full boost from the smaller turbo. I try to avoid massive boost on the first few runs, for fear of overheating the points of highest wear (on the rings). As we have no boost gauge, I just use "perceived thrust". You can sort of feel how much load is on the pistons - seat-of-pants-BMEP.

So I would advise the first runs to be "low-medium" acceleration, then "medium" acceleration, then "hard" acceleration.

Then don't take a motorway for 1,000 miles. Leave a little earlier and go A roads all the way.

From then on, always be easy on a not-yet-at-temperature engine, then go for it.

rb5201

Original Poster:

285 posts

124 months

Wednesday 9th November 2016
quotequote all
That seems alot of work!

What you say makes sense. if it's so important though why do cars not come run in. They could do it on rolling roads for example. Wouldn't the cost of this mean less engine warranty claims etc in the future?

V8A*ndy

3,703 posts

222 months

Wednesday 9th November 2016
quotequote all
rb5201 said:
That seems alot of work!

What you say makes sense. if it's so important though why do cars not come run in. They could do it on rolling roads for example. Wouldn't the cost of this mean less engine warranty claims etc in the future?

I've watched the guys driving the brand new cars of the boat.

Often sideways, revs hitting the limiter, usually a bit of smoke from the tyres.

Cars (in Northern Ireland that is) are certainly run in by the time you get them furious

Edited by V8A*ndy on Thursday 10th November 09:53

GTEYE

2,510 posts

241 months

Wednesday 9th November 2016
quotequote all
rb5201 said:
That seems alot of work!

What you say makes sense. if it's so important though why do cars not come run in. They could do it on rolling roads for example. Wouldn't the cost of this mean less engine warranty claims etc in the future?
Indeed, not sure how many of us could be that scientific about the process!

My philosophy, take it easy for the first 1,000 miles, make sure you vary the speed (ie not all motorway, not all town) and don't let the engine labour (in a manual obviously).

Despite what the dockers have done to it previously (better not knowing), you show then have a well run in engine.

Another tip, don't buy an ex hire car. Obvious why really.

apotts

254 posts

238 months

Wednesday 9th November 2016
quotequote all
GTEYE said:
My philosophy, take it easy for the first 1,000 miles, make sure you vary the speed
Taking it easy for the first 1,000 miles will give you reduced performance (efficiency, power, oil consumption) for the next 100,000 miles. It's all about getting a good seal between the ring and the bore. If you fail to get a good seal in the first few miles, then the escaping gasses will form a coating (called "glaze") that will prevent the seal and bore from ever mating. The only recourse then is a strip down, honing and start again.

Manufacturers do their best to minimise this problem. However, they do insure against improper run-in by:
  • Under stating max power
  • Quoting a huge oil consumption rate as "acceptable".
When a car comes off the line, it is started (that will be the first time the engine has run), driven over the alignment machine, quick test of electrical items, and then given a run up to high speed, back down again and the job is done. That initial run is done at WOT and at high speed - and a chunk of the running in is done there and then. And then you have the delivery drivers - and the PDI.

(PS "vary the speed" I'm sure is a mis-translation. It could mean "cruise at 70 for 10 minutes, cruise at 60 for 10 minutes" etc - but what it really means is "do lots of accelerating and slowing")

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 9th November 2016
quotequote all
I've had a number of new cars over the last two decades. A few BMW diesels and petrol, MB petrol, 997S, VW diesels, Caterham duratec, Mitsubishi VR4, Mazda V6. Always started off steadily and gradually increased revs and throttle over first couple of K miles but no conscious 'running in' programme.

After that always warm thoroughly before driving hard. Typically changed cars at 75/80K.

Never had an engine that used oil; never had an engine or transmission issue.

Mr-B

5,140 posts

225 months

Wednesday 9th November 2016
quotequote all
There was an in depth article somewhere on the web, American guy I think and possibly more related to racing engines??, but he was an advocate of thrashing them from day 1. The article had photos of pistons and stuff showing the different wear patterns of gently treated engines and those given no mercy and the latter seemed better for it.

apotts

254 posts

238 months

wax lyrical

1,076 posts

272 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
My 2008 E93 335i uses hardly any oil (maybe 1 litre every 10/12k miles) and the car currently has 124k miles on the clock! I bought it at 50k miles, 4 yrs ago, so the previous owner must have 'run it in' properly - whatever that actually means.

I've always found it odd that the same (or similar) engines could have such wildly varying oil consumptions. It CANNOT be normal or 'right' for a car to be using 1 litre (or more!) every 2/3k miles, whatever BMW says is 'acceptable'.




Edited by wax lyrical on Thursday 10th November 07:52

apotts

254 posts

238 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
My car shows full on the oil when I take it in for each 18,000 mile service. Not a drop in, not a drop out. It's a modern miracle!

Cars that have been run in by gentle driving for the first 1,000 miles will use oil because the OCR is not bedded and never will be. Poor bedding of rings does no harm (as in nothing will break so it will cost nothing to BMW on their warranty) - you simply lose oil and performance.

Even if it's as bad as the spec tolerance, so what? Leaky rings do not lead to anything breaking.

GTEYE

2,510 posts

241 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
apotts said:
My car shows full on the oil when I take it in for each 18,000 mile service. Not a drop in, not a drop out. It's a modern miracle!

Cars that have been run in by gentle driving for the first 1,000 miles will use oil because the OCR is not bedded and never will be. Poor bedding of rings does no harm (as in nothing will break so it will cost nothing to BMW on their warranty) - you simply lose oil and performance.

Even if it's as bad as the spec tolerance, so what? Leaky rings do not lead to anything breaking.
Maybe depends on the definition of gentle then...

My experience of gently run in engines over the last 25 years or so, is that they have not used any oil either - never had to add a drop....

Just saying!

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
GTEYE said:
apotts said:
My car shows full on the oil when I take it in for each 18,000 mile service. Not a drop in, not a drop out. It's a modern miracle!

Cars that have been run in by gentle driving for the first 1,000 miles will use oil because the OCR is not bedded and never will be. Poor bedding of rings does no harm (as in nothing will break so it will cost nothing to BMW on their warranty) - you simply lose oil and performance.

Even if it's as bad as the spec tolerance, so what? Leaky rings do not lead to anything breaking.
Maybe depends on the definition of gentle then...

My experience of gently run in engines over the last 25 years or so, is that they have not used any oil either - never had to add a drop....

Just saying!
My experience too, as already posted. Each to their own, I'll stick to what I know works for me but, as you say, could depend on definition of 'gentle'.

One thing that puzzles me, it appears many cars are fine for several tens of thousands of miles then they start to use oil. Were they run in the wrong way, whatever that is?



Edited by anonymous-user on Thursday 10th November 20:34

XMT

3,948 posts

178 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
I always find people very strange that have the mindset that just because you lease it you can thrash it , how very odd.

Why not just respect the property which quite frankly doesn't belong to you anyway.

One of the many many wrong perceptions people carry with them these days: well it won't affect me anyway so I don't give a dam........until it does!

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 11th November 2016
quotequote all
And don't forget there is bit more to run in than the pistons and bores - transmission and brakes for instance.

4rephill

5,171 posts

209 months

Friday 11th November 2016
quotequote all
roofer said:
Nope, thrash the bks off it, its under warranty!
Posts like this make Me laugh!

Why?

Because in a few years time, the very same people who gave out the advice to the cars first owner to: "thrash the bks off it", will be replying to a later owner of the car who's posted about having issues with their recent purchase that are going to be costly to put right, and they be saying something along the lines of:

"Looks like you've been unlucky mate! I bet some wcensoredker who owned it previously didn't give a scensoredt about the car and thrashed the bks off it!"